Brian Batko: Well, the Steelers are headed to the Frisco bay, but they're sitting on the dock of 0-2, and maybe watching the season roll away? I suppose this is now a Ben Roethlisberger season-ending elbow injury chat.
ALB: Wow! Can you see I guess Deon
Brian Batko: Deion Sanders, man. What did he know? Can he see the future? But hey, let's not forget, Prime predicted retirement for Ben this season. We don't have any indication that's on the horizon just yet.
Daggum Defense: It’s Mason time...... bummer for Ben man. Going to be a very interesting rest of the season for sure.
Brian Batko: A monkey wrench thrown into this 2019 campaign for the Steelers, no doubt. I thought Mason Rudolph looked solid. Seahawks safety Brad McDougald, who had no real reason to say anything particularly complimentary of Rudolph, said he thought Rudolph was as good as you could ask any backup, especially a young one, to be in that circumstance.
Seven’s Coming: Hey Brian- I’ve heard it said that the Steelers now have to be a run and defense first team. Can’t Rudolph throw? He’s not the only young QB to step in for his team. Do you see the Steelers becoming run heavy now?
Read More
Brian Batko: Not if we go by Sunday. Both Mike Tomlin and the Seahawks DBs I talked to said the Steelers offense stayed completely the same from a schematic standpoint with Rudolph in there for Ben. Not that any team is going to switch up its offensive structure mid-game, but that's encouraging. I even thought Rudolph showed some savvy on a few plays buying time in the pocket for himself and extending a play, though obviously that may very well be the biggest drop-off from 7 to 2.
TC in Charlotte: Hodges move up #2 with Ben out? Will they look to sign a 3rd QB (Landry Jones?)
Brian Batko: Good question. Devlin "Duck" Hodges is now one quack away. Would Landry really want to put the XFL on hold? He's the face of the league!
Tom in Dallas: How soon before we play Miami? We need a confidence builder....
Brian Batko: Not until after the bye, I'm afraid.
Ron: Ben didn’t seem right since the beginning. It seems the FO has had been timing with contracts. They ate money on Brown, they’ll eat it on Big Ben. That said, Mike Tomlin is just not a good head coach, and I don’t know why he gets such a passion things with ownership. If the Steelers finish third in the division and miss the playoffs, who is in greater peril, Tomlin or Colbert?
Brian Batko: Didn't seem right in terms of this season, like Week 1 at New England? Or injury-wise? Or mentality-wise? Because he seemed completely fine between the ears from minicamp until now. Obviously, this was completely unexpected all around. At that point, if your scenario comes true, I'd say Tomlin. Although the Donte Moncrief signing isn't shining on Colbert right about now.
Mik: Hi Brian, I first wanted to thank you for not beginning your chats by referring to your readers as kiddies like others do, it's kinda insulting. I'm not a doom and gloom guy, but is it really possible that the Steelers are as bad as they appear? I was hugely optimistic for this year. Also, how is it possible for this offensive line to be this bad at the running game?
Brian Batko: Well, not to toot my own horn or insult you kiddies, but I did predict an 0-2 start all along. I also said on our North Shore Drive podcast last week that I thought the Seahawks would win. Of course, I couldn't have foreseen the way it would all unfold. Still don't think they're as bad as 0-2 would lend you to believe, but yeah, the run game is a major issue as well. James Conner hasn't had a lot blocked for him, but he also hasn't made a lot of guys miss when he does.
WPASTEEL: It's probably for the better. Now we can see if Mason is the future. The team is bad. Offense is pathetic and so is the defense. This team needs big changes. Tomlin needs to go and so do both OC & DC. Lots of overpaid players on both sides of the ball. Especially on Defense (Heyward, Dupree, Nelson, Haden, Tuitt). If Moncrief was in New England he would be cut. Don't you think this team needs big wholesale changes?
Brian Batko: I hesitate to say that, WPASTEEL, I really do. They were 9-6-1 last year and were harpooned in several games by a slumping kicker. They've faced one projected Super Bowl contender and another possible playoff team to start this season. But hey, guess what, they're getting a wholesale change for this year at least with Mason Rudolph coming under center. I can certainly see your point on a lot of what you acknowledge here. How the defense is built is a whole other subject worth discussing.
George: Hi Brian
Brian Batko: What's up, George?
Justin: 15 years ago to the date (week 2) Big Ben replaced an injured Tommy Maddox because of an elbow injury. Is history repeating itself? Were we witnessing the beginning of a QB transition to Rudolph yesterday? The spark he provided (aside from Moncrief's butterfingers) was obvious to me. What say you?
Brian Batko: Quite possibly. The parallels really are Erie McDowell, even going back to Terry Bradshaw, whose own career ended with an elbow issue.
Pure Juice: Add yesterday's game to the ever expanding list of games under Tomlin that the Steelers come in uninspired, unprepared and undisciplined.....and zero adjustments at halftime. Don't give me the never had a losing season story. Historically he has done less with more....this year, he will do less with less. Next up....a West Coast team...and we all know how well he does when he travels West. We are staring at 0-3. His coaching seat has to be getting warm doesn't it?
Brian Batko: Did you know he's never had a losing season? OK, OK, yes, it was another game that was a bad look for Tomlin and the coaching staff. If a coach's seat gets warmer or cooler with every win or loss, then yeah, it's heating up. Maybe this is a season he does more with less and helps guide this team out of an 0-2 hole and injury to its most important player.
Steeler Joe: In the larger scheme of things, it hardly matters, but I was curious: Why didn't Ben have a giant bag of ice on his elbow on the sidelines yesterday? Isn't that usually what happens when you have "inflammation" during a game? I've certainly seen it many times.
Brian Batko: As we now know, Joe, it wasn't inflammation. It was something nerve-related, which is bad bad bad. I'm actually surprised that the Steelers never actually ruled him out. He was questionable to return, and obviously, never did.
Steve: When the Seahawks needed one yard at the end of the game, they ran at Dupree. He needs to be replaced!
Brian Batko: He was fairly invisible yesterday, yes. Someone on Twitter legitimately asked me if he was playing. Or at least I think it was legitimate. Maybe not. It was Twitter, after all.
Busted Coverage: T/F: Losing Ben for the season gives Tomlin an "out" for this season. He will stay on as coach regardless of how poorly the Steelers do this year.
Brian Batko: It could go that way, sure. And maybe it should. Then again, it'll be our first chance to see a Mike Tomlin-coached team without 7 at QB for an extended period.
PGM: The poor decision making of Colbert and Tomlin continue. Thomas last year, along with Brown, Bell, Skipper, Dobbs, and so on. It's time for them to go.
Brian Batko: Your complaint is noted.
BB: Brian - Edmunds showing he realy is a third round talent like the rest of the league thought?? Big reach for the Steelers FO on that one?
Brian Batko: Early returns are not great. I thought he took some steps forward in preseason, but these first two weeks are a good reminder that preseason is only preseason. Edmunds was pretty distraught after that game. He knows it was a bad one for him. Can't let it linger, though.
Retirelisberger: Should I just ride off into the sunset? Just me and my drama
Brian Batko: It is pretty nice outside today
Jesse: Brian, with Davis hurt again and in the last year of his contract, what are the chances the Steelers will trade for Minkah Fitzpatrick? If so, you think a #2 will do it?
Brian Batko: Possibly, but I think there are now too many long-term concerns to really worry about that at this point.
Kyle: Short quick passes have been a problem for the defense for 2 years. Last year it was personnel but that was addressed. At what point does it become a scheme problem? Or a coaching adjustments problem?
