Notre Dame's Brian Kelly: Chase Claypool answers the bell every week
Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to the chat. Post your questions and we’ll get started soon.
Baghdad_Ben: One fact no other team can say - the Steelers have a pro bowler with one of their 2020 picks. Using that #1 on Fitzpatrick has to be considered when grading this draft. I like it on paper but time will tell.
Ray Fittipaldo: Not only Pro Bowl but All-Pro. You make that trade 10 times out of 10.
Tampa Too: Ray Since there is a good chance the season may be shortened and some exhibition games may be cancelled do you believe that it will be harder this year for an undrafted free agent to make the team?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes. Undrafted free agents need OTAs, minicamp and a full training camp to impress the coaches. Unfortunately, that’s going to be a byproduct of this pendemic if camps are shortened. Also, rookies, not matter their pedigree, are going to see their progress slowed. They might not get on the field as quickly as they normally might.
Tampa Too: I find it rather silly to “grade” a draft class immediately because it takes a minimum of 2 to 4 years to really evaluate the picks. With that being said how would you grade the Steeler’s 2016 and 2017 drafts? Thanks and stay safe!
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: The 2016 class: C. People read this and think no one is left. How can it be a C? That’s true, but Javon Hargrave was a four-year starter and a big contributor the past few seasons. Sean Davis was a three-year starter before his season-ending injury. Maybe not a great one but good enough to start. Artie Burns was a bust so he brings the grade down. Obviously, you’d like to re-sign at least one or two guys from a draft class, but that wasn’t in the cards for a variety of reasons. As for the 2017 class, it’s probably an A-. Watt is a budding superstar and Smith-Schuster has been to a Pro Bowl. So has James Conner. Plenty to like about that class. I was curious about how people graded the 2017 class right after the draft. One guy from SI gave the Smith-Schuster pick a C+. I think he was wrong. LOL.
Tampa Too: If Conner has an injury free very productive year this season would you offer him an extension?
Ray Fittipaldo: Depends on the season but probably not. You don’t see a lot of RBs get second contracts with their original teams.
Ray Fittipaldo: News just came across that the Steelers exercised the fifth-year option on T.J. Watt’s rookie contract. Obviously a no-brainer. Now it’s time to sign him to a second contract.
InvisibleInterruptingPenguin: Were you surprised the Steelers went with Claypool over Dobbins, and then drafted a running back later?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not really. It was going to be a WR or RB all along. I liked Cam Akers more than Dobbins and apparently others did, too. He was taken about six or seven spots ahead of Dobbins. I just think Colbert thought the offense needed a deep threat to open up the passing and running game.
livinthedream: Ray, really enjoyed your podcast on the draft. My question relates to someone we didn’t draft. Joseph Charlton is the punter at SC. He has no problem kicking 60 plus yards or getting in inside the 20, he has had only one blocked and his average is 47 yards. Instead the steelers bring in a young man who did not play last year and whose numbers don’t compare to Charlton’s. What am I missing?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers only had six picks. It’s hard to spend one of those on a punter when there were so many other needs to fill. Maybe they’ll go out and sign Dustin Colquitt. He was cut by the Chiefs today. His father, Craig, played for the Steelers and won a couple of Super Bowls as their punter.
Thomas: Any chance the FA punter makes the team over Berry?
Ray Fittipaldo: That didn’t take long, did it? Two early questions about the punter. Maybe Thomas, but as I mentioned earlier undrafted free agents might have a tough time opening the eyes of coaches this year if camps are shortened.
Jeff: Thanks for the chats Ray. Overall I feel pretty good with draft minus the RB pick. What were your thoughts? Were we close to getting Fournette?
Ray Fittipaldo: I never got that idea. As for McFarland, he’s a change of pace guy to complement the others. Don’t think he’ll have a big role as a rookie unless there are injuries. We’ll see.
John in Hbg: Why is everyone always so quick to praise the Ravens after every draft and say that they draft better than the Steelers? Since their Super Bowl win in 2012, they have 1 playoff win and missed the playoffs 3years in a row (2015-2017).
Ray Fittipaldo: That might be true, but I agree with the people who said the Ravens had a good draft this year. They drafted Patrick Queen and Malik Harrison to play inside linebacker and they also got receiver Devin Duvernay. It also helps they had many more picks than the Steelers. By the way, drafting well doesn’t mean your team is going to do well in the playoffs.
