Brian Batko: Bonjour. Do you have any questions, about the Steelers or otherwise? Send them in, Jeromes.

Eric L: with minimal change on the defensive coaching staff and Butler having additional responsibilities for the outside backers, why should we expect the communications issues that have plagued that side of the ball the past few years to be better (worse?!?) in 2019? Thank you

Brian Batko: Well Eric, I think it's reasonable to expect the players themselves to be better at that aspect with an extra year under their belts, not only individually but with each other (other than the new guys, obviously).

At least in the secondary, Terrell Edmunds and Sean Davis spent a really long time - 10 or 15 minutes, at least - today after practice talking. Those two being on the same page will be crucial for the back end, for sure, and they're still relatively young safeties in this league.

Advertise with us

Paul: Marcus Allen had a higher draft graft my draft grade over Edmunds by many draft experts. Will he get a real chance to compete or just earn a reserve role?

Brian Batko: Did you ready Gerry Dulac's story this morning on those two guys specifically? https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/06/03/Terrell-Edmund...

I don't think Allen will compete to be a starter, but that doesn't mean there won't be areas for him to find a niche. Whether that's as a dime linebacker - he's big enough - or in certain subpackage defenses. Edmunds is probably about as entrenched as a second-year guy can be, when you look at how much he played his rookie season, but it's far too early to write off someone like Allen.

John Strange: Should Big Ben be micro managing what numbers players are assigned?

Brian Batko: Micro managing, that's an interesting way of phrasing the whole deal with Roethlisberger suggesting rookie TE Zach Gentry might want to switch off of Heath Miller's 83. Tough to truly know how Gentry feels about it, but maybe he sees it as good advice from a veteran. In general, though, I would say no. Let someone pick his own number, if it's available.

Advertise with us

Guest: Brian B. - Thanks for the chat. Anyway, I'm wondering about Mason R. - will he be the #2 this season and could J. Dobbs get cut? Also, has anyone ever told you you look like actor Hugo Weaving? My wife commented on it the other day. Thanks!

Brian Batko: You're welcome, Guest. I do think Mason Rudolph will ascend to backup QB over Josh Dobbs, who was drafted one year earlier and one round later. Should be a pretty close competition, though. Good thing we have four preseason games to help sort it out.

As for that observation by Mrs. Guest, no, that's a new one. Though I know the name, I'm not even entirely sure who Hugo Weaving is, but...

Brian Batko: Let's put it to a poll

Doug from Raleigh: Gut feeling on Boswell? If it was physical or mechanical it should have been fixed by season's end. If he had a case of big money (for a kicker)/big expectations, will a year of living with that resolve things? Thanks.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: My gut feeling on Chris Boswell is that last season really stunk for him, personally, and that he doesn't really care very much if you or I or anyone else - fans or media - ever know how he dealt with it. I do think he will bounce back, though. Don't think the yips have fully engulfed him, but you never know with that sort of thing.

Lloyd's 3-Count: Which national sportswriters do you enjoy?

Brian Batko: I really don't read national stuff as much as I used to, but like most sports fans my age, Bill Simmons was pretty influential and must-read material when I was growing up watching the NFL and NBA. I like reading Gary Parrish on college hoops and Andy Staples on college football. Also have to give a shoutout to fellow Shaler High School alum Sam Vecenie, who covers the NBA draft from wall to wall.

Thomas: So big IFs still on D, but do you think they are positive IFs, like if Bush is legit, and if Edmunds matures and if the new CB from KC is at least slightly above average....this D should be top 10, or better?

Brian Batko: Man, Top 10 is tough. Only 10 teams get to be in there. But yeah, if they falter again, it won't be because they're too old, that's for sure. And probably not too slow. Seems to me they're trying to improve the unit in accordance with the way the NFL is trending. Steven Nelson will be key, absolutely.

Advertise with us

team PGH: Hi Batko, I always think you cover baseball because your name has BAT in it. LOL. Anyway, has JT Jones shown anything so far at OTAs? Thank you.