Brian Batko: Scheme, adjustments, communication, all big-picture ideas that often get thrown out in these situations. All probably have a hand in what's gone wrong. But so do little things that become big things, like Terrell Edmunds not making that play on DK Metcalf in the end zone. Or Devin Bush being just an inch or two short to cover the TE on his first TD. Or missed tackles on the perimeter. There are only so many defensive looks you can run. There's always a way for an offense to beat it. At some point it just comes down to making plays.
Steeler in Virginia: Bigger fish to fry today, but... have we cut Moncrief yet?
Brian Batko: Not to my knowledge. I assume he'll be a target of reporters at 1:15 when the locker room opens.
Shannon: Sean Davis seems to always be hurt. Will he and Hargrave be back?
Brian Batko: Yeah he's been fragile in 2019, for sure. Shoulder, ankle, shoulder again. I don't think Davis will be back. Leaning no on Hargrave too just because they didn't get a deal done before Week 1 and he's still not playing even half the snaps.
Eric Carr: Can you picture them just going with Rudolph and Hodges? Have to look at available vets, right?
Brian Batko: Wouldn't shock me. Clearly, they liked Devlin Hodges from the time they saw him in his rookie minicamp tryout, to keeping him around for OTAs, and enough to trade away Josh Dobbs for a fifth-round pick and then sign Hodges back to the P squad. But we are gonna find out just how much they like him. Tim Tebow and Johnny Manziel are available.
Picksixlisberger : Do you think the Steelers need to sign an experienced backup to help Randolph or are they going with Duckboy?
Brian Batko: In all honesty, pickings are slim. Matt Cassel is a free agent. He's 37 but actually played in two games last year for Detroit. David Fales and Brock Osweiler are younger options. Brandon Weeden, no one really knows how old he is, but he's out there.
Ben: Roethlisberger injury aside, aren't the FO and coaching staff guilty of some pretty insular thinking? They've sunk a lot of money into an O line that can't run the ball and they've failed to develop any defensive backs since Ike Taylor (basically). In today's NFL, if you can't control the clock and stop the pass, how do you win? I think the system needs a good review as much as the personnel... what do you think?
Brian Batko: Ben, is that you? But really, I don't have an issue with the OL spending and construction. With a franchise QB like Ben, more than anything, you need to make sure you have five guys who can keep Roethlisberger upright. They do need to do some soul-searching in how to get the ground game going, though.
Rob: I think it is time to clean the house with Tomlin and old man Keith Butler at the end of the season. You can't tell me the Steelers couldn't lure someone from the college ranks like from a Clemson, Georgia, etc
Brian Batko: That seems like more of a challenge than a question
DuBe: Steelers need to trade for Cam Newton
Brian Batko: Dude, DuBe, this is genius. Then they could have not only FIVE Cams or Kams on the team, but also the most famous one. Bring in Cam Cameron as OC. https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/09/07/players-named-...
Reality: Tough break that both Tomlin and Big Ben just got contract extensions. That kills their cap going forward. Time to promote Hodges and let the new era begin.
Brian Batko: Promote Devlin Hodges to No. 1 QB and hire Bill Cherpak as head coach. That's reality.
SOMD Panther: Where are you on the "NFL Teams Should Hire a Clock Management Specialist" debate?
Brian Batko: Makes sense to me, man. We've got so many consultants and quality control and outside receiver coaches, and none of those seem as valuable to me as a 17-year-old kid who beats the crap out of everyone due to flawless decision-making on Madden,
PdxJaxon: Brian, I think we can all agree...Moncrief has to go. Im also concerned about Switzer. Do we bring back Eli Rogers and Diontae spencer?
Brian Batko: Well, Diontae Spencer is in Denver, where he's being used almost entirely as a punt returner. Eli Rogers is just sitting around waiting to get signed by somebody, whether it's the Steelers or another team. The Donte Moncrief experience has been awful so far, don't get me wrong. I still think Switzer, whose usage was down this week by the way, continues to be near the bottom of the list of problems.
