Brian Batko: Good afternoon. I still can't believe the Steelers lost yesterday. I was busy typing up the "Kenny Pickett wins NFL debut" instant analysis story as, well, that happened. So let's talk about it.
Vegas Steeler: With so many people calling for Canada to be fired, I wonder who takes over if that ever happens. Do you know who on staff would be the most likely person to be the new OC? I am really curious if we have someone with that type of qualifications on staff.
Brian Batko: QB coach Mike Sullivan, who's in his second year on staff and was hired for that role when Matt Canada was promoted, is the only realistic option. He was Giants OC for two seasons with Eli Manning, and no one else on the staff has called plays, at least not in the NFL.
Yogi in Yonkers: Would Dick LeBeau have lost that game yesterday?
Brian Batko: Maybe
mrbig: same problems year after year.... Tomlin's STILL not on the hot seat?
Read More
Brian Batko: I get it, mrbig. It's hard to not have some of those thoughts after that game. People who read these chats often probably know that I'm generally a believer in Mike Tomlin as a coach and stability as a philosophy. The way I see things now are: the Kenny Pickett era is here, and having Tomlin in place to oversee this transition makes sense. He's tied to this QB. If things go south beyond this season, it will be time to have discussions about whether you keep at it with one, both or none.
Ed in Carrick: Let’s start the Pickett and “rebuilding” chat. Thanks Bats.
Brian Batko: Already there, Ed! And perhaps you're referencing Diontae Johnson using the "rebuilding year" phrase yesterday postgame. Interesting, but I'm not sure that's a huge deal. He's just being honest, and regardless of what you think that might say about the direction of the franchise in the big picture, it's factually correct that they're rebuilding the QB position at this point and even the WR corps to an extent. I'm not going to assume he meant it as "we're gonna stink this season but we knew that," as I'm sure some will interpret.
LarryG from Punxy: Great to see Pickett play the second half. I thought he played well, interceptions aside. Do you think he starts the next game? How about for the rest of the season?
Brian Batko: Yes, I do, LarryG. Mike Tomlin said last week he'll exercise patience with the offense, and a lot of folks ran with that as "he doesn't think there's an issue and won't change anything." But he's a guy who chooses his words carefully and actually said he'll exercise "the appropriate" amount of patience. Obviously, he'd seen enough of Mitch Trubisky in the first half Sunday and thought it was appropriate to switch. And I've thought all along, since they drafted Pickett, that once you go to him it's mighty hard to turn that stone back over. Gotta let him live and learn now.
Johnny U: Would you agree this has to be the least talented coaching staff in the AFC? Yes Flores is there but he is limited to what MT mandates. Canada should be fired and let Sullivan handle for now especially since Kenny will be taking over . Thank you.
Brian Batko: That's hard to quantify/answer, John. Coaches and coordinators always look better with better players, especially in the NFL. To be honest, I have no idea how various position coaches stack up between the Steelers and, say, Bengals. The thing about Canada is I know for a fact some of his offensive concepts have caught the eye of people we'd all consider "good coaches" in the NFL.
Lou: Hi Brian. Any updates on the returns of TJ, Calvin Austin, and Kazee?
Brian Batko: Nope. Perhaps Mike Tomlin will have updates tomorrow. I think Austin is getting close, if they're ready/willing to use him. Haven't seen Kazee around because of his suspension, which has one more game to go. As for Watt, I noticed him on the sidelines the last couple games but not yesterday. For whatever that's worth.
More unpopular: More hated in Pittsburgh ? Matt Canada or Bob Nutting ?
Brian Batko: Probably Matt Canada because you have to care about something to have hatred toward it right? Based on some of the crowd shots lately, I think apathy has set in for many when it comes to the Buccos. Not sensing that in Steeler Nation, and even if they continue to struggle the rest of this season, it'll be the Kenny Factor that keeps fans invested, I bet.
Miles McGuire: Good morning Bats,
Gut wrenching loss, reminisce of with Ravens loss with Mike Vick at QB. Thoughts on T. Austin running the Defense? I would assume is seat starts to warm with the outside noise.
Brian Batko: Good afternoon, Miles. Too early to say on that. The defense has been disappointing, no doubt, especially to this particular reporter who thought they'd be a top-5, maybe even top-3 unit. Now, of course, that was accounting for the presence of TJ Watt. But the Jets were in shambles yesterday, too, and they couldn't finish the job.
