Gerry Dulac: OK, kids, we're doing this a day later than normal, but all that does is give everyone an extra day to come up with more questions. We'll start our chat in about 20-25 minutes so get ready....
Gerry Dulac: OK, here we go kids....
Henry in Blawnox: Austin biggest steal in Steelers draft?
Gerry Dulac: He might be. I like the choice. I like his speed, the fact he caught a lot of balls the past two seasons as a pure wideout and the fact that two of their top 4 picks were WRs to help restock that position.
Nostradamus Your are not: Gerry, time to step up your game, first the Miles Jack prediction, then your pre-draft take on QB draft. Come on man, what is your encore?
Gerry Dulac: To somehow get people to spell Myles Jack's name correctly.
Read More
Henry in Blawnox: Hey Gerry - is it time to cut Tuitt and his almost $14M cap hit? I honestly feel bad for his situation, but its either time to commit to work or get cut - my job would be sympathetic if i was in the same situation, however, lets be real i would've had to report back to work after a year. Do you agree?
Gerry Dulac: Henry, he's played 21 games in three years. That's not what you would call dependability.
ElCid97: Do you think Mitch lasts a season as our starter? Or if Pickett isn't the starter on opening day, he will be at some point during the season?
Gerry Dulac: That's what we're going to find out. I know this, if Trubisky is the starter -- and I expect that -- he will be in a difficult position. The minute he throws a bad pick or has a bad game, the fans will be howling for Pickett
TXSteeler: ol, we get you really didn’t like picking a QB - but what I’m the world makes you think you know better than a FO and Scouts who have been extremely successful at this? And before you say “the rest of the league didn’t want a QB” you don’t know that 1 you have no idea who would have taken Pickett and when if the Steelers passed.
Gerry Dulac: Yes I do. And, I never made it about any one QB, nor did I ever say they wouldn't draft a QB. What I have always said is it would be a waste of a No. 1 pick if they drafted a QB. And it is. This is an above average football team that needs more help than taking a QB (let alone two) from an average class.
SteelTheOne: Gerry, have you heard anything from coaches or front office staff about Buddy Johnson? He was incredibly productive at Texas A&M but fell completely off the radar last season. Aside from Myles Jack (admittedly a great pickup), ILB still seems to be pretty thin. Thanks.
Gerry Dulac: You know, I don't have a recent update, only because there has been nothing going from which to obtain an update. But I know they weren't exactly enamored with what they saw last year but are willing to give him a second year to see how he develops/improves
SMF: Hi Gerry: Thanks for the Chats, No one really mentions it, but my hats off to Tomlin for his complete curve ball fake media show that he was all in for Malik Willis. Very, very well done…...virtually every so-called pundit fell for it hook, line, and sinker. Was this his best Houdini act?
Gerry Dulac: Other than a quick disappearing act from the postseason, yes.
Justin: While it's way too early to grade the draft, I was disappointed we didn't add another Defensive Tackle. Do you see the Steelers adding any or going with what we have? Not much behind Alualu.
Gerry Dulac: I doubt it. Is not that they merely need another defensive tackle -- they have plenty of bodies -- they need a young, quality defensive tackle, someone who can be the next Cam Heyward or Stephon Tuitt. You don't typically find those on the third round or lower. The Steelers tried to trade up in the first round, but it should have been for Jordan Davis, not for Kenny Pickett, which they were prepared to do. By the time Pickett was still there at 16, the Steelers could have traded down in the draft and still landed him.
Steeler in Virginia: How much young Ben do you see in Pickett's game? And do you think the Steelers' experience bottling up Lamar Jackson - a very mobile QB with questionable accuracy - led them to shy away from a similar QB in Willis?
Gerry Dulac: I am certainly not about ready to compare Pickett to Roethlisberger in any form. Ben was the third QB taken -- and it turns out, the best QB -- in arguably the best QB class ever drafted. When it comes to number of Super Bowl victories, it is the best QB class ever drafted. And I don't think their ability to defend Lamar Jackson had any effect on Willis' position. If anything, the problems Jackson presents enhanced the Steelers desire to get a mobile quarterback.
Mendy: Hi there Gerry, if you had to take an estimate, how do you think Kenny Pickett's career will turn out?
Gerry Dulac: I have no idea. Kenny Pickett is a nice kid and I'm sure he will have a nice career. But he will be under a ton of pressure to play in the same town where he was a college hero. And to replace a HOF QB.
