Brian Batko: Great afternoon. Hope you all did enjoy your long weekend and will enjoy your short week. But not even a holiday can stop us from our weekly Steelers chat ... lol ... fire away!

Guest: If you had to bet a million dollars either way .... will or won't the Steelers win a playoff game this year?

Brian Batko: Wow, Guest coming in hot, making me place a wager I most certainly couldn't cover on a newspaper salary. But I would say WON'T on that one, my friend. Considering only, what, four teams are guaranteed to win one each season? And, at most, that number would be eight? Yeah, I'll pass. (Please let me know if my math is wrong)

ALB: Who will have the best year in 2019: Ben, Bell or Brown?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Ohhh that's a good one. Hard to quantify, but I think, relative to their position, I'll say Ben Roethlisberger. I think he'll finish higher in terms of passing yards than either of those two will in rushing or receiving yards. With JuJu Smith-Schuster, he likely has a better No. 1 WR than AB has a No. 1 QB in Derek Carr. Bell plays a position where it's difficult to stay healthy for 16 games. Very close between Ben and AB, but I'll say No. 7, all things considered.

His team also has the best chance of making the postseason, and that much probably isn't close.

Danny: Who are some of the smallest NFL all time great players? Who’s the best little guy in Steelers history? Can Sutton Smith be great?

Brian Batko: Sutton Smith is certainly small for his position if he turns out to be an OLB, and Devin Bush is undersized too. But they're still relatively big dudes. I'm sure there have been some wideouts, RBs and DBs who were small even among the human race. Darren Sproles, Tarik Cohen and MJD come to mind right away. Smallest Steeler? I don't know, but Amos Zeroueu was 5-8.

iowasteelersfan: What would you put the odds at - for the International TE on our practice squad last year to someday become a productive NFL TE?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Christian Scotland-Williamson wears 49, and I'd put the odds much lower than that. I actually think he'd have a better chance as a tackle. Dude is listed at 6-9, 274.

will: How much do you think the Steelers will use Jaylen Samuels this year?

Brian Batko: I could see him being tough to keep off the field. Was a versatile pass-catcher in college, so we knew he could probably do that at the NFL level, but he looked better as a pure runner than I thought he would as a rookie. It might take some creative packages to get him involved, but why not try it?

Mountain Gus: Should Tomlin go hands-off with the defense and let Keith Butler sink or swim?

Brian Batko: In order to make some kind of judgment on Butler long-term? I don't necessarily think that'd be wise. I think Tomlin should help the defense, if he thinks he can help the defense.

Advertise with us

Chris: Any chance we bring in a vet tight end or ride with what we got?

Brian Batko: There's definitely a chance, considering the Steelers reportedly put in a waiver claim for Jets castoff Jordan Leggett. But the Bucs got him instead.

Steel in MS: Would you rather play the Patriots in the opener or on week 10? I love that we get them early.

Brian Batko: Week 10. The home field advantage in NE should be even stronger coming off a Super Bowl season, all that pregame pomp and circumstance, etc. The Steelers played them Week 15 the last two years, one game that they won and one they likely should've won, if not for the Jesse James overturned touchdown catch.

Antonio brown: Could you swing by and mow my grass?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I don't even enjoy mowing my own lawn, so no.

jake: cmon Brian, how does Barry Sanders not come to mind?

Brian Batko: I was only 7 when Barry Sanders played his last down. But yeah, he was a good small player, too.

Mark: Hi Brian. I didn't understand Joey Porter's criticism of Big Ben. Did Porter long for the days of Kordell and Maddox? What do you think?

Brian Batko: Yeah, that was a strange one, but I guess if it's something he felt and wanted to get off his chest for a long time, now's the offseason to pile on. From what I understand, those two have a bit of a history, so he might not have been the most surprising voice on that subject.

Advertise with us

Chuck_in_DC: Sir... How long a leash on Dud Dupree this year. If he doesn't show any progress, which week will we see a change? Thanks sir...

