Ray Fittipaldo: Happy New Year everyone! Let's get the chat started.
Alan: It seems to me that the Steelers not only need an offensive playmaker or two but they also need to start adding some youth and toughness to their O line. What do you think their strategy will be this off-season in terms of the draft and free agency to help address these needs?
Ray Fittipaldo: Great question, Alan. If I'm Art Rooney, I'm paying attention to what the teams in the playoffs are doing with their offenses. The Titans beat the Patriots with a QB who threw for 71 yards in a playoff game. That would have been unheard of five years ago. But things are changing in the NFL. Look at all the playoff teams that value the running game. It's not only the Titans. It's the Ravens. It's the Bills. It's the 49ers. It's the Vikings. You don't need a great QB if you have a strong defense and a reliable running game. Some of those teams have running QBs. The Steelers don't have one of those so they'll have to go about the reinvigorating their run game in a different manner. But it can be done. And it should be done, especially with Ben Roethlisberger turning 38 in March and coming off elbow surgery. I'd be floored if Rooney doesn't make the running game a priority this offseason both in terms of philosophy and the personnel they acquire in the draft.
Lloyd's 3-Count: Outside of Barron, who else do you predict to be a likely cap causality?
Ray Fittipaldo: Barron is a possibility, but he's not at the top of my list. Ramon Foster and Anthony Chickillo are two likely cuts. After that there are others that might be considered. Barron is one of them. Vance McDonald is another. Jordan Berry is another. But if you're talking slam dunk cap casualties all I got are Foster and Chickillo. We can debate the decisions on the others.
Lloyd's 3-Count: So did Keith Butler suddenly become a genius or did he actually have the horses?
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: Minkah Fitzpatrick helped a whole lot. But let's give credit to Butler and Mike TOmlin for understanding where his value lied. They used him very well in their defense.
Lloyd's 3-Count: How much of the end of season slide do you attribute to teams actually having enough tape on Hodges? (Not to mention luck running out.)
Ray Fittipaldo: Probably a little, but I was more swayed by what Bud Dupree had to say in the locker room after the game. He basically came out and said offenses realized if they were able to run the ball and not turn it over they had a great chance to beat the Steelers. He was right. Look at the final three games. The Bills and Ravens had great success running on the Steelers. So did the Jets in certain situations. They didn't commit a lot of turnovers, either. That's something I'd study hard over the offseason if I was Tomlin. The blueprint is there. Now they should consider adding a big run-stopper along the defensive line to help with that. Or maybe reevaluate how they deploy their LBs, at least in terms of who the QB is.
Lloyd's 3-Count: If you were a betting man, what are the chances we have three Steelers inducted in HoF this year? Related: is Ed still the rep?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Polamalu is a good bet to get in on his first try. I think Faneca deserves to be in, but there are still a lot of linemen eligible. And I don't have a strong feel for which one(s) will get in this year. And I have no feel for the panel that will elect the senior candidates, which includes Bill Cowher. And yes, Ed still is the local rep in the room, but I believe Dale Lolley will be handling it this year.
Steven: Colbert made a ton of great moves this season (i.e. Fitzpatrick, Dupree Option) but having no backup with experience cost them the playoffs. Shouldn't Mason be the number 3 QB running the scout team while a veteran QB with experience be the number 2 in case Big Ben gets hurt. The number 2 does not get many reps in practice and having no experience there is costly.
Ray Fittipaldo: All depends on the doctor's report in February. If everything in on schedule with Ben and he's set to begin a throwing program then I think they can afford to go into the summer with Rudolph as the backup. However, if the report suggests the rehab isn't going well and there are some questions about his ability to be ready for the season then I think they'd have to look hard at a veteran that could at the very least compete with Rudolph.
Nate: Hi Ray, I know Tomlin mentioned there could be possible staff changes. What do you think the chances are that Danny Smith (and Jordan Berry, for that matter) is let go? And will Tomlin hire a QB coach? Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin said he is open to hiring a QB coach. In terms of the assistant that might or might not be retained it's not easy to find out whose contracts are up. Most of the assistants sign two-year deals, so we can speculate who might be up based on when they were brought on board.
