Welcome to Brian Batko’s first weekly Steelers mailbag. We’ll endeavor to make this a weekly item on the website, even during the lean weeks of the NFL offseason — if there is such a thing (there isn’t). You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything in between. Let’s get started:
John L.: I see in your chats where you keep mentioning and showing concern for how undersized Bush, Barron, etc., are. Pretty sure everybody had the same concerns about Shazier and that seemed to work out just fine. What say you?
Brian: Congratulations, John, on being the inaugural participant in the inaugural Steelers mailbag. Not sure what you consider your fondest life achievements, but this has to be on the short list now.
As for comparisons of first-round pick Devin Bush and free-agent signing Mark Barron to Ryan Shazier, let’s pump the brakes a bit. But I think the main reason why linebacker size is something worth noting is that as defenses get smaller and faster to counteract spread-out offenses, eventually the other shoe will drop and offenses will counter with bigger and stronger. Still, for the topic at hand, Shazier measured in slightly larger than Bush and Barron coming into the NFL. Here’s a one-by-one-by-one comparison of the three and their combine measurements:
Shazier (2014): 6 feet 1, 237 pounds, 32⅜-inch arms
Barron (2012): 6 feet 1, 213 pounds, 33⅝-inch arms
Read More
Bush (2019): 5 feet 11, 234 pounds, 32-inch arms
As you can see, even among three undersized prospects, Bush is on the shorter side, though he is thick. Barron, for his part, entered the league as a strong safety rather than a linebacker, which accounts for his slimmer frame. Really, Shazier was the perfect pick at the perfect time, a speedy inside linebacker who reportedly ran between 4.35 and 4.4 at his Ohio State pro day, unofficial as those times inherently are. Obviously, it can work. Shazier is evidence of that, and Barron (whose weight is now listed at 230) already has made the transition from defensive back to 3-4 inside linebacker. But Bush is his own player, so he’ll still have to show he can overcome some of the same physical limitations in order to both cover well and keep from being bullied against the run. If size is one of the few holes in your game, that’s usually a good thing.
Dr. Mac (in California): One thing I would like to know regarding the Steelers. Prospects are subjected to a variety of psych tests prior to the draft, including the so called Wonderlic test. I would ask Kevin Colbert that in light of the disasters that Bell and Brown turned into, did he go back and review their pre draft psych tests? Even in retrospect, is it possible that he missed something that might have warned him of what they ultimately turned into?
Brian: Well, Dr. Mac, if the Steelers have any secrets to determining how a guy will or won’t change once he gets rich and becomes a star, they’d probably like to keep them in-house. As for the Wonderlic test, it’s hardly a catch-all method for evaluating where a prospect’s head is. Really, it’s more about trying to measure cognitive ability, and even then it’s often been criticized as not-all-that-predictive for NFL purposes.
If anything, the idea you’re getting at probably has more to do with some of the seemingly bizarre questions prospects get asked in the pre-draft process. Former Pitt running back Qadree Ollison said an NFL team at the combine quizzed him on whether he’s a dog or a cat. According to 2010 draft pick Austen Lane, he was asked: “If you could kill someone and not get caught, would you?"
When a scout at the combine asked me... "If you could kill someone and not get caught, would you?" pic.twitter.com/mwK5UX8gvW
— Austen Lane (@A_Train_92) February 23, 2016
Maybe the Steelers use some off-the-wall questioning methods such as these, maybe they don’t. But Kevin Colbert and Mike Tomlin faced plenty of questions this draft season about how much emphasis they’re placing on “character” these days. In fact, just last Saturday after rookie minicamp, Tomlin was asked how much that played into the offseason additions. Tomlin’s answer: “It always does, but not in response to anything that’s transpired. It always does.”
“Transpired” should probably be on a Mike Tomlin big words bingo card.
Jud (in Connecticut): OL consistency starts with the coach and keeping the same scheme correct? Can you give us a “deeper” dive into the new coach and whether he plans to play a similar scheme to Munch? Personnel consistency is important, but much more so the scheme and implementation. Otherwise, Conner doesn’t average better than Bell, and Ben doesn’t have time to throw to JuJu/AB. Also, keeping a TE/RB in to block removes a target for Ben. Seems like that might be an important factor when we get to games.
Brian: I’m not going to profess to know much, if anything, about new Steelers offensive line coach Shaun Sarrett — other than it might be a struggle for a while with Sarrett vs. Surratt vs. Surrett. Given the success of Mike Munchak’s tenure here, I can’t imagine there will be many schematic changes, if any, with a veteran group. Sarrett hasn’t spoken with outside media since his promotion from Munchak’s assistant, so all we really have to go off of is what he and players have said through the Steelers. But in light of your question, I did reach out to Dave Harding, who’s now a college football analyst for the ACC but was an offensive lineman at Duke from 2009-11 when Sarrett was an offensive quality control coach and offensive line assistant there.
Here’s Harding: “Shaun Sarrett is amazing! The moment I got to campus as a freshman I could tell that Shaun had my best interest at heart. He has a unique ability of connecting with players and earning the trust and respect of those he coaches. He is easy to work hard for because you can see the effort he puts into his job every day. Always staying late, working behind the scenes, and doing all the little things required to be great. You know he cares about you as a person, not just for what you can do on the field, and that makes him so easy to trust. Having played offensive line in college [at Kent State], he has instant credibility in the offensive line fraternity and knows how to lead a room of linemen and foster a winning mentality. It is extremely rare to find a coach with the combination of football knowledge, dedication, and personality that Shaun Sarrett has.”
Larry R.: Brian, do you know why Johnson’s receiving stats as a junior were so much lower than what he did as a sophomore? Seems funny.
Brian: Best I can tell, there are a few reasons third-round draft pick Diontae Johnson went from 1,278 yards as a sophomore to 761 as a junior. No. 1, he did play one fewer game in 2018 than 2017. But Toledo also had much better quarterback play two years ago. Logan Woodside was a three-year starter who became a seventh-round draft pick of the Bengals last year and is now with the Tennessee Titans. Obviously, he really liked Johnson as a target. It looks like the Rockets were a little more run-pass balanced last season, too, probably as a result of their quarterback issues.
@4450Dawson: Hi, Bri. What are Steelers next year's draft TOP NEEDS first 3 rounds?
Bri: Whoa, really, a 2020 draft question? Some might balk at such a thing, but what fun is following sports without occasional baseless speculation nearly a year out from something? We can take a crack at it.
Bud Dupree has one more year to prove himself as a pass-rusher, thanks to the Steelers picking up his fifth-year rookie contract option. He’ll either do that, and make himself quite expensive to re-sign, or not do that, and make himself expendable. So, first-round need? Edge rusher.
Sean Davis has one more year to prove himself as a free safety, as he’ll be an unrestricted free agent after this season. He’ll either do that, and make himself quite expensive to re-sign, or not do that, and make himself expendable. So, second-round need? Defensive back who can play center field.
As for the Steelers’ third-round pick in 2020, it now belongs to the Denver Broncos thanks to their big draft-night trade a few weeks ago. So, third-round need? Devin Bush.
Be sure to compliment Joe Starkey and also send me questions. Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.