Lenny from NY: Good afternoon Ray. If Carr or Trubunski become available before the season starts, do you think the Steelers should or could go after them. Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: I don’t think so. Carr would cost some $ as a backup and not sure Trubisky would be a better option than Mason Rudolph.
PGH Kid in Cleveland: Ray: Steelers did not draft a QB nor sign one as an Undrafted Free Agent. I would have loved to see Jameis Winston be the #2 on the depth chart but could we still be in the market to sign a proven NFL QB to join the Black N Gold and if so....Who is your top choices?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don’t think they’ll sign a QB unless Ben experiences some elbow discomfort and they’re worried about that.
Retire21: No one had Claypool at that spot. Did the Steelers revert to need rather than rating at 3
Ray Fittipaldo: No, the Steelers liked Claypool.
Lloyd’s 3-Count: If Claypool is to see offensive snaps, whose is he taking?
Ray Fittipaldo: They’ll find playing time for a player that can stretch the defense and make some big plays. Maybe a little from Washington, Switzer, etc.
Picksixlisberger: Ray, What are the chances that Claypool ends up as a tight end in a few years? Could be Antonio Gateslike.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don’t get the idea the Steelers have those plans at all. Randy Fichtner talked about him being an outside WR, where he is most comfortable. I even asked his WRs coach at ND about that. Del Alexander said he’s a receiver at the next level.
Abbotsford: Shout out to the steeler nation from Abbotsford. Hometown of our steeler star Chase. Stay safe. Go Steelers.
Ray Fittipaldo: New Steelers fans in British Columbia. Welcome to the chat!
Rick Sunner in Orlando: Hi Ray! Thanks for the chat. Have the Steelers reached out to Barron about resigning with the Steelers? Seems like a mutual fit if no one else has/will sign him for more money.
Ray Fittipaldo: That seems like it might make some sense, but I haven’t heard any rumblings that might happen. maybe closer to camp especially if things aren’t going well in camp.
BB: Ray - Thanks for the draft coverage you have done. Isn’t McFarland just more of what the Steelers already have? I don’t understand that pick when you had a shot at a true three down back earlier. Do you see any of these 2020 picks helping to win any games this year? The boss, AR II, said we have to get better in the run game...it doesn’t appear that anyone was listening?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Claypool has a chance for early playing time. I wrote about that today: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2020/04/28/chase-claypool.... As for the run game, like I said earlier, maybe Ben’s return and Claypool’s presence will open things up. But yeah they didn’t address the run game early in the draft.
Lloyd’s 3-Count: Is Dotson the steal of the draft?
Ray Fittipaldo: Time will tell, but a lot of people are high on him. Looking forward to watching him compete in camp.
Lloyd’s 3-Count: No 1st rounder, two Terrapins, a walk-on from Charlotte and a Canadian. Sounds like a bad joke. What’s the punchline?
Ray Fittipaldo: Bill Belichcik picked a safety from a Division II school in the second round. Sometimes you have to find players at smaller, lesser-known schools.
Where’s My Clark Bar: Kudos to you and BB for the draft coverage. What options do the Steelers have for the ILB position? Even without injuries it is a weak area that could severely hamper this defense.
Ray Fittipaldo: Actually lots of options, but we’ll see how it plays out. Devin Bush obviously is ready for a bigger role so he can pick up some of those snaps from Barron. But you still need Ulysees Gilbert or Marcus Allen or Antoine Brooks to step up. Or maybe safety Terrell Edmunds plays the Barron role and they insert someone like Cam Sutton as the deep safety on those downs. Again, not sure how effective any of these options will be, but they do have plenty of options.
Oscar Goldman: Hey Ray, any news on Ben’s Bionic Arm?
Ray Fittipaldo: The $35 million dollar man. And no new news. Everything appears on track for him to be ready when the games start.
Steeltyke: Ray, Gerry Dulac said prior to the draft that the Steelers should draft a No.1 back with pick 49 or not draft one at all. So is drafting McFarland in Round 4 a wasted pick?
Ray Fittipaldo: I’m not going to wasted pick, but I hope there is a plan for him. On the surface it seems like they’re just throwing numbers at the position.
Utah Jim: I was disappointed when they took a WR with some of the top RBs still on the board, but I really liked the McFarland pick. Could the Steelers be moving to more of a committee approach that other teams have used with success? I know Tomlin prefers a bell cow, but with Conner’s durability it might be the smart move.
