batko fan: Hey Batko, I'm surprised holton has Practice Squad eligibility. Have they changed the rules on that?
Brian Batko: Not that I'm aware. As far as I can tell, Johnny Holton has "accrued" two seasons of the NFL and spent most of last year on the practice squad in Oakland. But yes, at 28, I imagine he's one of the older practice squad guys out there. I'm sure he's happy to collect the paycheck.
Guest: What's the dealio with Sutton Smith? Surprised he didn't get signed or is he maybe interested in getting on a PS that isn't PGH?
Brian Batko: By all accounts, Smith enjoyed and appreciated his time here, injury issues notwithstanding. I am surprised that no one else has picked him up yet, but hey, those 31 other teams have 30-some guys with whom they spent months getting to know, trying to develop and evaluating, as the Steelers did with Smith.
Eric Carr: Brian, what to you was the most surprising cut?
Brian Batko: Probably Eli Rogers. Big vote of confidence for Ryan Switzer and, to a slightly lesser extent, Diontae Johnson. But none of the cuts were shocking.
Read More
Jud: who do you feel will be team MVP this year?
Brian Batko: With a new-look cast of pass-catchers, I'll say Ben Roethlisberger still has a very good season and for that reason gets the nod. Of course, he's like LeBron James as MVP in the NBA or Bill Belichick with the coach of the year award. Ben could probably get team MVP every year.
Eric Carr: Do you think it was the right decision to keep a 9th OL, Johnson, over Holton?
Brian Batko: Yes, but I think finding a spot for Diontae Spencer would've been a better decision. Whether that spot came from the OL, or LBs, or QBs, I thought he had value, especially as a return specialist. Denver might've validated my thoughts on that by signing him right after the Steelers cut him.
Richard: It would appear that none of the TE's available from other team rosters has caught the Steeler's attention. Do you still see a chance someone will be added?
Brian Batko: I suppose so, but maybe not in time for this week at New England. And after Week 1, everything pretty much goes into overdrive, so that's tough. Based on reports, Steelers must have thought Ricky Seals-Jones was gonna be their guy, but Cleveland got him.
Gravel: Hi Brian- Do you see Holton staying on PS until there is an injury? 5 WRs for this offense with 1WR the return guy seems like a problem waiting to happen?
Brian Batko: Maybe an injury, maybe lackluster special teams play, either on coverage or in the kick return game. Holton certainly had some moments in the preseason, but did he really do anything against starting defenders? I still don't think he's a more useful contributor on offense than Switzer, Rogers and maybe even Spencer.
Matt F.: After Week 1, players with "vested veteran" status can be signed as free agents with less financial commitment from the team. I believe that's why the Steelers have yet to sign a veteran TE.
Brian Batko: Could be. The one I like the most is Luke Willson who got cut by Oakland. Or maybe Ross Travis, former Penn State basketball player cut by Colts.
Steve G: I think, like a lot of people, I hoped Sutton Smith would make the PS at least. High energy guy. Small school. David/Goliath, etc. Have we seen the last of him?
Brian Batko: In the NFL? My guess is no. With the Steelers? My guess is yes.
Richard: Has Hodges been picked up by anyone?
Brian Batko: NO. I keep hearing/seeing people saying that Devlin Hodges is headed to the XFL. That all started with Hodges "waving" at the XFL account on Twitter. He later clarified that he was not offered a job in that league, but that he just wanted to let them know he's interested. Hodges is a free agent. But sign me up for seeing him in the XFL.
Harold H.: With Ju Ju #1in most peoples’ eyes, in what order do you think the Steelers’ receivers have gained the confidence of #7 coming out of preseason and training camp?
Brian Batko: I think that order is very similar to the actual pecking order. It probably goes JuJu, Moncrief, Washington, Switzer, Johnson. Although, given that he's purely a slot guy, Switzer might have -- and might need to have -- Ben's "confidence" as much as anyone. Lots of intricacies to that position. Patriots have a guy who does it quite well.

Alan in Nashville : Hi Brian. I was a big proponent of Johnny Holton and surprised when they cut him and happy when they added him to the practice squad. My opinion though is for what he offers, I’m not sure he’s a practice squad development guy. I see him as a younger DHB that is probably a better pass catcher that could help out now. And it surprises me since they only kept 5 WR’s. Your thoughts?
