Welcome to Brian Batko’s weekly Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds.

Let’s get started, and don’t forget to join us on our weekly all-sports podcast, The North Shore Drive, whether you use Apple, Spotify or any of the other major platforms.

@contra412: If Duck throws 2 picks in the first half against the Jets and nothing positive, Mason starts the 2nd half?

Brian: First of all, I regret to inform you that in a search of all the photos we have access to at the Post-Gazette, there is indeed one of a duck on a leash. But it costs $35 to download and use, and unfortunately, the bosses tell me there just isn't room for that in our budget right now as we near the end of our fiscal year.

Advertise with us

Obviously, I don’t know what Mike Tomlin is thinking as we approach Sunday, and neither does anyone else. But here’s the thing that it seems a lot of fans are forgetting about Duck Hodges: He’s had one poor performance. Let’s recap his season to this point …

• Makes NFL debut in relief of Mason Rudolph and nearly beats the team that’s now the odds-on Super Bowl favorite.

• Wins first NFL start in prime time.

• Returns to the bench, stays ready, provides a spark and helps avoid a loss to the league’s worst team the next time he’s called upon.

• Makes second career start and beats the only team the Steelers had lost to since Week 5.

Advertise with us

• Has best game of his career at Arizona in another victory.

• Struggles mightily against the league’s third-ranked pass defense while being asked to throw 38 times — against the league’s third-ranked pass defense.

And now a whole bunch of people think he should go home to Greenbow, Alabama?

The leash, such as it is, might not be long for Hodges. When Tomlin benched Rudolph in the third quarter at Cincinnati, he kept going back to that decision being a “feel thing” for him, so even he may not be able to tell you at this point what he’ll allow and what he won't if the road gets rocky in East Rutherford, N.J. — one pick, two picks, three picks, no picks but no touchdowns, who can say?

But this is the first adversity Hodges has faced in his NFL career. As Tomlin himself said Tuesday, it’s fair to give him a chance to bounce back from it, and the Steelers must hope he fares better in that regard than Rudolph did following his own four-interception debacle in Cleveland.

Advertise with us

Tommy in Ann Arbor: Correct me if I'm incorrect but I believe that was the first time this season that the Steeler QB went under center then went in motion. Either way, clearly Hodges had no idea because he was seen politely asking the official for clarification ... that and Pouncey snapped it when Hodges was just clearing the line.

I believe, by visual evidence... they practiced it that way... giving the BOTD [benefit of the doubt] that they did practice it ... thus if it was/is Fichtner ... well ... it deserves to be asked of those mentioned.

Brian: You make some astute observations here, but it actually wasn't the first time the Steelers got into the wildcat look in that manner. While true that the one time they ran it against Arizona — a 16-yard gain that I didn't see anyone complaining about — Hodges did not go in motion, they did have him shift into his position a couple times the previous week against the Browns. Not sure if that makes the illegal shift penalty against Buffalo better or worse.

Clearly, there was a breakdown in communication as to when that ball was supposed to be snapped or what Hodges was allowed to do, but it was not necessarily a new idea or spin on the formation from them. In Week 14, on the first wildcat play, they came out in a pistol look, then Hodges and Tony Brooks-James (remember him?) motioned out wide so that Jaylen Samuels could step up for the snap. Brooks-James then went into motion for the fake handoff. They ran it twice more in that game, the same way pre-snap, and never had an issue with Hodges not coming set.

Maybe they just shouldn't use the wildcat at all anymore, right? We have reason to believe that page of the playbook is going back into storage. Last time they ran it and got a catastrophic turnover as a result (interception against Baltimore), it got put on ice for six weeks. The ‘cat has been back for the past three, but did not reappear Sunday night after the Diontae Johnson fumble.

Advertise with us

@benandlambert: Would one of you guys actually ask the tough questions of Steelers staff/players, like why didn’t Duck spike it despite Tomlin telling him to and why the heck they never, ever use the middle of the field in the passing game?

Brian: Here’s what Hodges said when I asked him about this Monday afternoon in the locker room, by which point he had ample time to watch the film and discuss that play with the powers that be: “Yeah, I'm sure he wanted me to clock it. It was the perfect opportunity to clock it. I didn't hear it, and it was just a rookie mistake."

Maybe I’ll be back on the South Side this week to ask about the whole middle-of-the-field issue.

Be sure to compliment Joe Starkey. Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.