Brian Batko: Hi everyone. Getting ready to start another week of Steelers practice this afternoon. They’ll go Monday-Wednesday before getting some time off. Questions?
Guest: just can't wait for this season, first buffalo and ben looks like he really is, over weight,old, dead arm,qb,,,,,i look for 6 wins, whats your prediction please,,,,thank you
Brian Batko: You do indeed sound very enthused. I predict they’ll win more than 6.
Jarvis Ragdoll Jones: The Steelers declined the 5th year option on Edmunds. Has he shown any significant improvement during camp? Do they part ways with him after the season? They really don't have an option behind him at the moment.
Brian Batko: Not that I’ve noticed. Although sometimes with him it’s good if you’re not noticing him. He was far too noticeable at times in 2019, and his issues in coverage didn’t do him any favors come option time I’m guessing.
John P: If we trade Berry or Dobbs what would be a reasonable draft compensation pic for the two? Wouldn't be much I assume, but we know what happens when we assume..
Read More
Brian Batko: I don’t see why any team would trade more than a seventh-round pick for a punter. Wouldn’t you be irate if the Steelers did that?
Brian Batko: As for Dobbs, same deal. He was a street free agent earlier this offseason before the Steelers re-signed him. That tells me his market isn’t exactly buzzing.
Blackhawk Bob: Good Morning….I was wondering if all NFL teams have done away with paper tickets and forced fans to go digital or is this just a policy of the Steelers.
Brian Batko: I believe it's league-wide, Bob.
Lou: Is Matt Canada the kind of guy who will dial up a gadget play? I miss those!
Brian Batko: Yeah, I think he has those clubs in his bag. He certainly had some creative play-calls at Pitt. Not sure all of that can or will translate to the NFL level, but Canada has a very good mind for scheme.
Yankton Ern: Brian, Depending on how bad Allen’s hamstring is, can you see Spillane being cut? He has looked awful this preseason against both the pass and the run.Thank you.
Brian Batko: Didn't think he was particularly bad against the run. I'd be surprised if they cut him. He's good on special teams and has earned his keep, often to the praise of the defensive coaches, be it Mike Tomlin, Keith Butler or Jerry Olsavsky.
jud: Did Haskins play himself into a 3rd QB spot? If he starred, could we have gotten a pick from him in trade?
Brian Batko: Not Friday night, but over the course of camp, I think so. It seems like forever ago, but he came into this process with the weird night in Vegas looming and some renewed questions about his maturity. But then he looked very solid in practice, had one great showing against the Eagles and has likely bought himself a year to learn/grow here in Pittsburgh. Trade bait, though? I doubt it.
Dobre Shunka: I thought Ballage earned himself a spot on the roster ahead of McFarland or Snell. He's a North/South runner that gains yards after initial contact. Am I alone in this assessment?
Brian Batko: Nope. I have him ticketed for the 53 as of now. Don't feel great about it, but Tomlin has picked up plenty of veteran rushers over the years and plugged them into backup roles. Stevan Ridley, Ben Tate, etc.
Jeff: Running back seems to be most crowded. I'm not a bif fan of Benny Snell. who do you think ends up being the odd man out?
Brian Batko: My guess is Jaylen Samuels. Special teams might save him, but his pass-catching skills are now rendered somewhat expendable by Najee Harris. Samuels is versatile, yes, but I think Harris is already a better receiver. Better question is whether Snell and Ballage are redundant pieces? You could convince me of that, no doubt. I don't think it's crazy to only keep one of those three along with Harris and McFarland.
ppozone6031@gmail.com: I think the Steelers need to trade for a CB and also get a LT. Do you hear any rumors?
Brian Batko: No. But if they add another CB, they should make it an inside guy, right? Think of it this way: you have a relatively solid four-deep at outside corner. Joe Haden, Cam Sutton, James Pierre, Justin Layne. You can barely even go two-deep in the slot. Sutton, Arthur Maulet (?), then ... who?
Guest: If the Steelers struggle it will more than likely be because of the offensive line. I don't understand these Ben haters?
Brian Batko: Agreed. Roethlisberger showed me enough against the Lions to make me think the OL is the biggest cause for concern going into this season. I'm also not convinced that Roethlisberger can still play so well that he elevates that whole unit, but hey, he's 39. Not sure anyone should expect that of him. Does that make me a hater?
LA Diaspora: Why not just give Minkah the green dot? He never leaves the field.
Brian Batko: That's a good question. Obviously, he has the mental aptitude to handle that. As far as I know, the Steelers have traditionally had an inside linebacker do it. My assumption is that's because they're in the middle o the defense, playing right behind the D-line and able to communicate with those guys up front. Would be a bit tricky for a safety to do, although I know other teams have done that.
Tim: Do you think Devin Bush plays a full season or does his undersized frame equate to more injuries?
Brian Batko: I'm not gonna try to predict injuries. But to equate it to his size, or lack thereof, doesn't make a ton of sense to me. He went down last year with a torn ACL, not a broken femur or something.