Brian Batko: Good points, Alan. I mostly agree with you there. Not sure Johnny Holton would really be much of a hot commodity around the league.
Everyone, allow me a quick story about Alan, one of my favorite long-winded readers/chatters/emailers. A couple weeks ago, he sends me a couple long paragraphs to answer in my weekly mailbag. Only problem? There was no question! Not even at the end. So I wrote him back saying as much. To Alan's (hilarious) credit, he responded by basically saying, "You're right, I guess it's more just my comments. So, if I were to make it a question, I would just ask if you feel the same way?"
These are my readers!
Brian Batko: Really though, we try to make it a very inclusive, engaging experience. Between these chats, the mailbag, and last week's Punt, Pass and Chat event, I think we're doing a good job. Now, back to business.
Ukraine: Hey man, I was recently reading a biography of Nestor Ivanovych Makhno, the Urkranian anarchist and revolutionary figure. I learned that his nickname was bat'ko. It made me think of you. Are you a fan of his and/or are you of Ukranian descent? Thanks!
Brian Batko: This is quite a revelation. I had no idea, but I just looked this up, and it's actually true that this, uh, anarchist dude had a nickname of bat'ko. Whatever that means. I consider myself more of a nihilist, and yes, I think I am Ukranian. Or Slovak. Or something. Thanks for enlightening me there.
is it you?: Jason Mackey insinuated in a recent chat that one of the Steelers reporters is a big fan of the band Train. They sing Drops of Jupiter and also Meet Virginia. My best guess is that you are the Train fan, cuz it can't be Gerry. Anyway, I'm not a fan, but do you have an album you'd suggest? They are kind of lame musicians in my humble opinion. Thanks!
Brian Batko: Why couldn't it be Ray Fittipaldo? It isn't me, but Meet Virginia is a banger.
K dot: Which player will get the most FF points for us this year? got a draft coming up, and I always take someone from the team or should I go for the sleeper in the Defense.
Brian Batko: Probably JuJu. But I also like Ben as a QB you can get pretty late, from my experience.
:(: Meet Virginia is NOT A BANGER! C'mon, Batko!
Brian Batko: Yes, it is.
Jenny: Can we keep Hargrave after season if not done now? Seems unlikely .. what have you hear or thoughts Brian thanks
Brian Batko: Sure they can. Just because they aren't signing him now doesn't mean they'll definitely let him walk. As Mike Tomlin mentioned this morning, the Steelers still want to see more out of Hargrave, still want to see if he can "diversify" his game given how rarely-used traditional nose tackles are in 2019.
Guest: Who will start at the two safety spots on Sunday?
Brian Batko: My prediction is Terrell Edmunds and Sean Davis. I think 21 will be back from injury, but that's just a gut feeling.
NM Mike: Hi Brian, good job on the chats. All the talk about the Steelers pouring over the waiver wire to find "comfort" at the TE position...is it just possible the coaches who work with the players each day know better then fans and reporters? If Zach Gentry could contribute as he did in his first preseason appearance, he could help the team this year. I see no reason he can't develop to be at least as productive as J.J. was. Thoughts?
Brian Batko: Thanks, Mike. It's not just possible, but guaranteed that they do. But that said, the other Mike - Tomlin - said himself just last Tuesday that he hadn't seen enough from his tight ends to that point. And I'm not sure Thursday night's game in Carolina changed that. Jury is still very much out on Xavier Grimble and, to your question, Zach Gentry.
Guest: Seeing Hines Ward wearing Jets gear as a Jets coach is hard to watch. Do you think he is "dead" to the Steelers fans now that he has gone on to work for another team? This is sad news for Steelers Nation, which is usually awesome man.
Brian Batko: No, he's not dead to anyone. He'll always be beloved, even if he did make some brutally honest remarks about the team in the offseason.
ALB: Why is the practice team always referred to as a “squad”?
Brian Batko: I don't know, but that might keep me up tonight.
Eric Carr: Brian, are you at all concerned about the potential for not many more Int's than last year? I think we only got 2 in the preseason final after none in the 1st 3 games if I'm not mistaken
Brian Batko: Yes, I think it's still a concern. But it always is. We'll see if Steven Nelson infuses some splash plays, if Terrell Edmunds is around the ball more in Year 2, and if Kam Kelly has some ball skills that make him a significant addition to the equation.
