Steelers-Colts: Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo break down the Steelers win

It didn’t matter that the Steelers had the second-longest interception return for touchdown in history. Or that they had five sacks against a team that protected their quarterback the way a dog guards a pork bone. Or that the Indianapolis Colts were down to their third-string quarterback.

When it was all over on a crisp fall afternoon at Heinz Field, it took a missed field goal from the NFL’s all-time leading scorer to give the Steelers their third victory in a row, fourth in the past five games and a move back to sea level for the first time this season.

Adam Vinatieri, the ageless kicker who had accumulated 2,650 points with two different teams in 24 seasons, was wide left on a 43-yard field goal with 1:14 remaining to give the Steelers a 26-24 victory on Sunday and improve their record to 4-4 at the midpoint of the season — a significant bounce-back after an 0-3 start.

“It’s good to be .500 at the turn, given where we’ve come from,” coach Mike Tomlin said. “It’s still going to be awhile trying to get that September stench off us. It’s good to be sitting at 4-4. I never thought I’d hear myself say that.”

Advertise with us

The miss by Vinatieri, the oldest active player in the league, was an unexpected ending because the 46-year-old kicker had converted 20 of his past 21 attempts in the final minute of a game or overtime. He has made 24 game-winning kicks in his career, including last week when his 51-yard field goal beat the Denver Broncos.

It wasn’t as costly as Mike Vanderjagt’s shanked 43-yard field goal with 21 seconds remaining in the 2005 AFC playoff game against the Steelers — a loss that kept the Colts from hosting the AFC championship game. But it was just another close encounter for the Colts, the only team in the league that has had every game decided by seven points or fewer.

“It’s great to get a win against a winning team that’s been in a lot of close games and won a lot of them,” Tomlin said. “It’s good when you can be in a game against a team that’s used to winning close games and pull it out.”

After beating the winless Cincinnati Bengals and Miami Dolphins at home and winning on the road against the two-win Los Angeles Chargers, it was the first time this season the Steelers beat a team with a winning record. They get another chance next Sunday when the defending NFC champion Los Angeles Rams (5-3) are at Heinz Field.

“Coach Tomlin was preaching all week that we really hadn’t beaten a great team,” said running back Jaylen Samuels, who filled in for injured James Conner (shoulder) after sitting out the past three weeks with a knee injury and had a career-high 13 catches for 73 yards. “For us to beat a great team who was 5-2, they were hot, it was huge for us and the organization.”

Advertise with us

And yet, after the Steelers had taken a 23-18 lead on the third of Chris Boswell’s four field goals at the start of the fourth quarter, it was a fumble by Samuels at the Steelers 30 that set up the Colts’ go-ahead touchdown — a 4-yard pass from backup quarterback Brian Hoyer to receiver Chester Rogers — that made it 24-23 with 8:43 remaining.

But the Steelers got a big 40-yard completion from Mason Rudolph to his former college teammate James Washington on the first play of the ensuing series, then a pass interference call against cornerback Marvell Tell on receiver Diontae Johnson to the Colts 7 two plays later to set up Boswell’s fourth and final field goal, this one from 26 yards with 6:36 remaining.

The Colts never scored again, despite a 35-yard pass interference penalty against Steve Nelson and two failed interference challenges by Tomlin that cost the Steelers a pair of timeouts on the Colts’ final drive.

“It gives more validation to what we can do and it will give us confidence,” said linebacker T.J. Watt, who had 1½ of the five sacks against the Colts. “Winning in the NFL is tough, regardless who it is, but when you beat a team with a winning record and is really respectable the in AFC, it definitely helps.”

The Colts had allowed only 11 sacks in their first seven games, but four of the five sacks were against Hoyer, who threw for 168 yards and three touchdowns after he replaced injured Jacoby Brissett in the first quarter.

Advertise with us

The Steelers also had three more takeaways by the defense, giving them 22 in eight games, none more spectacular than safety Minkah Fitzpatrick stepping in front of a Hoyer pass for tight end Jack Doyle and returning the interception 96 yards for a touchdown with 2:21 remaining in the first half — the team’s longest interception return for touchdown in the regular season in 86 years.

Of course, the longest interception return for touchdown was 100 yards set by James Harrison in Super Bowl 43, which is considered one of the greatest plays in Super Bowl history.

“I was just reading the quarterback,” said Fitzpatrick, who has had a hand in eight of the Steelers’ 22 takeaways this season, despite not joining the team until the third game of the season in a major trade. “He looked right first, then he looked hard left, shoulders turned and everything, so I just started drifting that way. He let go of the ball and I went and got it.”

But it wasn’t just Fitzpatrick. Outside linebacker Bud Dupree forced a fumble on one of his two sacks when he stripped the ball from Hoyer on fourth-and-4 at the Steelers 35 in the third quarter. But his biggest play was stopping running back Marlon Mack for a 3-yard loss on third-and-1 at the Steelers 22, keeping the Colts from bleeding the clock and forcing them to send Vinatieri on the field for what most people thought would be the go-ahead points.

“It was great to beat that team,” Dupree said. “A lot of people said we hadn’t really beaten anyone with a winning record so we had to go out and show we had it in us, to show we can compete with a team like that.”

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac