Brian Batko: Howdy, folks. Thanks for your interest in the chat. The Steelers are 1-4. Where should we begin? I'll let you all decide.
Tom: What ever happened to a defensive player being able to get back onsides before the ball was snapped? I get if they are unabated to the qb or bump an O lineman but what about a guy clearly going stepping back?
Brian Batko: You're talking about the neutral zone infraction called on TJ Watt on Baltimore's first drive. Yeah, I didn't understand that one. I figure we'll have a lot of questions/comments about the officiating today. Let me just say this: I'm really not into blaming the refs for losses and spending a ton of time on dissecting calls. It's a difficult job, and yes, they affect the game, but it's just something you have to deal with. If you run into a bad ref in the morning, you ran into a bad ref. If you run into a bad ref all day, maybe reffing is just really hard.
REID: Brian, The Duck looked better in the pocket than Mason. More comfortable, went through the reads, threw the ball downfield. I don’t understand why Rudolph seems to be behind other 2nd year QBs and even rookies as far as “NFL Ready”.
REID: Who gets the start next week if Rudolph is healthy?
Brian Batko: Probably Hodges. If he would've bombed, maybe Paxton Lynch gets promoted to the active roster and to QB1 in one fell swoop. But instead, I agree with you Reid, Duck swooped in and looked the part. I disagree with you on Rudolph, though. I thought he was playing well until the injury. In fact, one of the many shames of it is he got hurt on maybe his best play of the day.
Read More
Roger c: We have taken the ball away 12 times this season, what is the reason why we cant capitalize on them?
Brian Batko: Having a short field, apparently. The Steelers are like one of those basketball players who can make threes but stink at free throws. Go figure. Don't really have an answer for you on their shortcoming in sudden change situations, other than going over those specific drives and what went wrong.
Puzzled: Brian, Do you have any idea why our offensive line is so poor at run blocking? By the way, LeVeon Bell is gone. Why do we continue running from the shotgun formation when our running backs are not named LeVeon Bell and can't run with his distinct style?
Brian Batko: We've discussed this. It's a line built more for pass pro to begin with, and it's also more difficult to run-block out of shotgun. I think the usage of that formation is probably for Mason Rudolph's comfort more than anything, though of course he said he's fine going under center, too. It is also an aging line. That could have something to do with it.
R Russell: I’ve never a person after being knocked unconscious told to sit up and walk. Why didn’t they use a backboard and stretcher if the cart was broken? Aren’t there two carts? Seems like bad medical care. He could have had a spinal injury. Who’s responsible?
Brian Batko: Yeah, that was bizarre. That's why I thought it had to be asked to Mike Tomlin after the game. Obviously, he's not in charge of that process, which is what his answer amounted to. But it's reasonable to expect he was provided some sort of explanation from those who are. If he was, he didn't want to get into it. If he wasn't, then he could've just said the team would look into it. Really strange and tough to watch all around.
Brian Batko: And yes, it's since been reported that there is another cart on the opposite sideline. Some players also said Rudolph wanted to walk off on his own. But still, bad look for everyone there.
Kyle: What will it take for them to come up with a different plan to cover the middle of the field?
Brian Batko: I mean, you can't cover everything. Every defensive scheme is susceptible to something. Steelers played pretty well on that side of the ball, for the most part. If you start paying more attention to tight ends, what might happen to you in other areas of the field? At some point, guys just have to be able to win one-on-one matchups. Devin Bush lost and won one in the same play on his interception, which was a fairly mind-boggling feat of athleticism by him.
WhoNu: When do you think Conner and JuJu will get the DO YOUR JOB message?
Brian Batko: I'll tell them that WhoNu would like a word
Shingles: When the first score (TD) wins the game, the opening kickoff in OT should NEVER be deferred - change my mind.