John Strange: The Steelers beat the Patriots 17-10 last year. Is there any chance Big Ben doesn't have to be carried on the defense's to get a win back Sunday night?
Brian Batko: Yes

SaltyRon: Looking back at the roster situation, I found it puzzling that the Steelers weren't able to get another back-up tight end (like Luke Wilson) to back-up McDonald. At this point, are we stuck with Grimble as the TE#2?
Brian Batko: Yeah, I think it's Grimble more than Gentry. But perhaps the Steelers won't use two-tight end sets much in Foxborough. I probably wouldn't bother much if I were them.
James from Philly : Hey Brian! Thanks for the chats. Who are the primary backup OLB's this week with injuries to Chickillo and Ola? Any chance Skipper sees some action?
Brian Batko: I live to serve, James. That's a good question. I imagine they'll mostly role with Bud and Watt, but hey, they put Tuzar Skipper on the 53 for a reason (though there's no guarantee he'll be active on gameday).
Craig: Thanks for the chat Brian! So what is your take on the opener with New England. I know our record there is pretty horrendous, but I'm feeling just a little optimistic. Am I wrong to feel that way?
Brian Batko: Probably, yeah
DaquidoBazzini: Do you think Tuzar Skipper dresses and plays ST's for the opener in NE?
Brian Batko: Ehhh it could be tough for him to get there. Obviously, Josh Dobbs is one of the inactives. Beyond that, it's probably Ola, one of of the tackles, one or two DBs, one of the DLs. It might be close for Skipper on that front.
team steelers: What areas are the Pats weak in this year? It looks like their O-Line is hurting.
Brian Batko: Yeah, they've taken some hits on the OL. There's probably not a team in the league that got worse at tight end than they did by Gronk retiring. We'll see how their receivers play with Josh Gordon and Demaryius Thomas just getting back into the mix, and a couple young guys after them.
Mr Medium Chest: As a lifelong Steelers fan am i rooting for a Raiders 0 & 4 start and an AB meltdown coupled with Le’Veon being a average player behind a below average line or is it time for me to just let go?
GhostOfIvanToncic: I believe "Batko" means "Big Daddy" in Polish. Has anyone ever called you "Daddy" or "Big Daddy" or "Pops" as a nickname? If not, a missed opportunity. (Also, did you have any other nicknames?)
Brian Batko: I don't have any children, so no. My other nicknames can't be shared in this forum.
Sterling A: OK Brian, prediction time. It's Sunday night, Patriots' first possession. 1st and 10 from the 20. Who are the 11 defenders on the field for the Steelers?
Brian Batko: A sterling Q from Sterling A and I hope to give a sterling A myself. 91, 97, 48, 55, 26, 90, 22, 28, 34, 21, 23
STEEL72: Was I alone in wondering why Devin Bush needed to play so much in the final pre-season game. It was agonizing. What could possibly go wrong? One thing not to "live in our fears" and another to use a little more caution as 3rd stringers are going wild to make their respective teams.
Brian Batko: No, I don't think you were alone, but I didn't hate it. I understand why from Mike Tomlin. Top-10 pick or not, he still has some work to do. Speaking of which ...
Ann Arbor Memories: Bush was torched in coverage, even when keying on receiver before the snap, at Michigan (see: Paris Campbell Ohio State 2018 game). I saw that continue in the preseason. He's a MLB in name only... Surely the Pats see it. Tell me the Tomlin/Butler brain trust knows that his current liability in coverage must be accounted for or should I get the 'definition of insanity' post(s) ready... Jabrill Peppers 2.0
Brian Batko: Mike Tomlin today was asked if any of his big three additions defensively - that would be Bush, Barron and Steven Nelson - can help neutralize someone like Julian Edelman in the Pats passing game. Tomlin said no, those three guys will have other responsibilities, and that it will be up to the likes of slot corners Mike Hilton and Cam Sutton to minimize Edelman's impact.
123: What are the 2-3 keys for the steelers to win sunday at FOXBORO STADIUM IN MASSACHUSETTES?
Brian Batko: I would recommend scoring on offense and creating turnovers on defense.
