Brian Batko: Hello, thanks for joining. The chat will begin momentarily. We've got some breaking news to attend to first, as NFL Network's Ian Rapoport is reporting the Steelers have traded Josh Dobbs to Jacksonville for a fifht.
Brian Batko: OK, time to chat.
Dan: Hello? Has the chat started?
Brian Batko: Yes.
RooneysDontRule: Josh Hobbs being traded is breaking news?? Unless we are trading Tomlin, no one cares.
Brian Batko: Great start.
Read More
rman: Which is the Latin word for "can't catch"....donte or diontae?
Brian Batko: Aaaaand we're off...
BigPoppie: Do you think the Steelers have a legitimate NFL ground game with James Connor as their featured RB?
Brian Batko: Oh, nice, a real question. That's cool. I do think they can have a good running game with James *Conner because, well, he's pretty good. Didn't have a lot of room to work last night. Sure, he got stopped in short-yardage situations a couple times, but the pitch play never gave him a chance. That call was a head-scratcher, but hey, if it worked, it'd have been a great call.
JerseySteel: Hi Brian - the Steelers do not run those crossing routes against man coverage with the legal pick play as often or as well as the Patriots do. Why can't the Steelers do that just as effectively?
Brian Batko: Well, we did see them try it last night with rookie Diontae Johnson, and he just flat-out collided with a defender, and got flagged for OPI. So, that tells me, it's not as easy as the Patriots make it look. Obviously, they coach it well and their wideouts do a good job of picking up on the little nuances of making it an effective but legal play. Maybe that can be Donte Moncrief's new role.
Kol Diamond: Worst Steeler performance since loss to Eagles 3 years ago. Think Tomlin should have used first teams more in Pre season
Brian Batko: It probably is, yeah. Actual and factual that it's the first time they've failed to manage more than one measly field goal since that game. Hindsight is 20-20, because no one would have that take if Ben or JuJu or Pouncey had gotten injured as a result of more exhibition reps.
Guest: Fact or fiction? The news of AB signing with the Pats festered in coaches and players heads and was the single leading factor to their unfocused and humiliating play. AB will continue to be a distraction for them all year?
Brian Batko: I can't answer that because I'm not in their heads.
FC: When is enough is enough with these coaches?? 'Not ready for prime time"? Are you kidding me? What a joke?
Brian Batko: What else is he supposed to say? It's the same thing everyone is angry at them for. I guess he could've just quit in shame on the spot.
TC in Charlotte: Is it a straight up 5th for Dobbs? We used a fourth on him. Also, any word on injuries from last nights game?
Brian Batko: That's what I'm seeing. Steelers haven't confirmed anything yet and neither have the Jags. No word on injuries, but the Steelers locker room will be open in an hour. We'll see what we can find out there.
Justin Mathewson: Do you think Steelers trade for a WR? Everyone but Ju and Switzer looked terrible. If not, I think Steelers need to get Switzer the ball more. Thoughts?
Brian Batko: No, but maybe they give Eli Rogers a call and say "Hey, about that cut..."
Izzy: For all the praise the Steelers OL gets (routinely called a top 5 OL) why are they so bad at opening holes in short yardage situations?
Brian Batko: That's a good question. I'm sure it will be a topic this week for those guys to answer to. On the early second-quarter third-and-1 that got stuffed, big Danny Shelton just clogged the whole thing up. Mike Tomlin said last week that nose tackles are becoming like Blockbuster videos in this league, but Shelton looked plenty useful on that play.
Emmanuel: Hi Brian, to me is now evident that neither Tomlin nor his DC, OC and ST coordinators are capable enough to coach and scheme this group of talented players. They have wasted and continue to waste Big Ben's bets years. Do you see Mr. Rooney making a bold movement in the coaching staff once as for all?, or, is Mr Rooney the problem in that he is not willing to make it.?, Thank you.
Brian Batko: After one game? No, I don't see it. Thank you, as well.
Texas Steeler: Brian... That looked way too much like a pre-season game out there. Why all this talk of shortening pre-season when it's obvious the Steelers aren't getting enough work as it is?