Ray Fittipaldo: That’s a good question, Utah Jim. As you say, Tomlin has never been a back by committee coach. So it would definitely represent a change in his approach to the offense. Maybe he’ll evolve some, but we’ll see.
Utah Jim: Follow up question. If the Steelers do move to a committee approach does that make it more likely they keep Whyte? He could be the speed backup to McFarland with Snell the power back up to Conner. Maybe Samuels is the odd man out unless they keep five plus Watt.
Ray Fittipaldo: To me, McFarland and Whyte are similar so Whyte might be the odd man out. Samuels does offer the best hands of any RB on the roster and he’s a matchup problem for some defenses.
Tunger Gewd: Some national sportswriters suggest Claypool will get converted to a TE? No way that happens right? Maybe run some TE routes, but I’ve heard no one from Steelers suggest this.
Ray Fittipaldo: No one from the Steelers has suggested it. It’s all about labels I suppose. Down the line they certainly could ask him to line up in the slot and play like a pass-catching TE. But to start with, according to Randy Fichtner, he’s going to be an outside WR. Once he learns the playbook they’ll ask him to learn all the WR positions, including slot.
Ohio Chuck: Would you consider the OL pretty much set now going into camp? Al, Wis, MP, DeCastro, Feiler. Dotson backup OG, Banner extra sub OT, Oks as backup swing OT.
Ray Fittipaldo: That’s a pretty good guess. It appears Dotson’s selection points to Feiler staying at tackle, but we’ll see in camp.
Hugh Felter: Are people forgetting James Conner was a Pro Bowler 2 years ago? He’s gets injured, and needs capable back-ups, but the Steelers were not desperate for a RB.
Ray Fittipaldo: Conner is a good back. Can be effective when healthy. Honestly, they could have upgraded if they took one of those backs in round 2, but they decided on WR instead.
DaquidoBazzini: Greetings, Ray - I thought the Steeler draft went pretty well, but I’m concerned about NT and ILB. Do you think we have in house help, or might they try to get outside help? Any ideas?
Ray Fittipaldo: They already acquired Wormley to add depth. Alualu and McCullers will be the nose tackles. Unless there are injuries I don’t see them making other moves on the DL.
SPIKE: Did the Jaguars trade Fournette ?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not unless it happened during this chat.
lamberto58: still no real nose tackle??
lamberto58: what am I missing here???
Ray Fittipaldo: Alualu has played there. So has McCullers. Only need them for 20-2 snaps per game, maybe more depending on the opponent.
Nate: Hi Ray, I hope JuJu sees more time in the slot with the selection of Claypool. I know Steelers will use JuJu everywhere, but I felt he was more effective in the slot with his size. What are you thoughts? Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, with Claypool being an outside WR, I think you’ll definitely see more of that. Diontae Johnson might even get some reps inside. He’s a good route runner too. Plenty of options for Ike Hilliard and Randy Fichtner.
Guest: Ray, Will the Duck still be quacking come the season opener?
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe with a clipboard in his hands
Ryan: Ray I dont get a lot of the negativity from fans about the draft, I thought Kevin and Co did a really good job this year, big red zone weapon with speed for Ben, a potential starter at OLB, home run threat RB, likely future starter at Guard, what’s with all the negativity?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think with six picks fans were always going to be disappointed, especially with no first-round pick.
Nate: Hi Ray, with selection of Dotson, does that mean the Steelers would like to keep Feiler at RT? Or was Dotson just the best olineman available at that pick? Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: Feiler still has that versatility, but Shaun Sarrett said Dotson will have an opportunity to compete at guard. I honestly don’t think the coaches want a three-way competition so I’m leaning toward Feiler staying at RT and Winiewski and Dotson competing to take Foster’s spot.
DK: Do you see the Steelers locking up both Dupree and Watt long term?
Ray Fittipaldo: Definitely Watt. I think they’ll try with Dupree, but there was a reason Highsmith was taken in the third round.
pdxJaxon: Ray Im confused....when folks discuss Edmunds filling in for the role of Barron at ILB, they say that Cam Sutton will have to fill in at Deep Safety....where is Minkah in this scenario ?
Ray Fittipaldo: Minkah is still on the field. Sutton would play “strong” and Minkah free.
Cq: Is there a reason the Steelers aren’t trying to extend JuJu now? Seems like they would be in a better financial position to do so after a down year. It seems like they will want him long term.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they probably want to take care of Heyward first and then see where they are with the cap this year as well as in the future.
