Devlin Hodges, Mason Rudolph reflect on Steelers season

Brian Batko: Hi everyone, sorry for starting a little later than usual today, but the Steelers just had their final locker room session of the season. Exit interviews for the players (with us) in a sense. Let's get rolling.

Mr Medium Chest: Am i searching for something that isn’t there or does Tomlin seem like he lost some of his passion? Seemed like he isn’t the same guy who tried to trip Jacoby Jones back in the day. I started to notice it when he gave a “no comment” after the Myles Garrett fiasco. I’m curious to hear your opinion. Happy New Year

Brian Batko: I don't sense that, MMC. Mike Tomlin might come off as dispassionate in his public comments, but that's because he just doesn't have much use for saying things through the media and things of that nature. Obviously. The Myles Garrett incident was a good example of that.

Steeler in Virginia: In hindsight, should the Steelers have offered a fourth for a Andy Dalton-type QB to come in and get this team to the playoffs? Or was it not worth losing that future pick?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: In hindsight, sure, but at what point in the season? Coming into it, Mason Rudolph was so encouraging that they traded a QB (albeit not a veteran type) FOR a mid-round pick. They probably didn't foresee the turn Rudolph's season would take. I know I didn't.

Vasily: Hey Brian. Enjoy the chats. I thought Jaylen Samuels’ running and receiving talents were under-utilized this season. Do you foresee him getting more playing time next year?

Brian Batko: Thanks, Vasily. Funny you say that because yesterday when he caught a pass out of the backfield, I remarked aloud, "Hey, Jaylen Samuels, I remember him." Seems pretty clear as the season went on that the Steelers liked the way Benny Snell was running more than Samuels, who had a couple extended auditions but didn't quite take advantage the way he did last year. Still a useful piece for 2020 and possibly beyond.

Anthony : ben best years re behind him

Brian Batko: Thank you, Anthony

Advertise with us

JV: Hi Brian, how would you rate Coach Tomlin’s performance with the media? Considering that a coach’s media interaction is one of the primary methods they have to connect with the fan base (i.e. the paying customer) I wish owners would invest more training in this area, and insist that their primary spokesperson (the coach / manager) improve their ability to give meaningful, non-evasive answers to legitimate questions that fans want to know more about. Perhaps I’m just living in my fears, and I should embrace the standard.

Brian Batko: I don't spend a lot of time thinking about it, to be quite honest with you. Hey, wait, that sounded a lot like a Tomlin answer. But really, I think it's pretty meaningless in the grand scheme. Does it make our jobs harder at times? Sure, but no one cares about us. Just ask my wife.

Tim Biakabutuka: How far is this team from being good again?

Brian Batko: Wow, great chat name and bonus points for correct spelling. I don't think it's far, Tim. It was good at times this year. Occasionally very good. So much hinges on Ben Roethlisberger, of course, but it's just as crucial that this defense remains in the upper echelon of the NFL.

The ghost of Franco: Bigger need for this team a stud running back or TE? Conner is to injury prone and the rest are just adequate backups the way I see it? How do you see it? Thank you.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: It's tight end to me. Look at the guys from the Ravens who were breaking tackles and ripping off long runs yesterday. Gus Edwards and Justice Hill, undrafted and mid-round pick. You can find those types and they'll succeed behind a strong offensive line. But tight ends can really be game-changers, and Vance McDonald didn't do much of that this year coming off his breakout season.

Ryno: Was it just me, or was TJ Watt playing angry yesterday? Cant wait to watch him over the course of his career.

Brian Batko: It did seem like it. He got called for a couple offsides penalties, which he couldn't have been happy about. Talked to him today in the locker room and he seemed quite frustrated about the season, despite his own success. Look for a story on the site at some point this week as we wrap up the season.

Alan F: Just a precaution, does Colbert and Tomlin bring in another QB to compete for the backup going into the pre-season? Or do you have Lynch and Rudolph compete with Hodges clearly a 3rd string?

Brian Batko: That's a big question going into this offseason. Are there guys out there the Steelers like? Are they comfortable with Rudolph and Duck? Is it even viable salary cap wise to bring in a vet like that? Guessing here on Dec. 30, I don't think they're ready to give up on Rudolph ... yet.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: And by that I mean as a backup.

Jay: Steelers being 8-8, Tomlin doing a fine job or AFC super weak this year?

