Welcome to Brian Batko’s offseason-occasional Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds.
Let’s get started, and don’t forget to join us on our weekly all-sports podcast, The North Shore Drive, whether you use Apple, Spotify or any of the other major podcasting platforms.
Liz D.: Re: Jameis Winston — why is everyone ignoring the considerable personal baggage he has? Even if he would be willing to be a backup, I don't think the Steelers want his baggage.
Brian: Perhaps it’s time we take on this Jameis Winston idea head-on in this space. Plenty of chat questions about it this week for myself, Ray Fittipaldo and Gerry Dulac. Our friends Andrew Fillipponi and Chris Mueller, “The PM Team” on 93.7 The Fan, have been discussing Winston to the Steelers for going on a month now. You need not look too hard to find national pundits calling it a good fit, but they’re driving the bandwagon locally. They ask seemingly every guest about it. Even pulled me into it last time they had me on a couple weeks ago, and my resistance was met with a great deal of hostility. Now, Bill Cowher joins their movement (sort of).
It’s become a very committed bit. Especially in this sports-less world, there’s never been a better time to gleefully beat a hot-button topic into the ground. This debate has it all. People love talking about the quarterback position, Winston is a huge name and it’s a lot more appealing to the casual fan than debating whether Chuks Okorafor or Zach Banner will win the right tackle job. For the purpose of this argument, we’ll separate it from whether Winston himself would even want to come to Pittsburgh when half the league has a less established starting quarterback. And we’ll divorce it from what the Steelers already have said publicly on the topic of signing a free agent behind Ben Roethlisberger.
While Liz’s point is only one aspect of the equation, it’s a relevant one. But the biggest is almost certainly salary cap implications, not just for the Steelers but for any team that might consider Winston. As free agency rolls along, Winston and other players on the market lose leverage by the day, but we don't know exactly how much. Let’s humor this and assume that a guy who made almost $21 million last year will take a major pay cut, and let’s assume that the Steelers could somehow fit him in on top of what it will take to sign their draft class.
Read More
How good is Winston, and do you want to hitch your wagon to him as your backup, let alone Roethlisberger’s successor? He’s a No. 1 overall pick and has thrown for nearly 20,000 yards through five seasons. Last year he led the NFL with 5,109 yards in addition to 33 touchdowns, and even with a league-leading 30 interceptions, he’s clearly a much more accomplished player than Mason Rudolph, not to mention Devlin Hodges and Paxton Lynch when you look at the Steelers backups. But look at the quarterbacks other franchises have already chosen over Winston this offseason. Philip Rivers. Ryan Tannehill. Teddy Bridgewater. Brian Hoyer? The likes of Marcus Mariota and Case Keenum have been hired for backup gigs. There has to be a reason they all were picked instead of Winston. Looking at wins for a quarterback might not be much better than looking at wins for a pitcher, but Winston’s career record is 28-42. In 2018 — that was two years ago — he was benched for Ryan Fitzpatrick, who promptly turned the job right back over to Winston.
And then, there’s the crux of the mailbag question. For an organization that in the past 13 months rid itself of Antonio Brown and Le’Veon Bell, what to make of Winston’s history as a malcontent? In terms of legal troubles, he’s probably somewhere between Brown and Bell, with a past that includes shoplifting and a sexual assault allegation (both in college) plus a 2016 groping incident that got him suspended by the NFL for the first three games of the 2018 season. It’s only fair to allow for the possibility that Winston has matured in the last three years — he’s been in the news for doing his part to help in the response to the COVID-19 situation — but he also has never been the same caliber as Brown or Bell as a player, which makes his “baggage” weigh quite a bit more.
There are plenty of other nits you could pick with Winston. He has an outsized ego. He’s had recent health issues ranging from a broken thumb to a torn meniscus to LASIK eye surgery. Even if he had a spotless background, bringing in a 26-year-old former Pro Bowler who just led the league in passing could cause at least a minor distraction in the Steelers locker room. But more than anything, while his playing style compares somewhat to Roethlisberger’s, it feels as if there’s a multitude of reasons for why this marriage won't happen — money, drama, turnovers — as opposed to one smoking gun.
Alan in Nashville: Hi Brian. I’m usually pretty in-tune with many of the Steelers decisions, even some of the unpopular ones. That being said, and I’m 50-years-old so I’ve been following for a while, I have never been so mystified by anything like the retention of Dan McCullers for 6 years. It’s not even like he has some niche specialty. And he’s no “Rudy” because many of the stories that I’ve read suggest that he’s lacked confidence, motivation and has to be closely monitored or he’ll slack off. Do you have any inside info on what exactly is going on with this or why the coaching staff feels that he’s worth the extra effort needed to get him going? Thanks!
Brian: No inside info on McCullers, really, other than that in one year covering the team, the big man hasn't struck me as someone who’s a problem as far as the things you mention. In fact, he seems to be fairly well-liked in the locker room and by Mike Tomlin. He’s quiet in-person and not at all a problem off the field. McCullers doesn't really do Twitter and Instagram. Not that that alone makes you worth keeping around, but here’s the thing: he’s never cost the Steelers all that much, either.
Last year was the first season McCullers made $1 million. That number and, accordingly, his cap hit will go up in 2020, which could make it the right time to move on from him, especially if the Steelers draft another lineman to add to the reserve group of Tyson Alualu, Isaiah Buggs and now Chris Wormley. But it’s probably not accurate to say he doesn't have a niche. If anything, a specialist is all he is, as a true nose tackle who gets dusted off to play against run-heavy teams. He can't do much else, but then again, Javon Hargrave is gone now and Buggs might not be his replacement. McCullers is simply a veteran backup making veteran backup money, but yes, his lack of upside and versatility could finally find him out of a job after the draft.
Tom D.: Brian, If Cole Kmet is available at 49 do the steelers take him?
Brian: Not now that they've acquired Eric Ebron. And part of me wonders if bringing in Ebron was at least partially motivated by the Steelers having a pick not quite high enough to get Kmet, and No. 49 being too high for any of the other tight ends.
It wouldn't be surprising if Kmet is far and away their highest-rated tight end. Not only is that a general consensus among draft analysts, but Kmet has size (6-feet-6, 262 pounds) and college production similar to what Heath Miller had when the Steelers drafted him in 2005. Plus, Kmet has big school pedigree coming out of Notre Dame and NFL bloodlines, with a dad who played in the league and an uncle (Jeff Zgonina) who was actually drafted by the Steelers. That all makes him sound like a guy this front office would covet, but they went a different route, perhaps because they didn't think Kmet would last until their second-round pick. And now, even if he does, it’s tough to imagine them bringing in another tight end behind Vance McDonald and Ebron.

Be sure to compliment Joe Starkey. Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.