Rick from Irwin: Besides adding 2 players to the rosters, is there a plan to expand the practice squads?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes from 10 to 12 this year and 14 by 2022 or 2023.
Guest: Ray, Conner staying healthy is only one of his issues. Holding on to the ball is another. Cost them some big games. He would be good back not the man. Hope Mc Farland is a surprise.
Ray Fittipaldo: Agree. Fumbling, especially at inopportune times, has been a problem for Conner. He has to clean that up.
exiled in the south: what’s the delay with getting an extension for cam hayward? the steelers could use a little wiggle room on the cap, maybe to sign one more depth-type veteran (i’d still like to see a barron return if he could be had on the cheap), and beyond restructuring tuft and decastro, there aren’t many more options for creating cap room.
Ray Fittipaldo: They can extend Heyward anytime up until the start of the season. No real hurry in doing that unless, of course, they want to sign more free agents, and I don’t get that idea right now.
Lloyd’s 3-Count: Is Antoine Brooks the LB/S hybrid folks have been hoping for in Edmunds?
Ray Fittipaldo: He’s a sixth-round pick. You don’t ask sixth-round picks to come in and contribute as rookies. Not unless you are really desperate. Marcus Allen was a fifth-round pick in 2018 and has barely played.
Carolina Steeler: Hi Ray! Thoughts on Claypool’s hands and ball skills? I heard a lot about size and speed. As Zeise outlined in his article, Steelers have a bad habit of picking lots of athlete’s who can’t catch.
Ray Fittipaldo: Bryant had that knock too. Lots of times NFL teams believe they can correct that with extra work on the JUGS machine and extra coaching.
Sergio: Do you think Kerrith Whyte and McFarland both make the team as they basically have the same running style and speed? Thank you Ray.
Ray Fittipaldo: I doubt it. I think they’re similar players. Maybe keep Whyte on the practice squad if they can sneak him through waivers.
Carolina Steeler: Ray, don’t know a ton about Claypool’s skills. yes, big and fast. do u know about his hands and can he catch? Reading Zeise’s article on history of drafting receivers with BAD hands...always makes me wonder. Add Antonio Bryant to the list of bad hands to the ones he named!
Ray Fittipaldo: I don’t remember hearing about hands being an issue with JuJu or Diontae Johnson. I mean, sure we can cherry pick some guys like Sammie Coates and Limas Sweed, but it’s hard to argue with their success drafting receivers over the years.
Nate: Hi Ray, on his podcast, Mark Madden stated that JuJu is gone after this year, no matter how he plays. Have you heard anything? Or what are your thoughts? Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: No. If JuJu has a good year and they can’t re-sign him they can always franchise him.
livinthedream: Ray, Charlton is still out there. Invite him to compete. Why not?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don’t profess to know much about college punters, but since all other 31 teams decided not to draft him or sign him then maybe he’s not good?
NY steelers: So what’s the real catch about Claypool? That combine with that production, yet considered a reach in the second round? What am I missing?
Ray Fittipaldo: Honestly, I haven’t heard much about him being a reach, I know the Steelers are satisfied with the pick and where they got him.
Ryan: With the signing of Claypool, that probably means the chances of Cain sticking around over Switzer Is close to -0- unfortunately... agreed?
Ray Fittipaldo: Probably but you never know. Might come down to Cain or Switzer.
Dennis: Ray, enjoyed your article on Chase clay pool, it got me excited to have a player who could open up space foe D Johnson, Ju Ju and company
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks! It’s always good to look back on history to figure out how the Steelers might use players. They haven’t been shy about playing their rookies WRs, have they?
NY steelers: What is the point of drafting a RB In the middle rounds seemingly every year? They are all more or less the same and the position can be competently filled inexpensively thru free agency? I don’t get it
Ray Fittipaldo: Throwing numbers at a position and hoping one of them stands out?
Jeff M: I have heard Carlos Davis in the 7th round will have a lot of trouble making the team cause DT don’t play ST. All 7th rd picks are iffy. But if his 4.7 40 is legit why couldn’t he be involved in ST?
Ray Fittipaldo: Like Orpheus Roye!
Bones: your best guess: Full NFL Season, Truncated Season of 10 games. or less than 10 games
Ray Fittipaldo: Of those three choices: full season. But I could see a 12 or 14-game season if the testing isn’t to a better capacity by August or September.
NY steelers: After seeing him for a season, any concern about Bush’s size in playing ILB?
Ray Fittipaldo: He’s always going to have to deal with that especially against heavy teams that want to run the ball down your throat.