Tim: Was there a player on the board that the Steelers brain trust passed on that you were surprised they didn’t select ?
Gerry Dulac: Not really, not surprised. I thought they might be inclined to take Georgia's other DT, Devonte Wyatt, whom one former NFL head coach told me would be a better fit for the Steelers than Jordan Davis. That's what I thought they should have done when Davis was gone. But, knowing what I know now, that was never going to happen with Pickett still on the board. The only good news is they didn't have to give up more draft capital and do something even more questionable (dumb?) like trade up to get him.
Utah Jim: Is Pickett’s ceiling really that much different than Trubisky’s?
Gerry Dulac: That's what we're going to find out
ElCid97: When they say Leal needs to bulk up by fifteen pounds to play, does that translate to him being the D-Line version of what we saw of Kenrick Green last year? Too small and easily pushed around?
Gerry Dulac: He needs to bulk up a bit to play inside. Hey, Leal might not be a bad pick. Might be a good pick. But he wasn't the type of player the Steelers needed to help their run defense. And, like I said, you typically don't find Cam Heyward or Stephon Tuitt on the third round or lower
Salvador: Hello Gerry! Hope everything is great at your side. know OTAS will just start in 2 weeks but with the FA we signed, the youth movement in the Offensive side in the Draft + Brian Flores acquisition and Austin promotion the team seems more replenished. Are we going to see this year a change like the first year of Cowher's tenure ?? or more of latest 4 ?
Gerry Dulac: Honestly, I don't see any kind of dramatic one-year turnaround. But, let's not forget, they have been to the postseason each of the past two years so it's not like they are some type of bottom-feeder. Cowher inherited some very average non-playoff teams when he became coach in 1992. This team is not like those.
Utah Jim: They had the worse rush defense in the league last year and play in division with heavy run teams Cleveland and Baltimore not to mention Joe Mixon who ran for over 250 yards against them last season. Why do they refuse to get someone to play NT and is Tomlin the most stubborn coach in the league?
Gerry Dulac: Four teams ran for over 200 yards, most in the league. They were only team to allow an average per rush of 5 yards. No team came even close to allowing as many runs of 20+ yards (24). You think they need help, especially when their starting DL averages over 32.3 years old??? Uh, yeah
Alex: I think 2021 and the 2022 draft really put the steelers in a good spot moving forward. Remember, no on though this years draft would turn them into a SB team. Next year they can pound OL, DL and DB in the draft. And THEN be a SB type team for 2023 and beyond. Plus, they have lots of money to spend next year, even after they sign Minkah.
Gerry Dulac: Now there's a positive outlook. But I will point up they did a lot to "pound" the offensive line in free agency.
Alfonso: Pay the man for the Draft Grade! ¿Any interesting FAgent DT , within reach ? Never retire
Gerry Dulac: I kinda like this guy!
Tom M.: I was in agreement with your thoughts to not take a QB. But, after seeing how the draft played out with Davis and the best WRs off the board, who would you have taken?
Gerry Dulac: I might have been inclined to take Devonte Wyatt
Edward A: I've seen a bunch how the Steelers got one over on the Ravens with the Austin pick, but I think the Ravens got the bigger one over Pittsburgh in the third. Do you think it may have been wiser to grab Travis Jones in 2 and see what happened at WR in 3 and 4?
Gerry Dulac: That's what happens when you draft a QB in the first round and not address what you really need. If they take a WR in the first round, then they could get Travis Jones in the second and not let the Ravens get him in the third. And, if you really wanted a QB, the Steelers had at least three of those guys with a No. 1 grade, meaning they could have had one of them in the third round.
leonard from austin: Gerry: Am I alone in thinking that having Tuitt back, that the Steelers will not only have one of the Best defenses in the league but also contend for a title with just an efficient offense?
Gerry Dulac: Leonard, I'm afraid you are alone in your thinking.
Edward A: You'll get this 1000 + times but got to ask. Everyone thought the pick was Malik, why was everyone so off on the qb the Steelers preferred? How surprised were you that it was Kenny over Malik?
Gerry Dulac: I wasn't shocked because I knew they liked Pickett. But I was a bit surprised. Also, some draft experts had Pickett going to the Steelers, though not as many who thought it would be Willis.
John Q: I thought the Steelers passed on some good tackle prospects in the 6th to get Heyward. Did the team indulge an emotional/familial connection, or was he rated that highly?
