Gerry Dulac: Ok kids, we will start our chat is about 10 minutes. So get ready.....

Gerry Dulac: OK, kids, let's get started. BTW, it was brought to my attention that some chatters last week thought I was demeaning and condescending. They obviously have me mistaken for someone else.

YinzerinVa: Who gets shut down for the season first? Ben or Najee?

Gerry Dulac: Neither. As long as they're healthy, they will play till the end.

Advertise with us

redsteeler69: Gerry I never thought I would ever know what it felt like to be a Brown or a Bengal fan. Can we really be this bad at everything, especially the coaching ? I understand the injuries, but not making any adjustments is unbelievable.

Gerry Dulac: The past three games have been tough to watch, save for the fourth quarter in LA.

BWV: Gerry: I don't know if this team wins again this year. I see a 2 to 3 year rebuild ahead with needs at T, NT, QB, CB, SS and ILB. Do you see the same?

Gerry Dulac: Trust me, they will win again. All I know is they need to pay attention to both lines of scrimmage high in the draft. Like, at the very top.

redsteeler69: Gerry was it my eyes or was Ben especially bad Sunday ? Does he have injuries we don't know about or is he just finally worn out ?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Ben did not play well Sunday. But his injuries are his injuries. He plays through them. But I suggest you go back and look at the two interceptions and see why his passes missed the mark. Pay particular attention to the offensive linemen.

Chicago Rob: Gary: Thank you for the chats. When do you think the Rooney's will hold MT accountable? Starkey's article on Monday morning was very telling. You can see him firing Butler but this is Tomlin's defense. Wasn't Butler a student of Coach Le Beau?

Gerry Dulac: He is not going to fire Butler. Why would he? He calls the defensive signals because, yes, this is his defense. And Butler was a student of LeBeau.

412man: Hello Gerry. Why didn't the Steelers spend Juju's money on the O-line? Even if he didn't get hurt, I think it would have been better money spent.

Gerry Dulac: I had no problem with them re-signing JuJu when they were able.

Advertise with us

Fineline: In all the years you’ve covered the team have they ever been this bad at the line of scrimmage on both sides?

Gerry Dulac: Nope. Terrible. Thank goodness for Cam Heyward.

Fanfromsaskatchewan: Who was a better center Sean Mahan or Kendrick Green .

Gerry Dulac: Haha....now that's a question I didn't expect. Sean Mahan was Tomlin's first big free-agent signing. And not a very good one. They signed him to a five-year, $17 million contract and cut him a year later.

blackandgoldattack in Ohio: When in your opinion will Tomlin finally say let's see what we have in our back ups in key positions and make some changes. We are in desperate need in many positions in the off season and the way my beloved Steelers have been playing why not really see if we have anyone that can fill an area so they can have a better focus on free agents and the draft next year.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: This is not a college program. He won't, and 99 percent of all NFL coaches wouldn't do it either. Their objective is to win each week, not get ready for next season. After all, for some coaches, there might not be a next year.

Rob: Good morning Gerry, was wondering if you listened to music today to get yourself fired up for today's Chat...Appreciate your hard work and dedication...

Gerry Dulac: Ha....another funny guy!

Sergio from Mexico: Hello Gerry! As always, thks for the chats and insights on our Steelers. I have been a huge Ben fan and Tomlin backer, but I feel than we need some changes for next year. I know that if it ain't broke don't fix it worked for some years with MT, but now I feel that it is completely falling apart. What do you say on the issue? I know there wont be coaching changes, but what can they do?

Gerry Dulac: Well, you're right, there won't be a coaching change. But they need to address both lines of scrimmage and they need to do it both in free agency (with a top tier T or G) and the draft (DL with the 1st or 2nd pick). They haven't drafted a D-lineman higher than the fifth round since Stephon Tuitt was a second-round choice in 2014. And that's Isaiahh Loudermilk this year. That's why they have what they have.

