For a little more than the decade, the Steelers have changed how they approach planning for the first round of the draft. Used to be, they would spend days conducting any number of mock drafts with their coaches, scouts and general manager, trying to predict and get ready for any possible scenario.
Not anymore.
“It was a complete waste of time,” general manager Kevin Colbert said.
Predicting what will happen in the first round of the NFL draft has the same accountability as a 10-day weather forecast. You might get the first couple right, but one storm of trades or a surprise selection (Darrius Heyward-Bey?) and everybody’s plans are disrupted.
What the Steelers do now is compile the number of players with first-round grades that matches their spot in the draft. So, with the 24th overall selection, they have compiled a list of 24 players whom they deem worthy of their first pick, regardless of position. That way, one of those players will be available to them.
“We’ll have 24 guys in an order that we would take them, and it’s not necessarily the order that you have on your board,” Colbert said. “So the order of the picks is set and you just wait and watch, and the only decision you have to make is whether you’re going to trade up or trade back. It doesn’t matter what happens in front of you because you’ve already made that decision.”
Read More
Colbert has already said the Steelers will not trade up in the draft as they did to get players such as Devin Bush (2019), Santonio Holmes (2006) and Troy Polamalu (2003). There is always a possibility they would trade back to either acquire extra draft picks or move up in another round. That would make the most sense if it allowed them to move up from the 55th spot in the second round.
So, as the first round of the draft approaches Thursday night, this much is known about what the Steelers would like to do:
Of the top 24 players they have listed, two of them are running backs — Najee Harris of Alabama and Travis Etienne of Clemson. And with the significant focus of the offseason on fixing the running game, the final piece of the puzzle is finding the player who will complete the rebuilding.
Yes, there is always the possibility of a tackle or center on the first round, but there are several factors suggesting that won’t happen.
The Steelers think they have two starting tackles on their roster — Chukwuma Okorafor and Zach Banner — and they signed Joe Haeg in free agency to be their swing tackle. If the Steelers are serious about thinking they can contend again in the AFC North — and bringing back Ben Roethlisberger, JuJu Smith-Schuster and Vince Williams would suggest they are — then they need to find players who can come in and start immediately.
Nonetheless, here are a couple names to keep in mind later: Alex Leatherwood of Alabama, Samuel Cosmi of Texas, Walker Little of Stanford.
Which leads us to center.
The best center in the draft is Alabama’s Landon Dickerson, a first-round talent for sure. But his history of knee problems — two ACL surgeries — make him in the eyes of NFL coaches and general managers a one-contract player, meaning he might have a hard time lasting more than five years in the league. That is a risky investment for a first-round pick.
More than likely, Dickerson and the other top centers in the draft — Oklahoma’s Creed Humphrey and Stanford’s Drew Dalman — can be had on the second round. Keep in mind, too, that since the Steelers’ selected Maurkice Pouncey with the 18th overall pick in the 2010 draft, only seven centers have been selected in the first round. They are not desirable commodities on opening night. The Steelers will wait a day to make that selection.
OK, consider other positions that have been suggested in any of the countless mock drafts conducted around the country:
Outside linebacker? It’s the most important position on the defense and a spot in need of a backup behind T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith. But the Steelers won’t use a top pick on a backup.
Inside linebacker? Bringing back Williams on a one-year deal precludes the immediate need to find someone there. His return allows Robert Spillane to be a backup at both inside positions. Again, if the Steelers are all in in 2021, drafting a backup with the first pick is not in their plans.
Cornerback? With their draft history? Uh, no.
Which brings us back to their most likely landing spot: running back.
Because the NFL game has become more vertical than horizontal, the value of running backs in the first round has decreased immeasurably. Only eight have been selected in the first round the past five years, just one in each of the past two years.
The Steelers have four running backs on their roster — Benny Snell, Anthony McFarland Jr., Jaylen Samuels and free-agent pickup Kalen Ballage — but none are considered feature backs. That they elected not to re-sign James Conner and let him leave in free agency was a strong indication they are looking for a No. 1 running back, a potential three-down player who meshes with Mike Tomlin’s bell-cow philosophy.
Harris and Etienne check that box.
Which player they pick will serve to foreshadow what type of offense the Steelers plan to run under new coordinator Matt Canada. It is already known there will be a lot of motion and pre-snap shifts — elements he hoped to infuse last year when he was the quarterbacks coach. If part of the change in scheme involves more wide-zone run blocking with new offensive line coach Adrian Klemm, Etienne might be the better fit.
If the Steelers still want to maintain some semblance of power football to complement their motion, then the 232-pound Harris would be the better fit.
It is possible some team that drafts before them could make their choice an easy one, leaving them just one of the two backs on the board. Of course, it is also possible both backs could be gone at No. 24, forcing the Steelers to look in another direction in the first round, though the likelihood of both being off the board is slim at best.
But what happens if both backs are available at No. 24? What then?
One thing is almost certain: Barring a strange turn of events that can sometimes occur in the first round, the Steelers will draft a running back.
The pick: If he is there, it will be Najee Harris.
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.