Welcome to Brian Batko’s weekly Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds.
Let’s get started, and don’t forget to join us on our weekly all-sports podcast, The North Shore Drive, whether you use Apple, Spotify or any of the other major platforms.
Doug from Raleigh: Surprised they let Moncrief go?
Brian: No, Doug, I’m not. Thought there was a chance he might get one more game to suit up, but once the compensatory draft pick formula became clear — or, less murky — it was an obvious move. Even if he’d been playing well, it’s tough to pass up on a likely third-round draft pick.
But the better question might just be, what the heck happened to Donte Moncrief? Back when he was failing to catch pretty much any pass thrown his way and getting the inactive tag on Sundays, I reached out to sports psychologist Dr. John F. Murray, whom the Washington Post — and Gene Collier — once referred to as “The Freud of Football.” Basically, my question was, can a wide receiver get “the yips” much like a quarterback, or a kicker, or a pitcher?
“The answer to your question is, why not?” Murray told me. “What the hell, of course he can have the yips. It happens in all sports. We usually talk about it in golf, but it’s not limited to golf. It’s absolutely possible.”
Read More
Murray asked me how Moncrief was attempting to explain the drops in media interviews. Overthinking, trying to be perfect and putting too much pressure on himself were his most consistent responses.
“That's definitely psychological … and the overthinking clues me in. It sounds exactly like what we see in any situation where somebody does not perform the way they obviously have the talent to perform, so it goes right into the same category,” Murray said. “He’d be a good client to try to figure it out.”
Of course, only Moncrief knows whether those were his real issues. Maybe there were lingering effects from his finger injury in training camp. Maybe he would've gone on a tear had the Steelers played him more than 32 total snaps in his final three active games, or targeted him more than four times in that span.
Either way, he’ll now get a chance to figure it out in Carolina, where the Panthers could use a receiver who caught 59.1% of his passes throwing his way over four seasons in Indianapolis and 53.9% last year in Jacksonville. I asked Moncrief if he sought out anyone for help during his struggles here — be it another wideout who had drop issues, or someone like Murray — but he said no. Murray has worked with plenty of NFL players but couldn't remember seeing a receiver.
“There’s usually an ‘arousal performance curve’ that when you get excited, you perform to a certain optimal level, but if you get too intense that kind of declines a little bit, so if he’s thinking too much about it, it might decline,” Murray said. “But there’s also a theory called the ‘catastrophe theory,’ where if you combine anxiety with intensity, at some point, performance suddenly and dramatically collapses.”
The only way Moncrief’s free agent signing could've been more of a catastrophe for the Steelers is if they’d also let it cost them a third-round draft pick.
John F.: On the Colts’ missed extra point yesterday, Minkah picked up the ball and was running downfield when the officials blew the whistle. Has the rule changed? I thought you could return a missed extra point for two points. Thanks.
Brian: Minkah Fitzpatrick could not have run the ball back for a 2-point conversion after Cam Heyward got his big mitt on Adam Vinatieri’s blocked extra point. According to the NFL rule book, on a scrimmage kick, it’s a dead ball once it touches the end zone.
Lysander from Watts, Calif.: My question is, will my Steelers go mostly with a 40 front because it is paying dividends with the pass and rush? We're getting sacks and pressure with only 4 rushing now we can throw in occasional zones mixed with man! Thanks for taking me question
Brian: Watts checking in! Love that.
The Steelers play an odd front in their base defense, but calling them a 3-4 has been a fairly obsolete term for a while now. Bud Dupree and T.J. Watt are essentially defensive ends, especially in sub-packages with two down linemen. That’s why a lot of folks have taken to calling those players “edge-rushers” now, because it really just depends on the system they're in whether they're labeled as outside linebackers or defensive ends.
Bryan B.: Brian — Minkah is a good young player and having a solid safety is nice ... but considering Ben is injured and at the end of his career, and that there are several good QB prospects in the upcoming draft, don’t you think that first round pick could’ve been better used on a potential franchise QB of the future? Tua, Herbert, Burrow, Love, etc
Brian: Every year, there will be a new crop of potential franchise quarterback enters the draft. I don't think the Steelers are at that point yet, because 1.) Ben Roethlisberger still plans on returning next season (and beyond) and 2.) the process of evaluating Mason Rudolph is still ongoing. There’s no guarantee that the Alabama quarterback or the Oregon quarterback are sure bets to be the next great passer in the NFL. Joe Burrow is a sure thing, because my boss and sports editor Tyler Batiste is an LSU grad. Here’s hoping he’s reading this and just gave me an extra day off.

Be sure to compliment Joe Starkey. Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.