Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Send in your questions and we will get started.
Mtsteel : Hi Ray, thanks for your time with these chats. What's your take on Justin Layne as 3rd round pick? Do you see him as an answer in the secondary somewhere or more like a Cam Sutton who obviously is not an answer as a 3rd round pick himself. Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, they're obviously hoping he is someone who will develop into a useful player for them. He's a third-round pick. Players selected in the third round should be useful players. They plan to start him on the outside, which means he'll be in a backup role to starters Joe Haden and Steven Nelson. But with his size and athleticism he also might be able to help out in sub-packages. He's an intriguing prospect. I think there is a lot of potential there. It's just a matter of the Steelers coaches getting it out of him.
CourtneyWest: Mr Fittipaldo, can you see a scenario where Artie Burns breaks camp as the teams nickel corner, playing like the first round pick he is then earning a long term contract after the season?? People forget that he just turned 24 in May and everyone expects the team to extend Joe Haden even though he’s 30 years old and that means if Haden loses even Half a step his days are numbered. Your thoughts?? By the way- I appreciate you answering one of my questions last week.🇮🇹
Ray Fittipaldo: My gut reaction to that is no. Artie Burns has never played in the slot. He has only played outside corner. He's a long, lanky guy who can run. Those types of players usually have success on the outside. The inside slot guys usually are smaller and quicker and better able to deal with small and quicker slot receivers. Now maybe Burns does well in camp and finds a role in sub-packages, but I don't think they're counting on that happening.
Steeltowntim@aol.com: Ray, With the rookie deals done and Ben;s extension adding to cap it doesn't look like we will have much cap space to sign anyone from other rosters on cut down days. About ho much we got left?
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: You're right. Not a lot right now. But if there is someone worth picking up in early September the Steelers can always redo a deal of a veteran to free up some cap space. They do it all the time.
Jason in Slippery Rock: Ray, what is your opinion that Zach Gentry will a) make the team and b) will supplant Grimble as the number 2 tight end?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'll let you know by the middle of August. Let's give him a chance to compete in training camp.
thomastown: It seems the only logical reason to extend Tomlin this year (2 years left on contract) would be thinking if they make it to the SB, his price would go up. But if that happens, I would think they would gladly pay that later. What other reason is there for them to do it now?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you 100 percent. If he wins the Super Bowl and they have to pay him more $ then it's money well spent. Otherwise, you're extending a coach who in the past two years has: 1. lost a home playoff game as the No. 2 seed in the AFC; 2. choked away a playoff berth with an epic collapse last season; and 3. overseen a locker room that has been chaotic and disruptive for several years.
Larry in KY: Hi Ray. Do you get the feeling that the Patriots are always ahead of the curve? While 31 teams are frantically drafting smaller, faster ILB's the Patriots are stockpiling bigger players to run over them?
Ray Fittipaldo: This all started late last season after Josh Gordon was injured. They changed their offense and won the Super Bowl. Shame on NFL teams for not recognizing if they're caught off guard.
pbourdon: Ray - I don't truly believe that a guy like Ben needs to lot of Incentives outside of the Ultimate prize to be at his best. He has shown that throughout his career... That being said, do you think that what transpired in the off season can provide additional motivation for Ben (and in a lot of ways, the rest of the team)? Ben will certainly want to prove that he can win without Brown and Bell (although IMO he has already proven it - his record speaks for itself). Can it really help in the long run?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes. I don't think this would ever be anything he verbalized, but any competitor wants to prove people wrong.
Priofessor Flush: Is BJ Finney targeted for an extension and pay raise to keep him in the Black and Gold for several more years?
Ray Fittipaldo: At this point I'm not sure. If they viewed Finney as a potential starter they would have let Ramon Foster walk and signed Finney to a long-term deal to be their starting LG in 2019 and beyond. Instead, they extended the 33-year old Foster for two more years and offered Finney a restricted free agent tender. He signed it, but he'll be an unrestricted free agent in March unless the Steelers give him a new contract in the weeks after next season.
AK: What is your opinion of Sean Davis’ play for the Steelers? Do you think he has played well enough to get an extension?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not really. I'm not saying it's entirely his fault, but he hasn't played to my expectations. I think part of the problem has been the coaches changing his position so often. He went from slot corner as a rookie to strong safety for a year and a half and then to free safety last season. That's three positions in three years. That being said, I expect starting free safeties to have more than one interception. That's all Davis provided last season. And overall, I didn't feel like he was really close to getting many others. So to answer your question, I think Davis has to play better to warrant an extension. If they give him one now it'll be purely out of desperation for lack of any others to fill that role or projecting what he might be. Either way, I think it's a bad gamble to extend him. Let him play it out.
Black Jack Bill: Do the Steelers have any say in their opening week matchup vs. the Cheats up in Beantown? I know several teams have whined and moaned about playing in the first game of the year, but I assume that money (and ratings) always win out.
Ray Fittipaldo: Sure, they'll have a chance. Not a great chance, but they could go in there and surprise if Roethlisberger and the offense plays well. Too many times over the years that hasn't happened in Foxboro.
Kiwi Jimmy: How much importance do you place in veterans attending OTAs?
Ray Fittipaldo: In a year like this year, after such a bad end to last season and the tumultuous offseason, I think it's much more important than other years.
jrmycllns: Ray with the recent loading up of smaller faster linebackers are you predicting a defensive scheme shift for the future. I realize they have always wanted fast linebackers but this year's draft was a larger focus.
Ray Fittipaldo: That's the way the league is going. I think it will be smart if teams kept a player like Vince Williams on the 53-man roster in case teams want to line up and run the ball. But overall, the game is trending in another direction and teams like the Steelers are trying to adjust their personnel.
ron: Hi Ray, appreciate your chats, just wondering if there was more to joey porter being let go. Performance results or a good player not being a good coach and not getting enough from what he had to work with.
Ray Fittipaldo: Not really. Outside linebackers, other than TJ Watt, haven't exactly been the strong point of the defense in recent years. And Joey had some off-field incidents that I'm sure didn't help.
Troy: I seem to be in minority, but I felt that the Steelers defense wasn't bad last year. They did lead (tie) NFL with Sacks. I think if they improve the TO ratio and get off the field late in games, your looking at a Top 5 NFL defense.
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree, but turnovers haven't been something these players have provided the past few years. And it's laregely the same group of players except for the addition to Steven Nelson, Mark Barron and Devin Bush. Maybe those guys will make a big difference. We'll have to wait and see.
Ben M: Hi Ray, I understand t least 6 of our picks were in Danny Colbert's scouting area. Not sure if he also covers Kentucky. So I'm curious to know, is Danny Colbert a next level scout, or might he have undue influence in the Steelers War Room on draft day?
Ray Fittipaldo: It might have just been a coincidence. And a young scout such as Danny doesn't have great influence on the draft. He might have a very good idea of what his father wants though. That might explain some things.
Kiwi Jimmy: Why not bring in a bunch of punters for open tryouts?...There is this boy we call the Milkeman in NZ who can punt a ball to Tasmania....surely there is one lad better than the shanker the Steelers have used the past few years!!!
Ray Fittipaldo: All the way to Tazmania? Send him over.
Professor Flush: Who will return punts this season? Switzer or by committee?
Ray Fittipaldo: Diontae Johnson returned some punts in college. He could compete for that role too. And maybe Eli Rogers.
Eric Carr: Ray, I know it's WAY early but right now in May, how many draft picks do you predict will make it and who do you think will not?
Ray Fittipaldo: You're right. It's way too early. And you never know how injuries will play into things. I can better answer that question in August.
Kiwi Jimmy: Love these chats. Will defense play more 5 and 6 backs in passing situations, or is 3/4 still the staple on first and second downs?
Ray Fittipaldo: They played in sub-packages 75 percent of the time last season. That's obviously dictated by offensive personnel so you never know how a season will unfold, but it seems like a good bet the numbers will be similar this season as well.
Ed: Ron Cook wrote that Mike Tomlin should get a contract extension. Why now? Let's see how he does this season first after the previous turmoil. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm with you. Why now? It might be good for all parties to wait and see what happens.
Kryder: Do you think a wild card birth and first round loss after all the turmoil would be enough to warrant an extension for Tomlin? Personally, i am hoping the Steelers dont extend Tomlin PERIOD!
Ray Fittipaldo: So that would still mean two playoff victories since 2011, right? I mean, if that's what you deem a successful head coach then go for it.
Kryder: If Steelers lose opener in NE and home opener against Seattle (not unfathomable) do you think Steeler Nation will hit panic mode?
Ray Fittipaldo: They'd have their fingers twitching to hit the panic button, for sure.
Kryder: Is this the year the Browns turn the tables on the Steelers and sweep both games?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'll believe it when I see it.
Bill Maloni: Is FA Safety Tre Boston a signing option for the Steelers?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not at the moment. I think the Steelers are going to evaluate their safety group this spring and summer, see what they have and then go from there.
Vico: Hi Ray! Has Mike Hilton signed his contract?
Ray Fittipaldo: To my knowledge he has not. Al Villanueva did the same things a couple of years ago and ended up getting a new contract the day training camp started. He showed up for OTAs and minicamp and the organization took care of him. I don't know if things will play out the exact same way for Hilton, but he appears to be handling this contract in a professional manner.
Nittany Lyin : If Mason Rudolph becomes Roethlisberger’s backup, does Donna make the team?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would think so. Who else would be No. 3?
Jw: Hey Ray thanks for your chats I really enjoy them! Do you have any inkling as to what the middle of the d will look like as the team starts otas?
Ray Fittipaldo: We will find out tomorrow. In 2014, Ryan Shaizer lined up with the starters in OTAs. He was a rookie and the No. 15 overall selection in the draft. Devin Bush was the No. 10 overall selection.
AA: Do you think Matekavich’s roster spot is in jeopardy
Ray Fittipaldo: If some of these fast rookies show up on special teams and prove they can pick up the defense then maybe. It's no secret they want to improve their team speed on defense and their special teams.