Brian Batko: Also confusing that a fellow BB, Bill Brink, did cover baseball for us. Haha. He's no JT Thomas, if you ask me. You're welcome.

Bobby: Does Haden get offered an extension?

Brian Batko: He just turned 30 and is coming off one of his healthiest seasons in the NFL. Just shook my snow globe and it says "Most likely"

Emmanuel: Greetings from Mexico. Yesterday I heard a debate in a local ESPN show about whether the Steelers will continue their steady offensive production after loosing AB and LB or they will dramatically decline because of it. Local presenters leaned towards decline. What's your take on it?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Thanks for joining from international territory, Emmanuel. I think that's an easy, and logical, take to have. But keep in mind this offense didn't have Le'Veon Bell last year either, and a sleeker James Conner was more than up to the task. The argument to their opinion would be that Ben Roethlisberger can spread the ball around more without worrying about locking into his No. 1, No. 84. I can see both sides of that one, but still think I'd rather have Antonio Brown in my passing attack than not.

Javi: Hello Brian. How realistic is it that the Steeler brass will consider firing Tomlin if we fail to make playoffs again?Will he be given a longer leash with Brown and Bell gone and as well as the other changes?

Brian Batko: Hi, Javi. I think it's certainly possible, especially if that offseason extension doesn't materialize. I don't think those guys leaving affects the leash, considering they essentially caused many of the issues they did under his watch. This town will be on fire if this team misses the playoffs again, man. And I think that's possible, too.

Bobby: Do you think Adeniyi takes the starting job from Dupree at some point or are the Steelers truely sold on Dupree?

Brian Batko: If I had to bet, I'd bet against that happening. Partly because they do need to see what they have in Dupree - for the long term - and partly because Anthony Chickillo might be the next OLB in line anyway in the event of injury or lack of production. I do like Ola Adeniyi, though.

Advertise with us

TITAN in Charlotte: First off, congrats to the WPIAL 5A baseball champs! Can JuJu be cloned and sent to Charlotte? What a great kid, athlete, and Steeler!

Brian Batko: Oh heck yeah. Shaler baseball's season ended yesterday in the state playoffs, but what a season it was. BIIIIIG ups to the Titans. Don't think science is advanced enough yet, however, to answer your question. It sure does FEEL like JuJu is in multiple places at once, though.

Guest: If one of the starting cbs gets injured, who would be the primary backup to start?

Brian Batko: At the time of this writing, I'll still say Artie Burns, but I like what I've seen out of rookie third-rounder Justin Layne. And Cam Sutton still qualifies as a corner, too.

Luigi: Your thoughts on the browns. Are the steelers going to be 2nd class citizens?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Might be third-class if they fall behind Baltimore, too. But seriously, I do think Cleveland is going to be pretty good. I could see any of those three taking the North.

J: During off season interview, MT hinted the cleansing is the remedy to steelers' disappointments. Would cleansing have helped the Jacksonville or NE playoff losses?

Brian Batko: Cleansing the opposing team from the end zone would've helped.

Rosie Nix 4ever: Is Sutton Smith gonna make this team as a FB or not at all???

Brian Batko: No, I wouldn't say that. In fact, I still think he'll be listed as a linebacker first and foremost. But it can't hurt to do more than one thing, and possibly be useful in all three phases of the game. Doesn't mean he will or won't make the 53, but he's trying to make sure he's not expendable, so good on him for that.

Advertise with us

Eric L: Brian, welcome!

Brian Batko: Thank you, Eric Lindros.

Scott: Keith Butler was recently quoted saying the dropped interceptions were the difference between 13-3 and 9-6-1. Does ANYBODY on the Steelers coaching staff EVER take ANY responsibility for ANYTHING? What a joke.....

Brian Batko: Your comment is noted and published, Scott.