Lloyd's 3-Count: Think we've seen the last of Big Ragu?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but I thought that last year too, and they decided to bring him back. I don't think they can afford to do it again. That line got real old real fast, and he turned 34 this week. Not to mention he wasn't very good.
GSMP: I know it wouldn't be an exciting pick but could you see the Steelers drafting a guard with their first pick? I think the line needs more help than a lot of people are saying.
Ray Fittipaldo: you're right. It wouldn't be sexy. This isn't a great year for guards in the draft. I was looking at one top 100 board this morning. There were two guards in the top 100. There were 18 receivers. And probably 12 offensive tackles. So yes the Steelers desperately need a guard, but they might not find the player they want or need in the second round or third round or fourth round, for that matter. With Matt Feiler's versatility, I think they are in position to draft the best available offensive lineman if that's what they decide to do early in the draft. Maybe you find a really good tackle that falls to 50. Maybe he's ready start as a rookie, and the easy solution is moving Feiler to guard. Or maybe you draft a tackle, redshirt him for a year you still move Feiler to guard but insert Chuks or Banner at tackle. There are a lot of options for the Steelers when it comes to rebuilding their line. Feiler's versatility is a big key in that.
Jack Lambert's tooth: What if the Feb report on Ben's elbow is bad. What to do then?
Ray Fittipaldo: If I was the GM, I'd go after a QB that can run and pass. Maybe a guy like Marcus Mariota. Maybe a new environment would help him progress as a QB. But even if a running QB isn't an option, I definitely put a lot of resources into improving the running game.
Alan in Nashville : Hi there. Do you think the Steelers just stick with the status quo with Ryan Shazier? One of these years a tough decision is going to have to be made. My uneducated guess is that he never plays football again. Do the Steelers continue to hold on as long as he still has hope?
Ray Fittipaldo: Shazier will have a place with the Steelers as long as he desires. Right now, it really doesn't matter what capacity. He's involved in scouting and such and I can see that as an avenue down the road. Just not sure when that develops.
Nate: Hi Ray, pretend you're Colbert for 2020 draft. There is still some 1st round talent in the 2nd round. You have your choice of some really good skill position players. Which position would you select: TE, WR or RB and why? Would love to get your thoughts. Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: All three! Honestly, they could use a RB especially with Conner entering the final year of his rookie contract. They didn't have a lot of RBs that could make defenders miss. They could use another WR to compete with James Washington for playing time. You're set with 18 and 19 as your top two, but how about a deep threat that can run 4.40 or better and make some plays. We all saw how teams defended the Steelers last season. They faced a lot of man coverage, and the WRs and TEs didn't get open often enough. So if you have a speedy playmaker I think that helps the offense. Same goes with the TE position, but the TEs in this draft aren't great. This is a much deeper draft for WRs so I think it might come down to picking the best skill player when it comes time to pick regardless of position.
Lloyd's 3-Count: Of the remaining teams, which potential Super Bowl matchup is most intriguing to you?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. I know the Ravens are heavy favorites, but I'm not convinced they're going to get there. I think the Chiefs have a shot to make it. In the NFC, the 49ers have the edge because they have home field, but I wouldn't be surprised if the Seahawks made a run. So how about Chiefs-Seahawks, Mahomes vs. Wilson. That would be fun.
kjacksonpgh: Hi Ray, the Steelers can't look at a top veteran QB at this point until Ben's evaluation is complete right?
Ray Fittipaldo: Correct.
AK: Do you think Donnie Shell will be voted into the HOF?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes forgot about Shell. He's one of those senior candidates, too. I think he has a shot obviously.
KK : The TE draft is supposed to be weak. Who would be a good pick for the Steelers?