Brian Batko: Patriots starters didn't play much more in the preseason, if at all more, than the Steelers.
Scuba Steve: Are the Steelers really THAT bad or are the Patriots just that much better than Pittsburgh?
Brian Batko: Hey, Scuba Steve! I don't think the Steelers are that bad. I do think it's pretty frightening for the rest of the league that even amid all their personnel changes, the Patriots still looked that sharp. Brady is aging in reverse. All three running backs have defined roles they're good at performing. Julian Edelman is as good as ever, Josh Gordon still has it, and the backup WRs are more than capable. They still have tight ends coming back and are getting a new wideout who has led the NFL in yards, catches or TDs five of the past six years or something like that.
Jumping off the ledge: Brian, welcome to your 1st Steelers regular season chat with angry fans. Although it's only one game, it appears our Fearless Leader, DC, and OC haven't changed one bit. The predictably of playcalling and lack of scheme change/adjustments in game is very alarming and head scratching. How can this thing be turned around with our current coaches? Or is it a lost cause expecting change?
Brian Batko: I didn't necessarily think the play-calling was predictable. It didn't work at all, that's for sure, but predictable? The complaints would be the same today if the Steelers had gone all zone on defense and gotten picked apart by Brady and Co. underneath all the same. Offensively, that pitch left to Conner was, uh, unpredictable on third-and-1. Thanks for the warm welcome, though. This sure has been a chat so far.
Frank: then let me follow up, 4th and goal at the one, down 20 in the 3rd, and you kick a field goal. Tomlin just told the team, 'I quit'
Brian Batko: You guys can crush me for this, but I actually didn't hate that decision. If anything, doesn't it say he believed (foolishly, perhaps) in the defense to actually get some stops? A similar decision worked out yesterday for Kliff Kingsbury and the Cardinals, who kicked a FG from the 2 late in the first half when they were down 17-0. People laughed at them, but they came back and forced overtime and, eventually, that marathon game that ended with a tie.
JerseySteel: Hi Brian - It looked like the Patriots D-Line got pressure regularly against or O-Line and Our D-line did not start to generate even a whiff of pressure until late in the game. Are the Patriots Oline and Dline THAT much better than the Steelers units?
Brian Batko: Possibly. I thought the Steelers DL was getting some pressure early, but of course, Brady gets rid of it quick. And while he's technically not part of the DL, TJ Watt is on that front four a lot of the time, and he was absolutely bringing pressure off the edge.
E.J.: I did a Google search to see if, in fact, the Steelers had a training camp before last night's game and couldn't find anything. Can you confirm or deny that they did have a training camp this off-season? Right now, I'm not sure they did.
Brian Batko: They did. I drove out to Latrobe like 15 times to watch it.
Artie Bridge: So how do we recover from that stinkbomb? And how many more until Mike joins the unemployed?
Brian Batko: I'd recommend scoring more on offense and getting more stops on defense.
Steve Jablonsky: Patriots lost a HOF TE in Gronk and didn't miss a beat. What happened to our TE passing game? Jesse James can't be that big of an impact, can he?
Brian Batko: Yeah, the lack of involvement with Vance McDonald was a bit of a mystery. He played 71 percent of the offensive snaps. Xavier Grimble played just two snaps total. Maybe they should trade for Ryan Izzo once the Pats get their guys back.
Brian: What game outcome was more surprising to you, The Browns -Titans, Cardinals-Lions, Steelers-Patriots ?
Brian Batko: Browns-Titans, no doubt. The first-team Tennessee offense looked horrendous against Steelers in the preseason. And then they go and beat up the Browns at home. Strange, but Browns.
Jason: Brian, Butler will be the main reason Tomlin at some point will no longer be with the Steelers. His ineptitude in preparing and adjusting game plans is a big reason for this teams defensive struggles. Sure coaches do not play but players need a plan in place to give them the best chance of success. What say you?
Brian Batko: I say that this franchise would move on from Keith Butler first and give Mike Tomlin a chance with a different DC before they got rid of both in one fell swoop.
