
Brian Batko: All right everyone, time for another chat. Steelers don't play again until Monday night. Hope everyone's making it through the long hiatus OK.
Tom: With a couple of million dollars in your pocket, is it really that hard to stay out of trouble?
Brian Batko: I wouldn't know.
Nino Bruce: Is Ben Rothlesberger re-signing a guarantee?
Brian Batko: Ben is under contract for two more years after this one. I would say that him being back for another deal after that one is far from a guarantee.
Old School: I think the national media has been a bit tough on Mason Rudolph - essentially writing him off as a potential quality starting QB. The guy was not a first round draft pick, is starting his first few games, is replacing a Hall of Fame quarterback, and is without all world receiver AB. I think they ought to give the guy a little time, at least a season or so before making final judgments. Your thoughts?
Read More
Brian Batko: Yeah, but a lot of people prefer to make snap judgments and rush to make up their mind these days. How about everyone crushing him after the 49ers game, when we now know that they might just be the best defense in the league outside of New England? My thoughts are the jury is still out on Rudolph. But they likely have 10 more games to deliberate.
Mike: Do you think offense will continue to open up for mason to take more downfield shots? If so, is that a good thing or dangerous thing in your opinion? Thanks!
Brian Batko: I think it will. And to me, that's a good thing, not just for him but also for someone like JuJu Smith-Schuster, who's been pretty quiet.
VAmsterdam: Do you think smoking weed before a game would help the players? How about the refs?
Brian Batko: Probably not, no
MD: What is it going to take to get Finney on the field over the inept Foster? Is the organization so focused on saving face for signing Foster to a bad deal that there is nothing that could happen outside of injury to enable this change?
Brian Batko: I think it would take some pretty poor performance, much worse than he's been, for Ramon Foster to get benched. But if any interior lineman goes down, you'll probably see Finney in there.
RJT: Hodges being under center last week really helped the Steelers run game. Offensive lineman can line up in 3 point and fire off the ball. With mason back I’m afraid this will go away because he is not comfortable with it.
Brian Batko: No one has ever said he's not comfortable with it. In fact, Rudolph has gone out of his way to say he's happy doing anything. Lining up under center, play action, QB sneaking. It's probably more a matter of what the Steelers think he's best at doing.
Greg: Do all NFL coaches give their players vacation during the bye week? Seems like too much opportunity to make a poor choice. Reminds me of when Joey Porter was shot outside that Denver sports bar in 2003 (Sunday at 2 am).
Brian Batko: I believe so. Really, it shouldn't be a concern. The Steelers almost got out of it unscathed. But not quite. Lots of guys went away though and stayed out of trouble. IT only takes one.
JB: do you feel we need to drafter smarter players as opposed to superior athletes like the Patriots. We seem to always have communication problems and be out of place. I know you still need athletes but they seem to put a lot of emphasis on spart testing
Brian Batko: Not really, no.
mrbig: isn't MNF the type of trap game Tomlin is known for playing down to? Bad team on road-
Brian Batko: Stay tuned for a story on this later in the week. We've still got a long time until gameday.
TXSteeler: Aren’t we all being a little too dramatic to say the Steelers running game got back on track? Connor did great work as a receiver but still averaged less than 4 yards/carry?”.
Brian Batko: Are we just going to ignore Benny Snell?
John Strange: Hopefully the Steelers can defeat the Dolphins at home and the Bengals on the road. Any other wins on their schedule?
Brian Batko: Colts at home, possibly. Bills at home still looks good. Jets on the road. Browns are looking mighty unimpressive. And Arizona, well, they're still rebuilding. There could be several wins still left on the schedule.
Pauline: Ravens Won . Season over? Need to go 8-2 as a fact from now on, either for wildcard or Division .. Am I right Brian ?
Brian Batko: I'm going to play the odds and say that no, you are wrong. Especially on the season being over part. I definitely have to work the rest of this week.
Delusions: I can't believe there are fans and local media members thinking Steelers can finish 10-6 or 9-7 and make the playoffs. What games and team are these people watching? I wish I could be that detached from reality.
Brian Batko: More of a rhetorical question, but OK.
Mason Rudolph prepares for the Dolphins
Fielding Fowler : If the defense continues to get take away, and the offense only improves, all games on the schedule are potential wins, n'est pas?
Brian Batko: You and Delusions should have a sidebar.
Rich from Indio: After watching the Ravens game it is clear that they are the superior team in the AFC North. They committed to the run. The Steelers have not and are paying the price with or without Big Ben. What would it take to get them to refocus on the run?
Brian Batko: I agree with you Rich, the Ravens are the best team in this division and will win it. The Steelers will still try to run the ball. Miami should offer a chance to go over 100 yards on the ground for a second consecutive game.