Stat Man: BB, I don't think you are the PG stats guru, but if you were, could you kindly research if a disgruntled and miscast back-up QB ever captained a team to non-losing record?
Brian Batko: I
Brian Batko: will see what I can do!
Zburdette34@gmail.com: This defense who Tomlin said he expected to be “dominant” both due to personnel and schematics coaching is putrid and has now lost this team three very winnable games in a row VS what should be considered the softest part of our schedule. And this is Tomlin’s Defense - when will this man ever be held accountable for constantly getting out coached and his defense looking like Swiss cheese instead of being dominant, when, if ever, we are all dying to know man??? Because the one liners that you guys in the media love so much are way past old to die hard steeler fans such as myself who watched this severely over rated coach absolutely waste the vast majority of a 1st Ballot HOF QB’s career!! He’s done nothing in 12 years, NOTHING!! When will he be held accountable, when, please, for the love of god????
Brian Batko: Did you read my story from yesterday's game on the defensive collapse? I made it pretty clear that Tomlin's explanation didn't hold up. Now, I can't make him answer questions truthfully or the way fans want them answered, but no one's letting him skate on this: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2022/10/02/pittsburgh-ste...
Utah Jim: Did Kenny get any first team reps in practice last week?
Brian Batko: If he did, they were extremely minimal one-offs. The way he put it after the game, he tries to "steal" as many chances as he can to work with George Pickens, et al.
Art from NC: Hi Brian- Well will the D coaches address the over-the-middle coverage that is killing us? NE, Cleveland, and yesterday in crunch time the opponents through to TE's or WR on crossing routes for whatever yardage they needed for a first down to keep these 4th quarter drives alive. One game OK, but where are adjustments to this issue?
Brian Batko: That's a good question. I think it's pretty clear the middle of this defense is where you can attack the Steelers, personnel-wise. The outside corners do their job for the most part, unless it's Mac Jones throwing deep to Nelson Agholor. Naturally, teams want to stay away from Minkah Fitzpatrick in the deep third. But when you're asking Arthur Maulet, Robert Spillane, Devin Bush to cover guys over the middle, that's not ideal.
Bob in TN: I for one am glad for the change in QB. If we are going to have a losing season I prefer to do it with the QB of the future not a stopgap QB. Payton Manning had a losing season his first year.
If Mitch is not back as the starter, who do you think will be number 2 now?
Brian Batko: It'd surprise me if they don't make Trubisky the No. 2, but hey, Mason Rudolph's presence complicates it more than your typical QB depth chart would. I'd say Trubisky made his displeasure pretty clear yesterday without being overly dramatic. Could've been worse, but definitely could've been more diplomatic, too.
SouthernYinzer: How long will Tomlin leave Gunner Olsomething in the lineup to fumble punt returns? I sure don’t remember him having so many in New England. Has he fumbled one in every game so far? They’re having enough trouble in every other facet of the game (with the exception of Bosworth
Brian Batko: Not every game, but sure, I'm with you. Why not give Steven Sims a helmet one of these days to see what he can do? Doesn't mean you have to bench Gunner for good. Just give someone else a chance, not only on returns but maybe with a few offensive snaps here and there, too. Or Calvin Austin if he's healthy enough.
Manassas John: With Mark Whipple probably being a short timer at Nebraska, what are your thoughts on him being a good OC replacement for Canada? He and Pickett had great chemistry at Pitt.
Brian Batko: I don't know. They did. But if the Canada experiment doesn't work, it'll be a tough sell to go back to another coach from the college ranks. I'd rather see a coach with more of a pro resume who might be able to unlock something different in Pickett, I think.
Sunner in Orlando: So the Steelers have not won a game the last 2 years without Watt. What does that say about the rest of the defense? I say they are overrated and need to get back to the basics of stopping the run which they have not done all season. If they win 1 of the next 4 games, I will be surprised.
Brian Batko: Yeah, pretty much.
Ryan: Good afternoon Brian does Kenny start vs the bills i think he should he looked good vs the Jets
Brian Batko: That's my expectation, Ryan. I would guess Mike Tomlin announces tomorrow that they're moving forward with Kenny, but hey, he wasn't exactly transparent with the QB "competition" through camp.
