Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Let's get started.
livinthedream:
- Ray, Blame this question on Brian's "master plan". If you are Art the duce would you trade your 2021 1st round pick for a 2nd and 3rd round picks in 2020? The chat hasn't started yet.
Ray Fittipaldo: No I would not. First-round picks are very valuable. You build your team around players you get in the first round. So I'm keeping them unless, of course, I can get another Minkah Fitzpatrick.
Joey: Ray in my opinion the Cheatriots as they called them are going to remain with brady, the OC and the hoodie , if they do can you see them wining another one? Can’t stand them, hopefully 12 retires ..
Ray Fittipaldo: The Patriots had some problems last season with the Hoodie, Brady and Josh McDaniels. What they need is a legit No. 1 WR and a legit TE. They had neither in 2019. Also, their defense was really good, but the majority of those guys are 30 or older. As the Steelers experienced last season with their offensive line, you never never when age is going to catch up to you.
Nate: Hi Ray, would the Steelers ever consider selecting Jalen Hurts with their 2nd round pick (even with a healthy Ben)? Thanks!
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think so. I think they have too many other needs such as RB, OL, TE, WR, DL. I admit they might need to add some quality QB depth in the coming years, but I don't think it's this year. At least, not if Ben is healthy.
DaquidoBazzini: Hi, Ray - Any idea why Chuks Okorfor took a step back this year? It seemed like he showed some potential in his rookie season.
Ray Fittipaldo: He had shoulder surgery last offseason and didn't have a full offseason to prepare. I think that's part of it. Also, Zach Banner progressed well, and Okorafor, for whatever reason, wasn't able to earn it back. I think they still have high hopes for Okorafor. They invested a third-round pick in him. We'll see if he's better this spring and summer with a full offseason to prepare.
DaquidoBazzini: What kind of money would you guess that Marcus Mariota will command on the open market. Would you say that he would be out as a vet QB that the Steelers could consider adding in the off season?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Mariota will try to find a team that will give him a chance to compete for a starting job. He won't have that opportunity here unless Ben isn't ready for the season. So starting QBs usually gets $10-15 million even if they're in that stop-gap range that Mariota would be in this year as a UFA.
Nate: Hi Ray, suppose Ben's prognosis comes back negative - do the Steelers still franchise or transition tag Dupree, or would that $16 million be better spent on a FA (actual starting) QB? Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a big hypothetical. I still think they would. They want the defense to stay together, and Dupree was a big part of that. My guess is they would cut salary somewhere else to ensure Dupree comes back. Just my gut feeling.
Capologist: RB in the Second round?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a pretty good guess in mid-January. I think it's RB or OL or TE. We'll see what they do in free agency. That will give us another clue.
Jason in Slipplry Rock: Do you think that the Steelers will take a serious look at Slippery Rock QB Roland Rivers III? He is 6'3" and 230 pounds; he also was the D-2 player of the year with insane career numbers in passing and rushing. Looks like a Lamar Jackson type to me.
Ray Fittipaldo: I'll take your word for it. I never saw him play at Slippery Rock. But at 6-3, 230, he's much bigger than Jackson.
Nate: Hi Ray, Art Rooney feels it's more than likely the Steelers will be in the HOF game. Would the NFL force them to play the HOF game and participate on Hard Knocks? My hope is that it's one or the other. Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: They can make them do both. Guess that's what you get for missing the playoffs two years in a row.
AWB Tennessee: Ray, thanks for all the great chats. What's the most impactful coaching change the Steelers can make this offseason?
Ray Fittipaldo: We've heard some speculation about a QBs coach. I'll give you a suggestion out of the blue: a run-game coordinator. I don't know if they'd add two to the offensive staff, but the run game is in desperate need of some new ideas.
TX Steeler: Why so quiet on the coaching change front? I doubt we’ll see major changes but don’t they need to at lease add a WR Coach and, possibly, QB Coach?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, my guess is we might hear some news by the end of this week. The Senior Bowl is next week, and usually coaches like to have their staffs in place so they can hold meetings and scout players together. Changes could happen after the Senior Bowl, but I think Tomlin would like to have it done before then if he's going to make changes.
Patriot Fan: Is there any truth to the rumor that the Patriots are hiring AJ Hinch?
