Brian Batko: Praise you all for coming here. You could be anywhere in the world, but you're chatting with me. Steelers rookie camp begins Friday, so let's commence with the questions.

Emilio: Who is more hyped Bush or the Cleveland Browns?

Brian Batko: Devin Bush is but a man, so my vote is for the Cleveland Browns

FloridaSteelers: Brian, do you think the Steelers did enough in the draft to offset Brown & Bell & improve the defense?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: In the draft itself, I would say not necessarily. But the draft combined with free agency? Possibly. I thought the Donte Moncrief signing was fine, and I like the pick of Benny Snell. But replacing those guys you mention will be more about developing players already on the roster (the Jameses and Jaylen).

As for the defense, yeah, it might have to do more heavy lifting now with Brown and Bell gone, at least in the early going. But I think the outlook for this roster is still bright on paper.

Mike: When does Rookie camp start?

Brian Batko: Friday, ends Sunday. Workouts are open to the media Friday and Saturday, so we'll see what we'll see.

Heath Miller Fan: Brian, does DC Butler now have all the pieces to put a respectable on the field without the 4th quarter meltdowns? And does anyone know exactly what Tomlin actually brings to the defense? Thanks.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: As I said above, I liked the Steelers FA signings this offseason. Mark Barron is an interesting piece at inside linebacker, and Steven Nelson should be an upgrade at corner. However, I can't guarantee you that fourth-quarter meltdowns are a thing of the past.

SteelerInIowa: Will Mike Tomlin get an extension before the 2019 regular season kicks off?

Brian Batko: I'm saying ... yes.

Guest: Hi Brian, As it stands today all things being equal and as we all know the 'greatest' player in Steelers history is Mr. Greene. Who would you rate as the 2nd? I think he's on the team currently going into year 16. What say you?

Brian Batko: You won't get much of an argument there from me. Though I think No. 12 is still in that discussion, long as we're talking about QBs who led this franchise to Super Bowls, plural.

Advertise with us

Paul from Louisville : What is your general feeling about how the lockeroom or Coach Tomlin will be like after all the drama from Bell and Brown during the off-season?

Brian Batko: In general, I think "The Room" will be considerably more placid. Would have to be, right? I wasn't in there last year with Gerry and Ray, but from what I understand, Antonio Brown spoke with the media once a week and it was usually quite the scene. Not only are those two (very talented) distractions in new cities, but Joey Porter is no longer on the coaching staff, and he had some off-field stuff that players had to answer about in recent years as well.

Kris: With the addition of Devin Bush, a true 3-down linebacker in modern day's NFL, do you see Williams being the backer opposite on 1st and 2nd downs and Barron on 3rd downs and/or passing downs?

Brian Batko: That could happen, but it's too early to say for sure. When Mark Barron signed, he made it a point to say that he'll be a three-down linebacker for this team. But he also said he'll do whatever's asked of him, and that was before the Steelers traded a second-round pick to move up 10 spots and draft another similar ILB at No. 10 overall. A lot of flexibility there now in the linebacker corps, and that's probably the most important thing.

MD: I was surprised by the seeming lack of fan reaction to Ben's mega deal. Given the short duration of the deal, this is a very expensive contract. Russell Wilson's deal can at least be averaged out over time and an increasing cap. Did you expect Ben to offer at least some type of hometown discount?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: You know, I kind of did, but can't blame a guy for not doing so. Especially a quarterback, when the market at that position pretty much increases every year. I think there was a decent amount of fan reaction - I've heard people having conversations in public about whether it was a waste of money - but then again, it wasn't much of a surprise that they were going to get a deal done. Hard for any of us to know all the dynamics of those negotiations from the outside.

Chris: Were you surprised as much as I on Steelers 3rd round pick with Hakeem butler still on the board.

Brian Batko: I thought they might pull the trigger on Butler, the 6-6 guy from Iowa State, but hey, no one else picked him in the third either. It's clear now that the Steelers thought Diontae Johnson was a better fit for their offense, and a better player overall.

Rocky: Hi Brian, nice chat. Why do the Steelers always overlook the punting problem. I believe it could have easily been fixed had they drafted one in the 5th or 6th round. What is your opinion on the punting situation? Thanks.

Brian Batko: Thanks, Rock. I don't think anyone can blame the Steelers if they had bigger concerns this offseason after missing the playoffs with that much talent, but sure, I'll say that Jordan Berry doesn't inspire the utmost confidence. Then again, while you would've been pleased with getting a punter in the draft, many others would've been up in arms about using a pick on a special teams player.

Advertise with us

BatkoBrokeMyHeart: You stabbed me in the back

Brian Batko: I would never.

Stiller Fan: In your opinion if Tomlin was so high on Sills, why is he not on the team? Is he still available?

Brian Batko: David Sills, the former quarterback who played wideout at West Virginia? Uh, I don't know, because they were higher on Diontae Johnson, I reckon. Sills went undrafted and signed with Buffalo. Talkin' proud.

