Brian Batko: Well, hello. The chat has begun, dovetailing nicely with the start of Steelers OTAs. Fire away, friends.
Silly in Philly: Yo Bats. Ben “apologizes” 6+ months later for calling AB out after games- day late and buck short, right?
Brian Batko: Sup. Yes and no. I think his goal was probably to clear the air, so to speak, before OTAs and minicamp ramp up here, and then eventually training camp, but Ben still had a media throng around him today after practice. HOWEVER with the way he has answered questions about this today in-person and yesterday on KDKA, the record will reflect that he took the high road in the end.
Is it just me?: I asked this question in a prior chat and got a smart reply in return. Serious question. Why is seemingly nobody concerned about our offensive line. We were something like 30th in the league in rushing and a couple late losses in which our D collapsed masked the fact that if we were able to move the chains in the 4th q might have been victories. Lost a starter and the "guru" coach and nothing in the draft in return. Why is nobody concerned?
Brian Batko: A smart reply? Hopefully it wasn't me. I would never do such a thing. But anyway, maybe it is just you. I can't say I personally have too many concerns about that particular unit. Had Ramon Foster left, they'd be short one more veteran. The right tackle spot is still somewhat of a question mark, with Matt Feiler most likely having the inside track but a relatively small sample size of success there. It's often hard for rookies to make an impact there right away anyway, so the draft thing doesn't bother me. I still think they'll be solid, especially in protecting No. 7.
Guest: From what you’ve seen so far, which WR will be playing opposite JuJu when the games count?
Read More
Brian Batko: I'll say James Washington, and if not him, then Donte Moncrief. But that doesn't mean rookie Diontae Johnson can't close the gap between now and then with the way he might perform in training camp/preseason.
pdxJaxon: Hey Brian, aside from his boneheaded play late in the season, is Grimble a viable TE #2 this year if we need to stick with him?
Brian Batko: What's going on? I think a lot of folks are gonna have trouble forgetting that prime opportunity that Grimble bungled. Doesn't mean he can't still cement himself in that spot. I'm sure the Steelers would love it if he does. Probably a better chance of him doing so than the rookie Zach Gentry.
The Line: Can Gerald McCoy be a DE in a 3-4 base? Should the Steelers be interested?
Brian Batko: Probably, and probably not. He wouldn't come cheap, right?
Silly in Philly: High road, eh? Ben calls teammates out, kicks people under the bus and lots of times takes shots AND NOW all of a sudden he takes the high road- is that media speak??
Brian Batko: What else would you call how he handled his interviews today and yesterday? I won't pretend to know if he's always done the right things, but he is saying the right things lately.
Pompeani v. Nutting: Brian Allen is now listed at safety. He's got a few years under his belt, how does the team now feel about his development and what are his chances this year to see the field? He seems like a perfect fit size/speed-wise to fill some of the roles in the multiple DB sets.
Brian Batko: On the roster passed out to media this morning at the facility, Brian Allen is listed at CB. I think he's more on the fringe of fighting to make the team than fighting for gameday reps, but hey, one step at a time. He is long.
The Mirror Has Two Cases: Speaking of... Isn't AB starring in his own, perpetual, Snickers commercial?
Candy... Oh: If AB had a Snickers would he turn into.... AB?
Brian Batko: Not entirely sure what's going on here, but I do know it's going way over my head. Seems like he'd be more of a PayDay guy, though. Maybe Nutrageous.
Vince: Hi Brian ...welcome aboard! who were you most impressed by of the rookies at the minicamp; and which rookie free agent impresssed you the most
Brian Batko: Thank you, Vince. You're a nice man. It's not really a setting for them to do anything particularly impressive, but certainly Devin Bush's ball skills as an inside linebacker are plainly evident, as is the compact build and quickness of Sutton Smith. As for UDFAs, Samford QB Devlin Hodges is small but I can see why the Steelers kept him around after his tryout.
MIKE: We need to sign Tre Boston asap to be our 3rd Safety
Brian Batko: OK.
Marlon: Since Sensabaugh beat out Burns last year, why do the Steelers continue to bring Burns back? Even as a backup he has less value then Sensabaugh.
Brian Batko: Well, Sensabaugh is a free agent now, and certainly Steven Nelson should be an upgrade. It's tough to cut ties with a former first-rounder. Steelers did at least move closer to cutting their losses though by not picking up his option.