Brian Batko: Not really gonna try to change your mind, because I agree with you wholeheartedly. I didn't think it was a good decision by Tomlin at the time and I still don't. Not gonna change my tun because it more-or-less worked. That'd be what smart people call results bias, right? Simple enough: if you have a chance to win the game, take it. If the other team has a chance to win the game, don't give it to them.
Retire21: MT's strategy to kick rather than receive should have paid off, what with the newer rule guaranteeing teams a possession. Why are people so critical?
Brian Batko: Ha. The current OT rules in the NFL do NOT guarantee both teams a possession. Official Walt Anderson misspoke at midfield for the coin toss. The team that defers only gets the ball if the offense doesn't score a touchdown. So, yeah, as well as the Steelers D was playing, all it took was one busted coverage or breakdown against Lamar Jackson and that would've been ballgame.
Daniel in Ohio: These head scratching decisions by Tomlin keep getting overlooked...if the return game is bad enough to risk losing a game, why hasn’t it been addressed...I am personally tired of the excuses being made for this group of coaches...any thoughts?
Brian Batko: Well you can't really make those type of changes in-game. Plus, Tomlin's issue was more about Justin Tucker's kickoff ability, so there's not much you can do about that. He didn't want to get into that field position quandary, he said. But guess what? The Ravens have a really good punter, too, so you were gonna be embroiled in a field position battle you'd have to fight your way out of regardless. Take the ball. Let your Duck flag fly.
Doug from Raleigh: I agree that officiating is very difficult, more so because of the league parsing everything into 15 sub categories. But what is the excuse for New York not fixing egregious calls that the whole world can see for what they are? As is stands, they would not have reversed the play that caused all this mess, the non interference call on the Rams.
Brian Batko: Or maybe they would've.
Iron City: Personally I am proud of the way the Steelers played and were coached. Yes, it did not surprise me that the Ravens were fully prepared for the Wildcat so the Steelers has some mistakes, but they did adjust when they had to. The biggest problem now is their leaders, their stars are making to man mistakes. It is hard to fix that with coaching
Brian Batko: More of a comment than a question, but thank you, Iron City
Ken: Coach Tomlin has NEVER had a losing season. What do you think? This year may be the his first?
Brian Batko: Sure looks that way, Ken. That's my middle name. Thanks, Ken.
PittsburghPolka: I didn't think Ola's hit on Lamar Jackson deserved a flag, but why was Ola in for TJ Watt on that play in the first place? It was the 2nd play of a potentially game-clinching defensive drive - why was TJ out?
Brian Batko: They rotate defensive players, usually if a starter needs a break. I don't have any more of an issue with Ola being in on that play than I do with the general philosophy that I wrote about a few weeks ago when four backups were in for Seattle's long rushing touchdown by Rashaad Penny https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/09/19/steelers-mailb...
Guest: With the bye coming after next game, do you foresee any coaching changes ala Danny Smith/Keith Butler?
Brian Batko: No I don't expect anything like that to happen midseason
livinthedream: The Steelers are a very good team plagued by selfdestruction
Brian Batko: They're living the nightmare
Franco: Before the season I thought NO way Bud dupree gets extended next year. He would either be terrible and they will let him go or will break out and they wont be able to afford him. He seems to be in the middle of both of those right now. Is there a chance they can sign him to a moderate deal next year and stays in Pittsburgh? I know many people hate him because hes not playing to a first round caliber but hes better than alot of other options out there...
Brian Batko: Possibly, but I don't think that'd be a great fit for either side. Unless he really blows up over the last 11 games here. Bud could probably use a change of scenery and the Steelers could probably use some new blood on the edge.
GSMP: The inability to have a consistent running game is one of the most frustrating aspects to the Steelers play this year. Could the loss of Mike Munchak been that significant?
Brian Batko: On an individual personnel level, I don't think so. But perhaps he did more with Randy Fichtner from a run game coordination standpoint than people realized. Keep in mind though the Ravens had their nose tackle Brandon Williams back healthy Sunday after missing him last week when the Browns and Nick Chubb ran all over them. The Steelers have played pretty good fronts.
