You might remember that the Steelers’ first play from scrimmage in their playoff loss to the Browns back in January went pretty poorly.
Maurkice Pouncey snapped the ball over quarterback Ben Roethlisberger’s head. Cleveland recovered it in the end zone for a touchdown. And that was the beginning of the end of a once-promising season.
The gaffe wasn’t a total aberration, though. In fact, one efficiency metric shows that it was actually representative of a larger trend of early-down struggles that had dogged the team throughout the campaign — even when it was 11-0. And it’s one the Steelers will have to turn around in a major way if they have any championship aspirations in 2021.
Football Outsiders’ defense-adjusted value over average, or DVOA, communicates what it says. Value over the league average — expressed as a percentage — in a given situation with consideration given for the quality of the opposing defense.
At the Post-Gazette, we’ve traditionally used it to measure individual players’ performance, but it can be used as an overall efficiency measurement, too. And it tells a pretty damning story of the Steelers’ efforts on first and second downs last season.
The team ranked 23rd in the NFL in first-down efficiency with a DVOA of minus 8.8%. That put Roethlisberger’s offense in a league with some of the worst in the NFL. Of the nine teams that finished behind them in this metric, only Washington made the playoffs and did so with a losing record at 7-9.
Read More
By contrast, New Orleans led the league with a 23.4% DVOA and was followed by four other top contenders in Green Bay (22.6%), Minnesota (20.2%), Buffalo (18.8%) and Cleveland (11.9%.)
The Steelers will want to be closer to them than to the Football Teams of the world. And they’ll really, really want to get better on second down, too, as their struggles compounded there in just about every situation.
Football Outsiders breaks out performance in short, medium and long distances, and the Steelers were pretty rough in all three. They ranked 22nd in short distance at minus 9.7% DVOA. They were 16th in medium distance at 1.7%. And they were 24th in second-and-long at minus 11.4%.
Add it all up, and they ranked 25th in overall second-down efficiency at minus 6.8%. Once again, of the seven teams behind them, only Washington made the playoffs. And the top five in the pecking order were all among the NFL’s best; Green Bay (27.5%), Kansas City (27.4%), Tennessee (22.3%), Tampa Bay (21.2%) and Seattle (20.2%) all made the playoffs, with three of those teams reaching the conference championship round.
Not coincidentally, these numbers track with a struggling running game, as early downs tend to be more run oriented. The Steelers were very poor in that area in 2020, with a running game that ranked 30th in the DVOA rankings at minus 26.3%.
If there’s an encouraging trend for the Steelers looking forward, it’s that they were somehow more than competent when the pressure was greatest on third and fourth downs. Sort of.
Their efficiency in third- or fourth-and-short was horrendous at minus 30%, putting them ahead of only Denver. In mid-distance situations, however, they were extremely solid at 48% — the fourth-best mark in football. And in long distances, they were 15th at 10.2%.
Those figures explain why the Steelers were able to mask their shortcomings for as long as they did in making it to November with an unbeaten record. Even if they fell behind the proverbial eight ball, they were able to bounce back and convert anyway — something the other teams at the bottom of the first- and second-down efficiency metrics could not match.
Hiding shortcomings and thriving are two different things, though, and an offense that’s more efficient across the board is generally going to be better over the long term.
That’s where an improved running game can make its biggest difference.
An extra tough yard here or quick burst for 5 yards there probably won’t go down as plays that define a season, a game or even a single drive. But gaining them consistently should lead to more favorable down-and-distance situations, which should translate into longer drives and more points.
And the best part of that for the Steelers is that they don’t need to become the NFL’s most explosive unit overnight to accomplish that goal.
Simple progression to the mean would likely add up to a boon overall. Kansas City, for example, was a mediocre 13th in rushing DVOA but ranked as one of the best teams on early down because of their downfield passing game led by the incomparable Patrick Mahomes.
Granted, Roethlisberger probably isn’t in the same class as Mahomes at this stage in his career. It’s not realistic to expect him or this offense to rank as explosively.
What they can do is make more incremental improvements that trickle down in a big way. And maybe make the big mistakes a bit less costly in the year ahead.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.