Brian Batko: He did a fine job

Sugarfoot: Do you believe Tomlin is on the hot seat? Coaching was horrible in the 3 game skid and Fichnter neeess

Brian Batko: Nope

Advertise with us

Doug from Raleigh: I had my fear going into the season and now at it's end I certainly feel Juju is more Jim Smith, Calvin Sweeney, or Frank Lewis than John Stallworth or Lynn Swann. What do you think, and does the organization need to draft yet another WR?

Brian Batko: Is there concern? Sure. Am I ready to write off JuJu as incapable of being THE guy? No, not yet. He was playing with a piecemeal quarterback situation and a couple young receivers, one rookie, who were inconsistent but showed flashes of excellence. Let's see how he fares with a healthy Roethlisberger.

Mrbig: Steelers took advantage of the hitting rules on run option plays. That's how you stop those QBs. Was that why watt was so erratic?

Brian Batko: Erratic? I thought he played well, as usual. Overpursued once or twice, but I'll take that with the way he gets into the backfield at will.

Utah Jim: For years the Steelers have been telling us they don't need a traditional NT because it's a passing league. Well they won't do anything until they can get past Baltimore who figures to remain run heavy for the near future. Will the Steelers change their mind?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I mean, they have Dan McCullers on their roster right now!

Jack: Running and/or disguising runs, aka passes to the LOS, on first and second down and throwing on 3rd and long is what ales this team. Defenses know this and stack the box on first and second down, and then blitz on 3rd. In the end it makes the QB, RBs, WR/TEs and OL look bad. Moreover its no way to coach when you're undermanned and cant win one on one match-ups. Tomlin has been doing this since 2007, except this year he doesn't have Ben to clean up his mess with a game winning drive. Fire Tomlin!

Brian Batko: Huh, I didn't think that's where that question was going. Well, comment, not question. I think just as many people would argue that it was the players, or lack thereof, who hamstrung the play-calling efforts. Jimmy's and Joe's rather than X's and O's, if you will. But hey, at least we got one more "Fire Tomlin!" before we head into 2020.

RamblinJim from DC: Brian, long time lurker, first time asker - Left to Right, what do you think our O-line looks like to start the 2020 season?

Brian Batko: Wow, first-time chatter busting in with the tough question. I'll say: Al Villanueva, Matt Feiler (moves from RT to replace Ramon Foster), Maurkice Pouncey, Dave DeCastro, Chuks Okorafor. Foster yesterday after the game in Baltimore was talking like a guy who senses he won't be back. But I'm not at all confident in predicting who could replace him. Zach Banner? Someone we're not even aware of yet?

Advertise with us

RealityMan : Ok, while the D has been greatly improved and has some young strong talent, it is not even close to an elite D. The Bill, Jets and especially the Ravens were able to run quite easily on this team, even when they knew it was coming. Having a stronger offence will surely be the focus next year but there are holes to plumb in the D as well. Barron, Edmunds, are obvious weaknesses but the D line also has to take some heat. How many changes do you see on the D?

Brian Batko: At least a couple, I imagine. Mark Barron could be a cap casualty (as he was in LA). Obviously, Bud Dupree and Javon Hargrave are valuable but might be expensive to keep. Terrell Edmunds isn't going anywhere. At this point, my prediction is that there will be two new starters next year, one way or another.

Daffy Duck: Brian, thanks for the chat and Happy New Year! What a nightmare conclusion to the season, no? I can't help wondering how much better the Steelers would be today had they drafted Darius Leonard instead of Terrell Edmunds in the first round, 2018. There would have been no need to use all the draft capital to get Bush, plus they probably still would have gotten Edmunds in the second or third round. They sure could use those picks now.

Brian Batko: Thanks, DD, same to you. Always easy to look back with a could've or should've. Darius Leonard would've been considered a reach all the same, but of course, that's the inexact science of drafting. Does it appear Edmunds was taken too high? At this point, yes. But he hasn't been an outright bust just yet. At least not to me. Needs to take a big step forward next year.

Artie Bridge: What's your order of priority for the off-season: qb, rb, wr, te, ol, lb, db? We need help at all of them, but how do you rank the levels of need?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: My personal ranking: OLB (assuming Dupree is gone), TE, OL, ILB, DL, P, WR, QB, RB. Kicker is last, I know that.