Brian Batko: There are a lot of factors, probably too many, in that equation to really say for sure. What counts as a lack of progress, is it just sack numbers? Is anyone else making a push behind him? Is the defense as a whole playing well? I'll say he starts more games than he doesn't, put it that way.

soCal Steely Dan: Watching the Vegas gambler bet big on Jeopardy made me think NFL teams should go for two after every TD. IF a team scored more than 50% of their attempts then they would have more points than just kicking... I think the Steelers could make 70% or more of their 2pt. conversations and revolutionize the whole thing? Possible?

Brian Batko: Didn't the Steelers try to be pioneers on that idea not too long ago, when the NFL pushed back the distance on extra points? Maybe the Steelers should just hire Jeopardy James, though I think I read that he's more of a baseball guy.

Who’sReffingWho?: Which are the biggest rules changes for the upcoming season? In other words, how will the Shield try to keep the Steelers down? JK.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: The big one, of course, is that they're expanding replay on a trial basis for this year. Per NFL bylaws, that includes "pass interference, called or not called on the field." So, basically, the Saints Rule. Most people will call it that because of the way Saints-Rams ended in the NFC championship, but Steelers fans can call it that because of Joe Haden.

Rambis: Beyond the obvious (Bush), which rookie's development is most important to this season?

Brian Batko: Diontae Johnson, for sure. Even if James Washington breaks out and Donte Moncrief fits in great, you can always use more weapons on offense. And they didn't spend a high third-roudn pick on him to just sit around and wait for his turn in the receiving corps. He could be useful in the return game, as well.

Kurt: Hi Brian. How did Isiaah Buggs look in the rookie mini camp and OTAs? Also did Layne sign his contract yet? Thanks.

Brian Batko: He's big, but watching D tackles in individual drills doesn't really tell a whole lot. I could tell you he makes vicious movements on the blocking sled and whatnot, but I'll refrain.

Advertise with us

No, you haven't missed anything on Justin Layne. It'll get done eventually.

Wisconsin Winters: Troy P is up for HOF consideration at the end of the 2019 season. Is that when we can expect to see him in again? Why the hiding, is he bitter?

Brian Batko: I don't know Polamalu, never spoken to him, but he always had a reputation of being pretty quiet and introverted, if I'm not mistaken. I get the sense he's not real fond of being in the spotlight, despite his massive popularity over the years

iowasteelersfan: I was in Vegas a couple of weeks ago and put money on the Over for the Steelers win total to be 9 games. Safe bet in your opinion?

Brian Batko: Not sure I'd call it safe, but certainly not crazy either.

Advertise with us

Scott: If the Defense falters again who will be the scapegoat?

Brian Batko: Me!

Mark: Brian, when the team travels to away games do certain players get preferred treatment? i.e. their own hotel rooms, vs. having to share, better seats on the plane, etc? I imagine rookies have to pay their dues, but what about vets? Wondering as it relates to the perception of preferential treatment, or "coach's mentality".

Brian Batko: I'm sorry, I don't know. I hope rookies don't have to pay too many dues when the Post-Gazette team travels to games, though.

Danny: I think Walk-Up-music for batters in MLB is the choice of the players for the most part. Do NFL players have any say in the stadium music? Just wondering if players even notice it or use music to get more jacked up for game action. I use music when running or shooting hoops. Does Devin Bush have a Ray Lewis dance routine yet?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Good question, Danny. I'm sure they do get a say in it. I can remember Verron Haynes always dancing wild to the pregame music at Heinz Field when the team would stretch. Not sure about Bush's celebrations/dancing.

Mountain Gus: Does it say something about JuJu's character (or lack thereof) that he had to be reminded by team leaders to accommodate the media?

Brian Batko: We don't KNOW that Ben Roethlisberger told JuJu to meet with media last week. He might have. Not really sure it's my place to weigh in on whether players should always talk to the media. Of course I'm biased. I don't think not doing it makes someone a bad character.