Ed: The only other coach to elect to kick in OT, under the current format, was “former” coach Hue Jackson, how many more bad decisions do the fans have to endure before we hear those glorious words “former” coach Tomlin?
Brian Batko: Don't know Ed, but I'm with you that Hue Jackson is not great company to be in when it comes to head coaching moves.
Mark: Under the current overtime rules, is Tomlin the 1st coach to ever defer possession?
Brian Batko: No Mark, Hue Jackson did it in 2015 against Miami. They had a third-string QB who was struggling. They lost anyway.
Thomaas: Brian, Do you have faith in Conner being a No. 1 back? To me he is a good complementary back but not your go to guy? What say the omnipotent Brian?
Brian Batko: I'm more omnipresent than omnipotent, but I do still believe in Conner's ability at this level. I think he's changed his body and style enough since his Pitt days to be more than just a short-yardage or complementary bruiser.
Harold H. : Mike Tomlin chose to kick off (it worked, by the way), and then fully explained his reasoning for the decision after the game. Tomlin didn’t fumble. Why all the negativity? I thought the coaches did a nice job. Also, was Hodges not fully prepared by the staff to step in run the “O” so confidently? The coaches did that!
Brian Batko: You make good points, Harold. And I did appreciate Tomlin's explanation. But for every person like yourself who wants to credit the coaching, five people want them all out on their butts. Blame JuJu for fumbling, credit Hodges for his composure, eat Arby's.
Hoops Mcann: On bright side - D is creating turnovers and not giving up the big play, special teams don’t suck and Boz appears to be back; however O is not capitalizing, which is understandable minus Ben, but the crucial late turnovers remain a killer. Juju and James fumbled away 3 games last year (Cle, Den NO) and 2 so far this year. Is it time to commit to gadget free run game (see Indy)? And is our O line capable?
Brian Batko: It should be. And sure, it would seem that the Steelers need to go a little more conventional with the run game to try to get it on track. But then again, the "gadget"esque approach worked wonders against the Bengals, with many of Mason Rudolph's completions just being an extension of a running game more than a traditional passing attack.
Anon: Do you think they will review roughing the passer penalties next year? Seems like they should. Bad calls all over the league.
Brian Batko: I kinda hope not. As you can maybe tell by my somewhat official-defending mini-rant up there, I'm fine with having less replay and more living with the human error aspect of sport. But hey, as long as teams still only get two challenges, I can see why some people would support this.
Myron : Tomlin has said he does not live in his fears he sure coaches like he does. No problem with OT call but still at home letting Ravens get the ball and win with a TD. Double Oi!!
Brian Batko: He wasn't afraid of the Ravens scoring a touchdown. Obviously.
fire and ice: 12 and 4 might get us in the playoffs! Defense is dominant and the offense is "that far" away from clicking on all cylinders.
Brian Batko: Difficult for me to quantify your "that far" but your optimism is refreshing. You go, "fire and ice"
Daniel in Ohio: Has there ever been thought of having an open discussion forum rather than just a chat setup for one question at a time?
JD: Why does Tomlin constantly ignore the kick-off return? He seems to pick the slowest guy all the time. Switzer, Toussand, Redmen, etc.
Long Island Steelers: Im not a big Tomlin fan - but that OT call to defer worked to perfections. The Ravens didn't score a TD in the second half and was playing well. our Kickoff team is a nightmare- why not defer. The defense held them to a 3 and out and we got the ball on the 30ish yard line. its not Tomlin's fault Juju fumbled. if he doesn't a FG wins it and all these Yinzer haters are singing a different tune today about that call
The Chief: Why are so many "fans" giving up already? The season isn't over, right? And the lame excuse of possibly trading away a top-10 draft pick for Minkah is foolish, at best. 1) Minkah is already proven, and locked down a position that just needed shoring, 2) If the Steelers do THAT badly this season, their #2 draft pick will be borderline #1 anyhow, and 3) Tony Mandarich, Ryan Leaf, Akili Smith, etc, etc., etc. Thoughts?
Steel one: Hi Brian - to me...Ramon Foster looks slow...how do view his intensity and game speed?
Brian Batko: There's a taste of an open discussion forum.
Dan: Basically gave the opening possession away without even trying... 2nd and Goal at the one, Steelers go Wildcat ... Steelerskickoff in OT after winning the toss, which is always the wrong decision... Botched time management at the end of the first half (and arguably the second half with the timeout before the Boswell FG attempt)... We could go on... How long can we keep defending these coaches?
Bulldogs: Comment to fire and ice re 12-4: if you're not being sarcastic, note that drugs are bad so don't do drugs, OK?
Steeler Nation peasant '63: Cam Heyward seemed confused about the OT conversation he was having with Walt Anderson at midfield... any insight?
Brian Batko: Yeah, I thought the same thing initially, and speculated on Twitter that he might've been confused about the Steelers kicking off. But I asked Cam about that postgame and that wasn't the case. He and Mike Tomlin were clear on what their call was if they won toss. Seems to he was flabbergasted that Walt Anderson didn't know the rule! Or at least misspoke about it on national television. You and me both, Mr. Heyward.
Sam: Come back, Brian
Sam: Any info given, or do you have a theory about why the gameplan and play calling for Hodges seemed much more like one you'd give a legitimate NFL quarterback than anything they've given Rudolph through three starts?
Brian Batko: To me, it seemed like Randy Fichtner just went with a much more conventional offense when Hodges came in, probably to simplify the approach somewhat for a guy getting his first exposure to that level of play. Maybe they're trying their best to set up certain things for Rudolph downfield? But yeah, the passing concepts with Duck in there made sense to me. Not as much "gimmicky" stuff to use Mike Tomlin's word.
Guest: Noticed Ed Werder tweeted Daniel Snyder's reported interest in Tomlin for the Washington job. Is there insider sentiment that he will be let go by the team this year?
Brian Batko: Not that I've sensed. Another team making a hard run at him could potentially make things interesting, though. Almost have to wonder that if this thing really goes south, would Tomlin want to just go embrace a new challenge? Although, if Ben Roethlisberger comes back fully healthy, that'd obviously be a boon to this team's chances in 2020..
Brian Batko: .
Alaska Steeler: Another game with horrible clock management when we needed it. Does this "coach" just not get how important this is?
Brian Batko: No, I think he knows
Texas Steeler: BB - had to listen to the broadcast online due to being surrounded ugly blue teams (silver/blue, red/blue/white)... until the fumble, I felt like the game was ours. Not quite as "sky is falling" as everything I read on PG this morning. Our defense was playing well and our offense was being effective enough. Am I missing something that was obvious from watching the game that I missed on the radio?
Brian Batko: Don't think so, my Texas chatting pal. By and large, the Steelers played an OK game. The start was bad, though. Real bad. Credit them for clawing back, but if they start faster, they probably end up doing enough to win.
Ralph: Brian, Speed kills ..... also lack of it on offense kills. we have no threat either downfield or in the backfield to break one. You have to have a threat. No, NO < No not Johnny Holton. What a waste of a roster spot
Brian Batko: Yeah, it's an indictment of this team's receiver depth how much he's playing now, I'll say that much. Donte Moncrief was brought in partially to be a potential deep threat. So much for that.
Titan in Charlotte: I LOVED Tomlin's call to differ. Can you really expect the "Duck" to go down the field and score an opening OT TD to close out the game? We would have punted to the Ravens, giving them decent field position, with Tucker needing a FG to win. Our defense played well enough late in the game to stop the Ravens from scoring a TD, but not well enough to stop them from driving into FG position. The decision worked, except for JUJU, so can we give Tomlin a little credit???
Brian Batko: Why not expect Duck to go do it? He's your backup for a reason. He was playing well. You're also saying that not only would Hodges not have led a TD drive, he wouldn't even have led a FG drive. So by that logic, Tucker opens with a FG, and then you expect Hodges to lead a FG drive? Can't eat your cake and have it too.
Geo Net: Hi Brian. The Duck played admirably, no doubt. But why didn't he just dive on the loose ball from JuJu fumble? I haven't heard any mention of it, he was right there!
Brian Batko: Fair observation, Sir Geo Net. But that was a wild loose ball drill in the heat of the moment. Duck said afterward the ball took a funny bounce and it's tough to adjust to footballs bouncing the wrong way. Don't think anyone can get on him too much for that one.
Tom in Dallas: LB is averaging 51.5 yds/game and 2.9 per carry. I would think way below his and the Jets expectation. Are these numbers reflective of sitting out a year, skills going down hill, or a really bad Jets team? He is averaging more yards than Conner, though....
Brian Batko: The Jets offense stinks, and does so especially with Luke Falk at QB. I don't think his skills have diminished all that much even after the layoff. Will these guys even be able to keep him healthy enough to face his old team Week 16? I hope they do.
Daniel not from Ohio: Brian, since someone asked about an open forum (I'd be against that), could you tell us what kind of questions you take?
Brian Batko: Honestly, there are so many questions every chat, especially this time of year. Same goes for Ray Fittipaldo and Gerry Dulac when they do theirs Tuesday and Wednesday. As I said at the end of the chat last week, I can never get to all of them. Not enough time in the day. I kind of just scroll through randomly and pick ones, trying to get to someone I haven't answered yet in that chat.
James from Philly : Jason La Canfora just tweeted that he firmly believes Dan Snyder and the Redskins will try to acquire Mike Tomlin. Not likely, but what would it take to get that deal done? 2 1st round picks?
Brian Batko: I have absolutely no feel for coach trades, including whether the Steelers would ever entertain that option.
Rags: Any chance they bring back Eli Rodgers
Brian Batko: Methinks that ship has sailed, Rags
Jacob: If God forbid Hodges were to have gone down yesterday, what do the Steelers do in that instance?
Brian Batko: Not really sure. I said on Twitter that I don't know who the emergency QB is. A couple people said it's obviously Jaylen Samuels and one person jumped down my throat for not knowing the answer to a question that rarely comes up and even more rarely matters. It's probably safe to assume that in that scenario, they just run Wildcat the rest of the way and do what they can. As far as who would be the next man up to try to throw a hail mary or something along those lines, I really do not know. Used to be Heath Miller for a long time.
Williamsburg : This defense is getting really good. What say you?
Brian Batko: I say yes
William: So the refs can throw 45 flags a game but miss the one play where a guy is layong on the ground unconscious. What is up with the officials today?
Brian Batko: They threw a flag eventually.
JerseySteel: Hi Brian - any update on how long James Washington might be out? He was starting to heat up against the Ravens before he got injured
Brian Batko: No update yet. Saw him in a sling in locker room. Doesn't necessarily mean it's serious, though.
Senor Beavis: Any update on Mason Rudolph's health?
Brian Batko: Not since it was reported last night that he's back home and resting up. He'll be in concussion protocol, and have to think he'll have a hard time clearing that in time for Sunday, but you never know with these things.
Greg: Why can't we find a kicker like that?
Brian Batko: Like Justin Tucker? No one can find a kicker like that except for the Ravens, Greg. He's the best in NFL history so far through what's probably only the first half or so of his career.
ME: I am sure I've missed this in past chats, but what is your record prediction? I'm feeling pretty optimistic that we could still pull off a winning record.
Brian Batko: I wouldn't say you "missed" it, ME. I think my initial prediction was 9-7. Then I moved down to 7-9. Maybe I should dip down a little more, but why? I didn't think they'd beat Baltimore anyway. I'll stick with 7-9. For now. Thanks again for chatting, everyone, gotta go.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.