The Cowboys had never used Garrett Gilbert in a game, and Gilbert had never made a start in the NFL. And yet, there he was, a seventh-year journeyman quarterback who has played for eight teams and two professional football leagues at the age of 29, trying to lead “America’s Team” on a two-minute drill, followed by a 38-second drill for the win.
“They did a really nice job changing looks up,” Gilbert said of the Steelers defense. “And I was really proud of our guys, especially up front, the way they communicated and got us out of some bad plays and into some better plays.”
Gilbert had two previous run-ins with the Steelers, not counting a regular season game in which he threw an interception to practice squad linebacker Matt Galambos. Perhaps you remember him taking the final snap last year in Cleveland after the on-field brawl. And if not, it was also Gilbert who threw two incompletions in relief of an injured Baker Mayfield at the end of the first half last season in the rematch with the Browns at Heinz Field.
With the Browns off this week, and Mayfield placed on the reserve/COVID-19 list Sunday morning, he made no secret that he was watching his former backup face the team leading his division.
“LETS GO GARRETT!!!!!” Mayfield tweeted at 4:37 p.m., right around the time it became apparent that Gilbert might actually be able to have some success against arguably the best defense in the NFL.
A five-star recruit in the class of 2009 who played in college at Texas and SMU, Gilbert had 243 yards, one touchdown and one interception on 21-of-38 passing. Not the prettiest stat line, but maybe most important for Gilbert is that he was only sacked twice by the league’s most pressure-happy defense. In the end, it still wasn’t enough for the two-touchdown underdogs to come out on top.,
Read More
“Losing sucks,” said Gilbert, who went unbeaten as a starter in the Alliance of American Football two years ago. “I felt like our guys played really hard today and played really well and we deserved a chance to win that game. Obviously, we gave ourselves that chance, but it’s just tough when all of us together put everything into that thing and come up short.”
Local ties
Cowboys coach Mike McCarthy, Greenfield’s favorite son, fell to 1-4 all time against the Steelers as a head coach. Of course, his one victory was with the Packers in Super Bowl XLV.
Dallas linebacker Sean Lee, an Upper St. Clair and Penn State graduate, played against his hometown team for the second time in his 11-year NFL career. In his second game back from hernia surgery, he played sparingly and finished with one tackle.
Pine-Richland product Ben DiNucci, who also played at Pitt before transferring to James Madison, was inactive after starting last week for the Cowboys at quarterback. DiNucci was a seventh-round pick in April.
And how about this for a (literal) local connection? On the third punt of the game for the Steelers, Jordan Berry’s 62-yard rocket was caught by receiver Cedrick Wilson Jr., who fired a lateral throw almost all the way across the field to C.J. Goodwin, a reserve defensive back and special teams ace who returned it 83 yards to the Steelers 11 (although an illegal block negated a chunk of those yards). Wilson’s father was a Steelers wideout from 2005-07, and Goodwin is a Wheeling, W.Va., native who played football at Cal U before spending the 2014 season on the Steelers practice squad as an undrafted free agent.
Other Pittsburgh ties with the Cowboys include McCarthy’s defensive line coach, Steel Valley High School alumnus Jim Tomsula, and senior vice president of public relations/communications Rich Dalrymple, who played quarterback at North Hills High School and Westminster College.
McCarthy takes high road
Even as his first season in Dallas gets worse from a record standpoint, McCarthy wasn’t about to complain about how this one finished. Asked about two fourth-quarter penalties against his defense — an unnecessary roughness call on Leighton Vander Esch that moved the Steelers into field goal range and a roughing the passer flag on Jaylon Smith that extended the next drive on third down — he reiterated what he told his players after the game.
“I’ll tell you what, you can write on it as much as you want. Go for it. As I told our football team, we need to focus on the things we can do better,” McCarthy said. “What was called, what wasn't called, we don't have control of that.”
McCarthy also faced a question about his decision to kick a 39-yard field goal with 2:13 left in the third quarter. The easy three points ensured the Cowboys a two-score lead at 19-9, but they had fourth-and-1 at the Steelers 22 and they’d just converted two consecutive third-down attempts.
