Brian Batko: Good afternoon. Just had a late lunch at home, where I'm cold but also refusing to turn the heat on in mid-May. Let's warm it up with some questions.
CanadianSteelersFan : How confident are you that Big Ben’s interceptions will drop dramatically without force feeding a star WR to keep him happy? I worry that with integrating the young and new receivers into the passing game, there could be too many interceptions early on due to timing, wrong routes, chemistry, etc.
Brian Batko: Not that confident, really. While there was undoubtedly a big chest and big mouth to feed there, Antonio Brown was still someone who got open with regularity and even made some spectacular catches when he wasn't. For what it's worth, AB was responsible for a 92.7 percent QB Rating when targeted, according to playerprofiler.com. That ranked him 57th in the NFL, only seven spots behind JuJu Smith-Schuster.
Greg: Do you think it’s important to stock different types of wide receiver? Boykin seemed like a better draft choice to me when they drafted in the 3rd round. Maybe because JuJu is 6’1” and Moncrief is 6’2” they took a different style of WR? Unless they thought Johnson was truly better, I wouldn’t think you could have enough tall, fast WRs ....
Brian Batko: That could be part of it. While I think some of the AB-Diontae Johnson comparisons have been overblown, he does have a similar skill set, in theory. If you figure the offense/passing game was a strength last year, might as well try to replace AB with the closest (reasonable) player you can find.
Dr. Strangeglove: My ears are still bleeding from listening to Romo do analysis. Can't anything be done about this?
Read More
Brian Batko: Really? I actually enjoy listening to Rony Tomo call games. Although I have heard people like you, Dr. Strangeglove, who do not. In my experience, it's that way with a lot of broadcasters, for whatever reason. Especially true with Steelers fans and Cris Collinsworth, another one I happen to like just fine.
Don from Youngstown: Who do you expect to be our nickel corner? Hilton got exposed last year and I'm not confident he's the guy anymore.
Brian Batko: I suppose the possibilities here are Mike Hilton, Cam Sutton, Justin Layne and Steven Nelson. But I don't think Justin Layne will beat out Nelson for the outside job as a rookie, and Layne doesn't have much slot experience. So, making a prediction at your request on May 14, I'll say it's Hilton's job to lose.
Questions : Could there be any similarities with Sutton Smith and James Harrison? Both small and quick around the edge. How's Smiths strength?
Brian Batko: Well, the Steelers certainly hope so. I don't know if James Harrison ever ran a timed 40 or anything like that, but Smith was a 4.69 at the combine. Can't imagine he's stronger than Harrison was (or is) though. The first thing that stuck out to me when I saw Smith at rookie camp over the weekend was just how real those size concerns are with him. Not surprising at all that he was recruited to college as a running back (though I'm certainly not writing him off).
Scott: Stay strong on the no heat until Halloween pledge. Mr. Big Chest in court today? What's up with that?!
Brian Batko: Oh, I will. I think I saw that the sun is even supposed to come out sometime in the next few days. Anyway, Antonio was in town to resolve, finally, that rackless driving charge he caught way back in November. Pled down to excessive speed. You can read more about it at this link https://www.post-gazette.com/news/crime-courts/2019/05/14/antonio-brow...
Stiller fan: Other than the Pats Steelers game, is there a game that you're looking forward to?
Brian Batko: I'm most looking forward to Steelers-Bucs Aug. 9 at Heinz Field. Have to take it one game at a time, my friend.
Brian Batko: Just kidding. Ravens at Steelers on 10/6 is always a circled date on the calendar. Also very intrigued by Aaron Donald and the Rams coming here 11/10, the first time in his NFL career he'll play in his hometown. Both Browns matchups, which are only 17 days apart, should be great theater. And, of course, the trip to NY for a rendezvous with Le'Veon Bell in Week 16 could be fun.
What's In A Name: What's a 'Batko' ?
zbluez1: Brian, welcome to the chats! Given the unusual amount of roster turnover that happened after rookie mini camp do you believe the coaching staff is sending a message to the bottom half of the roster that no one is "safe" and they had better push the guys in front of them?