BeantownStiller: As fans, we have no idea. In your opinion, is clubhouse harmony that important to a winning team? I remember the Raiders of the 70's, for example. Is it even remotely possible that the Steelers can be better this year?

Brian Batko: I don't see how it can be worse for a bunch of guys who no longer have to answer when their No. 1 running back will be reporting or why their No. 1 wide receiver tweeted this or that. But I do think team chemistry is somewhat overrated. You need good players and schemes more than you need that, rather than the other way around. Just my opinion.

Advertise with us

ALB: Is Hader, the tight end from Youngstown State the Steelers signed several months ago still with the team?

Brian Batko: Kevin Rader, yes. He's also from Pine-Richland, and he's still here on the 91-man offseason roster.

stranded in cleveland: Hi Brian. Welcome to the Steelers beat. What is the feeling among players and coaches regarding Mr. Porter and his divisive comments?Thanks and nice having you on board. Enjoy your writing style.

Brian Batko: Hey, thanks! I didn't ask anyone about Joey Porter today after practice. Thought Chris Boswell is a more interesting story, and that's what I wrote about: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/05/28/chris-boswell-...

Brian Batko: Although it would've been funny if I asked the kicker what he thought about the former outside linebackers coach taking a shot at the quarterback

Advertise with us

jake: i saw that Sutton Smith was practicing at Fullback last week and I also read that he was a really good high school running back. Are they considering moving him permanently to offense? I really want to see what he can do rushing the passer.

Brian Batko: Eh, I don't think so. Probably just trying some different things with a rookie who's eager to help however possible.

Rob: Do the Steelers believe that Mason Rudolph is there next Franchise qb or they think that guy is not on the current roster Brian?

Brian Batko: Rudolph's rookie contract has three years left. Ben Roethlisberger just signed up for three more. So, they'll be done at the same time. Would be a good problem to have though if Rudolph is ready and Ben is still playing at a high level.

George in OKC : Did you get an invite to the defense’s steak cook off?! Looks like everyone was hanging out and having a good time. I think the locker room dynamic is going to be really different this year. What say you Brian?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I think my invite must have gotten lost in the mail.

iowasteelersfan: Who is one former Steelers player you wish you could have been in a position to interview had you been in this capacity back then? Why?

Brian Batko: Think I'd have to say Jack Lambert, mainly because of his "Mad Man Jack" personality. I'm sure those were interesting times.

Chris: If Mason Rudolph can't move up and take over the number 2 spot this pick was a true waste . What say you Mr. Batko?

Brian Batko: Not if you can still get something in exchange for him. But yeah, generally, any third-rounder who doesn't become a starter is pretty much one that got away.

Advertise with us

Greg: Would be great to see a late round or undrafted free agent surprise and make a nice contribution to the roster, like FWP did. Any idea who you might see doing that this year?

Brian Batko: Maybe one of the safeties, Dravon Askew-Henry or P.J. Locke? Travon McMillian might not be Willie Parker, but he's probably competing for one of the last roster spots at RB, should they decide to keep four tailbacks (Conner, Samuels, Snell the clear top three).

c of c cougars: Do you think the steelers window has closed on a super bowl run or is there more gas in the tank?

Brian Batko: As long as they have Ben Roethlisberger at QB, I think the window is open.

Wisconsin Winters: Darrell Green was the best small CB ever.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Noted

Greg Lloyd Unblocked: Over/under on Steelers D sack total. 45. Individual team leader over/under. 12.

Brian Batko: I'll say over again, and over, accordingly.

Adam Case’s Thoughts: Hmmm.... wonder if the Steelers would be interested in making a deal for our running back??? ... thinking of trading him.... hmmm.... what is the market like?????

Brian Batko: Wait, who is Adam Case?

Brian Batko: And with that, this chat has ended. Go in peace.