The Steelers’ first pick in the NFL draft will come in the second round for the first time in decades. Here’s a look back at the highlights and lowlights of selections they’ve made in that spot over the years. The range of outcomes is stark.

Hits

1. Jack Ham, 1971 — The Johnstown native was a winner before he arrived in Pittsburgh. At Penn State, he helped lead the Nittany Lions to two undefeated seasons in 1968 and ‘69. He then made a seamless transition to the pros, starting 13 games as a rookie before maturing into one of the best defensive game-changers in league history. His Pro Football Hall of Fame bio credits him with 25 sacks — an unofficial stat at the time — 21 fumble recoveries and an incredible 31 interceptions from his outside linebacker spot. He was selected to eight Pro Bowls and six All-Pro teams. And, oh yeah, he helped the Steelers win four Super Bowl titles in the 1970s. His Hall of Fame induction in 1988 was the Steelers’ first for a second-rounder since Ernie Stautner, who we’ll get to in a bit, decades earlier.

2. Jack Lambert, 1974 — Perhaps no one is more synonymous with the dynasty-era Steelers’ tough reputation than this guy. He was a great player, to be sure. He was named NFL defensive player of the year twice and is right there with Ham in Pro Bowls (9) and All-Pro selections (6). His stats are nothing to sneeze at either. His 28 interceptions and 17 fumble recoveries would make most modern linebackers blush. If you ask most Steelers fans what they remember most, though? Simply, that he was a tough you-know-what who dealt more bone-crushing hits than perhaps anyone of his era. That’s what elevated him from merely a 1990 Hall of Fame inductee to cult hero.

Advertise with us

3. Dermontti Dawson, 1988 — The Steelers didn’t just replace the legendary Mike Webster at center with another Hall of Famer. They found a guy who helped change the way the position is played. Dawson’s unique blend of strength and athleticism gave him the ability to pull out quickly or pick up additional blocking assignments beyond those of a traditional center. The result was a dynamic running game that carried the Steelers’ offense for most of the 1990s. The Steelers did not win a Super Bowl during Dawson’s tenure, but his contributions helped get them close a few times. He went into the Hall of Fame in 2012.

4. Ernie Stautner, 1950 — He defined Steelers greatness for generations before the 1970s dynasty came along. Stats are hard to come by because many defensive categories were not official in that era. His Hall of Fame profile credits him with 23 fumble recoveries, and he notched three safeties. Fortunately, his honors tell a more complete story. Nine Pro Bowl selections. Four All-NFL honors. Best Lineman award in 1957. Hall of Fame induction in 1969. No wonder he was the first Steeler to have his number retired by the team.

5. Le’Veon Bell, 2013 — The only non-Hall of Famer on this list isn’t particularly popular in these parts because of the contract dispute that ended his Steelers career last year. Stats don’t lie, though. Bell shattered the record for scrimmage yards in his first four seasons and joined Eric Dickerson as the fastest to 7,000 total. He made three Pro Bowls and garnered two All-Pro selections in just five seasons here. And he carried the Steelers’ offense in the 2016 run to the AFC championship, rushing for 167 and 170 yards, respectively, in wins over Miami and Kansas City. He is easily the best skill position player the team has ever drafted in the second round, whether or not you’re a fan of his at this point.

Honorable mentions: JuJu Smith-Schuster (2017), Chad Brown (1993), Levon Kirkland (1992) and Carnell Lake (1989).

Misses

Advertise with us

1. Senquez Golson, 2015 — It’s not really his fault. Just legendarily bad luck, really. The Mississippi product was injured in three successive training camps after the Steelers selected him with the No. 56 overall pick in 2015. The first two injuries to his shoulder and foot, respectively, kept the cornerback completely out of action in his first two seasons. In Year 3, he ran out of time. A hamstring injury in August 2017 led to the Steelers cutting him. He never saw the field for a single snap of game action in black and gold.

2. Limas Sweed, 2008 — Prone to drops, he almost cost the Steelers the Super Bowl with an infamous one in the AFC championship against Baltimore after the 2008 season. With a minute to play before halftime and the Steelers leading, 13-7, quarterback Ben Roethlisberger found the Texas product wide open down the left sideline. And he muffed a sure touchdown in the only play you really remember him for.

Fortunately for him, the Steelers went on to beat the Ravens, then Arizona in the Super Bowl, saving him from all-time goat status. He’s still an all-time bust, though, having caught just seven regular season passes in 20 games before getting cut in 2011.

3. Alonzo Jackson, 2003 — The Steelers were loaded at linebacker in the early aughts. James Farrior, Joey Porter and Jason Gildon were just some of the Pro Bowl regulars Jackson was forced to compete with for playing time when he was drafted out of Florida State. So it’s difficult to say it really hurt the Steelers to cut him in 2005, when they had plenty of better options. Most teams just hope for more out of a second-round pick than the 24 tackles he put up in three seasons, mostly on special teams. So he’s a bust, even if there’s probably not a whole lot he really could have done about it.

4. Jeremy Staat, 1998 — The Steelers liked the defensive end almost as much as they liked future All-Pro guard Alan Faneca and so much that they traded up in the second round to select him at No. 41 overall. Needless to say, his career did not end up nearly as successful as his draft classmate’s. In fact, there was some question whether he even fit in defensive coordinator Jim Haslett’s system. In the end, he played in 29 games and started just two in three seasons here, making 30 tackles before bolting for St. Louis, then the military.

Advertise with us

5. Scott Shields, 1999 — No, we’re not talking about the baseball reliever. A year after selecting Staat, the Steelers took a chance on the 6-foot-4, 228-pound linebacker from tiny Weber State. That investment seemed to pay some early dividends — Shields played in all 16 games and racked up 43 tackles four interceptions as a rookie. The following training camp did not go well, though. Shields was benched in favor of free agent Brent Alexander. And he wasn’t happy about it.

"I'd say it was a pretty big surprise,” he told the Post-Gazette. “I had no indication. At least, they could have talked to me about it before. It's not like I haven't had talks with them. They seemed like they were pretty happy. It came as a little surprise."

That was the beginning of the end. He played sparingly in 10 games in 2000 before he was unceremoniously cut the following year. A rapid flameout after a promising start.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.