CoalportKid: Why is Sean Davis not a show-in for a second contract?
Ray Fittipaldo: Why would he be? Listen, teams don't always extend players because they've earned. There might not be a player in the pipeline to replace Davis, and they might feel like they have to do it anyway. That could happen. I'm just saying he hasn't performed up to expectations for a second-round pick. I expect more turnovers and splash plays from safeties, and he hasn't provided them. That doesn't mean I think he's a bad player. I just wouldn't extend him if I was GMKC.
The Standard: If Artie can't make it at outside corner, could he try inside...is that easier?
Ray Fittipaldo: No, it's not easier especially for someone with Burns' build.
Kiwi Jimmy: Will the Steelers play a regular season game in London or Mexico City first? They seem to have a bigger following south of the border.
Ray Fittipaldo: I would imagine Mexico. They just played in London in 2013.
Kryder: Experts always surmise that old generation stars like Lambert and such wouldn’t be able to play todays game because they weren’t as big and fast as todays players. There might be some truth to that but what do you think about todays players playing in that era? I think these primadonnas today could never withstand the pounding and fierceness of the way the game was played back then. I could see Mel Blount crushing guys like AB or Odell...
Ray Fittipaldo: That would have been interesting. Blount would have to get his hands on AB first, but if he did it wouldn't have ended well for AB. It's such a different game now. It's like that for almost every position on the field. Back in the 1970s, you have offensive linemen that weighed 270 or 280. Now you're "small" if you're a 300-pound offensive lineman.
CoalportKid: Are they avoiding signing free agents right now for fear of losing a comp pick given only James, Bell & Fort were picked up?
Ray Fittipaldo: No. At this time of the year the comp formula does not matter.
Ron: Just out of curiosity, would you prefer Locke or Askew-Henry on the 53?
Ray Fittipaldo: Let's see who plays better this summer. And maybe it will be someone else. Those two are getting a lot of publicity now, but that's only because the Steelers didn't select a safety in the draft. They have to play well in camp to earn a job. If they don't they won't be on the team.
DaquidoBazzini: Hi, Ray- Any idea who the WR’s were that went down to Ben’s place in Georgia?
Ray Fittipaldo: I saw a video one of the players put on social media. I saw Switzer, Moncrief, JuJu, Grimble... I'm sure there were others.
P6brit: What is the requirement for 'Hard Knocks'? Will the Steelers eventually have to be featured in that show?
Ray Fittipaldo: If the Steelers miss the playoffs this year they could be eligible. Have to miss the playoffs two years in a row I believe.
Stiller fan: Why are people so quick to call the Browns the AFC North favorites? Just because they have a new head coach and a new WR?! They've had similar combinations every year for the last 20 along with numerous 1st pics, and they have to go through the Steelers and the Ravens. I'm confused by the hype.
Ray Fittipaldo: Star power and the way they ended the season have something to do with it. There is no disputing they have talent. Baker Mayfield proved he can play a little. O'Dell Beckham is really good when he's right. David Njoku is a good young tight end. They have good RBs and a decent offensive line. The talent is there. I can't pretend to know how they'll handle the pressure and all that, but they have enough talent to win the division. However, as Steelers fans know, much more than talent plays into teams winning and losing.
CoalportKid: Do the Steelers employ analytics staff, dedicated to crunching numbers?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes they have an analytics department. Karim Kassam handles a lot of their projects. I wrote about him a few years ago: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2015/08/23/Karim-Kassam-P...
John K: Hey Ray....who do you think is a Steelers player from the 80's (not named Rod Woodson or Dermontti Dawson, that you think gets overlooked?
Ray Fittipaldo: Brian Hinkle was a really good player on some average or bad teams.
Professor Flush: Thanks for the chat. How many days does OTAs last? Are pads involved, or would that be a shouldergate violation and loss of a draft pick (Thanks John Clayton!)
Ray Fittipaldo: There are 10 OTAs over the next three weeks and then a mandatory minicamp the following week. They won't don pads until training camp.
BlackJack BIll: Tuitt was a major disappointment last year. What backup could push him for playing time?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think there are any. The Steelers need Tuitt to reach his potential though. He would add another dimension to that defense if he could find a way to be as productive/disruptive as Cam Heyward.
Scott: Do the Steelers now prefer the smaller, more disciplined receivers over the taller ones? When they drafted Johnson they passed on some of the bigger guys.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, receivers coach Darryl Drake addressed this a bit when he spoke to reporters after the draft. Sometimes, those bigger receivers aren't complete receivers. In other words, they're fast and tall and an sometimes make big plays, but they can't run all the routes. The Steelers right now are looking for complete receivers that can do everything. I think that's why Diontae Johnson was selected over others such as Hakeem Butler.
Dave: Ray, if the Steelers cut Bud DuPree before the season starts do they owe him the 9.2 million?
Ray Fittipaldo: No, but they won't cut him.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK that's it for this week. Thanks for all the great questions. We'll do it again next week. Bye now.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.