Advertise with us

Rob: Is it concerning then Ben and Coach T see separate faults? MT blames the O line and BR doesn't....It seems the finger pointing has begun inside the locker room, anyone involved in a team sport knows that is the beginning of the end....Your thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: There is no finger-pointing at all. Ben is not going to criticize the offensive line. After all, they are the people protecting him. That's like complaining at the drive-thru about the slow service and poor quality before you get your food. Not a good idea.

Renaldo: Hi Gerry. Question: what do these players all have in common? Tuitt, Vince Williams, Decastro and Ingram. Answer: the Steelers misread all of them. There are probably more.. Tuitt was expected to play this year, Williams unexpectedly retired, Decastro's health unexpectedly ended his career and Ingram became disgruntled and was traded. The Steelers' constant personnel issues seem to be at the heart of their decline, and some of them should have been anticipated and dealt with before crisis hit. Rooney should take a hard look at how they anticipate and handle personnel matters. Do you agree?

Gerry Dulac: I think you are on to something!

C Roy: With 2 d-lineman out should they have looked early on to replace them instead of hoping backups could do the job. It seems to me that's the biggest problem in run stopping and getting push up the middle all year. You can blame the middle linebackers but they would look a lot better with quality linemen in front of them. Your thoughts.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: See earlier response about why the D-line is in the shape it is.

TomlinsD: With every loss you still see people finding ways to blame Big Ben. When is the Defense going to be held accountable for the decline of this team? How many number-1 picks are over there, and why do they continue to decline? Bush, Watt, Fitzpatrick, Edmunds, Cam, and Charlton are all number-ones. This is Tomlins D, so why does he get a seemingly free pass for this dumpster fire of a D?

Gerry Dulac: I think the defense IS being held accountable. Why do you think all those former Steelers are saying they suck and are ashamed of their lack of physical play. They are talking about the defense.

Troubled Fan: Do you believe there's anyway with the current offensive linemen and backups that they can have any consistency running the football this year?

Gerry Dulac: Nope. They are actually running it worse than they did last year after 11 games, and last year they had the worst running attack in the league.

Advertise with us

Alan from Indy: Hey Gerry, What’s our old buddy Todd Haley up to these days? So glad we dropped the dink and dunk for the stink and stunk…..

Gerry Dulac: He's doing Sirius radio. And this offense is averaging six points fewer a game than Randy Fichtner's 2020 offense.

Guest: Gerry,MT's base D is the 2-whatever (i.e. whatever DB he wants to add - please don't say the base is 3-4). Prior to the injuries he got away with it because the 2 came from a rotation of Hayward, Alualu and Tuitt. With any two of those bigs and the 2 OLBs the Steelers had a ligit pass rush and could defend the run.Few teams can do that with a 4 man rush. Now MT thinks he can continue the 2-whatever D with the likes of Buggs, Laudermilk and so on. He hasn't and he can't. OCs see our line as something that can't pass rush and can't stop the run. I don't know if actually going to the 3-4 will wins games but it will stop the embarrassment. Your thoughts.

Gerry Dulac: I don't think it will make much difference for the main reason you suggested -- they don't have the quality players (other than Heyward) to make a difference. Oh, it might help them a little more against the run, but don't be fooled either -- teams have been gaining yards rushing even against their 3-4. The loss of Tuitt and Alualu has hurt them tremendously.

Mercury: It’s December 1. Should we expect hell to be unleashed soon? Or hath hell frozen over this season?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Like Clark Griswold said in "Christmas Vacation" -- "Look around, Ellen, we're on the threshold of hell."

Johnny Sack: Ben came back for a SB run and now that it’s over why not turn to Rudolph and Haskins. Evaluate the now and don’t waste next year doing it. I’m 90% sure both don’t have it but nows the time.

Gerry Dulac: Hate to disappoint you -- that's not going to happen.

New Hampshire Bob: How would you rank the reasons for the Steelers inability to stop opponents dadgum running backs?

