The year was 1967, and around the world of NFL/AFL reporting, no one knew what to do with the Steelers in their mock drafts.
It was also the last time the Steelers didn’t have a first-round pick, an offseason scenario that hadn’t been seen again until they traded their top selection in the upcoming 2020 draft in exchange for safety Minkah Fitzpatrick last September.
If you’re practical and rational, you probably understand that whichever player falls to the Steelers at No. 49 overall, the 17th pick in the second round, will face long odds of being an immediate difference-maker. If you’re panicked and paranoid, you might think the Steelers are sure to reach for a bust or a project when they finally get to turn in their draft card.
Wherever you stand, just hope this experiment turns out better than the only other time the Steelers mortgaged their first-round pick. Because in that 1967 draft, the Steelers ended up with 14 little-to-nothing contributors under head coach Bill Austin.
“I’m pleased right now,” Austin told The Pittsburgh Press once the draft was over. “Of course, it always can be another story when August rolls around.”
Talk about “Timeless Draft Cliches,” right?
Read More
Without their first-rounder, which would’ve been No. 9 overall in the first draft after the NFL-AFL merger, the biggest prize for the Steelers was San Diego State halfback Don Shy. With the ninth pick in the second round, the Steelers were getting a dual football-track star with sprinter’s speed to become their new featured running back.
But the 6-foot-1, 210-pound Shy played just two seasons for the Steelers, leading the team in rushing his rookie year and eventually losing his starting job to veteran Dick Hoak, then got traded to New Orleans once Chuck Noll took over as head coach.
It won’t be tough to top that when the Steelers make their first pick next month — maybe even on another running back? — but they could stand to do much better than the rest of their 1967 draft haul, too. Three future Hall of Famers were taken after Shy — Chiefs linebacker Willie Lanier just 15 picks later, Cowboys offensive tackle Rayfield Wright in the seventh round and Oilers/Redskins safety Ken Houston in the ninth — and the Steelers didn’t draft anyone else who would become a piece of their 1970s dynasty.
Fourth-round pick Ray May at least made hay and started at middle linebacker two of his three seasons in Pittsburgh, and sixth-rounder Mike Haggerty started parts of four seasons on the offensive line, but that’s about it.
Now, the Steelers weren’t exactly good at drafting back then, as you might’ve guessed given their struggles until the Super 70s. But in 1965, they at least drafted Pro Bowl receiver Roy Jefferson in the second round. And in 1968, they unearthed a late-round gem named Rocky Bleier. All 1967 really got them was Sam Davis, an undrafted free agent who blossomed into the starting left guard for Noll’s four Super Bowl-winning teams.
Jump back into the time machine now and return to 2020. Whomever Miami winds up taking at No. 18 overall this year will be looked at by some as the prospect the Steelers could’ve had, perhaps unfairly compared to either the eventual 49th pick, or Fitzpatrick, who’s already an All-Pro in his second season. Then, there will be every draftee in between 18 and 49, all guys the Steelers would’ve had a shot at if not for trading the pick.
There might be some Alan Pages and Gene Upshaws — picks No. 15 and 17 in 1967 — but the Steelers didn’t have to kick themselves over the offensive lineman who wound up going to Green Bay in their original slot that year. Boston College’s Bob Hyland went ninth overall, played for four teams over 11 seasons, and you’d probably never heard of him. Granted, the players the Steelers received in return for that draft pick — Lloyd Voss, Tony Jeter and Ron Smith — were also soon forgotten, so this trip down memory lane isn’t a very fond one for anybody.
But at least you’ll know the answer to the trivia question of who the Steelers picked first last time they didn’t pick in the first. It’s Don Shy, who died in October 2006, according to SportsBusiness Journal reporter John Genzale. He was 61, and medical bills reportedly took a toll on his family in retirement.
In happier times for Shy, Pat Livingston of The Pittsburgh Press wrote about him making peace with how quickly his Steelers career fizzled, when Shy returned to Latrobe for a training camp visit in 1979.
“The Steelers that I played for were pretty disorganized,” Shy told Livingston. “When I left here, I never dreamed they’d be as good as they are. Especially, not so quick. Shortly after I left, they started going up and up and up. … That first [Super Bowl], I was thrilled for Mr. Rooney. Mr. Rooney was always good to me.”
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.