John: beside Bud Dupree, which other starting players will be UFA?

Brian Batko: John, read this https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/12/30/steelers-offse...

Gene: Do you think any of the 3 backup QB’S are on the 2020 roster?

Brian Batko: At least one of them, for sure.

Advertise with us

DG: Regardless of the QB, the offensive play calling has been atrocious this year. That would be a good "exit" interview.

Brian Batko: OK, next time I talk to Randy Fichtner, I'll be sure to ask him why all his good calls worked and why the bad ones didn't.

MikeM: When an NFL team designates a player for a draft round tender and the player signs with another team, is that other team's slot in the draft given up or is it at the end of the round?

Brian Batko: It's that team's draft slot, not an end-of-round comp pick

Steeler fan In California: As far as the QB situation goes how does Paxton Lynch fit into the 2020 equation?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Not well

bummed in Canton: How many draft picks do we have in 2020 and what rounds are they?

Brian Batko: They currently have five picks, one in the 2nd, two in the 4th, a 6th and a 7th. But they'll likely receive a comp pick, at the end of the third round, for parting with Donte Moncrief.

Wales Yinzer: Where do you think the team will go with the QB position? Stay put? Add in the 2nd round?? other?

Brian Batko: I think they'll stay put. Mason Rudolph likely helped himself with the way he came in and performed when needed against the Jets. It was a rebound of sorts that a lot of people needed to see. I absolutely can't see them drafting one with their first pick.

Advertise with us

WeegieT: Time to bring in a veteran QB? And Possibly a QB coach for Mason who seems to have the stronger arm?

Brian Batko: Rudolph and the others get plenty of tutelage from Randy Fichtner and offensive assistant Matt Symmes, but with no limit on NFL staffs, to me it never hurts to bring another cook in the kitchen.

Seriously?: I love how all the PGH media and Steelers apologists are so convinced an out of shape 38 year old with a bum elbow is going to make a huge difference on this horrendous offense. It's almost like they forget how bad the offense looked in the first game against the Pats and against the Seahawks before injury. What logically makes you think this offense isn't in need of a full rebuild??

Brian Batko: Logically, Roethlisberger might've already been dealing with that elbow injury in one game against what proved to be a(nother) fantastic Patriots defense and two quarters against a Seahawks unit that was good enough to make the playoffs at 11-5. I'm not saying Ben's gonna be his old self or anything close - because I would never want an anonymous chat participant to call me a Steelers apologist - but if we're to believe he's made a full recovery, well, to quote the man, the standard is the standard.

Big Ben: it is pretty evident that the quarterback makes the wide receiver and not the other way around. so why have a 18 million dollar wide receiver? I think juju is a great person and a good player, but what is he really worth in your opinion?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I do think that's a good point. Sometimes it can be the other way around, but yes, you can get by with less-than-stellar receivers if you have someone who can throw them open and put the ball where it needs to be. Then again, this offense looked pretty solid with a handsomely paid man named Antonio for a good while, and I think a team like the Saints are pleased with their return on investment for Michael Thomas.

NickFromVA: Does the duck mania finally go away? I mean it was a nice story, but there is no way Duck Hodges was going to be the answer going forward

Brian Batko: Yeah, probably. But give him credit for how he's handled the ups and downs. Once again today he took any and all questions about another rotten performance and overall disappointing finish to a once-promising rookie of the year. I figure he'd be happy to stick around and be a backup/insurance policy type guy for as long as they'd have him.

Two Bricks Shy: Time for changes in special teams... new coach... new punter. We made strides forward this year (in kicking and even in the return game)... but that’s more on Bos + Diontae vs. coaching. Do you see this as the most likely coaching move?

Brian Batko: No, the most likely move is replacing interim wide receivers coach Ray Sherman. But yes, there needs to be some honest evaluation of the punt and kickoff units.

Advertise with us

Kgkftz: Clearly QB played a role... but is Juju an elite #1 in your POV... do you feel that Diontae will push him for the #1 spot next year, and do you believe Diontae has greater upside longer term?

Brian Batko: Greater upside than JuJu? I don't think so. But with him plus Johnson plus Washington, I think you have a solid and firmly entrenched top three next year. Which is why I wouldn't necessarily draft one, at least not early.