Hickster : Thoughts on Edmunds liking AB’s post calling Ben 2 faced? More Drama still on the team!
Brian Batko: I mean, I'm certainly not going to read too much into a "like" on Twitter, but probably not a great look. He's a young guy, but ought to be cognizant of how things like that can be perceived.
Bigbirdssack: Jesse James was a liability as a blocker but had soft hands. Gentry seems to possess neither. Can you actually coach up a TE catching skills?
Brian Batko: I wouldn't jump to that conclusion just yet about Gentry's hands. But putting a guy in front of a jugs machine for a while should coach him up a bit.
Eric: Any word on progress by Mason Rudolph?
Brian Batko: Not at this time. I'm sure we'll talk to No. 2 at some point during OTAs.
I should be the agent: How about a ornery Lama wearing the Queen of the Norths new crown... Eats a Snickers... turns into Sansa/Sophie Turner with AB as the Queens hand saying "Drama Queen... better ending than GoT & Steelers 2018!
Brian Batko: You should be ... something.
Ryan: Any of the rookies stand out during this first OTA?
Brian Batko: Devin Bush was loud and proud in the middle of the defense today on his reps, so that was impressive. The others weren't really seen nor heard from much, working behind veterans and the like. We'll have a story from Sarah Spencer on Bush that should be online shortly.
DouglasD44: Do you see the defense taking a step forward this year?also can we change the game plan when we play the Patriots? Seems like have same scheme and we just hope we get the ball at the end of the game.
Brian Batko: I do ... if Steven Nelson shores up the corner spot opposite Joe Haden. No guarantees, but they paid him pretty handsomely to do so. I also like Mark Barron and Devin Bush additions in the middle, for sure. Dudes who were brought in to be able to adapt to any and every scheme the Steelers will see.
TD: Has anyone told Mark Barron that he won't be playing much this year? Going back to Blount all their problems seem to stem from them refusing to play backups, but not being upfront with them.
Brian Batko: Can't imagine he's been informed of that, no.
Tom : What if the Steelers and media just ignore social media? Nobody takes it seriously and it is just an outlet for people to say stupid stuff.
Brian Batko: The Steelers absolutely can, and should. But us? We can't really do that, because we have an audience to serve. People care about it.
Stiller fan: Have you learned to speak Tomlin yet? We'll need interpretations soon with all his euphemisms.
Brian Batko: I've learned that anytime you can use a larger word for a smaller one, you should do it. I like that about Tomlin.
NH Steelers Fan: Does Terrell Edmund’s like of AB’s tweet indicate that the issues of the team are so much more far reaching than the dismissals of Art II, Colbert, and Tomlin that blamed Bell and Brown—rightfully so—and that minimized how deeply Tomlin’s miscalculations harmed team dynamics? Should Tomlin be publicly placed on notice so that the remaining players don’t have to covertly bring attention to his poor decisions?
Brian Batko: That's quite an extrapolation from a Twitter "like." I remember when they used to be "favs."
Israel: I'd like your opinion on this. Do you think it was a good idea for Ben to air out his side of the story about Brown? Or should he had just said "no comment" and completely ignored it?
Brian Batko: I don't have a problem with him telling his side, especially since everything he said was pretty milquetoast. Does that count as "speaking Tomlin"?
CourtneyWest: Brian, do you think the Steelers will use a backfield by committee approach?? Like using Benny Snell as James Connor’s backup then using Jaylen Samuels as the third down back/H-Back?? I’m really interested in how they’ll go about using them. They need to find a way to maximize all three of them. Like New England would do.🤬
Brian Batko: Wouldn't surprise me if James Conner's workload is lightened a bit now with Benny Snell in the house. And Jaylen Samuels is particularly interesting because of his versatility. So yeah, I could see more of a "committee" approach, but Conner is the best all-around back they've got. Don't limit his action if it's not in an effort to make him more fresh and effective when he's in there.
Steeltowntim@aol.com: Brian, Artie Burns has all the physical tools o be above average if not great. I have seen how stupid he looks but if we just put him in man coverage wouldn't that take some of the thinking out of it.
Brian Batko: Ehhhh...
Mike's Platitudes Calendar 2019: When the "minutiae" is the elephant in the room, is it minutiae?