Jaxon: Good Morning Brian, Saw the news this morning re: Anthony Chickillo. I would imagine this will lead to more snaps for Ola. Will the Steelers need to find another Edge rusher on the mkt ?
Brian Batko: Not sure. Jayrone Elliott was their next OLB up and they cut him to make room for Paxton Lynch on the active roster last week. They could always bring him back. The only LB on the practice squad is Robert Spillane and he's more of an inside guy. We'll see what happens with Chickillo, but this should be a big opportunity for Ola.
NC Yinzer: Just curious if it was reported what was up with all the bad snaps last week? Every time I would look forward to seeing Duck do something the snap would be bad.
Brian Batko: Shaun Sarrett the OL coach said Maurkice Pouncey might've just lost his grip on the ball more often than he normally does, but that they'll get it cleaned up.
scrub: I have no faith in this coaching staff and am amazed by the player mistakes during games. However, I find myself rooting for this team more than in years past. Why is that?
Brian Batko: Duck
jds317: Do the Steelers cut Chickillo over this incident?
Brian Batko: Maybe. His contract seems to be pretty back-loaded. We simply don't have enough information at this point to know how they'll proceed. The NFL could also step in above the Steelers.
Alan in Nashville: Hi, Brian. I understand that the Steelers are not allowing Chickillo in the building today. I know we can't jump to conclusions but please tell us that if there's even a sniff of proof that he laid hands on a woman, he'll be sent packing. And I don't care who they have on the roster. They've done so much to shed the "Team Turmoil" label and they don't need a backup OSLB to change that at all. What do you think? Thanks!
Brian Batko: We know that NFL teams and decision makers don't value all players equally. To me, he's a player that certainly isn't going to warrant any extra wiggle room because of his ability to help the team.
AzVic: Hi Brian, we enjoy your Steelers chat. In your opinion, what are the Steeler's greatest needs come next years draft.
Brian Batko: I'm glad you speak for everyone there, AzVic. Edge rusher will be No. 1, assuming Bud Dupree lands elsewhere. And I think you can get a good one without a first-round pick. Look at Chase Winovich, who was a third-rounder. He's not playing all that much on defense for New England, but he's productive when he's in, and would maybe be a starter for a lesser unit.
Alex B : In order to compete for
Alex B : a playoff spot the offense will have to evolve a whole bunch, will we see that going on the Miami game and beyond ?
Brian Batko: Could go either way this week. Against Miami, you can probably play another very conservative style and win, maybe even easily. But it could also give you a chance to let Mason Rudolph air it out and gain some confidence against a bad team. Unless the Dolphins get frisky, I think you'll see the Steelers focus on the ground game, for the most part.
Jeff: Great chat Brian. I understand why Montcrief was getting benched but isn't it time to give him another shot? He had a great camp and early on seemed to be the only one getting separation. I get that interception from the missed ball was devastating but like we did with Boswell, let him work it out.
Brian Batko: They did give him a shot in LA, sort of by default though, with James Washington injured. And hey, he caught his only target. Thing is, if you intend on cutting him within the next three weeks to likely recoup a comp pick in the draft, you might not want to risk him getting hurt.
Maxwell : Hi Brian, I have noticed the past several games that Keith Butler play calling sheet have actually got smaller maybe the size of an index card size. It's it possible to think Austin is calling the defense now? And yes before it was a large one.
Brian Batko: Ha, I have not noticed this myself. Maybe he's writing smaller. As for Teryl Austin and his influence, not sure how much say he has in the calls, but he is a former DC and seems to be working wonders with the DBs. Wrote about him over the weekend https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/10/20/teryl-austin-s...

MD: Do the Steelers have the worst set of skill position players in the league?
Brian Batko: They won't even have the worst set of skill position players on the field next Monday night.
John from Florida: I have been a Steeler fan for over 50 years and a NFL fan for that same time. However I must say that this year has been the most confusing time for following the rules of the game. On any given play an official can throw a flag and everyone in the stadium including coaches hold their breath to see what it is for and if it should be reviewed. No one including the announcers on TV know what to say about the rules. The players just look at each other and complain but no one really knows what to say. Even the newly hired ex officials have a problem explaining how it works. For goodness sakes, lets get back to simple rules and quit ruining the game that I used to enjoy so much ! I'm curious, What do the players say in the locker room about the new rules ?
Brian Batko: They generally don't protest too much. The smart ones point out that you shouldn't let one play or one call affect an entire game. Keep your eyes peeled for a fuller look at this on the website at some point soon.