Ray Fittipaldo: A few of the top-rated TEs aren't exactly in the Steelers mold of TEs. Bryant from Washington and Hopkins from Purdue are mentioned as two of the top TEs in this class. Neither is known as a complete TE. They're pass catchers first and don't offer much in the running game. But those are the types of players the colleges are producing. So you either have to adapt your offense to them or go without the prototypical TE. You're not going to find any Heath Millers anymore. That's just not the type of TEs colleges produce nowadays.
KK : Is 2nd round too early to take a RB in the next draft for the Steelers, given all their needs?
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe not if the Steelers believe that RB is capable of helping the offense. I watched the Patriots-Steelers game this morning because I was doing some research. Conner and Samuels got most of the touches in that game and neither did d a very good job of making guys miss. There were instances when the Steelers blocked it up OK, and they just had to make one guy miss, but they couldn't make it happen. But I think WR, TE and OL are definitely possibilities in round 2 as well. Just depends on who is available and what they like in the player.
kjacksonpgh: Ray, do you believe with a few player restructures, and or player releases it would be possible to sign Bud and extend other key veteran players this off season?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes. I mapped that out in a story last week. https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2020/01/02/Pittsburgh-Ste...
Utah Jim: Seven of the top 10 rushing offenses made the playoffs while only 3 of the top 10 passing offenses did. Are offenses taking advantage of defenses built to stop the pass with smaller and faster players?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that's part of it. This trend started late last season with the Patriots, who won the Super Bowl with a run-oriented attack. I wrote about it last January and suggested the Steelers make a better commitment to running the ball. They obviously didn't take my advice. But other teams did see the trend coming and had lots of success. I'm not suggesting the Steelers have to become a 50-50 run-pass team again. But what I am suggesting is they have to be able to run the ball much better than they have. Their running game has been a joke for the past two seasons.
kjacksonpgh: Ray, why wouldn't the Steelers consider adding Bruce Gradkowski as a QB coach? He seems to be interested in the job, and may actually assist with the development of Mason.
Ray Fittipaldo: Bruce was up for the Rams QB job last year. So he's on the radar of NFL teams. Tomlin said he is open to hiring one. Not sure if Bruce is on his list, but it might be a good idea to hire one because of the young QBs on the roster.
Tampa2: What has happened with the NFL’s investigation of the Patriots filming of the Bengals sideline signals?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's still ongoing.
kjacksonpgh: Ray, do you believe that Conner's running style plays a role with him not staying healthy?
Ray Fittipaldo: No. He takes a lot of hits. All RBs do.
Eric Carr: Are either Lynch or Duck currently under contract for next yr? I know they resigned Barrett but have heard nothing of those 2? I assume they were only signed for this yr so does that mean we're done with both of them?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes. Both are under contract in 2020.
Lloyd's 3-Count: Did the O-line get old fast or did defenses realize our passing game was nonexistent and scheme appropriately?
Ray Fittipaldo: Both. And by the way, the line was getting older late in the 2018 season when I detailed their deteriorating play in a story.
Jeff: Hey Ray, thanks for the chats. What if anything can be done with Edmunds? yes I get if he wasn't a first round pick expectations would be lower, but when I look back at some of our great defenses, we had no weak links. He can be a weak link that will and has been exposed against good teams (and average ones). Assume we find RB in free agency, ff a top safety is there in the second round do you take?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. Maybe down the road Edmunds moves to nickel LB and they get a deep strong safety somewhere in the draft in the next few years. But as of now, he's the SS and I think the hope is he improves.
Gene: Do you think the Steelers will draft a WR this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I do. It's a great year for WRs in the draft.
DaquidoBazzini: Do you think it's definite that the Steelers will lose Hargrave? If so, what options do you see in replacing him?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think the possibility is strong they will lose Hargrave. They have a lot of money tied up in Heyward and Tuitt, and I just don't see a way for them to keep Hargrave when he's going to command a lot of money on the open market.
Lloyd's 3-Count: Bigger impact over the course of the season: Steven Nelson or Minkah Fitzpatrick?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Minkah, but Nelson was really good at CB.