John Strange: Hypothetically .... If the Steelers fired Tomlin after this season do you think Munchak would come back to Pittsburgh for a head coaching position? I do.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: No idea, but I have to think this would be a coveted HC gig, given the track record of stability here.

cfl: Diontae Spencer is small, but he had a VERY impressive career so far in the CFL. Do you think his CFL experience will translate to the NFL and should he not make the team is he a free agent who can sign with any team in Canada? I'd love to see Winnipeg get a shot at him as I feel he'd fit in well with their offense and QB Matt Nichols. Any thoughts on this? Thanks, Brian!!!

Brian Batko: Not sure about the ins and outs of CFL free agency. I think Spencer's skills can translate, but it's gonna be tough to break into this wide receiver room given the size, experience, and pedigree ahead of him. I'd love to see him in Winnipeg snagging missiles from ol' Matty Nichols, myself.

Scott: It was a question....perhaps a rhetorical one but a question nonetheless.

Brian Batko: Those are my favorite ones.

Advertise with us

Greg: Thanks for the chats Brian! What are your thoughts on using starters on special teams? Do you think it’s worth making the ST better but risking injury? (like Haden’s ST injury against Cleveland)

Brian Batko: Not a huge fan of it. Never really liked Antonio Brown returning punts, even if he is the most electric guy with the ball in his hands. Just think it's a needless injury risk, for the most part. Find backups who are either young and hungry or experienced and hungry, but hungry to make an impact in that area no matter what.

ScottM: Any signs of Mason Rudolph improvement to show he can some day take Bens place in the future?

Brian Batko: In OTAs, honestly, no. Not a ton to glean from the quarterbacks right now.

Guest: Batko, I have to say that I enjoy your personality in these chats. You have a cool persona! keep up the great reporting!!!

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Not even my wife would say that.

Jeff: Do you think Ben R will play the remainder of his new contract extension?

Brian Batko: I'll say yes, but there are reasons to predict that he might not. Injury, winning a third ring, etc.

DaquidoBazzini: What seems to be the problem with Diontae Johnson? Has he gotten any work in?

Brian Batko: Yes, he has. No need to fret.

Advertise with us

Wife: I concur, his personality ain’t that great....

Brian Batko: There you have it.

ALB: Puncey has said when Ben hangs it up, so will he. Have a QB and center who played their careers together ever entered the HOF together?

Brian Batko: I don't know that one off the top of my head, but I love that question. Might steal it for this week's mailbag.

Turk: Hi Brian, really enjoy your chats. After TJ Watt, who do you think will have the most sacks for the D this year?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: You're too kind, Turk. I'll go with Cam Heyward again.

FloridaSteelers: Brian, I noticed 2 Lions players that are represented by the snake Rosenhaus unhappy with their contracts & letting everyone on social media aware of this. Do you feel what Antonio & Rosenahus got away with last year has sent a trend in the NFL? Me personally would not sign or draft anyone represented by the snake.

Brian Batko: It's absolutely worth wondering if Antonio Brown forcing his way out becomes a blueprint of sorts for others. But here's the thing: Not everyone has the clout or resume of AB. As for the second part, that'll be tough to do, considering Devin Bush, Joe Haden, Sean Davis and James Washington - among others - currently on this team are repped by Rosenhaus.

James Davidson: When are we going to sign some safety depth? One injury to Davis/Edmunds and its a big drop off

Gene: Is Grimble our backup TE September 8 or do the Steelers try to grab one after preseason?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I don't know that they're going to go out and sign another NFL veteran, but if they do, it likely would be at one of these two spots. I'll say yes on Xavier Grimble, but this figures to be his last year to cement himself there.

Kool-Aid: Buy or sell that this season will be drama free for the Steelers?

Brian Batko: Buy. There will always be something, but I can't imagine it comparing to the last couple of Le'Veon Bell and Antonio Brown drama.

Lloyd's 3-Count: How many proms have you been invited to?