A-man: Zach Gentry is a huge TE and their best blocking TE. With fullback D. Watt, and with a 230 lb. N. Harris, your thoughts on if we could see some “power” looks from Canada’s offensive this year. NOT a big fan of 3 yards & a cloud of dust, but slobber-knocker football is occasionally needed (so says Wolf).
Brian Batko: Who am I to disagree with Wolf??? Yes, I think you could see that. And I think they'd do it in a different way than Randy Fichtner, who liked to bring in the "nipple-rubber" as that No. 3 tight end, an extra offensive lineman.
Eric Carr: Brian, do you think both Jones and Roche make the team? I think Jones is a no Brainer at this point but I'd hate to risk losing Roche
Brian Batko: Someone else asked me this over the weekend. I think it's possible, but not likely. Hey, let's rank scenarios for outside linebacker on the 53, from most to least likely. Just one man's opinion:
1. Jamir Jones in as the fourth and final OLB
2. Jones AND Quincy Roche make it, so they keep 5
3. Jones and Cassius Marsh make it, so they keep 5
4. They only keep four, and it's someone other than Jones
Bernard: OL seems to be the single biggest question facing offense going into the season. What about defense? Bush health, CB?
Brian Batko: I'd rank the secondary, specifically the cornerback group, as the biggest concern. But after that, Stephon Tuitt. Especially if he doesn't start practicing today to begin a week that is essentially like an extra ramp-up period to Week 1. And after that I'd say the Bush-Schobert combination at ILB.
Double-A ron: I was cautiously optimistic about the O-line being enthusiastic grinders which would make up for there youthful inexperience. But Chuks seems often inadequate, Dotson lone bright spot, Green gets beat on by bull rushers, Turner has not returned to top form and Banner just hasn’t played, suggesting he’s not fully healed. Do you have words of wisdom or encouragement or is this a train wreck waiting to happen.
Brian Batko: If you want to look on the bright side, the Steelers seem to have invested in pure athleticism and power with these guys. Given a bit of time to coalesce, perhaps that turns into a productive run-blocking group that can hold its own in pass pro. And I suppose you can sink your teeth into Adrian Klemm being an upgrade as the position coach.
Tommy: Thought it was interesting that no mention of how bad Shobert looked against Detroit by you guys... i.e. getting dragged 3-4 yards for a 1st down when they had the Lions 3rd down on their o
Brian Batko: Now that you mention it, Schobert looked bad against Detroit when he got dragged 3-4 yards for a 1st down when they had the Lions 3rd down.
Joe Snarky: Who is the Ted Lasso of this football club -- the coach who has the sunniest disposition, best relationship with his players, always dropping funny pearls of wisdom? Seems like six years ago the very easy answer would have been Dick LeBeau, but I don't know enough about the current staff.
Brian Batko: As a Ted Lasso viewer, I can appreciate this question, Mr. Snarky. How about Mike Tomlin? He's basically just a more hardcore Ted Lasso. Or bizarro Ted Lasso, Led Tasso. But he's got the isms, the rah-rah energy, the delegation down pat.
Farrell pool Jack: The Haskins experiment is done. Cut him now! He can't occupy a valuable spot on the 53 man roster. He can learn on the practice squad. Haskins = Josh Rosen.
Brian Batko: Did you hear me on the radio with Joe Snarky today? I sort of made that same comparison of Haskins to Rosen. Not ready to put Haskins in that box just yet, but Friday night was not encouraging. And neither was the Lions game, really.
SOCAL21: Isn't it possible, they keep Berry?
Brian Batko: Yes, it's possible.
NC Steel: Biggest problem fr the team appears to be the OL. I'm guessing they will be below average for the first quarter of the season, but then will gradually improve, and might be pretty good by the three quarter mark. Why does run blocking seem to be so much harder for these guys, even the young ones who never played under Fichtner?
Brian Batko: Right now, it could be adjusting to a new scheme with Canada, or new techniques with Klemm. On-paper, they have the requisite strength and burst to be good in that area. But early returns are worrisome.
Muth: Between Baby Gronk and Muth, it's pretty close, but I guess I can live with Muth. Plus, Baby Gronk is not conducive to a chant-like setting. Best hands in the 'burgh since Randy Grossman? Look it up if you have to.......Groooooooosssssss.....
Brian Batko: Plus he doesn't like Baby Gronk. I've suggested Muth Miller. Or Pat Freierheath. One thing that eludes me is whether Muth rhymes with youth or booth. Kind of bugging me.
ErnieHartnerMr.305LIT: My man da Killer B, will the Steelers accept bitcoin as a valid method of payment in the near future?
Brian Batko: If I hear anything I'll let you know.
Daniel: Happy Monday, I don't know what to expect from the Steelers this season as there are many positives as well as negatives. Positives: more fit Big Ben, Canada's offense, balanced attack with Najee Harris Negatives: what to expect from Chucks and Banner, TJ Watt holding, CB position, tough schedule. I think this season poses Tomlin's greatest challenge and will set his legacy in Pittsburgh. What are your thoughts for upcoming season?