RealityMan: While the Steelers D made big strides last year and possesses some very strong players I think Steeler Nation is ahead of itself anointing this an an elite unit. Clearly they could not stop the run when needed and did not play very many elite QB’s. With strong safety as a clear weakness any chance we can groom Hilton or Sutton this year to ultimately replace Edmunds? I think with Barron gone Edmunds would be better utilized as a role player up on the LOS as opposed to playing in coverage. This always them to not have to draft another D player, upgrade a position and save a pick for another area. Thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's sort of where I was going with my previous answer about Edmunds. I'm glad you brought up Hilton and Sutton. Yes, both have safety qualities. If you remember, the Steelers used Hilton instead of Edmunds in a package at one point late in the season. I asked Hilton how much safety he played this season, and he said "quite a bit" on locker cleanout day. So I think that is a possibility. I'm sure they'll look at that.
DaquidoBazzini: Ray - If you saw the Titans-Pats game....Do you think it was a smart move for Vrabel to go for two after the INT with 9 seconds left? If that ball comes loose, and NE runs it back....That game is tied.
Ray Fittipaldo: The final score was 20-13. If the ball comes loose and returned it's only worth two points. Vrabel was trying to boost the lead to nine points and end the game.
Alan: How would you rate Devin Bush’s rookie year?
Ray Fittipaldo: Bush had a good year, led the team in tackles, made some big plays. I'm sure he'll be even better next season. This was a learning year. They didn't want to expose him in certain situations. I think as he grows they'll expose him to more and he'll have a chance to grow.
iowasteelerfan: I've read a long term deal for Bud would be around $15M/year, and TJ is likely looking to be at least $20M/year. Would they really invest $35M in 2 OLB positions, and should they for the next 4 years?
Ray Fittipaldo: Probably not, but they can do it for one season with Bud on the tag for $16 million.
Paul: Ray thanks for the chats. I would like to see Marcus Allen get a chance to compete with Edmunds. Any chance of that?
Ray Fittipaldo: Marcus Allen wasn't even on the 53-man roster until Kam Kelly got cut late in the season. That ought to tell you what they think of him.
Lloyd's 3-Count: When could we expect an update on Colbert's future?
Ray Fittipaldo: He's under contract through the draft, but I'm sure Art Rooney II will be asked about it when he meets with reporters later this month.
John Strange: What was the excuse for the Steeler offense - replete with BIG BEN for gosh sakes --- being held to 3 points in the opener against the Pats?
Ray Fittipaldo: The WRS didn't get open very often, and when they did they dropped too many passes. Also, the running game was inconsistent and really bad in short-yardage situations. They couldn't convert a third-and-1 or a fourth-1 in the first half of the game.
Ralph LA: Would Roethlisberger be having the same issues with the blitz that Duck and Rudolph had this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's impossible to answer. He did have trouble against the Patriots in Week 1. But the Patriots had a shutdown CB in Gilmore and a very good defense overall. They didn't blitz much, if at all.
Rocky B: If you were GM, please rank your off season priorities, including: veteran backup QB, featured RB, TE, left OT, #1 receiver.
Ray Fittipaldo: WR, OL, RB, TE. Not really committed to the order just yet, but that's my feel on jan. 7. And I say WR just because I think there could be a good value at No. 50. Not listing QB as a need until I hear the doctor report on Ben is not good.
Ralph LA: Even with Roethlisberger at QB the wide receivers were dropping passes. Any idea what was going on? Were passes too hot to handle or in the wrong spot or receivers not having enough time to practice with the QB or were the wide receivers just not that good?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they can use another good WR to round that group out. 18 and 19 are your starters. 13 improved, but he can be pushed for playing time. They need a fourth WR that is capable of contributing.
Ralph LA: Throughout the season, could you tell if the wide receivers were getting separation or were they being missed when they were open?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would say getting open was more of a problem than the QB missing them. But I'm sure the young QBs made their fair share of misreads and bad throws, too.