Not with a bang but a whimper: In a few words how would you sum up the offensive and defensive philosophy of the 2019-2020 Pittsburgh Steelers?
Brian Batko: Not ready for primetime, but not ready for daytime either.
ab2: I told you last year: "trade me and you'll see"
Brian Batko: Man, I'll say this much: maybe it's an oversimplification of an idea that's generally accurate, but through two - actually, three - games without Antonio Brown, it is starting to look more and more like he made Ben Roethlisberger great than the other way around. I know he was plenty good before AB, too, but Hines Ward and Santonio Holmes were no slouches themselves.
Alan: When will they fire their clock management coach? How could they let Tomlin watch the clock burn 20 seconds prior to the 2 minute warning without alerting him to take a timeout?
Brian Batko: Indeed, that was bizarre. Not sure it really mattered in the end, but there was no defending that.
Guest: Hi Brian, Did they say specifics on the 'type' of elbow surgery? such as Tommy J?
Brian Batko: Nope, team gave no specifics
KC Grenier: Good morning Mr. Batko. I'm a first-time poster on your chat. My question is this, with Ben being out, does that change your forecast for the Steeler's season record and post season chances?
Brian Batko: For that, KC, I thank you. It, uh, certainly does. It's hard to really forecast anything at this point, given that we've seen one half of Mason At Work. I was lower than most around here, other than my dear pal Chris Mueller, on the Steelers at 9-7. Now? Maybe 7-9 is closer to the ceiling than the floor. But still, we'll have to see. To me, the most significant aspect here is that a Super Bowl is no longer on the menu. I feel much more confident saying that now than I did this time yesterday.
Tom: Brian, Time for the D to step up and start earning their money. Gut check time. Either whine or start winning.
Brian Batko: I'll pass it along, thanks
BoKnows: Hi Brian - would you say that this weekend's game is an important an early season game as we have played in a long time? HCMT has to demonstrate that he can not only rally the team from a low point, but that he can exorcise the demons of losing again to an (allegedly) inferior team.
Brian Batko: Not so sure we can call the 49ers inferior anymore. Jimmy Garoppolo threw for 297 yesterday as they blitzed the Bengals. Certainly, it's a vital game. Should tell us a lot. We don't even know what we don't know.
John D: Looks like there is some movement within the PG. Not a fan of the movement. Is this permanent?
Brian Batko: None of us are permanent, John,,
John from Florida: I suspect that Ben has had this problem from the start of the season, maybe even camp. He has just not looked the same this year. He has not had any real zip on the ball and has not been accurate with his throws. Would the team doctors know if this arm problem existed before yesterdays game ?
Brian Batko: His balls had zip on them when they were coming at me on the sideline during training camp. I can tell you these things almost surely will be asked of Mike Tomlin tomorrow in his weekly presser. He won't be speaking today, as far as I know.
Cgljr: Brian, Can you tell the O line is missing Munch?
Brian Batko: Eh, not really. They couldn't run the ball much at the end of last year, either.
Seven’s Coming: Do you think it’s possible we see an uptick in targets for James Washington. Not only do he and Rudolph have history but he’s on my fantasy team.
Brian Batko: I think so. Hold onto him. Don't sell low. He already got more snaps yesterday, and now a guy he clearly has a great rapport with will be slinging the rock.
Jason: Brian, I definitely think the FO will sign a veteran QB of some sort. To risky with just Hodges. Don't you agree?
Mr CJ Jr: Two words...Colin Kaepernick......he's better than any QB available....one could argue but it's a fact. Thoughts?
ALB: There’s a guy out there with initials CK.
guest: Any chance Steelers look at Kaepernick?
Kool-Aid: Would the Steelers even consider Kaepernik?
xyzzy: After signing the dog fighter, why wouldn't the Steelers just sign Kaepernick. He is probably the best option out there.
Brian Batko: Well all, thanks for the time. I have to get going now. Hope you enjoyed the chat.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.