2020 NFL draft: Steelers seeking offensive playmaker with first pick
Welcome to Brian Batko’s offseason-occasional Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds.
Let’s get started, and don’t forget to join us on our weekly all-sports podcast, The North Shore Drive, whether you use Apple, Spotify or any of the other major podcasting platforms.
Chas R.: They could use Jalen Hurts like New Orleans uses Taysom Hill and that gives us two years to get him ready to start or continue to use him that way if he is not able to start. I would only pick him with our third pick.
Brian: We’re at a point now where it seems more and more Steelers fans are talking themselves into drafting a passer, but only if it’s Jalen Hurts. It’s an interesting debate because it’s somewhat reminiscent of two years ago, when the Steelers were linked to Lamar Jackson but weren't thought to be in the market for a quarterback. Now this is not saying Hurts is Jackson, or will have the same kind of NFL success. But rather than rehash the should-they-or-shouldn't-they take Hurts topic, let’s walk through a redo of that 2018 draft, shall we?
Round 1, No. 28 overall
Real pick: Terrell Edmunds
Read More
New pick: Lamar Jackson (QB, No. 32 to Ravens)
This is the same way a 2018 redraft should begin for just about any team, rather than a specific pick for the Steelers. Jackson is coming off an MVP season. Who knows what his career would look like to this point if he went anywhere other than Baltimore, but the guess here is the Steelers could've found a way to use him as a rookie and then could've watched him take off in 2019 in place of an injured Ben Roethlisberger. Will they think about that in regard to Hurts (if they really like him)?
Round 2, No. 60 overall
Real pick: James Washington
New pick: Fred Warner (LB, No. 70 to 49ers)
Not a household name, and we’re passing up a few Pro Bowlers here, but Warner has become one of the better coverage linebackers in the league for San Francisco. The Steelers needed an inside linebacker in this draft, but didn't take one at all. Warner plays in a 4-3 defense now, but he’s been very productive and could help the Steelers linebacking corps.
Round 3, No. 76 overall
Real pick: Mason Rudolph
New pick: Michael Gallup (WR, No. 81 to Cowboys)
In a league-wide redraft, Gallup wouldn't last this long, but he was still on the board for the Steelers at this point in 2018 and that’s how we’re doing this. They drafted their quarterback of the future in the first round in this universe, so no need for Rudolph, and they went defense in Round 2, so they still need a wideout. Gallup has already been more productive than Washington anyway.
Round 3, No. 92 overall
Real pick: Chuks Okorafor
New pick: Ronnie Harrison (S, No. 93 to Jaguars)
It’s early, but it appears 2018 wasn't a great safety class after Derwin James and Minkah Fitzpatrick. That’s part of the reason the Steelers took Edmunds in real life. If we can't go back in time to sign someone other than Morgan Burnett — Tyrann Mathieu, Kenny Vaccaro or Eric Reid, to name a few free agents that year — we still need a safety. An Alabama product, Harrison is a strong safety who probably would’ve loved reuniting with his college running mate in Fitzpatrick.
Round 5, No. 148 overall
Real pick: Marcus Allen
New pick: Genard Avery (Edge, No. 150 to Browns)
One of the fun things about redoing a draft from just two years ago is it’s still somewhat early to evaluate these players. We might know who some of the stars are, but some breakouts are yet to happen. Perhaps that will be the case for Avery, who had a strip-sack against the Steelers in his NFL debut but was traded last season from the Browns to the Eagles. He could at least compete with Ola Adeniyi and Tuzar Skipper as developmental backups.
Round 6, No. 165 overall
Real pick: Jaylen Samuels
New pick: Jaylen Samuels
Let’s just roll with this one. Samuels didn't take a great leap forward in his second season, but he’s a versatile pass-catcher who still has some value in the Steelers backfield.
Round 7, No. 246 overall
Real pick: Joshua Frazier
New pick: Phillip Lindsay (RB, undrafted)
Samuels is OK, but Lindsay has been a Pro Bowl running back already for Denver. It’d be revisionist history to say Lindsay was a realistic pick, but in retrospect, it’s a no-brainer to add 2018’s best undrafted success story to the backfield. The Steelers wouldn't have needed to draft one a year later or be looking to add to the group again now.
John in Mass.: Brian, just a comment. In your podcast w/ Ray F. you stated that the Steelers passed on Darrelle Revis in the 2007 draft to draft Lawrence Timmons. In fact the Jets drafted Revis ahead of the Steelers at No. 14. The then drafted Timmons at 15. If I'm not mistaken, the Steelers were very interested in Revis and probably would have taken him if he was available
Brian: This is true. Thanks for listening to the pod, John. I wasn't clear enough in our “draft what-ifs” episode last week discussing the 2007 situation. The Steelers almost certainly would've gone with Darrelle Revis in Mike Tomlin’s first draft had he been available at No. 15, but you're right, he went one pick earlier. It’s easy to say now, but trading up to make sure they landed Revis would've been the perfect move in a year when the Steelers also made a great second-round pick in LaMarr Woodley.
Alan in Nashville: With most agreeing that Ben’s absence was the main reason for the offenses problems last year, including JuJu and the O-line underperforming, I’m not excited about spending the first pick on a WR or RB. First, without a No. 1 pick, it’s even more important that they get results right away. And that could be a pass rusher to rotate in with TJ Watt and Bud Dupree who can take over next year or even a nose. A big-time WR would take away development time for JuJu, James Washington and Diontae Johnson. A RB could be found later in the draft. What do you think?
Brian: A new receiver would only be taking away development from those guys if he proves worthy of leapfrogging them in the passing game hierarchy. If he does, then your offense should be a little more dangerous than it was a year ago.
That, to me, is the reason why you go receiver over a part-time or developmental defensive prospect, even a versatile one. Drafting a true deep threat on the outside puts some pressure on James Washington to step up more than he did a year ago. If he doesn't, you have some clarity in your wideout room going forward. If he does, now you have a four-player group that should make life easier on whoever’s under center.
As for running back, sure, you could find one later in the draft. But mid-round prospects comprise your entire backfield at this point. There’s going to come a time to invest in a clear-cut No. 1 rusher again, and the question is whether it’s this year or next. My projection is that you can get by with James Conner and Benny Snell this year shouldering most of the load, with Samuels and Kerrith Whyte in complementary roles, then let Conner get his next contract elsewhere.
Be sure to compliment Joe Starkey. Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.