Brian Batko: You pretty much nailed it Daniel, other than the TJ Watt thing. Not too concerned about that. Plug Tuitt in there and I'm with you. As for legacy talk with Tomlin, greatest challenge, etc., that seems like a bit of a prisoner-of-the-moment take. He's had a ton of challenges, big and small. It's certainly different due to the Roethlisberger factor, but hey, he's got a new OC and a youth movement on offense that kind of keeps this from being a particularly pressure-packed year.
RJT: Will James Pierre be the outside corner or do you expect the Steelers to make a move for a nickel back? I’ve read good things about Pierre in training camp but he seemed to be struggling in the preseason games.
Brian Batko: Everyone's going to give up catches from time to time. He looked strong to me against the Panthers, and yes, he's been steady in practice. If they make a move for a slot guy, it can bolster your secondary in dime packages and maybe in base, too. But hey, maybe they're still comfortable with Arthur Maulet as that guy.
FallsWarrior: Ray says Harvin makes the squad. Gary says Berry won the camp. What say you?
Brian Batko: Who's Gary? Give me Not Berry.
Jay Daven: Brian, when is TJ going to begin contact drills? The first game is in 2 weeks. Can his absence from contact go beyond the first game or is a contract agreement imminent, like in hours?
Brian Batko: I still think it's imminent. Does that mean he'll end the hold-in and do team drills today at 1:30? Probably not. But again, I'm not worried about this. It'll get done by Week 1, and probably even by the end of this week.
V. Fontaine: What one position do you think the Steelers will look to upgrade via the waiver wire or trade before the start of the season? Corner? ILB? OT? Something else?
Brian Batko: Maybe none, but if they do, my money's on slot corner, followed by OL - tackle or maybe even center. But Tomlin seems to be fine with Green as a Day 1 starter.
Weegie Thompson: Nice chat, if the Steelers do not make the playoffs , is Tomlins job in jeopardy?
Brian Batko: I don't think so.
The GM: Brian, from what you've seen thus far, would you feel comfortable going into 2022 with Mason Rudolph and Haskins as a potential starter if #7 does retire?
Brian Batko: If I'm trying to win the Super Bowl? No. If I'm trying to get an accurate read on what I have at that position, and thus how to proceed in the post-Ben era? Sure.
VaSteelersFan: Hi Brian, I know it wasn't a great day for Haskins (he looked like Mason Rudolph out there!). But he didn't get a lot of help from his receivers or O-line. Too many drops, lack of toe tap from Ray-Ray, and an unimpressive run game. Are folks being too harsh on Dwayne?
Brian Batko: Folks are usually too harsh on every player. Just ask Javy Baez.
Yuri: Hello Brian. Do you think Banner and Tuitt will play in the season opener against Buffalo? Thank you Brian.
Brian Batko: The guess here is yes.
Mike M: Brian, what’s your surprise cut to get to 53?
Brian Batko: Depends what qualifies as a surprise. Benny Snell? Could happen. Justin Layne? Maybe.
Dubby: I know that it’s fun to second guess everyone about everything all of the time, but shouldn’t Steelers fans just shut up and let the people who actually evaluate football players for a living evaluate the football players?
Brian Batko: As long as the media can keep speculating on it.
Jacque Strap: B Money! Who would you take, Snell or Ballage? Of course you have to take the line play into account, but Snell has never done anything impressive to me. Don't know why he'd be #2. Slow and not elusive, bad combo for this line.
Brian Batko: I think Ballage has been the better runner, but Snell might offer more on "teams," as they say in the biz. If one has to go, I'll keep Kalen.
Joe: Who you got making the 53 man roster at D line? And is there anything new about Tuitt and his situation or playing ability?
Brian Batko: Tough call but I'll go with Heyward, Tuitt, Alualu, Wormley, Loudermilk, Davis. And Buggs if they keep 7.
ev: Hello Brian, thank you for the chats. So far in this preseason, Big Ben was in the shotgun for the majority of his playing time (from the one game I saw, anyway). Will he be under center this year at all?
Brian Batko: Yes. He did it several times in the Lions game when they were scoring touchdowns.
John: I'm bummed about Sexton. Not like Ray-Ray hasn't had his share of miffs. Being cut at this round, does that mean he wont make the Practice squad?
Brian Batko: Eh, it's not a definite, but I would agree that's not a great sign. As exciting as he was at times, he was always a long shot.
Stinger: How much stock should we put into a win / loss at Buffalo?
Brian Batko: Not too much. But more than the preseason. Bills should be very good. Then again, you have to beat very good teams to win the whole darn thing.
Stlcrtn1974: I think this year will be the opposite of last year. Very slow start, strong finish. Hopefully they have enough wins to get in to the playoffs. Sound about right?
Brian Batko: Yeah, more or less. But being off by one or two wins could be the difference between missing the postseason and sneaking in as a wild-card for this bunch. At least that's my read.
Brian Batko: OK friends, we're all outta time. Plus practice starts soon. Gotta get out there and see what's happening. Talk to you later.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.