Everything always seems rosy and grand when immediately evaluating how a team performs in the NFL draft.

Typically, it begins with determining if a team addressed the needs it had on offense and defense. Then it’s evaluated on the players who have been selected to address those needs.

Left to their own analysis, each team has always managed on draft day to find the player they believe can strengthen their position of need. Or so they say. In the history of the draft, no team ever selected a player they didn’t want.

Like a putter in the pro shop, they all feel good on draft day.

Advertise with us

One thing is apparent about the Steelers’ 2021 draft that netted nine players: They most definitely selected the player they wanted in the first round — Alabama running back Najee Harris. And they addressed two positions of immediate need and another that likely would have to be addressed in 2022 in the first three rounds.

However, determining the success of those picks, along with deciding if giving away a fourth-round draft choice to draft a fifth-round player was a good move, is something that will have to wait. So will the decision to draft a punter in a round that once produced Brett Keisel and Kelvin Beachum. Time is the true evaluator.

But, for now, here is a look at each player drafted by the Steelers — how they fit, if they can have an immediate impact, and if they address a need. A letter grade evaluating the player and selection is listed, as is the draft round and overall number in parenthesis.

Najee Harris, RB (1, 24) — Any time a team can get the best player at his position — and the one they were targeting all along — with the 24th pick in the draft, it’s a home run. Of course, it also involves a little luck. Nonetheless, getting Harris to be the final component in the overhaul of the running game was every bit as essential as moving up to draft Devin Bush to fill the hole at inside linebacker several years ago. Grade: A+

Pat Freiermuth, TE (2, 55) — It might have been a little bit of a surprise to see a tight end get selected maybe a round or two higher than anticipated. But not when you consider Freiermuth is a throwback tight end who can block as well as catch, a combo not necessarily belonging to Eric Ebron and something that will be essential in Matt Canada’s motion offense. Plus, Ebron is a free agent at the end of the season. Grade: A

Advertise with us

Kendrick Green, C (3, 87) — Center was the other gaping hole that needed to be filled with a starter — and the Steelers did that with Green, who mostly played guard in college. Pairing Green and his self-described “mean” attitude next to guard Kevin Dotson is part of the change in mindset (and technique) new coach Adrian Klemm wants to install along the offensive line. Grade: B+

Dan Moore Jr., OT (4a, 128) — The Steelers believe they have two starting-capable tackles in Chuks Okorafor and Zach Banner. And they added veteran Joe Haeg as a swing tackle in free agency. With more immediate needs on offense, that’s why they waited to address the position. Moore was a three-year starter at left tackle, making him, for now, Okorafor’s backup on the left side. Grade: B

Buddy Johnson, ILB (4b, 140) — Of all the third-day picks, Johnson might end up being the biggest surprise. He is not only good against the run, he has the ability to play in coverage — something required of today’s NFL inside linebackers. Vince Williams was brought back for one more season, but Johnson has a chance to play in sub packages and eventually be a starter in 2022. Grade: B+

Isaiahh Loudermilk, DE (5, 156) — Loudermilk is essentially a fourth-round pick because that’s what the Steelers gave up in 2022 to get into the fifth round to take him. Players like that tend to be judged more acutely because of the team’s desire to obtain them. Nonetheless, the Steelers are lacking in young players behind Cam Heyward and Stephon Tuitt, and Loudermilk gives them a chance to develop one. Grade: C+

Quincy Roche, OLB (6, 218) — For a team desperately wanting a backup behind T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith, the Steelers waited a long time to find one. But Roche fits their classic mold — a converted defensive end with the explosiveness to rush the passer. Roche had 4 ½ sacks and 14 ½ tackles for loss after transferring from Temple. He will be given every chance to be their No. 3 OLB. Grade: C+

Advertise with us

Tre Norwood, DB (7a, 245) — Norwood is viewed as a cornerback, but he also played safety at Oklahoma. He bounced back from an ACL injury in 2019 to have the second-most interceptions (5) in the NCAA last season. At best, Norwood’s athleticism makes him a candidate to play in the dime defense. The Steelers will settle for hoping he can provide some young depth at a position that is down two players. Grade: C

Pressley Harvin III, P (7b, 254) -— This might be the most interesting pick in the draft — a thick 260-pound punter who can throw the ball at least 50 yards in the air. Harvin averaged 48 yards per attempt last season while winning the Ray Guy Award as the nation’s best punter. Like Harris, the Steelers got the best player at his position and an expected starter. For the 254th overall pick, that’s a big win. Grade: A

Overall: Starting the draft with four offensive players was as surprising as it was rare. Yes, two of the picks were a necessity — getting a No. 1 running back and a replacement for Maurkice Pouncey — but each of the four picks only further highlights the Steelers’ intention to change the running game and the overall scheme up front. Waiting six rounds to find a backup for the most important position on defense was probably not ideal, though that might be offset if Johnson develops into a future starter at ILB. Make no mistake, getting Harris near the bottom of the first round qualifies the draft as an instant success. What’s more, it’s not every day a team finds a starter in the seventh round. From where they were drafting, getting three potential starters for 2021 out of nine picks isn’t bad. Grade: A

Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac.