Go ahead and get on the Steelers for not being able to figure out their inside linebacker group since Ryan Shazier’s career was cut short in 2017. They richly deserve the criticism for their personnel decisions over the past four seasons.
Just know they’re not alone in their struggles to assemble players to man what has become the most difficult position to master in the NFL.
The Steelers traded precious draft capital — their 2019 first- and second-round picks and a 2020 third-round pick — to move up and select Devin Bush with the No. 10 overall selection in the 2019 draft. Bush, for a number of reasons, hasn’t lived up to the hype.
Now the Steelers must decide by May whether they will pick up the fifth-year option on Bush’s rookie contract or cut their losses and move on from the player they hoped would anchor the defense for a decade.
But Bush hasn’t been the only disappointment among first-round linebackers in recent years. The Cowboys last year declined the option on Leighton Vander Esch, the No. 19 overall pick in the 2018 draft, and the Titans declined the fifth-year option on Rashaan Evans, the No. 22 overall selection in the same draft.
The struggles of Bush, Vander Esch and Evans highlight how coaches and general managers are having trouble identifying which college players can excel at the next level.
Read More
Inside linebackers in today’s NFL have to be hybrid players — big and strong enough to play the run in the base defense and athletic enough to cover running backs, tight ends and, yes, even receivers when offensive coordinators spread the field and attack with the passing game.
Steelers inside linebackers last season struggled to stop the run and defend the pass. The shortcomings played a big role in the Steelers finishing last in the league in rush defense while finishing 20th in points allowed.
Pass coverage continued to be problematic. When opposing quarterbacks targeted Bush, they completed over 70% of their passes and had a quarterback rating of 102.8. Drafted to be a three-down linebacker that never came off the field, Bush was subbed out for sub-packages for a time before he eventually rotated back in after the Steelers’ other linebackers similarly struggled in coverage.
Joe Schobert, who was acquired in an August trade, also allowed over a 70% completion rate when targeted and opposing quarterbacks had a 90.0 rating against him. He wasn’t strong against the run, either.
Robert Spillane, somewhat surprisingly, had better numbers in coverage. Opposing quarterbacks completed 66.7% of their passes and had a rating of 85.6. In hindsight, the Steelers could have saved themselves a sixth-round pick (the compensation required to acquire Schobert) had they entrusted Spillane with a starting job in training camp.
The misevaluation only highlights the problems NFL scouting departments are having in ascertaining exactly what they need from players at the position.
Former Steelers linebacker Vince Williams, who retired on the eve of training camp last July, put a spotlight on the issue during the conference championship games with a series of tweets.
“Linebacker is dead,” Williams wrote. “Your MLB is going to have to be the most athletic player on your defense, [offensive coordinators] are hunting up linebackers and putting Number 1 [receivers] on them.”
There was no better example of this than late in this year’s Super Bowl, when Rams coach Sean McVay created a mismatch by putting Cooper Kupp, the NFL Offensive Player of the Year, in the slot and getting him matched up on Logan Wilson, one of the top young inside linebackers in the league.
Wilson, who had four interceptions during the regular season and another in the playoffs, was called for defensive holding, and the Rams scored the winning touchdown a few plays later. Even when teams have elite players at the position, mismatches can be created by bright offensive coaches.
Caught off guard by Williams’ retirement and concerned about how Bush would respond coming off ACL surgery, the Steelers seemed like they were always a little off at the position last season. Now they have more decisions looming as they piece together their 2022 roster.
Schobert is on the books for a $9.74 million cap hit, but the Steelers can opt out of the contract and absorb only a $1.7 million hit on their cap. That’s the likely outcome, unless Schobert is willing to come back at a reduced salary.
Spillane is a restricted free agent the Steelers are likely to tender. He made four starts and earned his way onto the field late in the season and in the playoffs when Bush and Schobert continued to struggle.
Then comes the call on Bush, whose fifth-year option is expected to be between $10 million and $11 million for the 2023 season. That’s a steep number for a player who underperformed in his first year back after ACL surgery.
Bush did not come close to matching the production he registered as a rookie, when he had 109 tackles in 16 games in 2019. He had 70 tackles in 14 games last season. On top of the lack of production on the field, there are questions about Bush’s study habits and passion for the game.
For those reasons, the Steelers are likely to let Bush play out the final year of his rookie contract and hope his surgically repaired knee responds better and his play improves in 2022. If he plays well, the Steelers will have an opportunity to sign him before he becomes a free agent next year. If not, they’ll be back to square one with no long-term answer at the position.
The Cowboys were in a similar position last spring with Vander Esch when they decided to use their first-round pick (No. 10 overall) on Penn State linebacker Micah Parsons, who was the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year and finished second behind T.J. Watt in the voting for the league’s Defensive Player of the Year.
If a top inside linebacker in this draft falls to the Steelers at No. 20, would they consider taking him?
It seems unlikely in a year they have so many other needs, but given the struggles the Steelers have endured at the position, it doesn’t seem out of the realm of possibility, either.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.
Top five prospects
Nakobe Dean, Georgia, 6-foot-0, 225 pounds
Devin Lloyd, Utah, 6-3, 235
Quay Walker, Georgia, 6-4, 240
Chad Muma, Wyoming, 6-3, 242
Christian Harris, Alabama, 6-2, 232
Source: cbssports.com
HOW THEY WERE BUILT
Devin Bush
Acquired: 2019 draft, first round
Contract status: Signed through 2022
Joe Schobert
Acquired: 2021 trade
Contract status: Signed through 2024
Robert Spillane
Acquired: 2019 free agent
Contract status: RFA
Buddy Johnson
Acquired: 2021 draft, fourth round
Contract status: Signed through 2024
Marcus Allen
Acquired: 2018 draft, fifth round
Contract status: RFA
Ulysees Gilbert
Acquired: 2019 draft, sixth round
Contract status: Signed through 2022






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.