Cburg Stiller: What is the answer/adjustment to stopping the Edleman crossing routes? We just can't seem to solve that.
Brian Batko: Maybe they should've tried switching them? But hey, it's not easy. No one seems to solve it. Edelman catches 900 passes a season. He's good at what he does.
BringBackWeegie: How do you rate Bush’s play as a rookie and that of Baron as new veteran to the team? Seemed Bush played okay for a rookie, but Baron looked terrible.
Brian Batko: Yeah I didn't think Devin Bush was a major liability or anything. Mark Barron did look a step slow in trying to cover James White out of the backfield, but a lot of opponents are. There's a reason why he catches 900 passes a season too.
Stiller in Seattle: With all the versatility we've been hearing about, why in the world would you ever have Vince Williams in coverage against Gordon?!
Brian Batko: You've got me stumped on that one.
guest: Hi Brian, safe to assume the season is officially over?
Brian Batko: Oh, for sure. Just pack it in. Let Mason Rudolph start the final 15 games, or maybe even tank for the No. 1 pick. Fire everyone, too. Almost forgot that.
CanadianSteelersFan : Well, congratulations to the Patriots on their 7th SB win. That defense, plus AB and Tom Brady is scary good. They will be dismantling the rest of the NFL soon enough. How many SB wins do you think our Big Ben quarterbacked Steelers would have if Tom Brady never played? 10?
Brian Batko: Obviously. Cancel the rest of the season.
California Bill : Pats had at least 14 on offense Steelers only had 9 on offense
Brian Batko: Players? I feel like the refs would've caught that.
jtown 45: How did edmunds play on defense??
Brian Batko: No one played particularly well. But he showed good closing speed a couple times. Didn't seem like they were completely picking on him or anything.
Ryan Ratko: Did any PG writers (including yourself) pick a Steelers win prior to last night?
Brian Batko: Ron Cook did. He was kicking himself for it afterward https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/ron-cook/2019/09/08/Ron-Cook-Steel...
Jack: Brian, What the Steeler's office saw in Montcreif is a mystery. The guy was subpar in Jax and he has carried that here.
Steelfan: Did Moncrief look THAT bad in training camp/practices? 10 targets and only 3 catches for 7 yards. That's awful
LI Steel: Donte Moncrief should be number 6 on wr depth chart. guy can't catch. seen him in a preseason game and last night and he just can't hold on to the ball
Brian Batko: Yeah, I suppose it's time we move on to the Donte Moncrief portion of this chat. He looked completely out of it last night. I went back and checked and didn't find any noticeable drop issues for him in Indy or Jacksonville, but his catch rate has hovered around 53 percent the past few years. Now, that's catch rate, not drop rate. So, not all of those targets were catchable ones. But still, it was not a good Steelers debut for him at all. He looked better than that in practice, especially this week leading up to the game.
JerseySteel: Hi Brian - did Kam Kelly blow his assignment on the long Patriots pass TD?
Brian Batko: I'm not sure if it was him or Terrell Edmunds. To my untrained and naked eye, it was Kelly. But either way, Mike Hilton was on Dorsett and got beat, from what I could tell. That'll happen, but the safety help over the top was, uh, what's the word I'm looking for. Non-existent?
Vicenzo: Hi Brian...now that Dobbs has been traded, do the Steelers go with only two quarterbacks ? Any idea who they might sign as a backup?
Brian Batko: Devlin Hodges is available. He's back home duck hunting, I'm pretty sire.
Dlongley44: Bud Dupree, went against one on one backup tackle and did nothing, basically!!
Brian Batko: Backup tackle? Isaiah Wynn was the team's first-rounder last year. Missed all his rookie season with an achilles injury. Dupree wasn't good, but let's at least be accurate here.
Guest: Where is was Nix? Did he get any snaps?
Brian Batko: Yes, he got snaps. 18 of them, all on special teams.
Western MD: Which is the biggest overreaction from week 1: Steelers are in trouble, Browns are in trouble, Ravens will repeat as AFC North champs?