Gerry Dulac: 1) Loss of Tuitt and Alualu 2) lack of quality depth behind them 3) ILBs who can't get off blocks because Tuitt and Alualu aren't there to occupy them 4) Bad gaps 5) Tackling.

Advertise with us

Johnny Sack: Any chance Steelers can trade Tomlin for draft picks?

Gerry Dulac: The comedians are out today!!

Guest: Do you feel the Steelers will be looking for a new punter for next year ?

Gerry Dulac: This one hasn't been as advertised

Alan in Nashville: Hi Gerry! I'm usually the eternal optimist and chief defender of the Steelers but I have a bad feeling that we may see a total collapse the next few weeks. I hope I'm wrong but I wouldn't be shocked if they would lose out. Am I just going crazy?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I can understand you going crazy after what you've witnessed the past three games. Maybe you should put the fourth quarter in LA on a loop and watch that to ease your demeanor.

wsb: Do you think it would be a mistake to draft a quarterback with a high pick before the line is improved. Alot of promising rookie quarterbacks got shell shocked and never developed.

Gerry Dulac: I don't know if there is one out there right now they like. But, trust me, they will be on the watch.

JP: Hi Gerry, why couldn't coach T just bench Ben after the half @Cincy? He mentioned personnel changes this week, do you think he would do it if they struggle again vs Baltimore?

Gerry Dulac: Now that would be a headline grabber if he did. But I'm not anticipating it.

Advertise with us

Linebacker Lounge: Hi Gerry, Will there be a day that AR forces MT to use the DC for calling the defense? Why have a DC if MT is going to call the plays? Thanks

Gerry Dulac: Pay the man!

Guest: Hi Gerry, I understand that we still have a chance to make playoffs but even if we do I think most agree a run is unlikely. That said, and I know you've long supported Ben playing for lack of a better option and I don't disagree, but would it not now, if ever, be wise to see for an extended period what both Mason and Haskins have to evaluate if they can provide acceptable play next year so we don't have to reach in a draft of underwhelming QB prospects. I understand Ben deserves respect for all he's done but the fans and the organization also deserve to have time to assess.

Gerry Dulac: I get your point, but, like I said, NFL coaches don't play for next year, especially not with six games remaining. They're trying to win, if for no other reason than their own personal gain/record. And, despite what we've seen, they are still a relevant playoff possibility. Not saying they will make it, but I've seen many a strange thing happen, especially so far this year in the NFL

Lord of Carson: Hi Gerry The Steelers have maybe 3 players that would be ranked in the top ten at their position in the league , all on D. Not sure this is Tomlins fault rather just a lack of overall talent, no ?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Agreed....for the most part

Linebacker Lounge: Why was 61 activated over 96 if he was not going to be used? Having Cam at NT was not working..why not move him back in game? Thanks

Gerry Dulac: That should tell you what they really think of 96.

HT: Gerry Tomlin bristled when asked about Claypool practice music but this is a culture that he has turned his head from for years now!

Gerry Dulac: He didn't bristle at all. He was very matter of fact, basically saying "You worry about playing, I'll handle the coaching." I loved his response.

Advertise with us

HT: Gerry there is a serious lack of talent on this team. evennthough they have spent to the max cap limit every year? What gives?

Gerry Dulac: There is a serious lack of talent on both sides of the line of scrimmage (Cam excluded of course). And there are two rookies and a second-year first-time starter on the offensive line.

Paul: Does our offensive coordinator ever heard of an end around or double reverse

Gerry Dulac: I think we've seen enough of those jet-sweep type of plays. They don't win games, just lose yards.

ohtransplant: Hey Gerry, it seems the Steelers are drowning in confusion, borderline dissention, secrecy and question marks off the field. Has management lost this team? Is it time to start focusing on next year?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: No. No. And there is no dissension.

FC: Also time to bench #55 until he's 100%. If they claim he's 100% now, then it's time to move on , agree? The back ups on the roster right now couldn't be any worse.

Gerry Dulac: Actually, they are worse, except for Spillane, and he's out.

