The thing about a first is that it can only happen once. In the case of Kenny Pickett’s NFL debut — coming in front of his home crowd, no less — it gave the Steelers and their fans an undeniable spark Sunday in the second half at Acrisure Stadium. But they failed to ride that wave in a 24-20 loss to the Jets that sent them to 1-3 and ruined what was set to be a downright euphoric day on the same piece of earth where Pickett rewrote the Pitt record books and led the Panthers to some huge victories.
There will never be another chance to recreate the dawn of the Pickett era in Pittsburgh, and Mike Tomlin’s team let lightning in a bottle go to waste. Pickett himself wasn’t asked to do too much after coming in cold in a halftime switch with Mitch Trubisky, and yet he couldn’t have gotten off to a worse start given that his first NFL pass was intercepted by former Pitt teammate Jordan Whitehead after Chase Claypool failed to come down with it. All told, Pickett finished 10 of 13 for 120 yards with three interceptions but also 15 yards rushing on six attempts, including a 7-yard first-down run on 3rd-and-6 that galvanized the building.
Pickett’s mere presence seemed to be a catalyst for momentum, but neither he nor the defense could sustain it. The offensive line helped him on a pair of quarterback sneaks, one to convert a first down on his first drive, another to give him his first professional touchdown and the Steelers a 13-10 lead midway through the third quarter. His 2-yard touchdown run was more impressive, requiring a second-effort finish to get across the goal line and providing the Steelers some cushion at 20-10 early in the fourth quarter.
But he threw another pick in the fourth quarter that clanged off Pat Freiermuth’s hands on a high throw. It was an ill-advised decision and it proved costly, as the Jets then scored the second of their two touchdowns in the final 7:31.
It will be a new age of Steelers football, assuming that Pickett takes the field first as the starter next Sunday in Buffalo against the Bills, a trendy Super Bowl pick. Not to draw too many parallels, but Pickett’s first start in college his freshman year came against No. 2-ranked Miami, and he guided Pitt to a stunning upset at home. There were fleeting shades of that game Sunday on the North Shore, and the Steelers can only hope there will be more to come next weekend and beyond.
It was over when: Pickett’s final Hail Mary pass was intercepted by Jets safety Lamarcus Joyner, and the Steelers stood stunned on their home field, many looking around wondering what happened.
Read More
Player of the game: Chris Boswell. On a day that ended on a sour note for the Steelers, Boswell at least booted a 59-yard field goal that tied his career long and set a record at Acrisure Stadium. You know it’s bad when the kicker is the player of the game.
Trending up: Freiermuth. A tight end can be a rookie quarterback’s best friend, and Freiermuth didn’t disappoint. Not only did he become an early favorite target for Pickett, but he finished with 85 yards receiving, catching seven of the nine passes thrown his way. Rookie defensive lineman DeMarvin Leal and veteran slot cornerback Arthur Maulet flashed a bit with an uptick in playing time, too.
Trending down: Trubisky. His offensive line deserted him at times and he dealt with a lack of separation and at least one drop from his receivers. But Trubisky simply didn't do enough to keep the offense moving, and it got him benched at halftime of his fourth game with the Steelers. His stats — 7 of 13 for 84 yards and an interception — were indicative of his struggles reading the field and inconsistency with ball placement to this point in the season. Barring an injury to Pickett, this may be the last we see of him throwing passes in Pittsburgh.
Next up: The Steelers have what might turn out to be their toughest game of the season, a trip to Buffalo to face the 3-1 Bills — who failed to beat the Steelers last year at home in Week 1.
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.