Retire21: Jesse James must be in his hideout in the mountains because he’s M.I.A. In Motown. Nell is running in quicksand in the NJ swamps. AB is begging to play....anywhere. Steelers lookopretty savvy? Although L,J. Fort looked god in Ravens purple yesterday.
Brian Batko: Eh, yes and no. James would've been helpful here, but he got paid well by Detroit. Bell has had some nice moments but just hasn't had much help in that offense. A.B. might still be the best receiver on the planet, but, yeah.Even the guys they've moved on from more recently such as Tuzar Skipper and Diontae Spencer aren't much more than bit role players for their new teams.
Guest: A friend watching the ravens game brought up an interesting point. Why are Qbs allowed to run toward the sideline,fake stepping out of bounds and then stay in to get a few extra yards. Seems a bit unfair to a defender who will certainly be flagged if he hits a QB the least bit out of bounds. Love to see the rule changed to call forward progress stopped at the spot of the fake.
Brian Batko: YEah, Lamar Jackson's pretty good at that, ain't he? He's fearless. Love watching him play. Also don't mind having him on my fantasy squad.
Doug from Raleigh: Does it appear that anyone who was nicked up last week will not be able to go Monday night, or is that a question best asked of Paul on Thursday?
Brian Batko: We'll certainly know more later in the week. I think the Steelers' first official injury report will be Thursday. There don't seem to be too many lingering issues, though.
stephen: What is the status of last year's OL draft- Okafer? Is he being groomed>
Brian Batko: Good question. Chuks Okorafor the third-round pick has been inactive for every game. I asked OL coach Shaun Sarrett about him last week and he said "I think his eyes are opened now when he sees the competition, especially like with [Zach] Banner. He sees, here’s a guy who’s a big guy who’s bringing a lot of energy, and it’s a competition. He knows the best guy’s going to go on the field, so he’s competing with him every week and right now Banner’s winning the job, so it’s just something he’s going to continue to compete and come after."
guest: Hi Brian, how can the national media hob-knob Aaron Rodgers to the enth degree after a bit of a fluke game. I mean last year alone against the Panthers Ben has more TD passes than incompletions and a perfect rating for the 4TH TIME!!!! (AR only has one just now) and yet Ben's game is just meh. Same with his 500 yards 3x and AR a fat ZERO! I mean i can go on but safe to say Rodgers is overrated regardless of what his stats are...he flames out when games count haha
Brian Batko: Aaron Rodgers yesterday was throwing to Marquez Valdes-Scantling, Geronimo Allison, Jake Kumerow and Allan Lazard. as his WRs. He should be getting MORE MVP buzz if you ask me.
Sterling A: Hi Brian. You're now the head coach of the Miami Dolphins. Do you continue tanking as you obviously did by going for two against the Redskins in the hopes of getting the first overall pick, or do you do everything in your power to beat the Steelers in order to maximize the first round pick you got from them in the Fitzpatrick trade? Decisions, decisions...
Brian Batko: Oh hell yeah, I'm rich!
You raise a good point, though. IF there's any game the Dolphins might want to win, it should be this one, just for the chance of incrementally improving one of their three first-round draft picks. If I'm Brian Flores, in addition to being filthy rich, I'm trying to win this game. I'm betting on myself to be so bad we still finish 1-15 and alone in last place
TXSteeler: Did anyone ask why William’s and others just sat there and stared at the fumble that Bush picked up and ran in? Seems rather basic to have jumped on it, esp for veterans
Brian Batko: Keith Butler said he's just glad Vince Williams didn't kick it
Jon Snow: The Steelers with Tomlin leading the charge were very high on Lamar Jackson. Had they drafted him the Ravens prolly would have not won the division last year and we would have been in better shape this year when Ben went down. What are your thoughts?
Brian Batko: It's an intriguing hypothetical. With how well he's played, I guess I'd be a fool to pick any path that doesn't have that guy on my team. I'm sure there are a lot of franchises right now wishing they would've snagged him with their first-round pick. The future would look mighty bright.
Bad Form: You say the Ravens are the better team, but really, it can't be by much. I was not in awe of Baltimore when they beat the Steelers in a very close game.
Brian Batko: No, but let's remember the Steelers actually played pretty well in that one. Mason was having maybe his best game until he got knocked out. Hodges stepped in and did so admirably. But the Ravens improved their defense by getting Marcus Peters, I think.
Mike: Maybe it doesn’t matter because it’s Miami, but would you rather face Rosen or Fitzpatrick? You never know when Fitzmagic shows up!!!!
Brian Batko: Yeah I think I'd rather face Josh Rosen at this point. And I'll admit, I liked him going into the draft last year. He just hasn't been able to right the ship for himself in two rather brutal situations. Fitzmagic on Monday Night? You never know.