Ralph LA: Is there any more insight that you can give in Artie Burns’ problems? I thought that he did well as a rookie. What went wrong after that?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Publicly, the powers that be openly admit Artie Burns has confidence issues at this point. Can be tough to come back from that, in any walk of life.

Bob: They got a punter as a UDFA. Better than wasting a draft pick.

Brian Batko: There ya go, Rocky.

One Time Walk-on: Would signing former back-up Pitt long snapper who caught the TD pass vs. V-Tech solve the Steelers punting problem?

Brian Batko: Signing Nathan Bossory, Pitt legend, would help solve the punting problems, the tight end depth and give the Steelers a reliable backup quarterback. I'm on record here.

Advertise with us

Gary: After signing their draft choices, will the Steelers have enough money left to sign a veteran Safety or TE that will be released in the next couple of weeks or will they wait until final training camp cuts?

Brian Batko: I don't think they'll be in any hurry. At those spots, it might be helpful to wait and see what other guys around the league get cut due to number crunches at their positions, salary concerns, etc. Antonio Gates is available.

Desert steeler: Run pass ratio this year?

Brian Batko: Last year was 67 pass, 33 run. Not sure how sustainable that is. I'll say 66-34.

Dave From CA : Patriots and Jags will run right at us with their bigs and their power running game to exploit our smaller faster LB’s. Is Belichek one step ahead again ?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: He's five steps ahead!

Truth: I struggle with the Steelers coaches high opinion of Bud Dupree, as evidenced by their exercising his 5th year option at 9.2mm. At best he is a one-trick pony; line up outside, attempt to beat the tackle on the edge, get pushed easily out of the play, and repeat. It's like clockwork. What are they seeing I am missing?

Brian Batko: They see a guy who has the physical makeup to still be a stud, not a dud, and would rather his Steelers career not end with a thud. It's also tough to move on from a first-round pick if he's at all productive/promising enough. But as you can see with declining Artie Burns' 5th-year option, I think they're at that point with him.

NW Steeler Fan: Brian, Have you heard and indications of what the plans for TE are? Jaylan Samuels was used as a HB last year but was listed on the roster as a TE/HB. Any chance he goes to full time TE?

Brian Batko: No.

Advertise with us

Dewey: A Leopard does not change spots.........Do you think the lights are blinking for the Jets, now that Mr. Bell is exhibiting 'his work routine' for them? Add the lack of 'stats' A.B. will log without Ben tossing him the ball.....and all of a sudden the Steelers must look pretty smart, huh?

Brian Batko: I will let you know in January.

John: Brian, Bell no show for mini-camp and Brown not playing in Exhibition games. NFL teams be careful what you wish for ........ thank God they're not our problem anymore. Are you surprised ?

Brian Batko: Nah

Mike : Would the Steelers be interested in bringing in the te from the Vikings if he became available forgot his name Kyle r

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Imagine Mason Rudolph throwing touchdowns to Kyle Rudolph. That'd be wild, man. i think they'd also have to bring in wide receiver Travis Rudolph from the Dolphins.

Jake: What's the vibe around Steelers hq these days? Maybe a bit more focused/chip on the shoulder than previously?

Brian Batko: I don't know, I'm new here

Stiller Fan: Way too early super bowl prediction?

Brian Batko: It'll be played Feb. 2, 2020

Advertise with us

Lloyd's 3-Count: Think we'll see Jaylon Samuels line up as H-back in two-back set?

Brian Batko: Now that , I think, is a more intriguing Jaylen Samuels idea. He's too good a runner to totally phase out that part of his game, but I do see someone who's versatile enough to be used in some creative ways. If you have three capable backs in James Conner, Samuels and rookie Benny Snell, but maybe not enough at TE behind Vance McDonald, I'd try to get my best playmakers on the field.

RealityMan: Looking forward Davis is likely not the answer at safety. Any chance they try to go for Tre Boston? Young and proven, would add A lot to the D.

Brian Batko: I'm not a huge Sean Davis fan either, but I don't think they're ready to write him off just yet. Should be a good prove-it year for him in his second go-round at free safety. Is Tre Boston related to David Boston? That dude was jacked (and on steroids).

paul: Why are people so down on Mike Hilton, I feel he competes every game he is in? He may not be an all pro but valuable team player.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Not sure, Paul. I like what he brings. But if Justin Layne comes along quicker than expected as an outside corner, and Joe Haden continues to play well, maybe you can move Steven Nelson to the slot and have three really strong coverage guys. That's a big IF with Layne though.

Desert steeler: How do you decide what questions to answer?

Brian Batko: As soon as someone sends in a question, I write it down on a scrap of paper and throw it into a hat. Then I pick out of said hat.

JustAFan: Do you think Haden gets an extension it are they hoping Layne can take over for him eventually?

Brian Batko: Of course they're hoping Layne can take over, they used a third-round pick on him. But given his relative inexperience at corner (he started out as a WR at Michigan State) that might take longer than some of the other corner prospects they were looking at in this draft. Still a lot to like, though, with Layne's size, athleticism, ball skills.

