Ray Fittipaldo: OK, let's get started.

Guest: I hope they put M.Fitzpatrick at Safety and keep him there. Ur thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Fitzpatrick will start at free safety this week. Mike Tomlin said today he will only play free safety vs. the 49ers in an effort to keep things simple for him as he learns the defense. In time, the Steelers will use his talents in different parts of the secondary. He's strong in coverage in the slot, and he's a nice chess piece to have in today's NFL.

RJT: Why are people down on the Fitzpatrick trade? He’s 22 years old, was the number 11 overall pick last year, the Steelers will have him for at least two more seasons, and Davis is gone after this year...

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Right. And Miami is on the hook for all his bonus money. All the Steelers pay is his salary going forward and his fifth-year option, which presumably they will.

Schenker: It seems recently that more players are speaking out about their discontentments and asking to be traded....do you think this a result of what AB did in speaking out and ultimately getting his way and setting an example for others?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think it's the NBA culture seeping into the NFL. Antonio Brown openly discussed this on an HBO show with LeBron James. However, Brown is a generational talent and could pull it off. Not sure how many others have the leverage to do that. I know Minkah Fitzpatrick asked for a trade and the Dolphins granted his request, but the Dolphins are in sell-off mode as they rebuild. That's kind of a different situation that doesn't happen all the time.

Nick in NL: With Jalen Ramsey asking for a trade and Jamal Adams maybe on the move that the Steelers could have gotten Fitzpatrick for cheaper if they had waited?

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe, but the Steelers had to move quickly with Sean Davis going on IR today. They clearly did not believe they could play another game with Kam Kelly as their starting free safety. I don;t want to say they were desperate, but they were getting close.

Advertise with us

Tampa Too: Ray. As always thanks for the chat. Cut Moncrief and resign Eli?

Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin didn't exactly give Moncrief a vote of confidence today at his news conference. When asked if Moncrief will be given the opportunity to work through his issues with the Steelers, Tomlin said: "We'll see." Sounds like he's already moved on. Not sure if they'll just cut him though. That would be admitting a huge mistake in free agency. And as we all know their record in signing outside free agents is an ongoing laugh line.

Victoria Lucas: Did the Steelers pay too high a price for Minkah Fitzpatrick? They needed someone at safety, but they just invested a lot on a single player, when I think their defensive problems are bigger than just one guy.

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe they feel different. I happen to think the front 7 is solid. I know they haven't played like it the first two games, but there are players to build around there with Watt, Tuitt and Bush. If Fitzpatrick can stabilize the secondary it might be worth it. I'm not saying he's going to fix all of their problems, but if he just does his part they might be in position to close some of these games out.

Victoria Lucas: Hi Ray, thanks for the chat! A question that I'm sure you'll get a lot of variations on today--have we just witnessed the end of the Ben Roethlisberger era?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think so. Every indication is he'll come back next year if the rehab goes as planned.

Hunkfudge: Will Moncreif sit to let Washington and Johnson have a chance? Steelers need a spark... and the enthusiasm of youth to develop with Rudolph.

Ray Fittipaldo: I'd like to see a heavy dose of Johnson and Washington this week to go along with JuJu. We'll see if Randy Fichtner is thinking the same way. Johnson can be a difference-maker for this team. It's just a matter of him being healthy and knowing the playbook.

BB: Ray - a ton of very high draft picks on the defensive roster now and they still underperform....bad talent selection, bad coaching or both?

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe a bit of both. Watt is looking like a great pick. And it's too early to tell on Bush. Others haven't been as good as Watt and have struggled. In some ways, the acquisition of Fitzpatrick is an indictment of their ability to draft defensive backs. Look at their secondary. Three of the four starters did not get drafted by the Steelers. And the lone draftee, Terrell Edmunds, has struggled.

Advertise with us

Hunkfudge: If Conner can’t go, will Samuels get most of the touches?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I think Samuels would get the majority of touches, but Snell would be used in short-yardage situations as he was vs. Seattle.

Tomlin's Heros : I like the move for Fitzpatrick and am hoping he helps complement Edmunds, what is your take?

Ray Fittipaldo: I like it at this moment though I reserve the right to change my mind if the Steelers go 3-13 and gave away a top-5 pick for him.