Aaron Smith fan: Ray, what do you feel realistic expectations should be for Derwin Gray, both in 2020 and beyond?
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, he was on the practice squad all season. I see him as more of a guard than a tackle, so I don’t think Dotson’s selection is good news for him.
NY steelers: I liked the minkah trade the day it was made. That said, his splash plays dwindled by the end of the year. Do you think that he played as well to the end and was the missing piece of the defense as we are led to believe, or did his play worsen and all the praise is due to his early production?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think opposing Qbs saw he was making big plays every week and decided to stay away from him.
TC: Hi Ray, In your humble opinion, why, specifically, didn’t the Steelers take Akers or Dobbins?
Ray Fittipaldo: I just think they believed Claypool would help the offense more.
Jeff M: I am haiving trouble thinking of a player, except maybe Megatron, that had sustained NFL success at Claypools size. Can you think of any? Also, several scouting bios I have seen say he is slow out of his breaks. Is that more important than the straight a head speed from the 40?
Ray Fittipaldo: Isn’t Julio Jones about the same size? Plenty of other lesser known guys too I am sure.
Bones: Does the 7th round pick NT have the best chance of starting this year, from this class?
Ray Fittipaldo: Um, no.
Bones: I wanted JK Dobbins in the first round. And what made it worse is Ravens got him. Talk me off the cliff.
Ray Fittipaldo: How much will he play for the Ravens? They already have Mark Ingram.
Dave: Hi Ray, no question today just a Thank You for all the mock drafts and other articles you wrote about the Steeler’s draft.
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for reading them!
Franco3272: Ray, do you envision alot of 2 tight sets with McDonald and Ebron circa New England in past years? Adding in Claypool that is a lot of size, especially in the red zone. Thx
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes using two tight ends causes lots of issues for defensive coordinators. Do you go dime to match up in the passing game and leave yourself vulnerable to the run? Or do you line up in base and become susceptible to the pass? Big reason why they signed Ebron.
Mary Lynn: Thanks for the chats Ray. How do you think McFarland will differ from Archer and Rainey? The Steelers haven’t had much success with the short, speedy backs other than Willie Parker perhaps.
Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. Maybe he will be different, but they haven’t had a lot of success with backs of that type, have they?
Rider Harde: Does your buddy Paul know Dri Archer was a RB? Just read this:https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/paul-zeise/2020/04/28/chase-claypo...
Ray Fittipaldo: That’s kind of a weird thing. He’s actually listed as a WR by pro football reference. Doesn’t really matter though. To Paul’s point he didn’t work out.
fLORIDA STEELERS: Ray, Thanks for the chats. I believe Joe Burrow is going to be one hell of a player for the Bengals. I also like the recent Steeler draft aside from the Maryland picks. Your thoughts please.
Ray Fittipaldo: Burrow should be a good pro. Don’t expect a lot right away though because that roster isn’t set up to win now. And I’m ok with the Steelers draft.
Lloyd’s 3-Count: Can you think of a recent receiving lineup that would match Vance, Ebron, Juju & Claypool in terms of size?
Ray Fittipaldo: And Ebron and Claypool can run too.
Need football: Given the covid situation and uncertainty, how many plays in an actual game do you think Ben will get before week 1?
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe none if there is no preseason.
exiled in the south: seems like all of the four top war’s -- juju, johnson, washington and now claypool -- are outside-type guys. so who plays the slot?
Ray Fittipaldo: JuJu can definitely thrive in the slot. And I think Diontae Johnson can move in there and have success too. Even Washington.
Cq: Do you think Claypool will fill the Gunner role on special teams that Johnny Holton had?
Ray Fittipaldo: I’m not exactly sure where he’ll line up, but I was told he’ll be a top special teams player for the Steelers as a rookie.
Nate: Hi Ray, even though Steelers drafted a safety, who is actually the backup for Minkah, if God forbid, he gets hurt? Their group of safeties lean more toward strong than free. Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: I think right now it’s Jordan Dangerfield.
Rob: Do the Steelers draft a qb next year?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that’s a good possibility, but also depends on where they’re drafting.
Ryan: Do you think we passed on Dobbins and Akers with McFarland in mind due to Tomlin and Canada’s connection to the MD program with the thinking he would be available in later rounds?
Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn’t say that, but I do think the Steelers drafted players where they had connections so Canada’s presence on the staff certainly played into those picks.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for all the questions this week. We’ll do it again next week at the same time.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.