Todd Haley: Brian, Missing me much???
Brian Batko: I never met you, Todd.
Susan Lucci: Drama aside. Do the Steelers miss Bell or Brown more?
Brian Batko: Brown
livinthedream: after watching the Denver OL the other day do you think old mike might be wishing he was back in pgh?
Brian Batko: I would've thought the Broncos OL would be crushing it given how many people in this chat were blaming the Steelers' issues on Munchak leaving
Thomas: Whats the chance the Steelers start throwing downfield again this year? You know, 10-12-15 yard routes, not 2-3 yards. Lets see what this kid can do.
Brian Batko: I'll go with 92 percent, Thomas
Jeff H.: How is Mason Rudolph's recovery from a concussion coming along? Is he close to getting cleared to play on Monday night?
Brian Batko: He's cleared. He'll start.
Ralph LA: When does it make sense for an offense to run the wildcat? Is it just a case that it’s novel and it’s disorientating if a defense hasn’t seen it before?
Brian Batko: Pretty much. Or if you're in a really unfortunate situation at QB. Maybe short-yardage, at times. Maybe if you have a unique kind of player that can run a lot and pass a little.
Jacque Strap: Did you watch any games this weekend? See or learn anything interesting?
Brian Batko: I watched some of the Pitt game Friday night. That was an interesting game. Spent most of my Sunday doing the RedZone thing, so I learned that the Chargers are having a season from hell. The end of their loss to Tennessee was abominable.
Retire 32: Why the indifference to extending Hargrave during the summer? The guy is an absolute beast and I can't see him staying now with his reputation growing every week. He's as good as gone after this year wouldn't you agree?
Brian Batko: He's good, but still at a position that just doesn't play a whole lot of snaps in today's NFL. He'll have a chance to prove more the rest of this season with Stephon Tuitt out.
guest: more buzz after one game! that's sickening. But you've proven my point. Rodgers has one game he's won MVP. Ben's done that PLUS on NUMEROUS occasions and meh. that makes him even more overrated with you're comment.
Brian Batko: It me, guy leading a one-man charge to gas up Aaron Rodgers for some reason
Buffy: Re: domestic violence issue --- I remember when James Harrison was charged and the Steelers stood behind him (notably, Dan Rooney); another player who was a back-up and had similar charges at the same time was cut immediately.
Brian Batko: You're thinking of wide receiver Cedrick wilson
Iron City: Is it too soon to say the Steelers get a good grade with the 2019 draft? I think it is B+
Brian Batko: Way too soon, my dear Iron City
Faris: When the offense is back on the field are they finally going to let the qb get in a rythym and stop with the stupid wildcat ?
Brian Batko: We didn't see the Wildcat at all in LA. Thinking we won't see it again with Mason Rudolph back in.
Utah Jim: I’ve read one of the reasons behind the struggling run game, at least before the Chargers, is Linemen don’t get in a 3-point stance when the QB is in the Shotgun, which the Steelers run a lot. Why don’t they?
Brian Batko: Need to be set up to get right into pass protection.
Guest: Do you foresee the team being active prior to the trade deadline? Any chance they move a guy like Hargrave or did that ship sail with Tuitt going down?
Brian Batko: I don't see it. They've already done more wheeling and dealing than usual, which depleted their draft picks, and the Steelers hardly have a surplus of valuable commodities on the roster at this point.
Jack Lambert's tooth: Any chance they can get tuzar back to play lb?
Brian Batko: Only if they trade for him or if the Giants release him.
Fielding Fowler : Maurkice was also quoted in the PG as in the middle of talking trash, and was surprised by the snap call from Duck. Blamed himself.
Brian Batko: Correct, he owned up to those snap issues vs. the Chargers
Mr Big Chest: Does a desperate team take a shot with me this year?
Brian Batko: I don't think so, but Michael Irvin is on his soap box asking for the Cowboys to do it
GhostOfIvanToncic: If there were an onside kick in the PG sports department, who is on your five-man/woman hands team, and why?
Brian Batko: I'm not putting myself on there, that's for sure. Our Pens guys, Matt Vensel (former goalie) and Mike DeFabo (solid high school outfielder at Latrobe). Paul Zeise was a soccer goalie I think, so I'll take him too. And then lastly, Ray Fittipaldo and Nubyjas Wilborn. They at least played college football. I like our chances.
Mark: What’s your score prediction for next Monday nights game?
Brian Batko: Something like Steelers 27, Dolphins 20. But maybe I'll change my mind in the next seven days. OK, that's all the time we have for today. Sorry if I couldn't get to your question. You can always tweet me or email it to me for our weekly Steelers mailbag. Enjoy this fall foliage, folks.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.