MD: Where do you think we have to finish to justify this Fitzpatrick trade? 11th or better? ESPN's FPI says there is a 62% chance that we would have had a top 10 pick.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Quite simply, the Steelers don;t think the way you do. They're not thinking about next year's draft right now. They're trying to make the playoffs. It's what they always do. When they started 0-4 in 2013 they didn't tank when they could have. They tried to make a run. And they did. If not for a short field goal miss on the final weekend of the season they would have made the playoffs at 8-8.

SOD NYC: Where is your over/under final record of the Steelers or draft pick # to still think that the Fitzpatrick trade was a good deal?

Ray Fittipaldo: 8-8 and No. 12 overall or lower.

TXSTEELER : Had anyone bothered to ask MT why they weren’t spying Wilson, esp after he sowed a willingness to run earlier in the final drive?

Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin was not asked that question today, but I did ask Bud Dupree about the lack of a spy Sunday after the game. They said they had no plans to use a spy in the game. It was not a part of the game plan whatsoever. They depended on linemen and LBs to remain in their rush lanes. Obviously, that plan did not work out, and now we are second-guessing their game planning.

Advertise with us

Curious Mind: Do you believe the Steelers are in a rebuilding or championship competition mode?

Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers never really go into rebuilding mode.

Zach: Given what they gave up for him and the reports of him unhappy with usage in Miami, do you think the Steelers already discussed their planned role for Minkah and made sure he was on board before pulling the trigger on trade? I’m dreading drama coming from him 2 weeks from now.

Ray Fittipaldo: All indications are he's a high character guy who simply got caught up in a bad situation in Miami. Tomlin said there are no concerns about bringing him into the fold.

The Windber Rambler: Ray, do you get any sense that maybe Kevin Colbert might be contemplating retirement soon with the Fitzpatrick trade? Meaning, that's very "unsteeler-like", historically (the last 30 years) trading the #1 like that … Is he trying to be in "win now" for the short-term? Is there potential for an entire "house-cleaning" if this season totally goes down the tubes, you think?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe but Art Rooney II still had to sign off on the move so Colbert obviously still has his trust. But I agree with you. On the surface, it seems like he's doing everything in his power to make sure things don't go sideways this season.

Plumbster: In your opinion, do you feel they have the talent on defense to be a solid unit and that the system is what the real issue is? If so is it time to turn the defense over to someone else?

Ray Fittipaldo: The biggest issue is their ability to cover in man. They're not getting the job done in that regard. But they also struggled with the run vs. Seattle particularly the scrambles by Wilson late in the game.

TXSTEELER : Has their been any explanation as to why the starters on the D-line and at OLB weren’t in during a critical 4th quarter drive?

Ray Fittipaldo: Presumably, their normal rotation. But I'm with you. The starters have to be in there in that situation. It was just after halftime. Watt and Dupree just had a long rest. Why let the backups play on that drive?

Advertise with us

Jud: Will Paxton likely replace Hodges after he learns the offense?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not this week, but I assume that will happen relatively soon.

The Windber Rambler: Would Omar Khan and the younger Dan Rooney be on a short-list of potential Steeler GM candidates - In the event Colbert retires?

Ray Fittipaldo: Danny Rooney is more likely to take his dad's job when he steps away in a few years. Omar and a few others already in the organization would be considered the GM job.

Jud: Where do you think we land with Rudolph at the helm?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: 6-10. Could be as good as 8-8 if things fall right. The schedule lightens considerably in the middle portion of the schedule.

Tom: Ray, Your thoughts on Ben vs Mason on physical abilities? Thank you.

Ray Fittipaldo: Mason's arm is not as strong. Then again, few QBs in the NFL today have Ben's arm strength. Mobility-wise, they're about the same. Don't expect to see too many more successful scrambles from Mason.

Y A Futtle: Ray, Mason likes to throw it down field. Do you think Randy will pull the reigns in on him?

Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin said today the personality of the offense will not change with Mason as the starter. So they'll let him do the same things Ben did. It won't be a dumbed-down version of the offense. Obviously, the play sheet might be a bit smaller, but mason has been around for more than a year and has a good grasp of how Fichtner wants to play.

Advertise with us

Duke : With all the news regarding Ben’s injury and the Fitzpatrick trade, just wondering if you have any thoughts , stories regarding the late Sam Davis

Ray Fittipaldo: Very sad to hear of his passing. I never met him, but reading the stories he obviously was well-liked and well-respected among his Super '70s teammates.

Dan: 6-10? Really?