Gerry Dulac: I think you got that one partially figured out
Tom M.: The Ravens always do a lot of maneuvering and still seem to get their guy along with extra picks. Since the draft is such a crapshoot, having a bunch of picks seems like a good idea even if some will end up getting cut. The Steelers just stay put and pick their guy. What do you think is the best strategy?
Gerry Dulac: It depends how good and how deep your team is. If you a playoff team that needs that extra gear, I think the best strategy is targeting the guy you really want in the first round and moving to go get him. That's why I liked the strategy -- repeat, strategy -- to go get Devin Bush in 2019. Now, it turns out Bush is not the player they envisioned, and for that their evaluation process should be roundly criticized. But I didn't have a problem at the time with the thought process behind the move
Henry in Blawnox: Everyone is saying Leal needs to gain 20 or so lbs. Remind me but didnt Keisel play at around 290 lbs?
Gerry Dulac: Yes, at the start, but he got up to around 300 pounds for sure.
Jackpot Winning Number is 8: Gerry, I know the Steeler draft has mixed reviews, but why do the Ravens get such high draft accolades??? They not only failed to address their biggest weakness, they allowed it to become a bigger weakness by trading Brown. How can all these great choices learn how to catch Lamar's inaccurate throws?
Gerry Dulac: You know, I'm always surprised at the Ravens reluctance to find receiving targets for Lamar. But they did the same thing for Flacco. That being said, the Ravens draft the Ravens style -- with big body players to punish teams along the line of scrimmage. I loved each of their first five picks. I give them an A+
SteelersinDetroit: Hi Gerry, if both Alualu and Tuitt return and are healthy (big if) how much better is our run D this year versus last year?
Gerry Dulac: It can't be any worse. Not after the way they performed. But there is no question a big part of that awful performance is because Tuitt never did play and Alualu missed all but two games. I thought Chris Wormley developed into a solid player and they think Isaiahh Loudermilk is going to be very good. And picking up Montravius Adams in December was a nice move. But none of them are Tuitt and Alualu.
redsteeler69: Gerry can't we at least get through training camp & preseason before the fans start crying about draft picks. I remember quite a few of them being crazy because of the T.J. Watt pick.
Gerry Dulac: You're right. Happens every year with draft choices. Can't please everyone.
Henry in Blawnox: Is Colbert going to make the HOF?
Gerry Dulac: He should.
JG: Hi Gerry - when the Steelers traded up to get D. Bush a few years back, there was such an emphasis on replacing Shazier it almost felt necessary. It was a collective sigh of relief. I felt the same way with Pickett. Hope. I know its not an analytical or value argument, but it felt the same. Thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: I think they hope Pickett turns out to be a better selection than Bush. The Bush move looks bad now because of how far they moved up to get him (10 spots) and at what spot they selected him (10th overall). Any time a QB is drafted on the first round, there are immediate high expectations. And the failures are probably much greater than the successes because teams often reach (or feel as though they are under pressure) to find that elite QB
Henry in Blawnox: Is CB the biggest unit weakness now on the Steelers or would you say it is QB?
Gerry Dulac: Probably is. But there's still time to make a move.
Alan from Indy: Gerry, hearing a lot about the possibility of K Green moving from C to guard. What leads to the assumption that he will be better there and do you agree?
Gerry Dulac: Because he played nearly his entire college career there. People always want to point up that Mike Webster and Dermontti Dawson, two HOFers, switched from guard to center. What they forget is that each didn't do so until they had a full season to get acclimated to the speed and power of the NFL. Green didn't. He was thrown in at center after starting just four games in college. Give him a chance.
kris: Since there was a seeming lack of quality QB’s available in FA/Draft this year what should the Steelers be able to get for a guy that had a 1st round grade in the draft a few years ago…?
Gerry Dulac: A fifth-round pick. If they're lucky, a fourth.
Nick: Gerry, were you surprised they took a QB in first round?
Gerry Dulac: Not after the time and travel they invested to study each of the top seven QBs in the draft.
kris: For a team that doesn’t use a FB I guess the upside is that we can now have one on a rookie contract rather than a high-priced FA. Is this another negotiating tactic for a contract that needs to get done, a la Watt? Cam being due $16ish million for each of his age 34/35 seasons seems like it needs some work…
Gerry Dulac: I'm sure that was exactly what they were thinking. Derek Watt is the third highest paid fullback in the league who averages 4.3 offensive snaps per game. One way or another, some All-Pro defensive player is going to be disappointed when they cut his brother.
Sunner in Orlando: Hi Gerry thanks for the chats! The picks of Heyward and Oladokun were unnecessary IMO as they would have been available as undrafted free agents. Not that there were a bunch of quality players in those rounds but maybe picking up an extra DL or DB for special teams might have been more prudent. What say you?
Gerry Dulac: I say you forgot the other guy they took in the seventh round -- ILB Mark Robinson. Probably could have signed him too as a free agent. However, I think someone might have drafted Cam's brother by the seventh round. One way or another, the Steelers were taking him, trust me.
Tom in NC: I was a bit perplexed on why the Steelers didn’t take a DL/OL earlier in the draft. Which positions do you feel still need some attention?
Gerry Dulac: You're not alone
Ed in Carrick: Any idea how team plans to use Leal?
Gerry Dulac: I think that's what the Steelers have to figure out. That was the problem NFL teams had with him -- they were not sure where he fit.
Henry in Blawnox: So Kenny Pickett has a relationship with Peyton Manning. In NO WAY am I comparing the two, however, I keep hearing Pickett has an amazing work ethic. Do you think he will “study” like Manning which could make up for his arm weakness. Being a QB in the NFL is also about being smart.
Gerry Dulac: I'm sure he does and that's important. But you can't find a quarterback anywhere smarter than Josh Dobbs, who spent two summers working at NASA, could recite the first 48 digits of pi and knew the playbook inside and out. Now that's smart.
Rocky B: I believe they really like Pickett, but part of it is that there was no way they were going to have another Marino situation, which still haunts the Rooneys all these years later.
Gerry Dulac: There might be something to that. But, if there was, it would only be because Art Rooney II could hear his dad on his shoulder, reminding him what happened in 1983
bobbyp28: Isn't the drafting of Pickett a sign that "we don't think Trubisky is good enough, we better find someone who might be POTENTIALLY better?"
Gerry Dulac: Not necessarily. But it does say they believe Pickett is their QB for the future. You don't take QBs on the first round to be a backup, unless your starter is Aaron Rodgers.
Mike from Erie: Hi Gerry, Did the Steelers make an attempt to get Jordan Davis ? or was the price too high ?
Gerry Dulac: I was told they did not. And that's too bad. They tried to move up for one guy -- and I don't get that either.
wiscoken: Gerry - what is your thinking on what the Steelers do with Diontae? I still can't see them signing/extending him, and clearly the draft speaks to some contingency planning. Will he eventually be simply a FA casualty... is trading even a possibility?
Gerry Dulac: More than likely. I'm sure he will test the free agent market to see if can get something close to what some of these other receivers are getting. I would say he won't, but I never underestimate the desperation and/or stupidity of some NFL GMs
SOCAL21: Hit send by mistake, did the Steelers interview you for the GM position yet, I am right with thinking they need to get younger on the DL. Not just younger, but better, much better. Note, anyone who disagree just needs those stats you pointed out about the games with teams rushing for 200 + yards...i.e.
Gerry Dulac: Pay the man!
Steelchuck: Hi Gerry - any players still available in FA or positions you'd like to see us make a move before camp?
Gerry Dulac: Joe Haden
Rocky B: Do you think Trubisky feels blindsided by their first round pick, or was the understanding all along that they would take a QB if one they liked was available?
Gerry Dulac: He would never say it, but I'm sure he did to a degree. He made a quick move to sign with the Steelers, likely with the understanding he would compete with Rudolph and even Dwayne Haskins to be the starter. I wouldn't be shocked if they didn't tell him at the time of their plans to take a QB. After all, it wouldn't be the first time they misrepresented a role to a free agent. Just ask Melvin Ingram.
Rocky B: Is it a bad sign that Tuitt hasn’t shown up yet for voluntary workouts? If he was really excited to get back, you’d think he’d be there, right?
Gerry Dulac: He still has plenty of time to do that, like when OTAs start. Now, if he isn't there for those, which are also voluntary, that would be different. But the Steelers are still a little leery of Tuitt's commitment to return and are waiting to see where that leads. His issues have nothing to do with his knee. He had non-major surgery at the end of training camp and was healthy to return before the middle of the season.
Gerry Dulac: Well, kids, that's all the time we have. Like the Penguins, we went triple OT. Thanx for the questions.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.