SaltyRon: Who returns kicks and punts now....is Switzer the only option now that Holton and Spencer are gone? Does Samuels find his way back their on kick-offs?
Brian Batko: Pretty much. Maybe Diontae Johnson if he gets a hat. I don't think Samuels is viable in that role, no.
Brian Batko: Cam Sutton has done some returning at times as well.
Rocky: Hi Brian, What were the results of the punting competition this year? Is Tomlin bringing back the same punter for 2019? Thanks for your chats.
Brian Batko: Yes, Jordan Berry is back in the fold.
ralph malph: Is Florida UDFA O-Lineman Johnson the next BJ Finney? What is his skill set like?
Brian Batko: Not sure I'd say that. Johnson is more tackle-capable and Finney more center-capable. Johnson is a lot bigger.
?: Does Fred Johnson have a personal history with Pouncey since they are both FLorida OLINEMEN?
Brian Batko: Not that I know of, but I'm sure there's a brotherhood dynamic at play there.
Nate: Hi Brian, if Sean Davis doesn't have a good year, and the Steelers let him test free agency, would Kam Kelly be in line for the starting free safety opening? Or do the Steelers solely view Kam as a back-up? Thanks!
Brian Batko: Well, from what we've seen this training camp and preseason and even going back to OTAs, they see him as more of just a backup. He might be on the field when it mattes in some sub-packages. For me, it's a really nice story, but let's see how he performs over the totality of a 16-game schedule in the National Football Lig.
Mike Tomlin speaks on Mason Rudolph as backup QB
K dot: 2nd: Who has more sacks throughout the year at OLB Skipper, Dupree, or Ola?
Brian Batko: I know he's a pariah to some here, but easy money is still on Dupree for sure.
british: How long can we keep the British TE on our Practice Squad? Does it work for him differently than a non-International player?
Brian Batko: Yes, there are different rules for him. In order to get that exempt 11th spot, CSW can't be called up to the active roster this season. I'm not sure how long he can be on there, but it would make sense for it to be the same requirements as any other P squad guy.
Gravel: Brain - Will you be predicting a winner for the game and a score? When?
Brian Batko: Yeah, I suppose I can do that at some point.
Kadel: Hi, do you see this as an issue moving forward? Only keeping 5 WRs and 1 reliable TE. Thanks
Brian Batko: Well, you can only have five skill players on the field at one time, so... but seriously, the Steelers also sometimes even like to use a tackle lined up as an eligible receiver. Maybe we'll see more of that.
Jabo J: Did Eli Rogers sign with another team?
Brian Batko: All I've seen is that he visited the Dolphins
John Strange: Would it be O.K. to call you Brian Batts in an homage to the Billy Batts character in "Goodfellas?"
Brian Batko: Sure
hammer time: Do you think there is reason for concern regarding Snell's rather pedestrian preseason numbers?
Brian Batko: Not really. He was never likely to be a key cog in this offense anyway. I wonder if there's concern about his shtick so far, the whole Benny Snell third-person and Benny Snell Football thing? Not saying he's a bad guy or anything, and in fact I think he's a lot of fun, but the production certainly hasn't matched the personality thus far.
Gravel: Will you be chatting during the game?
Brian Batko: No, Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo will be in New England and myself as the third beat reporter, I'll be home. "Off the clock" technically, so let me know what happens!
Jack 58: Um... Billy Batts ended up in the trunk of a car and buried in a unmarked grave...
Brian Batko: I'm not afraid
X Man: Would yinzers have more faith in me if I did not make a complete fool of myself failing to hold onto the ball against a much smaller human?
Brian Batko: Yes, I believe you are unfairly maligned for that play alone.
Guest: Fun question time - What is your favorite soft drink?
Brian Batko: Birch beer
CT: Where do you think Moncrief fits in? Not much noise about him yet
Brian Batko: I think he might be more of a possession, move-the-chains type guy as this team's No. 2 receiver. James Washington has shown more big play ability to this point, which is a nice development.
Matt F.: Prediction for Sunday night?
Brian Batko: Patriots 42, Steelers 33. Not sure how the black and yellow will arrive at such a number, but what can I say, it came to me in a vision.
OK folks, that's the end of the chat. I better get out of here before any further referendums on the musical stylings of Pat Monahan and company. Please check out our NFL/Steelers preview content this week and weekend. Be well now.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.