Ray Fittipaldo: I suppose you think they'll go 10-6 and make the playoffs? Listen, I'm not totally down on them, but they're 0-2 and Mason Rudolph is going to make his first NFL start on the road this week. Let's be real here.

iowasteelerfan: Thought I read Fitzpatrick wanted out of Miami due to being asked to play all over their secondary - Isn't that exactly what he'll likely be asked to do here as well with his talents? We like DB who can move all over.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I think it also had to do with the Dolphins deciding to tank the year.

K dot: If/when we cut Moncrief how much money are we on the hook for?

Ray Fittipaldo: He signed for $9 million over two years. I think they'd be responsible for $5 or 6 million if they cut him with a manageable dead cap hit next year.

BigBad: Is L Jones available

Ray Fittipaldo: Under contract with the XFL so not eligible to play in the NFL

Advertise with us

Cy: Ray, How could the Steeler's FO missed so badly on Montcreif? Living in Jax it was so obvious the guy was average at best and a 4 or 5th receiver.

Ray Fittipaldo: That's a great question. My opinion: He was a deep threat with the Colts and Jags, and the Steelers tried to make him into something else. Maybe he has been miscast here.

The Windber Rambler: Are the Steelers also actively looking for a better option at backup TE?

Ray Fittipaldo: I imagine they're keeping their ears open. Does Miami have a good TE. Maybe they'll trade him.

iowasteelerfan: In the past were drops a concern for Moncrief?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: He certainly wasn't known for his hands. But he wasn't known to drops passes like this either.

Chris: D. Bush looks REALLY small out there. Seems to get pushed around more than we thought he would and needs a lot of help bringing down the player. Did we overreach and underestimate how his size would factor in?

Ray Fittipaldo: He's struggling right now. He doesn't have a full grasp of the defense and that hasn't allowed him to play fast. He's always been able to play bigger than his actual size. Once he learns the defense I think he'll be much better.

Heath Miller Fan: Ray, can someone ask Tomlin why his players year in year out are such poor tacklers and so stupid and/or undisciplined which leads to penalties costing the team victories.

Ray Fittipaldo: That was a bad tackling performance Sunday, that's for sure.

Advertise with us

Jud: At least no one is talking about our special teams these days...

Ray Fittipaldo: Not true! McCullers heavily criticized for his miscue on the FG attempt. Huge turning point in that game. It's 7-7 instead of 7-2. When you lose by two points plays like that are huge.

Tony: What are the odds Davis comes back at some point to man the free safety position and Fitzpatrick gets the slot job he wants? How siginficant is davis's injury?

Ray Fittipaldo: If/when Davis returns I imagine he'd be a reserve and play in the sub-packages.

Mike-EEE: With Mason as the new QB, will the coaching staff elevate James Washington to a starting WR role?

Ray Fittipaldo: Given Moncrief's struggles and the long-standing chemistry with Mason I'd be surprised if that doesn't happen this week.

ME: Is Cam Heyward still great?

Ray Fittipaldo: The season is only two games old. Give him some time.

FloridaSteelers: Is it possible providing the Steelers have a losing season that wholesale coaching changes are in store for 2020?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure about wholesale changes, but there definitely would be changes with a losing season.

Stephen: Hi Ray..I would like to advise my fellow Steelers fans that it is way too early to question Bush ‘s abilities. Troy P. was not great by any means in his rookie season. I think we need to give our young players a chance to develop before judging them.

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. It's going to take some time.

denver: What was it that Mccullers got a penalty for?

Ray Fittipaldo: Hitting the long snapper on a FG attempt.

Don: you an never have enough qb's..did we make a mistake in trading Josh Dobbs or did he never have a chance to make it here in Pgh?

Ray Fittipaldo: You can never predict injuries. Clearly, they believed Rudolph was better. Why hold onto him when you can get a draft pick for him?

Ryno: Is the game clock on tv different than the one in the stadium? The play Big Dan got flagged on, the clock on tv was at about -1 when the ball was snapped, and the announcers never mentioned it.

Ray Fittipaldo: They always give some leeway on delay of game in that situation.

Steve in NC: the SI article that came out yesterday about AB made him sound like he is a real jerk to a lot of people. Curious what your take is on it

Ray Fittipaldo: Nice to see everything laid out like that. But anyone who spent any time around him knew he wasn't a good kid. He's a bad kid. He once was a good kid, when he first arrived. But he turned into a bad kid.

Ray Fittipaldo: Ok that's it for this week kids. See you next week.