Brian Batko: Yes
Brian Batko: OK, halftime chat plug for my Steelers mailbag: We'll roll that out again later in the week, so feel free to send me questions on Twitter or to my email at bbatko@post-gazette.com
Brian Batko: In a mailbag, you'll generally get a little longer, deeper answer to something than you'd get in one of these chats. All right now, back to the madness.
Mudd: Brian, do you think Ben's apologies were sincere, or that he was just saying things best for his image?
Brian Batko: Why not both? Simply as a human, I have a hard time believing he still considers AB a friend. How could you? But in Ben's position, saying something like that would only stoke the flames even more.
Andy: HI Brain. Thanks for your time. I've read and listened with interest about defenses evolving to deal with the ever changing offenses. The Steelers very much seem to buy into this conversation. That being said, what about the times we have heard : We try and make the opposing offense 1 dimensional. Stop the run and make them pass. It seems now we see teams trying to have every conceivable defensive package to stop what the offense is doing instead of trying to force them to do what we want them to do. Your thoughts?
Brian Batko: No need to call me "Brain." I'm not that smart. But yeah, offenses aren't stupid. They'll have counters. Sometimes, though, an offense can have one really effective dimension, even when you are geared up to stop it. Look at the Patriots dinking and dunking their way up the field. Now, what did they do more of a year ago? Power run game with Sony Michel. I'd say it worked out pretty well for them.
trag91146: Why have you blocked me?
Brian Batko: I have?
Mfinn: Last year Ben came to camp in specially good physical condition. Is there anyone this year that stands out like that?
Brian Batko: Not really, but kind of hard for me to say since I wasn't in this chair last season. I wouldn't really notice any remarkable physical developments, if there were any. Ryan Switzer didn't get taller or anything like that though.
JB: Why don’t we go after Rudolph?We need a 1A. Grimble has had his chances and we could line up in some 2 TE sets and get back to Steeler Football. Play some smash mouth but also be able to throw out of it.
Brian Batko: Kyle Rudolph, the Vikings TE? Maybe the financials wouldn't work out or maybe Rudolph wouldn't want to go someplace where there's a clear-cut No. 1.
Silly in Philly: What are you most looking forward to with you new gig covering the Steelers?
Brian Batko: Looking forward to the road trips with Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo. Also, seeing more of Joe Starkey. He's one of the more unique people I know.
StuckinDC: So, break the tension, 55 line up with the starters?
Brian Batko: Read this while sitting in traffic on the Beltway https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/05/21/devin-bush-ste...
kevin in Punxsy: Brian, at what position, on both offense and defense, do you consider the Steelers a little lacking?
Brian Batko: On offense, TE for sure. On defense, safety. They need more of a playmaker back deep, and if Sean Davis isn't that this year, he might not be long for Pittsburgh.
'Burgher in Warren, Pa.: If Sutton Smith proves he should play over Bud (very long shot, I realize), is it realistic to believe MT / Butler and Butler would sit their $9m man?
Brian Batko: I mean, sure, if Sutton Smith somehow does something that's more conducive to winning football games.
Ryno: How much rope will Boz get?
Brian Batko: He's shown he can make kicks in high-pressure situations before. He may very well get a chance to bury last year's struggles. But as plenty of NFL teams have shown, life in the kicker world can be here today and gone tomorrow.
Stiller fan: With the suspension and probably a cheaper price. If you were Gm would you make an offer for Az CB Peterson?
Brian Batko: Nah. You gave Steven Nelson a big deal and used a third-round pick on Justin Layne. Ride with them.
Simplify the simplicity: Now is the time to install a season plan for no huddle scripts, say a weekly rotation of 5 calls Ben can just yell out & go and to make sure these guys never slack with their pre/during/post hydration... If only.
Brian Batko: Hydration is definitely important, you'll get no argument from me there.
If I was a Carpenter: Is someone slotted to replace Ernie to Gerry's, Burt for pre/post video reports?
Brian Batko: Gerry and Ray will be handling most of the postgame and post-practice videos, but I'm sure I'll weasel my way into some, as well.
Silly in Philly: Bats! Will you be attending the remainder of OTA’s? If so, what will your role be??
Brian Batko: Watch. Write. Talk. Type. Yes, I'll be here. My first OTAs dispatch is here https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/05/21/steelers-offse...
Mark: In your opinion, true or false, LB doesn’t care if his new coach wants him or not cuz’ he got himself paid and that was all that mattered?
Brian Batko: True, I don't think Le'Veon Bell cares too much about that. I still kind of feel bad that this stuff is leaking out, but I don't feel bad for his wallet.