Ben: It would be great to see the Steelers keep this D together but I’m not convinced they should do a long term deal on Dupree. He had a great year and is solid, but what would it look like if Watt wasn’t on the other side? If they go long term on bud and Heyward in the off-season, I think there is a pretty good chance they look around in 2 years at their defense and the investments in aging players and have regret. Hard to imagine a situation where Dupree, Heyward, Haden, and Tuitt are healthy and playing at a high level. A lot of guys could look good opposite watt. What do you think?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know of a lot of people who are advocating a long-term deal for Dupree. I think they want to see him signed to the tag to see what kind of team they can have with the 2019 defense and a healthy Ben.
Steeler Joe: The signing of Tuzar Skipper to a two-year deal after the back-and-forth with him this year...is there a significance to that? Is it a sign that they see him as a potential backup or starter at OLB more than they did earlier this year? Or is it just adding bodies at this point?
Ray Fittipaldo: I need to find out because I agree they don't usually do that. He was going to be an ERFA. Maybe they didn't want to place a second-round tender on him, and this was a way to pay him more but not as much as the tender.
Steeler Joe: Is there a strategy to continuing to draft defense in 2020? I think perhaps using the first two picks on even more talent for this defense is a smart move--and then hope you can snag talent on the O line, TE and RB later in the draft, and win games with strong defense.
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not discounting defense as a possibility with their second or third-round pick, but I think overall this will be an offensive draft.
MD: Given that cap space can now roll over from year to year, how damaging is it that Tomlin sticks with medium priced, poor performing veterans instead of younger players? For instance, if Foster was not brought back, Finney would have started and Fred Johnson would have backed him up. If Chickilo was not brought back, we just would have gone with Skipper the entire year. Team results would have been the same. We'd have a developing guard like Johnson still on the roster. And we'd have about $7 million more of cap space to roll over to next year.
Ray Fittipaldo: Good take. I don't disagree with you. But obviously, the Steelers didn't think Finney was good enough to make that move. Otherwise, it was a no-brainer. Foster was done in 2018.
NickFromVA: Does Benny Snell have what it takes to be the feature back in this offense?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure about that, but he had a good rookie year.
WPASTEEL: Disagree with Barron being a must cut.. I thought his play was descent and he has good speed.. He play wasn't perfect but who else is going to cover RB's and TE's on passing situations besides Bush?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. Barron is a tough call. He played the second-most snaps by an ILB behind Bush.
NickFromVA: If the Steelers go with a platoon between Conner and Snell, do you think that will help Conner stay healthier?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't get the sense that it would.
Out of Duck: Do you see them targeting a run stuffing NT in the early rounds? Run defense wasn't great and needs improvement.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that's a sneaky need for the Steelers especially with Hargrave likely gone in free agency.
Rick: Is WR really that big a concern? WR was hurt less by AB's absence than by not having Ben throwing to whomever. Is a healthy Ben under center an instant upgrade to WR? Seems like JJSS, Johnson , Washington make a pretty good top 3.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they need a deep threat defenses will take seriously. Not Johnny Holton.
KK : Were you surprised that Shell and not Greenwood was nominated by the Veterans committee?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's funny. For the longest time I used to hear Greenwood's name and not Shell's. And then that changed in recent years. I'm not sure if it has to do with Greenwood's passing, but there was a time his name was mentioned before Shell's.
JerseySteel: Hi Ray - I watched a lot of Zach Banner when he was in this year. He seemed to get a lot of movement on the defensive player he was blocking - more than most on the line. Do the Steelers see him as a starter in waiting or a career backup?
Ray Fittipaldo: I have to see him more as a tackle rather than an extra TE. Obviously, the Steelers like him in that extra TE role. And others have graduated to starting jobs from that role.
Alabama Steeler fan: Is Deon Cain the deep the answer for a deep threat. I though the looked good in a limited role
Ray Fittipaldo: He's worth keeping around, but they had plenty of opportunities to use him in that role late in the season, and they didn't really play him a whole bunch.
Road to 7: Do you see Edmunds developing or is he a first round swing and miss?
Ray Fittipaldo: Still time to develop, but 2020 will be a big year for him.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for all the questions this week. Let's do it again next Tuesday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.