Welcome to Brian Batko’s offseason-occasional Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds.

Let’s get started, and don’t forget to join us on our weekly all-sports podcast, The North Shore Drive, whether you use Apple, Spotify or any of the other major podcasting platforms.

John in NYC: Do you think that Kevin Dotson will start? I love how he plays the game.

Brian: He’ll have competition from all angles when you consider the signing of veteran Stefen Wisniewski, the ability Matt Feiler has to play guard and the possibility of Chuks Okorafor or Zach Banner winning the right tackle job. Something that might be worth noting about Dotson is that while he played right guard exclusively in college, his quarterback last year was left-handed, in case that helps a potential flip to the other side of the line in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

But let’s extrapolate your question to consider all the rookies on this team, and what the virtual offseason program might mean — or not mean — for their chances of being able to contribute right away. The best comparison we have for this is the 2011 offseason, when the league was mired in a labor dispute and operated similarly from a locked-out perspective.

Much like this year, in 2011, the NFL staged the draft, then came to a screeching halt. Free agents were in limbo, as were undrafted rookies, and those who did hear their names called couldn't have contact with their new teams. As will be the case this month and next, 2011 witnessed no rookie camps, no OTAs, no veteran minicamps around the league. Some players got together for workouts on their own, which isn't as feasible right now, but then again, rookies and free agents couldn't enjoy Zoom learning back then.

Anyway, it’s not as if losing the entire offseason until training camp opened in late July wiped out the Steelers’ draft class from contributing in 2011. First-rounder Cam Heyward didn't do much, but these were the Dick LeBeau days, when Steelers rookies rarely stepped in and made an impact on defense in their first seasons. It was actually a couple of third- and fourth-round cornerbacks named Curtis Brown and Cortez Allen who made more tackles than Heyward that year.

Two other draft picks were either cut or placed on injured reserve coming out of training camp, but the Steelers’ second-rounder proved to be an immediate success story, even without a typical rookie introduction to the NFL. Marcus Gilbert was a quick enough study to lock down a backup job, then take over as the starting right tackle in Week 2 and hold it down the rest of the way for a team that finished 12-4 to reach the playoffs.

It might be easier to do what Gilbert did than for Chase Claypool or Anthony McFarland to establish a firm rapport with Ben Roethlisberger while learning the ins and outs of the playbook, especially if training camp and/or the preseason are dramatically different. But it’s one parallel we can draw from the only situation like this in recent years, and should be reason not to write off Dotson as a camp competitor, assuming there is a camp.

Advertise with us

Bill in Erie: Brian thanks for the chats. Won’t our running game improve with a lineup of Claypool, Ebron, McDonald, JuJu and Watt on the field blocking for Conner, Snell, McFarland, et al.?

Brian: Unless they're going direct snaps to the tailbacks with no quarterback in sight, it’s going to be tough to get all six of those blockers on the field at the same time.

But in all seriousness, Mike Tomlin and Kevin Colbert have probably used the word “physical” more than any other to describe Claypool’s game and what they like about it. Eric Ebron’s addition should allow the Steelers to get back to playing more often with two tight ends, something they did more than all but a few teams two years ago with Jesse James and Vance McDonald. And Derek Watt is being paid like someone who will have a larger role at fullback than Roosevelt Nix enjoyed the past couple seasons.

This is why moves like signing Claypool and Ebron have been met with pretty positive reviews, at least locally. The Steelers’ M.O. since the end of last season has been to improve their woeful ground game from 2019, but the double-edged sword there is that your team is still built around Ben Roethlisberger, so it makes sense to upgrade his supporting cast any way you can. Most of the offensive moves made this offseason seem to be trying to check both those boxes, maybe more so than drafting a gadget-type playmaker or bruising workhorse running back would have.

Rick in Orlando: Who will be the odd man out in the RB battle?

Advertise with us

Brian: Well, the first question is really how many running backs the Steelers will wind up keeping. The last two years, the Steelers came into the regular season with four, and that was including Nix at fullback in addition to James Conner, Jaylen Samuels and Benny Snell.

By the end of last season, the Steelers were carrying five true running backs on their active roster, adding Trey Edmunds and Kerrith Whyte to the above trio. Of course, that was largely a byproduct of Conner’s injury-plagued campaign, Whyte’s return ability, Edmunds’ special teams prowess and even, to an extent, Nix’s season-long absence.

Now, you add McFarland into the equation, plus Watt as a fullback guaranteed to make the 53-man squad. There’s no way they keep six ball-carriers. They could carry five if they skimp on some other positions, but the guess here is four plus Watt, with McFarland bumping out Whyte and Edmunds. McFarland can replace Whyte as a change-up option in the offense and as kick returner. The special teams units will move on without Edmunds as a do-everything grinder. Given Snell’s tough running and Samuels’ pass-catching, those two figure to be safe for at least one more year. And Conner is your No. 1.

Be sure to compliment Joe Starkey. Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.