Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds.
Don’t forget to join us on our all-sports podcast, The North Shore Drive, whether you use Apple, Spotify or any of the other major podcasting platforms. Steelers episodes go live on Fridays. Let’s get started.
Mike M: Brian, what former Steelers player would you add to this roster to give the biggest impact? I’m going with Dirt Dawson.
Brian: This is a great question. Reminds me of one I saw Pitt football coach Pat Narduzzi answer on the ACC Network a couple weeks ago.
Q: Which Pitt Football legend would you want on the 2021 team? ????#H2P » @Revis24 pic.twitter.com/kuoxPCvfJR
— Pitt Football (@Pitt_FB) May 13, 2021
Talk about an impossible prompt. Trying to pick only one former Steeler is just the same. But here goes ...
Joe Greene, Jack Ham and Jack Lambert all garnered consideration from this one-man panel, but ultimately we’re scared off by the notion that defensive players from that era would struggle in 2021, especially in the front seven. Perhaps these three legends would still be excellent today, but not quite as dominant.
Read More
Your center idea makes sense given the uncertainty there for the current Steelers, but asking me to choose between Mike Webster and Dermontti Dawson is enough to just scrap the whole thing. Plus, if I’m adding one man only, I might just stay away from the offensive line entirely, given how superb one linemen must be to make as much of a mark as those at other positions.
A few more who made my short list? All defensive backs: Troy Polamalu, Rod Woodson and Mel Blount. Polamalu paired with Minkah Fitzpatrick is a mighty enticing safety tandem, but Terrell Edmunds is probably a bit more reliable than some of the cornerback options on this team. Which brings us to Woodson and Blount, stars from different eras who could most likely get the job done opposite Joe Haden and allow Cam Sutton to stay inside full-time.
But there’s a reason they only made the short list and aren’t No. 1. Because when you think about most impact, you think about one position, and that’s the quarterback. Can Ben Roethlisberger still win the big one? Maybe. Maybe not. So, what I keep coming back to is, given the opportunity to add any former Steeler in his prime to this team, I’ll take my chances with the QB who led them to four Super Bowl victories.
Yes, I’m going Terry Bradshaw, who at his peak would almost certainly be an upgrade over Roethlisberger at 39. If possible, I’d probably prefer Roethlisberger at the height of his powers, but Mike’s question did say former Steeler, so, Bradshaw it is.
Ernie H in the 305: The NFL has promised full stadiums for this season, so will fans be required to be vaccinated to attend games? My governor in Florida has made it illegal to require vaccinations to attend ANYTHING. How will this work in PA and across the NFL?
Brian: I don’t think they will be, Ernie. That would open a major can of worms and I suspect that NFL teams will handle it like other businesses, be it MLB franchises (Pirates aren’t requiring vaccination proof or masks at this point) or Home Depot.
Obviously, full capacity makes that a different discussion somewhat, but that’s also not for a few more months now. In Buffalo, where the Steelers will play their season opener, the Bills have been making headlines with their crowd policies with regard to COVID-19. First it was their home playoff games last season, when fans had to show proof of a negative test to get in. Now it’s a tug-of-war between county and state over whether attendees will need to provide proof of vaccination.
Erie County, where the Bills are located, is pushing for it. New York doesn’t seem to be on board. It’s an off-field story line that has even trickled down to players and coaches at times, and the Steelers have stayed above the fray much more carefully than the Bills. Case in point, Cam Heyward’s answer Tuesday from OTAS when asked how he’s handling the vaccination discussion with teammates who might be hesitant or simply choosing not to receive it.
“I think everybody has to make that decision personally. I can vouch for it and say I got the vaccine because of my family, and with my current situation — I have bad asthma, I have bad allergies. When I was a kid I was always in the hospital to begin with, so I just thought to myself, I don't want to give another reason why.
“Everybody’s had different situations. My grandpa passed away during the pandemic and he was scared to even go to the hospital. Everybody’s got their own story and I can't think for them, all I can do is provide them the information and let them make a choice of their own. And I think guys have been doing that. Some guys have gotten COVID and are wondering, ‘Should I get the shot now?’ So they need to understand that, and understand why and when they should get the shot.”
Jeff in NJ: Why are people obsessed with how Ben looks weight wise in camp? He looks the same, year in and year out. Beard added 10 pounds
Brian: On one hand, I’m with you that I’ve never noticed much fluctuation or put much stock in Roethlisberger’s physique, at least not since I’ve been covering the team and this seeing him in-person. On the other hand, I can understand fans’ interest in players’ weights, mainly because the team rarely updates that information, even for guys who might be working their way into better shape or putting on muscle to bulk up and play a different position.
Much like the official depth chart and listed positions for certain players, the weights next to Steelers’ names should be taken with a grain of salt. And in the age of Zoom interviews taking the place of an open locker room, reporters can’t even approach a player who looks like he’s transformed his body and ask for an update on that.
I digress, but I do so in the interest of explaining why so many beat writers are pining for the face-to-face/one-on-one access of old. It informs us and informs the fans about the personnel who are responsible for helping your team win games.
Think you have better questions than these ones? Email bbatko@post-gazette.com or write him on Twitter @BrianBatko.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.