The Steelers greatly value what reserve interior offensive lineman B.J. Finney brings to the table. In March, they placed a second-round restricted free agent tender on him worth $3.095 million.
That’s good money for a backup offensive lineman, but it became fairly clear a few days later the Steelers weren’t as sold as much on Finney being a full-time starter.
How else to view the decision to sign 33-year old veteran starter Ramon Foster to a two-year, $8 million deal after they put the tender on Finney?
It was out of character for the Steelers to commit to an aging player when a capable player such as Finney was waiting in the wings. The Steelers rarely pay older and depreciating players when younger and cheaper options are in the system.
In this case, it was particularly surprising because Finney had established himself in extended starting opportunities.
In the nine games Finney has started, the Steelers are 7-2. In fact, some of their best offensive performances have come when Finney played in place of Foster.
Read More
In a 2016 game in Buffalo, the Steelers rushed for 240 yards with Finney as the starting left guard. They rushed for 149 in the same season against the Chiefs with Finney in the starting lineup and then 194 in another game against the Chiefs in 2017.
“It is what it is,” Finney said after practice Wednesday afternoon. “We knew we wanted to keep the room the same. We wanted to keep that continuity, that ‘it’ factor within the room. I’m extremely blessed to have that second-round tender put on me. That’s a huge for me, especially being undrafted. I’m happy. But I’m also happy for Ramon to get extended and getting the pay day he got.”
Finney will make almost twice as much this year as he did in his first four seasons in the NFL. He made $1.8 million from 2015 to 2018. Making $3 million in one year is life-changing for Finney.
“It’s a little bit of a reward and a taste of what can be,” he said. “It makes you drive that much harder. I’m going to keep improving my game and what is going to be is going to be.”
It should be noted the Steelers can easily move on from Foster after this season if they desire. It would only cost them $1.5 million in a dead-cap hit to cut him after the first year of his contract. But there is no guarantee they’ll be able to sign Finney after the 2019 season.
For the first time in his career, Finney has the chance to become an unrestricted free agent. The Steelers would have a two-month negotiating window after the season ends to offer Finney a long-term contract, but he would be under no obligation to sign it, especially if he wanted to find out his true worth on the open market.
“That’s down the pike,” Finney said. “I’m not focused on that. I’m focused on the season, on right now. I want to do my job and improve every day and help this team get better. Whatever will be will be.”
Finney might have only one chance to cash in on a big payday. He was 23 when he entered the league in 2015 as an undrafted free agent out of Kansas State. He spent his first year on the practice squad so he did not accrue any games toward his NFL service time. He’ll turn 28 during the season, and he has only a few prime earning years left.
Most of Finney’s starting experience has come at left guard, but he’s also filled in at center when Maurkice Pouncey has been injured. For the first five OTA sessions this spring, he’s been the starting right guard with David DeCastro missing the practices due to the birth of his child.
“He’s done a tremendous job,” Pouncey said of Finney. “He’s played two positions. Whenever you add value like that it always seems to work out. He’s been doing a good job of knowing all the calls. Everyone is comfortable with him in there.”
Finney’s worth to the team could be more this season if Matt Feiler remains as the starting right tackle. Feiler had also been a reserve guard before moving full-time to right tackle after Marcus Gilbert was injured last season.
Now it could be Finney’s time to prove to the Steelers that he can be a full-time starter. If not, he’ll be with another team in 2020.
“In unfortunate circumstances I have been able to play,” Finney said. “From what they tell me — and I’ll let them be the judge — I’ve played reasonably well. I still have things I can improve upon. As a team, we still haven’t achieved everything we want to achieve, and I’m a part of that. We just want to win.”
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.