Four years after Jesse James’ infamous touchdown-that-wasn’t against New England, the NFL is still applying its catch rule inconsistently.
The Steelers learned that the hard way Sunday when a replay review wiped out a long throw and catch from Ben Roethlisberger to Ray-Ray McCloud against Baltimore at Heinz Field.
With the offense looking to shake off some first half struggles, the quarterback seemed to find his diving teammate for what appeared to be an impressive gain of 32 yards on first down to start the third quarter for the offense.
Ravens coach John Harbaugh, however, challenged the play as the tip of the football appeared to touch the ground in the process of making the catch.
After a long review, officials ruled the play incomplete by noting that McCloud juggled the ball slightly after it appeared to hit the ground, negating control.
In #BALvsPIT, the ruling on the field was a completed catch. After review, it was determined the point of the ball hit the ground, which caused the receiver to lose control. Therefore, the call was reversed to an incomplete pass. pic.twitter.com/07hqIo0yuj
— NFL Officiating (@NFLOfficiating) December 5, 2021
CBS play-by-play commentator Jim Nantz was flummoxed, telling viewers that he’d lesser efforts ruled as clean catches.
Read More
Nevertheless, the call short-circuited what looked to be a promising drive, as the Steelers were forced to punt just a few plays later after failing to pick up the first down.
Fans on social media were obviously not please.
McCloud caught the ball just like Jesse James did….
— Lauren Conkle (@conkle_lauren) December 5, 2021
Ray Ray McCloud caught that ball #Steelers
— Jake Slan (@slanimalpart3) December 5, 2021
I just still don't understand the Ray Ray McCloud catch overturn. It was ruled a catch. It had to be clear and definitive to overturn. I didn't think it was. #Steelers
— Stronger Than Steel Podcast (@Stronger_Steel) December 5, 2021
McCloud caught it.
— Shea Castle (@shea_castle) December 5, 2021
At this point, slo-mo replay is ruining football. We’ve moved beyond “clear and obvious” to just being whatever the ref wants to do in the moment.
That wasn’t indisputable evidence on the Mccloud catch. NFL refs are so inconsistent
— Kyle Nap (@KyleNaps) December 5, 2021
It wasn’t the only controversial call of the game either. In the first half, receiver Diontae Johnson took a seemingly late hit from Baltimore’s Chuck Clark along the sideline, but no personal foul call was made.
huge hit on diontae johnson, no call pic.twitter.com/s5NZdpA5B5
— Benstonium (@Benstonium) December 5, 2021
And shortly after McCloud’s effort was ruled incomplete, center Kendrick Green was called for a facemask penalty that left the Heinz Field crowd booing loudly.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.