Advertise with us

DAne: I'm not familiar with your work, have you been on the Steelers beat awhile for PG?

Brian Batko: Yeah it's been a while, about two weeks now.

pdxJaxon: so......obviously jumpin the gun a bit, but it looks like next year again, our top need in draft will be "Edge".

Brian Batko: It could be edge. It could be safety if Sean Davis' improvement is minimal. It could be OT if the Matt Feilers and BJ Finneys of the world aren't great there.

WaltInGA: Is Barron simply not big enough to stop the run?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: I wouldn't say that. He graded out really well as a run-stuffer a couple years ago with the Rams.

Jacque Strap: If you could be NFL Commish for a day, aside from enjoying that sweet, sweet salary, what is one rule change would you try to implement?

Brian Batko: I would rule that NFL wideouts only need one foot down for a reception. They already make absurd catches now, but imagine the types of grabs you'd see from Julio, Odell, Tony Toe-Tap if they truly only had to tap one toe!

Pete Benedict: bud Dupree is a joke, Rush outside, gets ridden outside, over and over and over

Brian Batko: I'll pass it along

guest: welcome to the steelers beat. What did you think of the steelers draft ? how many if any will be impact players in your opinion?

Brian Batko: Thank you, guest. I thought it was fine. To me, they nailed their first-rounder and were pretty much playing with house money beyond that. Diontae Johnson was off the radar, but seems solid. Justin Layne was on the radar, but you wonder why he slipped. The other guys? I don't feel too strongly one way or the other.

Lloyd's 3-Count: How realistic is the kicking competition going into this year? McCrane doesn't look like he can make much beyond 40 and kickoffs are short.

Brian Batko: Well, that all depends on whether Chris Boswell can get his own confidence back. I think the Steelers should send him and Artie Burns on a vision quest.

One Time Walk-on: Do you think Steelers fans drove AB and LB out of town by the predisposed notion/attitude that professional Pittsburgh athletes “owe” the city?

Brian Batko: No, because I think a lot of their issues stemmed more from what they owed their own teammates, especially by the end of it.

FoolBack: Brian, in your opinion, how long before the #84 is worn by another Steelers player?

Brian Batko: Interesting question. I'm not sure if giving out that number sooner rather than later would help or hinder the "moving on" process. But there are only so many jerseys to go around, so I'll say someone gets it this season, even if just a P squad guy.

CanadianSteelersFan : Do you view the first game at New England as a positive? I personally am glad to get it over with right off the bat. I’m tired of hearing talk about playing the Patriots in advance and looking past other teams. Plus I feel the first game of the year is really a toss up. Both teams will be still figuring everything out about their rosters.

Brian Batko: I don't think it's a positive. If anything, I think it makes it that much more difficult to beat the Patriots, who you were going to play at some point in 2019. To have that pomp and circumstance around the game, I don't think it helps the ol' Steelers.

Dave B: I know it's early, but do you think the Steelers will showcase Dobbs or Rudolph this preseason in hopes of trading one of them?

Brian Batko: "Showcase" is whatever, but sure, they're each going to play a lot. Not sure how much trade value either one would have, but seeing one or both of them play well in the exhibitions could only help matters.

Scott: Isn't saying "replacing Bell this season" a bit off? Guy didn't play at all last year. Replacing Brown is the big chested question mark.

Brian Batko: Yes, yes it is. If anything, JCon and JSam should feel even more comfortable without that story line looming this year.

Paul from Louisville : Steelers usually keep six defensive linemen...who do you think will make the last two spots given that Heyward, Tuitt, Hardgrave, and Alalahu are guaranteed?

Brian Batko: I guess at this point, PoL, I'd say Dan McCullers and Isaiah Buggs. But McCullers has to be nearing the end of his run here, and Buggs was only a sixth-round pick. Big thing for Buggs will be his versatility and whether he proves he's capable inside and outside on the line.

Desert steeler: Team chemistry better this year and why?

Brian Batko: Yes, because the players won't have to answer any questions about 26 or 84. Or at least not nearly as many.

TJ: Hi Brian, Guys give Dupree a break - we could do worse and if he ever turns it on could be a stud. Hopefully this is the year and Oli looks promision.

Brian Batko: There you have it.

Bud: Where would you rank the Steelers chances in the AFC going into the regular season?

Brian Batko: Always like their chances with Ben Roethlisberger under center, and I don't think there are too many obvious holes. That said, the schedule isn't easy. Patriots right away. At the Chargers. Rams and Seahawks, but those games are at home, and you have to go on the road to beat the two lesser teams in that division. Plus, I don't think the Browns hype is all that unfounded, mainly because I'm a Baker Mayfield buyer.

I could see this team taking the AFC North with a 10-win season, or even being an 8-8 outfit.

Brian Batko: OK folks, we'll end it on that big-picture prompt. Thanks once again for joining Round 2 of my now-weekly Steelers chat. Enjoy the rest of the week!