The Line: Can Gerald McCoy be a OLB in a base 3-4.... again... $$$ aside...
Brian Batko: I don't know off hand how many 6-4, 300-pound OLBs there are, but I can't imagine many.
Basile: Chances of Rudolph being the second QB?
Brian Batko: I'd put it above 50-50, I guess
Time to move on: In "Renegade" are the Steelers the whining for his mama condemned criminal or the "long arm of the law" i.e. the "hangman?"
Brian Batko: I believe the Renegade, in question, is crying out for his mother.
Wisconsin Winters: Brian, Please tell the other sports writers to stop taking up column space on ex Steeler players. They are starting to sound like the ex-girlfriend. Let AB and LB to.
Brian Batko: Ah, yes, I see your point. But there remains an appetite for it here, right or wrong.
Simplify the simplicity: What % of hamstring injuries are dehydration related? I'd surmise that it's in the 90th percentile.
Brian Batko: Indubitably
Michael in NC: Great addition to the team - thanks for your chats! When will we Steeler fans realize that Mr. big chest just wanted a new deal since he had no more guaranteed $$$ and made an AB of himself to get out of town. I really feel that the whole team will be way more focused and driven to win a championship this year. What is your opinion on overall team chemistry since you've followed the team?
Brian Batko: Appreciate it, Michael. We haven't had a chance to see much of "team chemistry," really. But I don't know how it couldn't be a relief to be rid of a couple guys who talked a lot and tweeted even more. Guys had to address the offseason today, but eventually this stuff should die down.
Ryno: Will spreading the valley around more make up for losing AB? Defenses wouldnt w where the ball will go as much with AB gone.
Brian Batko: Possibly, but from an on-field perspective, I think I'd still rather have 84.
MIKE: I am nervous about our Safety's. Davis is average on a good day, though I think Edmonds has a chance to be good. Our back-up are spec
Brian Batko: Yeah, needs to be more production there. Marcus Allen and Cam Sutton seem to be trending more toward being used in subpackages than fighting for starting spots deep.
TITAN in Charlotte: Feels like this defense is moving towards being very good. If they achieve greatness, what will the nickname be?
Brian Batko: The Bush Brigade
Vacap: Where does Cook come off thinking Tomlin should be extended? Last year was an abomination..he should have been fired after last season...
Brian Batko: When you factor in his overall success rate and chalk up locker room issues as more of an AB problem than a culture problem, well, you get Ron's argument in this column from yesterday: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/ron-cook/2019/05/20/mike-tomlin-co...
Time to Move On: How about every time Bush gets a turnover and/or sack a blast of Sammy Hagar's "I can't drive 55"? I mean it keeps the criminal element tradition alive... musically speaking, of course.
Sid: Who wins the right tackle job?
Brian Batko: Matt Feiler
Stiller fan: winning formula for this season? (other than being ahead when the clock strikes 0:00) also I had to look up what a doldrum was haha
Brian Batko: I'm glad you learned something in today's chat. Like any football formula, win the turnover battle!
Silly in Philly: Yo Bats. Greatest receiver in Steelers history is???
Brian Batko: The end of the Antonio Brown era here was great for the legacies of Lynn Swann and John Stallworth, if you ask me.
G.O.A.T. Steeler WR: Hines Ward ! Hands down!
Brian Batko: And him.
Ryno: I really like both Rogers, and Switzer. Can they keep both?
Brian Batko: I think it's unlikely.
Michael in NC: With Special teams being more than a disaster last, and with the loss of DHB & possibly Dirty Red due to the youth movement, Could you see ST being a true strength with increased speed, etc., esp if Boz gets back on track?
Brian Batko: The book on a lot of the guys drafted is that they can help on ST right away, if not on defense. So, possibly. Speed was added, that's for sure.
Butch Cassidy: Paper skinned Brown couldn't handle anyone criticizing him... we'd have skinned him alive here at the Hole in the Wall... is anyone else on the current team so fragile?
Brian Batko: I sure hope not. As a reporter, really all I ask is that players understand we have a job to do, and that we strive to do it fairly. We're not out to get them or out to help their cause. We're a conduit for our audience.
Brian Batko: And with that, I'll end this chat before I get too philosophical. Ain't nobody got time for that. Thanks for coming, please tip your waiters and send in mailbag questions. Go Bucks!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.