Ray Fittipaldo: They are looking for an in-house video coordinator! (I can just erase that right here. No one has to know. No problem." Ha ha
Utah Jim: Even if another team volunteers to for Hard Knocks do you really see HBO and the NFL picking any team other than the Steelers? Add a likely HOF game with the early training camp start to the intrigue of Ben’s return and the team’s enormous popularity and there is no way they pass on those ratings.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah I'm already counting on spending an extra week in Latrobe. I'll be pleasantly surprised if I don't, (Nothing personal Westmoreland County)
kevin in Punxsy: The Steelers should be able to get a really good running back with the 49th pick. That should be a priority. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. I noted in my offseason needs story earlier this week there was only one RB taken in the first 52 picks last year. Miles Sanders was the next RB taken at No. 53.
chiefar: If you are a NFL General Manager trying to sign your HOF QB to a 2 year extension but he won’t sign until you sign two offensive linemen (center and guard). Would you sign and play the guard although his performance is declining at a rapid rate?
Ray Fittipaldo: Nice wording on your question. Obviously, in hindsight, I would not.
Justin: Thoughts on a running back in round 2? I will always root and pull for James Connor, but a possible really good running back could be available.
Ray Fittipaldo: I like the idea of getting an RB. Conner is a nice player when he is healthy, but he takes a lot of hits and gets banged up. That's the nature of the position. But even when he's healthy Conner and the other RBs on the roster didn't force a lot of missed tackles. If your line is struggling you have to have backs that can make you miss, and the Steelers didn't have a back that could do that last year.
Nate: Hi Ray, do you think the Steelers re-sign Hilton, or does someone like Sutton or Layne get his spot? Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: He's an RFA and yes I think they'll sign him for another year.
Jay: Ray, Easy fix for the QB of the future. Go 0-16 next year and take Trevor Lawrence. One year of pain for a bright future.
Ray Fittipaldo: Sunshine! I like him, but the Steelers won't be nearly bad enough to be in position to take him.
kevin in Punxsy: With all the accolades that TJ Watt is receiving, do you see the Steelers needing to give him a 5 year $100 million contract after year 5? Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: I think you're pretty close on the numbers for Watt's next contract.
iowasteelerfan: Did you see anyone from last night's championship game that would fit the mold of a Steelers type of player?
Ray Fittipaldo: I like the Clemson RB, Etienne. He has some skills the Steelers could use. I liked a bunch of WRs in the game. LSU has some good O-line prospects. But mostly, I watched the skill guys for obvious reasons.
Nate: Hi Ray, thanks again for these chats! If you were the Steelers, would you 1) move Feiler to G and have Chuks and Banner compete for RT spot, or 2) re-sign Finney, or 3) just draft a LG or even T instead? Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: 1 or 3. They have options. If they draft a G they insert him at LG and keep everything else the same. If they draft a tackle then they could move Feiler to G. I think Feiler can be a really good G. He's big, strong. That move could potentially help your struggling running game too.
Franco: Hello Ray, even if Ben does come back healthy, given the offensive woes, can the team make the play-offs next year.
Ray Fittipaldo: With that defense, anything is possible. They almost made it this year with Duck Hodges at QB for crying out loud.
iowasteelerfan: Will Vanett be brought back? Hate to see us give away a draft pick for 9 games from someone.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they'll bring him back at the right price. He liked it here, and I think he's a solid backup. He'll never be a No. 1, but he was useful last season.
Brian in CA: I like the idea of mid level FA signings to address holes, but while Nelson worked out, others (Bostic, Burnett, Green) havent. Is that just the way it is, or will the Steelers get better on that front
Ray Fittipaldo: Nelson and Barron were good signings. Moncrief, not so much. I'm sure it's like that with a lot of teams. It's why teams like the Steelers prefer to draft and develop. You know what you're getting with those guys. With guys from other teams it's always a little bit harder to know who they are and what they'll bring to the table.
Victoria L. : What’s your take on our current situation at tight end? How do we improve there? (Draft? Free agency?)
Ray Fittipaldo: They need to start thinking about their next starter. Vance McDonald is going to be 30 and is coming off a bad year.
Franco: I'm not fully understanding everyone saying we need a running back early. We drafted Benny Snell last year and I think hes solid with some good upside. Conner is a pro bowler when healthy even know I agree he gets hurt a lot. Samuels isn't bad either in a change up role. Give me a better O line and I don't care who's at RB, that is my philosophy.....Point being, we need to focus on OL and do it all TE way before RB. Thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe that's the route they go, Franco. But I think the speculation is there because there are some very talented backs coming out and the Steelers probably will be in position to take one of them.
KN: Hello. Thank you as always for the chat. I wanted to get your assessment of Mason Rudolph ? Do you see him as potential Ben replacement ? I know he has an up and down year but considering that it was his first year playing, I thought he showed potential and good comeback in limited action after benching . Thank you
Ray Fittipaldo: Obviously a tough year for Rudolph. Getting benched for Duck Hodges was not a good development for him. But Tomlin committed to him the day after the season ended. I'm sure he learned some things in 2019 and will look to apply them in 2020.
Steeler in Virginia: Thaddeus Moss would look good in black and gold, right?
Ray Fittipaldo: Randy's son is a junior I believe and can go back for another season. I haven't heard his name mentioned as one of the top TEs in the draft. But he's a good-looking prospect. I know he made a few big plays in the CFP.
Steeler in Virginia: If the Steelers had a first-round pick this year, do you think they would still be (likely) tagging Dupree?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes.
Brian: Now that he has game film to add to his resume, do you think the Steelers would take a chance on signing JP Holtz if he is available ? I feel he fits the mold of what the Steelers require from their TE's.
Ray Fittipaldo: I liked Holtz when he came out of Pitt. I thought the Steelers should have signed him. He was an UDFA. He played for the Bears last season and did some nice things. Usually teams like to keep those types of players. I haven't heard of any change in his contractual status so I assume he'll be back with the Bears next season.
Nate: Hi Ray, if the Steelers draft a RB, who is the odd man out (released or traded) besides Edmunds - Connor, Snell, Samuels, or Whyte? Each one brings a different skillset that can be useful. Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: Let them compete in camp. But my guess would be Edmunds, Whyte or Samuels.
SD Stiller: Is there any opportunity for the Steelers to refuse to do Hard Knocks or are they obligated to do it if the NFL brass say they have to?
Ray Fittipaldo: They're pretty much obligated if HBO wants them.
Steeler in Virginia: If you are Miami (I know, this is a Steelers chat) would you consider trading all three of your first round picks to get Burrow?
Ray Fittipaldo: I like Burrow, but you can do some damage with three first-round picks. They'd have to feel very strongly that he's a sure thing if they make that move.
kevin in Punxsy: I saw a national sports writers predictions for the upcoming draft (rounds 1 & 2). He predicted the Steelers to draft an OLB from Florida with their pick at # 49. Do any of these guys know anything about the teams that they are making predictions for?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not really, no. They just look at Dupree and know the Steelers might not be able to keep him long-term. The local beat writers are much better sources for offseason needs, draft, things of that sort. And even we don't know exactly what is going to happen. I knew Devin Bush was a target last February. Sometimes you just know because there are glaring needs. This year won't be nearly as easy for a few reasons. For one, we'll have 48 picks before the Steelers are on the clock. For another, there are several positions of need.
Da Beard: Thanks for the chats Ray. Based off the sudden drop off to the run game this year, who takes the blame, overall offense scheme or change in coach?
Ray Fittipaldo: Sometimes it's the personnel, too. And I don't get the idea Shaun Sarrett was a major issue. Perhaps they tweak their scheme and attack things a little differently in 2020, but I think for the most part they need to upgrade their personnel.
Sam: Ray, given the success that the Titans and 49ers (and Ravens, Vikings, and Seahawks for that matter) have had as run-oriented teams, do you sense that more teams might pivot more that way, especially given the perpetually low number of true "franchise" QBs?
Ray Fittipaldo: The smart teams did that last offseason. You could see it coming a mile away. I still think there is time for the Steelers and others to hop on the bandwagon. But teams will be better prepared in 2020.
DK: How much of the dropoff in the OL line play was due to Ben not being there? They weren't great in run blocking with hima and w/out a veteran changing protections I have to think it could have been a lot of it.
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree that was a big part of the issues in pass pro. Ben is very adept at changing protection and accounting for everyone on defense. But as you mentioned his presence can only do so much for the running game. They weren't very good running the ball in 2018, either. Certainly not in the second half of the season when they folded down the stretch. It's a huge issue and must be addressed. Ben fixes a lot, but he doesn't fix everything.
kevin in Punxsy: Ray, as great as the Steeler defense was this year, there were some warts. There were at least three games where the D let the other team's O go 70 yards, or more, drives that ended is TDs and cost the Steelers 1-3 games in the L column. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but most of those came early in the season without Fitzpatrick or at the very early stages of playing with Fitzpatrick. My concern with the defense is stopping the run. They didn't do that well enough, and it cost them late in the season, especially against Buffalo and Baltimore.
DallasDave : Ray - one thing I haven't heard mentioned in regards to the offense struggling this year was the absence of Rosie Nix and using a FB to open holes for our RBs. It appears that several teams in the playoffs utilized a FB to help their running game. What are your thoughts ?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers didn't really use Nix a lot when he was healthy. Maybe that was going to change in 2019, but we'll never know because he was injured and lost for the season.
SD Stiller: Do you think players like Conner are predisposed to injuries or is it just bad luck? Frustrating that some RB's can go on and on for years but others, like JC, are hurt every other game.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know. Does it really matter? He's been injury-prone. That's a fact. Running backs get hit a lot. I'm not going to say he's soft, but it would be false to say he's been reliable in terms of his availability.
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the questions this week. We'll do another chat next week.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.