MeatMaster: What is up with James Washington? Is Ben not looking his way? Is he not getting open? 1 catch for 3 yards last week!

Gerry Dulac: Uh, what has he done in four years that's any different this year? He doesn't get attention because his play doesn't demand it. How about trying to get open? Or win combat catches?

V. Fontaine: Do you get the sense from covering this team day in and day out that they recognize how deficient they are in talent across so many positions and that it's going to take a few drafts and endure some tough seasons before they can realistically compete for a division? Or have they convinced themselves that they're just a player or two away even though they're not? As a fan, I can put up with some down years to build a really good team. But being mediocre year in and year out is almost as bad as always losing.

Gerry Dulac: Actually, I think a lot of teams, maybe most teams, are just a player or two away in this league. And, c'mon, it hasn't been that bad. They were 12-4 and won the division last year. I know the end was a disaster, but all I'm saying is it could be a lot worse. And it's nowhere near that. And, with five losses, they're just one loss behind every top team in the AFC, except the Ravens. I'm not saying they're good, I'm just saying it's not THAT bad.

FC: When is Tomlin going to 'release hell'? Oh, that's right, he has, and as fans, we are in hell! Time to move on from he whole coaching staff and about 70% of the roster and rebuild.

California Yinzer: What do you think of Claypool wanting music at practice so it is more fun?

Gerry Dulac: I think he needs to be told this is the NFL and not college. This is a business, a job, not fun and games.

Jesse G: Steelers clearly need to rebuild their trench game. OL and DL should be top priority via draft and free agency that’s obvious and hopefully they do. What about position coaches Gerry, do you think they should also make changes there this off-season? If yes then who?

Gerry Dulac: Much like they did with the running game this past offseason, everything should be in play-- how they do it and who they're doing it with.

MeatMaster: Call me crazy but I think the offensive line continues to improve - Ben’s lack of mobility makes them look far worse than they appear.

Gerry Dulac: Now that's an optimist

Jim: Am I way off thinking Ben would be playing much better with an NFL line instead of a college one? Worst line in the NFL, no one could be productive behind these guys.

Gerry Dulac: Not at all.

Krugerrand: At what point is not putting Mason Rudolph in a blowout loss an indictment against him? Are not those missed reps a loss to the team's future growth? Or, was the goal to get Ben sent to IR?

Gerry Dulac: It's not an indictment at all. Ben is their QB, just like Cam Heyward is their DE.

Brian in VA: With all the glaring holes on the roster, wouldn’t it make sense to just pay Aaron Rodgers 40-50 million/year? I realise it’s not the steeler way but wouldn’t these same Steelers be a super bowl contender with Rodgers instead of Ben?

Gerry Dulac: Nope. And I'm a big Aaron Rodgers fan.

Steeler Guest: Is this team capable of bouncing back with the remaining schedule or at least looking respectable?

Gerry Dulac: Of course they are. I always remember something Dick LeBeau told me once during a painful stretch -- "I've seen sicker dogs than this get well in a hurry."

Jim: What has happened to this team, need better players, need heart, need discipline, need new HC?

Scott: Thanks for your work. What are the main reasons you would give for the Steelers being so weak in the trenches?

Gerry Dulac: Lack of big-time talent (except for Cam of course). I think people need to be reminded they lost three Pro Bowlers on the offensive line and two starters on the defensive line.

Retire 21: Sad to see Tiger basically admitting he’s pretty much toast. I wish he would have gotten up and down from “Big Mouth” on 17 at Oakmont because he would have dusted Cabrera in a playoff. Speaking of big mouths , where here in the area can we get some of those Bryson endorsed Koepka Cupcakes.?

Gerry Dulac: The members at Oakmont wish he would have too.

Jim: Am I wrong thinking this team is closer to Detroit than Cincy in terms of talent, discipline and coaching?

Gerry Dulac: Yes.

Jim: Did Tomlin shoot himself in the foot by stubbornly playing his starters late last week? Looks like PF will be out this week and we need him badly. Another bonehead move in a long line of boneheaded moves by the HC?