Brian Batko: Thanks! And I welcome you to my chat. But no, not really. Think it was just garden variety roster shuffling to make room for some guys they liked a little more than the also-rans.
Alan in Nashville: Hi Brian...I'm probably getting way ahead of myself but from everything I've seen, watched and read about Sutton Smith, the name Zach Thomas keeps coming to mind. I think he'll probably get eaten up as an outside guy but I could definitely imagine him playing next to Devin Bush on the inside 2-3 years from now. The speed, passion and motor are a great mix and he seems hungry. I think he'll be a demon on special teams right away. Thoughts?
Brian Batko: Definitely can see him being a huge help on special teams, also like one James Harrison was at the beginning of his career. I like where your head is at with ILB for Smith, but the issue with that projection is that he just simply didn't do that in college. Really hard to know whether he's capable of covering, what his ball skills are like, etc.
CourtneyWest: Mr Batko, what’s your take on Jerold Hawkins and do you think he’ll break camp as the teams starting RT?? Thanks.
Brian Batko: Hi, Courtney. He's a big dude, but really no bigger than Matt Feiler or Chukwuma Okorafor, both of whom will be his competition there. I think Feiler will keep the gig, one because he was solid there individually last year and two because continuity on an OL is so crucial, especially when you're trying to keep together a good one.
Steeler1974: Would having a player like Bush and Barton solve the offensive adjustment issues. They can both play run or pass. Teams should not be able to go big personnel and run at will. Shouldn’t having them on the field make offenses play more honest?
Brian Batko: Sure, that's the idea. But Mark *Barron has the size of a box safety, and Devin Bush is also quite small. Couldn't help but notice that at minicamp, either. Offensive coaches always have an answer for anything, especially in this day and age, so it won't be easy. The more versatile those two can be, the better. Hence the offseason moves of signing Barron and drafting Bush.
Silly in PHILLY: Hi Brian. I heard Ray, Gerry and the other guys are giving you a rookie hazing- is that true? And your technically not even a rookie.
Brian Batko: This is true. So far, I've had to buy Gerry lunch every day at the Steelers cafeteria. Ray makes me plug his laptop into the power strip all the time. I'm starting to crack.
Too Tall Ball: I may have missed it, but is there anyone currently on the roster to compete with Berry for the punter position? If not, how can I get a tryout?
Brian Batko: They did bring in a rookie punter as a UDFA, Ian Berryman from Western Illinois. I still haven't gotten around to watching tape of him with the Leathernecks. Perhaps this will be the week.
Scott: Did any of the draft picks leave the Steelers wondering why they drafted them?
Brian Batko: Not yet
What's In A Name: According to names.com "Batko" originates from Sanskrit which means you might be related to Luke Skywalker's surrogate uncle. Apparently it means "Gift of God" so I'd like to thank Him for your chat.
Brian Batko: Bless up
pdxJaxon: So Brian, Im one of those Nutty Draft Freaks...I LOVE IT.
Ive already made my reservations for Vegas Next April.
We all need to get together for a Beer to celebrate our first round Edge Rusher.....Jaxon's buyin
Brian Batko: There's a place for you and your kind in this world, Jaxon. If the edge position is as deep next year as it was this year, you'll be very happy.
From A2: I watched Paris Campbell destroy Devin Bush 1 on 1 Why should I believe Bush in coverage against a league of Campbells and better will be any different, considering he's really a hybrid Tomlin Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean, safety?
Brian Batko: Honestly, you lost me when you started talking about sausages.
CoachJyro: Great Stuff Mr. Batko. Are you a metrics guy or an eye test guy when it comes to looking at how a game went?
Brian Batko: Thank you, coach. I'd consider myself more of an eye test guy, in general, not just for football. But I do believe there's a place for metrics and analytics, no doubt. Just not as interesting to me as others.
Robert: 11-5 what say you?
Brian Batko: I foresee a lot of close games again, and I don't think the Steelers get to 11.
"Double Divot Dewey": After the 3-day 'Serenade In Shorts" is there any chance you observed anyone who could fill the mold of Mr. Palomalu?