“You don't just make fourth-down decisions off an analytics book,” McCarthy said. “There’s other factors involved.”
Texas forever
Sunday was a mixed bag in the Lone Star State for a couple of Steelers who know it well. Wide receiver James Washington caught a 17-yard touchdown with 1:10 left in the first half, his first catch since Week 6 and third score of the year after playing just 28 snaps over the past two games. Washington is from Stamford, Texas, about two and a half hours from Dallas.
Kicker Chris Boswell, who’s from Fort Worth, missed the ensuing extra point. But he redeemed himself as time expired in the first half by crushing a career-best and franchise-long 59-yard field goal through the uprights to make it 13-9, which came only after he missed a 54-yarder that was wiped out by a false start penalty on Cam Heyward. Boswell’s previous long was a 53-yarder in 2017 — to beat the Green Bay Packers coached by Mike McCarthy.
But Boswell was displeased again nine seconds into the fourth quarter when he failed to convert another extra point, this one blocked by Cowboys defensive lineman Tyrone Crawford after Crawford shot the gap between long-snapper Kameron Canaday and rookie guard Kevin Dotson. That special teams gaffe left the Steelers down, 19-18, and loomed large during the comeback. The extra points gone wrong were the first missed kicks of any kind for Boswell (still 100% on field goals) since he missed a point-after attempt in the season opener, and it was the first time he had a kick blocked since a 24-21 loss at Oakland in Week 14 of 2018.
Rudolph’s return
Steelers backup quarterback Mason Rudolph saw his most extensive action since becoming the starter last season, completing 2 of 3 passes for 3 yards while replacing Ben Roethlisberger in the final minute of the first half. Roethlisberger exited early with a knee injury. Rudolph technically led a scoring drive, as his 52 seconds of action led to Boswell’s 59-yard field goal.
Rudolph’s only other appearance this season came in mop-up duty against the Browns, when he completed his only pass for 6 yards. He then finished the game with three kneel-downs.
Canadians, eh?
One player who showed up big for the Cowboys in the early going was rookie defensive lineman Neville Gallimore, a third-round pick out of Oklahoma. Gallimore had three tackles, one tackle for loss and a quarterback hit, all in the first half.
He and Steelers wideout Chase Claypool — who set a career high with eight receptions and 13 targets — were the only two Canadians drafted in 2020. Gallimore is from Ottawa, Claypool from British Columbia. And how’s this for international flavor? The Cowboys have two other players from north of the border in Crawford, who had the blocked extra point, and long-snapper L.P. Ladouceur. There were only four Canadians on NFL rosters to start the season.
Williamson sits
In his first game as a Steeler, new inside linebacker Avery Williamson was active but was the only player not to touch the field. Williamson was not expected to play on defense unless there was an injury, but he didn’t see any special teams time, either. Due to COVID-19 protocols, Williamson could not join the Steelers in person until Saturday. He attended virtual meetings during the week.
The Steelers were without two defensive starters. Slot corner Mike Hilton was out for a third consecutive game due to a shoulder injury and Cam Sutton took his place on again in the nickel package. Justin Layne remained the extra corner when the Steelers played their dime defense. Nose tackle Tyson Alualu also did not play due to a knee injury. Second-year lineman Isaiah Buggs took his place in the lineup, but Henry Mondeaux was also involved. And rookie seventh-rounder Carlos Davis made his debut while finishing with two tackles and one for loss.
Quick hits
Rookie Alex Highsmith got an early sack to extend the Steelers’ streak to 65 consecutive games, now tied for the longest in franchise history. ... Per the NFL Media Research Department, Ben now owns the record most career seasons without playing on a sub-.500 team in league history. ... The last time the Steelers rallied from 10-point deficits two road games in a row was 1953. ... Steelers coach Mike Tomlin tied Marty Schottenheimer for the most consecutive non-losing seasons to start a career with 14.
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.