The story almost sounds mythical. Memphis offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner once told his charges a fable about Michigan coach Bo Schembechler (for whom Fichtner once worked as a graduate assistant) and his rival, Ohio State’s Woody Hayes, ice fishing together.

Schembechler was catching the fish, as Fichtner’s tale went. Hayes was not, and finally Hayes asked Schembechler for his secret. Fichtner then reached into his mouth, extracted several worms he had dug up outside the facility before the meeting and slammed them on the desk in front of him.

“Whatever it takes, mother*******!” Fichtner yelled. “You got to do whatever it takes to keep your worms alive.”

“He was a little whacky,” said Danny Wimprine, who played quarterback under Fichtner for four years at Memphis and relayed the story. “A little crazy guy.”

Advertise with us

This season Fichtner, in his second year as the Steelers’ offensive coordinator, has faced circumstances requiring similar desperation. A season-ending elbow injury to Ben Roethlisberger forced Fichtner to adapt his game plan to Mason Rudolph. Rudolph spent the past week in the concussion protocol after Baltimore Ravens safety Earl Thomas knocked him unconscious last Sunday. The Steelers are 1-4, and undrafted rookie Devlin Hodges will make his first career start on the road against the Los Angeles Chargers on “Sunday Night Football.”

“Obviously we started off our season very slow and [Fichtner] just kept a positive face,” JuJu Smith-Schuster said. “He always kept it brutally honest with us on what we need to do. He’s just straightforward. He never sugarcoats anything. He’s been in situations like this before, so he knows us new guys, we haven’t.”

Fichtner has spent 13 seasons coaching various portions of the Steelers offense after 22 years at the collegiate level. He was born in Cleveland but played high school ball in Meadville, Pa., before playing defensive back at Purdue. He immediately joined the Boilermakers’ coaching staff after graduating in 1985, then made stops at Michigan, Southern Cal and UNLV before spending four seasons as the wide receivers and quarterbacks coach at Memphis.

Fichtner returned to Purdue for three years as the wide receivers coach until the entire staff was let go after the 1996 season. His former coach at Memphis, Chuck Stobart, reached out to Joe Hollis, who had just taken the head coaching job at Arkansas State. “I got a young guy that coached for me,” Stobart told Hollis. “He’s a wonderful coach. I’d love for you to visit with him.”

“Any time you’re interviewing someone … you get the sense if they’re on the way down or they’re on the way up, and I got the sense overwhelmingly that Randy was on the way up,” Hollis said.

Advertise with us

Fichtner spent four years in Jonesboro as offensive coordinator. In 2000, Memphis came to town with an excellent defense. Fichtner’s offense was the only team to rush for more than 100 yards against them all year in a 19-17 loss.

“They couldn’t stop us,” Hollis said. “We couldn't stop them, but they beat us by less than a touchdown … The next thing I know, [new Memphis coach] Tommy [West] is on the phone with me wanting to talk to Randy soon as the football season’s over to hire him as the offensive coordinator.”

“I was going to start a total new offense, build it from scratch, wanted to be a spread, tempo team,” said West, now the defensive line coach at Middle Tennessee State. “Therefore, I wanted a guy with energy to run it, because to me it’s an energy offense. Nobody had more energy than Randy.”

Former players and colleagues describe Fichtner as energetic, outgoing, a jokester.

“He says he can draw, but he really can’t,” Smith-Schuster said. “He tries to draw. A whole bunch of things. Smiley face, cartoon characters the majority of the time. … He does not have the talent at all.”

Advertise with us

Film study and attention to detail helped Fichtner, who took over play-calling duties from Hollis in his second year at Arkansas State, create his own offense.

“He was more of a schemer, as in, trying to combat what the defense was doing,” Wimprine said. “He took a lot of control of the offense and tried to figure out, by watching a lot of film and figuring out what defenses were doing.”

While at Arkansas State, Fichtner coached alongside a young wide receivers and defensive backs coach named Mike Tomlin. When Tomlin took over the Steelers in 2007, he hired Fichtner as his wide receivers coach. Three years later Fichtner became the quarterbacks coach, and the Steelers promoted him to offensive coordinator in 2018 after Todd Haley was let go.

Roethlisberger led the league in passing yards last season and the Steelers ranked fourth in total offense, averaging 403.3 yards per game. This year, after losing Roethlisberger, Rudolph and Antonio Brown, the Steelers’ 280.6 yards per game ranks 29th. Fichtner employed a dink-and-dunk passing attack to take advantage of a weak Cincinnati Bengals linebacking corps in a Week 4 victory. He also used Jaylen Samuels out of the wildcat, with varying success, to try to jump-start the run game.

This week, Fichtner won’t have Samuels, who will miss a month after knee surgery. He also won’t have James Washington, who has a shoulder injury. He’ll have Hodges.

Advertise with us

“We don’t have separate meetings,” Fichtner said. “I don’t say, Ben, you come in and meet with me and then the other guys, we’ll catch you up. That’s not the case. They’re in there all the time.

For someone described as energetic, Fichtner was soft-spoken while addressing the media on Thursday. His dark brown eyes hid behind sunglasses to blunt the early-afternoon sun as he fielded a dozen questions about Hodges. He knew who Hodges was because Hodges won the Walter Payton Award, the Football Championship Subdivision’s Heisman Trophy, during his senior season at Samford. Fichtner’s father, Ross, was an assistant coach with the Chicago Bears during Payton’s tenure, so Randy keeps tabs on the award.

Hodges, Smith-Schuster and Johnny Holton all said Fichtner did not change his presentations of the game plan after the injuries, and it is expected that Hodges will run the same game plan as Rudolph would have.

“We’re going to play Steeler ball, that’s what we do,” Donte Moncrief said. “He’s ready to go, we’ve just got to get ready to play for him.”

Fichtner also planned to revisit film of Hodges in the preseason to find schemes that worked. He’ll need to find something: Only the winless Bengals are keeping the Steelers out of last place in the AFC North, and the Steelers are 0-2 on the road this season.

Advertise with us

“I think as far as just in game-planning for any new quarterback, you can’t keep it simple, so simple that it’s not effective,” Fichtner said. “But you’d better be careful.”

Steelers confident in Devlin Hodges

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.