Gerry Dulac: Injuries happen. You can't take everyone out of the game. They were already without Ebron. Someone has to play TE

Jim: On a positive note, all we need for next year is a new Oline, a few Dlinemen, new ILB'S and new CB's. How in the word do we get that done though, is it possible?

Gerry Dulac: That's an awfully big Christmas list

DaDonger: Why was Shazier’s number 50 used? We’re there no other options? That number belongs to Ryan and David Little

Gerry Dulac: With all due respect to Shazier, why should his number be untouchable (or, in this instance, unwearable)?

Retire 21: Following some recent departures, Conner and Hilton doing well. I guess we’ll see Big Al Sunday. Glad they didn’t sign Dupree. What Steeler would you have liked back?

Gerry Dulac: Pouncey. DeCastro.

Henry: Is Devin Bush Colberts biggest draft blunder?

Gerry Dulac: Artie Burns

Henry: If Tuitt is healthy and not playing, how can he ever look Cam Heyward in the eye.

Jesse G: gerry you are around this team a lot more than the media , the media says Kieth butler isn’t the one running the defensive Calls or scheme . That it’s all Mike Tomlin. Is this true ?

Gerry Dulac: Jesse, I've been telling everybody that for three years.

FC: Good morning Gerry, thanks for the chats. I think the #53 experiment should be over. Usually, you see some improvement as a rookies year goes on, butI'm seeing a regression. He's just too small to be a center..thoughts? Could he play anywhere else on the line?

Gerry Dulac: If he's too small for center, then isn't he too small for guard, too? I admit, he has struggled with big NTs. I don't think they have many options to have the "experiment" be over. And it was never an experiment.

Bob in TN: There was a video of Bush playing on a Bengals extra point attempt (maybe a field goal.) The ball was snapped and he never moved a muscle. Stood perfectly still while everyone else rushed to block. He turned, watched the ball go though he uprihten gged off.

Gerry Dulac: Not much different than some other plays we've seen.

The GM: Good morning Gerry. The Steelers are taking a lot of heat after that embarrassing defeat last Sunday, and they should. Everybody says they are a soft team, players keep hinting that they need practice with more intensity. So my question is this, does the team often take on the personality of their Head Coach?

Gerry Dulac: Of course they do. But, before you think Mike Tomlin is soft, don't. He's all about being a physical team. And when you hear veteran or star players talking about practice, they're not talking about the length of practice or intensity. What they are really saying is that there are too many guys not practicing or focusing hard enough.

Keith F: How can there be any positivity heading into Ravens week after all the trouble containing Herbert and Burrows? Can we really afford to designate a player in the secondary to contain and not get burnt in the passing game?

Gerry Dulac: Nope.

David: I really don't see the Steelers being competitive with MR as our starting QB. I don't endorse Haskin either. Among MR, Haskins, Trubisky, Darnold, a rookie QB, who would you go with? I know the list is not something you would be excited.

Gerry Dulac: Based on that list, the Steelers already have their QB for 2022

Yates: Gerry- Morning. Do you think MT mishandled Ingram situation? How about decision to move Cam to Nose in Bengals game or passing with less than a minute left before half time when Steelers field position was what is was and there was no reason to think they could get into scoring position given how lackluster the O was up to that point? Then you have some of the top players questions how the team practices? Are we talking practice??? No I am talking a head coach who is doing no favors to enhance his team’s chance of winning. Let’s evaluate MT’s complete body if work please

Gerry Dulac: Yes I do.

Jmoney: Hey Gerry, thanks for the chat. The end of last season was very poor in large part due to teams adjusting to take away the short passing game. This season, it now seems teams have realized the Steelers can’t stop the run. In your opinion, is the coaching staff slow to adjust both in game and over the course of games or is it more related to a lack of capable personnel?

Gerry Dulac: A little of both, but their failure to adjust in-game to what's happening is a little disturbing

Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're out of time. Not sure about the status of next week's chat because of the Thursday night game