Bill in SF: I know that Fichner is Ben's personal OC and the injuries this season were tough to overcome, but do you think that should be enough for the Steelers front office to ignore the historically inept offense he rolled out there all season and retain him?

Brian Batko: Yes, Bill, I do. Hesitate to say he gets a "pass" for this year, because that's not right, but the Steelers probably understand that he hasn't really had a fair shake of it this season, only his second on the job.

DaquidoBazzini: Has Stephon Tuitt been around since he got injured (out for the year) earlier this season?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Yeah he was just in the locker room today actually.

Seven’s Coming: Hi Brian- the season didn’t end the way we wanted but I’m still proud of the Steelers for never quitting! If they draft a running back, how do you see Benny Snell fitting in next season? Do they go one-two punch or is Snell back to a smaller role? I liked his aggressive style and would love to see more of him next year.

Brian Batko: If they do upgrade, or find a guy who's like a diamond in the rough type, I could see Snell's role being reduced. Same goes for if James Conner can get healthy and stay healthy. But yes, I'm with you, he makes sense as a short-yardage hammer or goal line guy. Of course, that was basically supposed to be the extent of his usage this year, I believe.

rman: Yesterday Harbaugh and the Ravens showed the Steelers what can be done when a team of 2nd and 3rd teamers are COMMITED to a run game. RG3's stats were similar to the Ducks stats. Do you think any lessons were learned by the Steeler coaches?

Brian Batko: Yep: play the backups. They're hungrier.

NC Yinzer: Another week of obvious offensive play calling, running on every first down play (even one when we needed 2 scores with 4 minutes left). Hodges, reportedly, is somewhat limited with arm strength, so after it’s clear TN was going to win, why not see what Lynch has? Wasn’t he a former first rounder?

Brian Batko: The Tennessee thing is meaningless. Steelers weren't really following that game on the sideline. They were trying to handle their own business. And Mike Tomlin said Tuesday they weren't comfortable enough with Paxton Lynch to use him in game action. He wasn't lying.

MrCJJr: Hello Brian, thanks for the chat. First, kudos to the Steelers for remaining competitive in the midst of all the trials this season. Most teams would've folded. Moving forward, the outcry has been to fire Fichner. I'm on the fence about it...while his play-calling is suspect, however wouldn't an experienced veteran QB (Ben, someone other than Rudolph or Hodges) been able to audible/check out of said play with confidence to make it work? And (if Fichner is fired) how will Ben do with having to learn a new system at age 38 and 15+ yrs experience?

Brian Batko: Can't imagine he'd really want to. I think you make a lot of good points about the whole situation. So, kudos to you, MrCJJr.

Brian in CA: Some thought Tomlin should be gone early in the season, others thought he should be Coach of the year after they went to 8-5, then they collapsed. Seems like he is above average, but not as exceptional as some... what do you think?

Brian Batko: I think a lot of franchises would love to have him and often times you must be careful about what's behind Door No. 2, if that makes sense.

LongestYard: Can’t believe I’m saying this, but 12 months ago I was on the bandwagon to move on from Bud... now he feels like a must sign. I’m wondering Edmund’s is the same...? Crazy talk?

Brian Batko: Could be. Edmunds strikes me as great from an intangibles standpoint. Guy's in great shape and will work his butt off. Decision on his fifth-year option is still a year away.

About Minkah: Why didn’t Fitzpatrick end the year strong? Did the coaching staff confuse him or teach him different less effective methods. He tailed off. Only thing I cAn think of.

Brian Batko: Just didn't really have as many balls come his way. I still thought he was sound for the most part. One or two missed tackles yesterday I noticed, but he's hardly a question mark going into 2020.

SteelerFaninCO: Is there a reason you encourage more of the "Fire Tomlin", "Fire.....whomever", "Play calling was horrible" questions/comments with your sarcastic responses to them? Why not ignore them instead of providing more fodder for your next chat?

Brian Batko: You should see how many DO get ignored! But seriously, we're out of time now today, and I suppose this may be the last Monday chat from me for the foreseeable future. We will still have plenty of chats the rest of the week, plus my mailbag, plus a new episode of our North Shore Drive podcast, and all the usual content we deliver on www.post-gazette.com. Thanks to all for following along in my rookie year on the beat, and you can always find me on Twitter @BrianBatko. Enjoy the new year!