Brian Batko: Aren't those all the same thing? But seriously, I'd say it's probably the Steelers one, actually. Still not picking them to win the AFC North, but the Browns and Ravens both played tomato cans - problem is, the Browns lost to one. (Apologies in advance if the Titans turn out to be good).
Guest: If I was a betting man (and I’m not) I would have bet the Pats to win 99 out of 100 times. Season isn’t over. I’m expecting a much better and angry Steelers team and a win at home next week. Am I the only one?
Brian Batko: It would seem so.
Communication: I’ll pass him off to you, ok, I’ll pass him off then too...is it just possible that this defense is too difficult to learn and or convoluted for the players coming out of the college game? They obviously can’t xommunicate this defense at game speed
Brian Batko: Well, there was only one rookie on the field. Two if you count Kam Kelly. One second-year guy in Terrell Edmunds. The rest were vets, more or less. It sure does need to improve, otherwise the Patriots showed the rest of the league's offenses how to pick apart this defense (granted, not everyone will be as good at it as Tom Brady and the boys).
LackJambert: Odds of 0-6 going into Miami on week 7?
Brian Batko: 1.3 percent
Eric Carr: Brian, do you know if skipper cleared waivers? Do you think, if he did, that they re-sign him to take Dobbs spot and go with only 2 QB'S, put him on PS and sign another Qb or neither? Think we could see Hodges again? I know they never go with 2 QB's but I don't think they should let go of Skipper so this could be the time
Brian Batko: No word on Tuzar Skipper yet. We'll see if he's in the locker room this afternoon.
Steve: Brian, Should the Steelers replace Bud Dupree with Josh Bell or Ola?
Brian Batko: I'm into the Josh Bell idea. He'll be free here shortly.
Utah Jim: On Washington’s long catch why did he run out of bounds? It didn’t look like momentum and he wasn't pushed out.
Brian Batko: The momentum/losing his balance thing is the only explanation that makes sense to me. But yeah, even then, you usually see players try to stumble along for more yards IN bounds. Nice catch, bad finish of the play.
Doug from Raleigh: I've read from 2 sources that the Pats offered a 1st round pick for Brown and were turned down. Isn't that short sighted and not in the best interest of the team? If KC had offered the same they probably would have made the deal, and KC is very much in the SB hunt. The Steelers obsession and jealousy of the Patriots is showing, I think. Your take, please.
Brian Batko: Could be, yeah. But imagine how that plays if you do it back in March. Sure, there would be some (arguably, smart) people saying it was a good deal. A lot of others would lose their minds over "helping" New England like that.
574 Fan: Glass 1/2 full take: NE always takes away your top threats (JuJu) and forces someone else to make plays. Johnson and Washington are developing, but weren't ready for last night. Offense will develop over the next month. Sound crazy?
Brian Batko: Not at all. Lot was made about how the Steelers might be getting the Patriots at a good time given all their personnel shuffling on offense, but hey, the Steelers had plenty of their own. On both sides of the ball. And it showed. Boy, did it show.
Tom: More overhyped...Browns or Moncrief?
Brian Batko: Browns
Bubba Gump: Why was Holton on the field, after just getting cut...and why did Ben keep targeting him?
Brian Batko: Those were definitely some Darrius Heyward-Bey-esque shots downfield, Bubba.
Big A Steela Fan: Do you see AB putting up Randy Moss-like numbers?
Brian Batko: Nah, man, 23 touchdowns is bonkers.
KillaKam: There was a sequence of plays where Devin Bush was split out wide for like 5 straight plays, only surrendering a short catch to Burkhead on the first one despite Brady staring at the matchup every snap. Just an interesting note. I thought the rookie acquitted himself well. Do we need to see more of him than Barron as we did in the first half last night?
Brian Batko: Possibly. That was definitely one of Bush's strengths coming out of Michigan, his ability to cover like a corner a little bit.
Jacob: Brian, how are *you* doing?
Brian Batko: I'm good, man. Just embracing the opportunity to conclude this chat and move forward. Thank you.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.