Brian Batko: There was not a chance, and this I did not.
scooter: Do you feel that the steeler offense is too safe most of the time? Where is the killer instinct? What will it take for them to run it down the other teams throat and keep going after them?
Brian Batko: To me, running the ball a lot would be the more "too safe" option of the two things an offense can do on a given play.

Eric Carr: Brian, what UDFA intrigues you the most?
Brian Batko: I'm a big kickers guy, so I think Matthew Wright from UCF is interesting. Accurate, but does he have enough NFL leg? Also the two safeties, Dravon Askew-Henry and PJ Locke. Askew-Henry, from Aliquippa and WVU, had an interception on both days of minicamp we got to see. I wrote about them over the weekend https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/05/10/pj-locke-dravo...
Lonnie: Hi Brian, welcome, hope I can get an answer from you and not a snide remarks luke..hmm..well we know. Anyhow why no action from Johnson? Is he hurt?
Brian Batko: Yeah, he probably had a little precautionary thing. No need to risk anything for that setting with a third-round pick.
Catamount: Berryman actually went to Western Carolina. So if you watch tape of the Leathernecks, you'll miss him. That said, he was kind of impressive statistically.
Brian Batko: Leathernecks > Catamounts, at least in terms of nicknames
stlrfan70: Dime LB? Barron, Marcus Allen, other?
Brian Batko: Probably Barron, an NFL veteran who's played different spots in his career
Sterling A: Any chance the near-lack of attention to the tight end position leads to Rosie Nix lining up at TE?
Brian Batko: That would surprise me.
Jeff: thanks for the chat. If you could give one piece of advice to Tomlin around changing the culture what would it be? Its clear his style of coaching led to many of the problems
Brian Batko: Yeah, I would tell him that if anything newsworthy is happening, feed the info to the fine beat reporters who write for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
pozone: Any FA names as you see affordable TE available for Steelers? Any word on Colbert staying after this year?
Brian Batko: Free-agent TEs out there you might've heard of include A.J. Derby, Levine Toilolo, MarQueis Gray and Antonio Gates. Couldn't tell you if they're affordable or not.
Justin: As a Steelers fan that has long attended these weekly chats, I for one would find myself more at home if you could ramp up your sarcasm and snarky replies like your predecessor. Jk. Thanks for insight into our Steelers!
Brian Batko: Man, I can't win here. I think I've been accused of being too snarky and not snarky enough today. Appreciate ya, Justin.
Define or Denial: Isn't Bush really a hybrid safety... especially in Tomlin's nickle & dime dream scheme?
Brian Batko: I think he's more of a pure inside linebacker than Mark Barron. But the beauty of him, and the reason you used such a high pick on him, is that he should be versatile enough to do all sorts of things and never leave the field.
Catamount: We hear about Smith, Johnson, Layne and obviously Bush, but did any of the other draft picks stand out a bit ... in a positive way?
Brian Batko: Ulysees Gilbert certainly looks athletic in shorts. Isaiah Buggs seemed quick for his size in pass-rush drills. Just very difficult to get much of a gauge on guys in that setting. Especially someone like Benny Snell, whose whole thing is running hard, being physical and thriving on contact.
Ralph LA: Before it broke into the open, was Antonio Brown’s behavior widely known among reporters that covered the team.
Brian Batko: Ah, I don't think so. But I'm not the best person to ask.
Silly in PHILLY: You don’t buy into the narrative that Steelers are better w/out LB and AB, right? They might be better on the life scale but not the playing field scale, agree?
Brian Batko: I can't imagine their receiving corps being better, no. But uh, backfield did just fine without Le'Veon a year ago. And defense has nothing to do with them.
Guest: Hey Brian! I feel like I’m the only one who thinks this team actually has potential to make a serious run for the SB. For a few reasons, the entire organization has learned from the errors of its ways (from Rooney to the ball boy), the cancers have left the locker room, and there is real talent, with a team concept approach ....thoughts?