Brian Batko: I've been to two proms, but wouldn't say either date particularly wanted me there.

Lloyd's 3-Count: Have the Steelers brought anyone in to compete with Jordan Berry?

Brian Batko: They've brought in Ian Berry, man. Ian Berryman, man. Ian Berryman.

Joe D: Call me overly sentimental, but I love the idea of a Griffey playing for the Steelers. Where would you say Trey is currently sitting on the depth chart?

Brian Batko: Trey Griffey is one of the bigger bodies in the mix, but I'd say somewhere between 6 and 9?

Guest: Hugo Weaving is winning...YOU HAVE A CELEBRITY TWIN!

Brian Batko: You're darn right.

biff: I read that JuJu S-S went to prom. Is that true? How is that allowed? He's not super old, but he's out of college. At my prom you could only take fellow students...and NOOOO I did not take my sister thank you very much!

Brian Batko: Guessing he got special dispensation from Chartiers Valley, what with being JuJu Smith-Schuster and all. Still think he doesn't have as much street cred there as T.J. McConnell.

Doug from Raleigh: So did Ed really jump ships to avoid the chats and the mock draft :) ?

Brian Batko: Only rumor I heard is that he couldn't stand Doug from Raleigh.

france: Did Stephen Nesbitt move back to France for a job or to be closer to his family? He was a good writer. You are good too.

Brian Batko: Thanks, partner. Yes, Stephen is back in France as I type this. I only report the facts.

Guest: Favorite FOOTBALL movie?

Brian Batko: The Replacements

Stiller fan: The last 2/3 years it feels like there's been a lot of experiments on Defense; OLB switching sides, now talks of 3 ILB and (what seems like) 5 safeties on the field at once. Seems like Butler is kind of reaching for answers. Thoughts?

Brian Batko: I think it's more about getting creative to try to slow down offenses that are getting more and more prolific. It also doesn't help defenses that we're in a really good time for QBs now, too. You have up-and-comers improving each year, all while some longtime greats such as Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Ben Roethlisberger and Aaron Rodgers are still getting the job done.

Cherry Garcia: Batko, are you a huge Grateful Dead fan like Jason Mackey? That dude is all about The Dead.

Brian Batko: no

John Strange: How long before the Steelers get their first win? Week 1? 2? 3? etc.?

Brian Batko: The prediction here on June 4 is Week 3 at San Francisco

Emilio: In the Steelers last playoff game, the Jaguars ran all over the Steelers. What has been done to prevent a running team to attack successfully the Steelers defense?

Brian Batko: Acquiring good players

Guest: Is Limas Sweed still a possibility to bring in for a tryout? Big body, good redzone target

Brian Batko: I don't think Limas is on the radar at this point, but you never know.

Guest: What band do you love then?

Brian Batko: How can anyone not love The Fray?

Lloyd's 3-Count: If I told you 12 months ago there's a team eligible for "Hard Knocks," that has the honor of having AB, Vontaze Burfict AND Richie Incognito on their roster, how much would you contribute to the Kickstarter campaign to get them on?

Brian Batko: Not a dime.

MTScott: Do you see Samuels bring used as a TE in some packages along with VM?

Brian Batko: When push comes to shove, probably not, but I think it'd be cool.

Shawn: I expect a big year for VanceMac, given he remains healthy. Could you see him being the teams 2nd most productive reciever and a top 3-5 test in the league. Dude is a freak athlete in as good system

Brian Batko: Yeah, I could see that.

Shawn: Thanks for the chat, B². If you had to bet a weeks salary on the Steelers making the playoffs or not...?

Brian Batko: I'd probably bet no, but that's a bit of a hedge, because if they make it my job will probably be more enjoyable.

Brian Batko: Well, would you look at the time. Gotta go, friends. Thanks for joining, and if I couldn't get to you or you think of something else, drop me a line on Twitter @BrianBatko or email bbatko@post-gazette.com for my weekly mailbag.