Brian Batko: Regardless, we will be in Buffalo this weekend to chronicle all of that. The P-G will send all three of us beat writers - me, Gerry and Ray - plus photographer Matt Freed and columnist Ron Cook. We're committed to providing great coverage of the Steelers and everything else in the city/region/Pittsburgh sports landscape. If you don't subscribe already, give it a shot. It's only $6 for 6 months right now: https://promo.post-gazette.com/digitaloffer
YUCK!: We just lost to the JETS....at HOME....blowing a 10-point fourth quarter lead. 3 points used to be a comfortable lead around here. Just what hope do we have of winning ANY of the next 4 games? Nice to see Pickett, but he's playing with WRs who drop passes, a bad OL, and Canada calling plays. Our defense can't stop anyone when it counts. We're staring at 1-7. Hope?
Brian Batko: There's hope. Hope in the first-round pick at QB, hope in the playmakers on offense, hope in the sheer randomness and parity of the NFL.
Fan from Saskatoon: Prior to the season Chase Claypool boldly stated to a member of the media that he was one of the three best wide receiver's in the NFL . Do you think he has lived up to this, this season ? Sunday he had zero catches for zero yards, hmmmmm
Brian Batko: He’s been a disappointment no doubt. I’m sure he wants more opportunities to make plays but what wide receivers doesn’t. When they come his way he needs to make them. Hasn’t done it the last two weeks in big moments.
Daniel11: Hi Brian, The Steelers interior defense has not been fixed. It looks like Alualu and Heyward are showing their age and it showed yesterday. I know the return of TJ will help but don't you think the Steelers need to get a true NT?
Brian Batko: Their D-line depth is still solid. But I'm not gonna lie, it would probably help to have, say, Jordan Davis in the middle. Or even Travis Jones. The draft didn't fall that way, though. In the meantime it might be time to give Isaiahh Loudermilk a look.
Judge Holden: We're all well-aware of the player turnover on the offensive side of the ball, but could some of the misfires be attributed to three new offensive position coaches?
Brian Batko: Could be. Frisman Jackson is a new WR coach and I'd say that position isn't as playing up to their talent. The O-line is trying to figure things out with a new coach, too. But coaches change all the time in this league. It's not an excuse.
pauljr13: Hi, has any of the coaches discussed why they don't rush more than 4 anymore? It seems like they rarely send more than that. I think some extra blitzing on that last drive, particularly on 4th and 7, could've forced some bad throws. Thanks.
Brian Batko: I agree with you. Zach Wilson's career numbers vs. pressure aren't very good and it seemed like the Steelers should've tried some more in that regard. Maybe they felt they couldn't because of how banged-up they were in the secondary.
Silly in Philly: Sup Bats. Feel like Claypool is more athlete than he is NFL wr. Size, speed and ability but even in year3, after NFL coaching up, he still jumps to make a stomach cradle type catch- which negates his size advantage and often times results in an incompletion. Can he not figure out the concept of “high point”?!
Brian Batko: You're right. It makes no sense that he isn't making more plays. He's a monster. He's fast. He's fiery. But something's just missing there. No way around it, it's a shame he hasn't progressed more after the way he played as a rookie.
Pete: Hi Brian Do you think MT gets a position in the office to make Flores the new head coach?
Brian Batko: Nah
Pete: Brian, first I want to say that I thoroughly enjoy your chats and the rest of the PG team's as well. Great writers, great to read each day. Question: How does Coach Tomlin, often called a "player's coach", "protect" a rookie QB for weeks/months and then, without any reps, over a 10-day "prep" period no less, throw him in down at the half? It appears more and more this regime is not ready for a rebuild (hasn't improved the OL and running game in 4+ years, nor have they recovered from Shazier's awful injury) and a the team needs to start over, new staff, top to bottom. Though I would transition the staff to Flores if possible.
Brian Batko: I can confirm these are two different Petes. So, thank you, second Pete. And I agree with you, the way he's handled this QB situation, first of its kind for him, has left a lot to be desired. Not just necessary about when/why he made the switch, but from listening to both guys going back to July, they really have had no idea what the plan is for them. Maybe that'll work out in the end and make Tomlin look smart. For now it just comes off as an arrogant way to approach it.
Jud: Barring injury, do you see a scenario where the Steelers go back to Mitch?
Brian Batko: Wouldn't shock me. The idea of going back to him at this point would be strange and potentially stunting for Pickett's development, but I think that's less of a worry with him than it is your typical first-round QB. He's already gone through a ton of ups and downs in his career. I don't think he has a fragile psyche or anything like that.
Stlrwaz: Would we have won more games with Big Ben at the helm this year....?
Brian Batko: I don't think so.
Brian Batko: OK folks, that's all the time we have for today. Gotta go talk to the players soon. Will have a story online later about ... something.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.