Brian Batko: That stuff is all well and good, and I don't doubt that they have Super Bowl potential as long as they have an elite quarterback like they do, but you still need a lot to go right. There were 31 other teams also trying to get better this offseason, and believing that they did it. I see a team that could be anywhere from 1st to 3rd in its own division, depending on how the chips fall.
Glenn from Md: I am somewhat surprised that the Steelers are not looking at bringing in a veteran running back to compete for the back up role. Neither Samuels or Snell have a track record for running or blocking on the NFL and some veteran competition would be the prudent thing to do...what are your thoughts?? I would love to see a guy like Alfred Blue signed!!
Brian Batko: Don't think they need to go that route, Glenn. There's already only enough carries to go around for three promising young guys back there.
Dan Patterson : Brian, I feel James Washington will emerge as a target favorite for Big Ben! He was lights out in preseason and lost some confidence. Your thoughts?
Brian Batko: Think I said last chat or the week before that Washington is my pick to be the "breakout" player on this offense. I still believe.
JerseySteel: Hi Brian - any insight into why the Steelers seeming suddenly gave up on Keion Adams?
Brian Batko: Not particularly, other than injuries often derail or delay NFL journeys, and in this case he probably fell behind guys like Ola Adeniyi and now a higher draft pick in Sutton Smith. It is what it is.
Jim: Can't help but think if we hadn't wasted a pick on Rudolph last year and gone with a ILB or CB our D would be looking really good right now. Think Colbert is thinking the same?
Brian Batko: Nah, I think Rudolph was great value where they got him last draft, and the cornerback position got a much needed upgrade this offseason between signing Steve Nelson and drafting Justin Layne.
Wisconsin Winters: Brian, I re watched the Oakland Raiders game. Why such the visceral response to Josh Dobbs. 3 dropped passes. An interception that was tipped. He picked up first downs with his legs. Give him a week of prep I think he will surprise as a viable back up to Ben. I think many folks are hard on him based on the urgency of that moment? Thoughts?
Brian Batko: Possibly. I wasn't paying nearly as much attention to the Steelers as I was the Pitt Panthers this time last year, but there's a lot to like with Dobbs, generally. Don't think it's a huge gap between him and Mason Rudolph at this point, but I think there's a better chance that it's Rudolph who plays his way into backup status in the preseason given his physical tools.
Ike Steelheart: Hello Brian, I believe it was better for The Steelers to draft Devin Bush this year, than drafting an ILB last year, I call it Faith. Do you agree?
Brian Batko: Ehhh in a perfect world, you draft Darius Leonard last year and be happy to have the NFL DROY and an All-Pro guy on your squad.
kjacksonpgh: Dupree was paid handsomely on his 5th year option, but doesn't he need to show more to get a long term deal from the team?
Brian Batko: Let me think on that for a secYES
Addition by subtraction: If the O goes 3 & out... a lot... it might end up having a lot 'to do with' the D.
Brian Batko: Your point is noted for the chat record.
Stiller fan: Speaking of preseason... I actually get excited seeing the rookies, UFAs, and bubble players play, but agree that for most it's a waste of time (even for vets). What's your take on it?
Brian Batko: Haven't covered it yet, but can't imagine it's great. I'll let you know sometime in August, I guess.
Sam: Did you read the Ziese article regarding a Tomlin extension? I'm curious what your take is on the subject.
Brian Batko: Of course, I read everything my Steelers colleagues and our columnists write about the team. I certainly see Paul's point, but I'm also a big stability guy, so I don't think it'd be crazy to extend him now.
Dan Patterson : I think with free agency and the draft, we may have a better defense than many may anticipate. Week 1 against NE should give us a good idea. Do you agree?
Brian Batko: There could hardly be a better, or more fitting, challenge for this particular franchise.
Brian Batko: Well, OK, we'll end on that poetic note of the New England Patriots always looming large for the Steelers. This chat is over, but there will be another one next week at some point once OTAs begin.
I'll also begin a new feature on the site, a Steelers mailbag, where we can go a little more in-depth than the chat on questions and answers. You can send along questions to my email at bbatko@post-gazette.com or tweet/direct message me over there. Thanks, everyone.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.