Not many people remember the Steelers’ draft of 2003 for getting a cornerback from a small Louisiana school named Ike Taylor in the fourth round or a backup quarterback named Brian St. Pierre in the fifth.

That’s because the most memorable aspect of that draft was the player they took with their first pick. And how they obtained him.

The Steelers traded with the Kansas City Chiefs to move up 11 spots in the draft to get safety Troy Polamalu, a player they felt could change the landscape of their defense and help them win a Super Bowl. They were right on both fronts.

Polamalu helped them win two Super Bowls — in 2005 and 2008 — on his way to becoming a future Hall of Famer. And he did it with spectacular, jaw-dropping plays, none more significant than the interception return for a touchdown that sealed their AFC championship game victory against the Baltimore Ravens in 2008.

Advertise with us

The Steelers drafted only five players in 2003 and just two of them — Polamalu and Taylor — became starters. But that draft will go down as one of their most memorable because of the player they took at the top and the manner in which they were able to attain him.

And so it is 16 years later with their 2019 draft class.

Nobody is going to bestow Polamalu-like status on Devin Bush, the Steelers’ No. 1 pick. Not yet, anyway. But he was obtained in the same manner — the Steelers moved up 10 spots in the draft to get him — for much the same reason as they got Polamalu: They were determined to get what they think is the missing piece in their defense.

If Bush becomes the difference-maker the Steelers believe, the 2019 draft class will be remembered in a similar vein for the dramatic move to get him. No matter what else happens with the other eight picks, the player at the top will define the success of this draft.

Here is a look at the nine draft choices with a corresponding grade, based on the roles they will play, the impact they could have, and how it may or may not have helped the Steelers.

Advertise with us

ILB Devin Bush — The Steelers hit a home run when they moved up 10 spots in the first round to get the Michigan linebacker and instantly repair the hole in the middle of their defense. That alone made the draft a success. Unlike last season, when the Steelers effectively did nothing to fix the biggest problem in their defense, they made sure to get one of the two players they wanted and not make the same mistake again. Bush checks every box of the type of player they have needed to replace Ryan Shazier. Grade: A+

WR Diontae Johnson — The Steelers had a first-round grade on Johnson and still got him in the third round, which makes the pick even more tantalizing. Johnson was the most underrated receiver in the draft and has a chance to be a reliable target for Ben Roethlisberger right away. That’s because he has a good understanding of route combinations and runs precise routes. Grade: A

CB Justin Layne — Layne is long (6-2, 192) and has good balls skills — he had 15 pass breakups last season at Michigan State — but he is not the type of player the Steelers needed to contribute immediately in their sub-package defenses. The Steelers needed a nickel back in the slot to challenge Mike Hilton, and Layne is not an inside-cover guy. And they did not take another defensive back in the draft. Grade: C

RB Benny Snell — The great nephew of former New York Jets running back Matt Snell, he is a Steelers-type of back — tough, hard-nosed, fighting for the extra yard. But the fourth round was a little high for a running back who is destined to be behind James Conner and Jaylen Samuels. It’s easy to like the player, just not where they addressed the position. Grade: B

TE Zach Gentry — Tight ends coach James Daniel pointed out after Gentry’s selection that Heath Miller was recruited to college as a quarterback, too. It wasn’t meant to compare Gentry to the Steelers’ all-time tight end reception leader as much to note that former quarterbacks typically have good hands and athleticism. Because of his size (6-8, 265), Gentry will be more like Matt Spaeth than Jesse James. He is not a good blocker, but neither was James. Grade: C

Advertise with us

OLB Sutton Smith — A converted defensive end, Smith might be one of those quiet surprises — if he can prove he can play against bigger, faster players. Smith could be another Tyler Matakevich — a disruptive tackle-machine who played against small-conference competition — but he merits a longer look because of the way he competed against offensive linemen who outweighed him by 60 to 70 pounds at Northern Illinois. Grade: C+

DT/DE Isaiah Buggs — It is one thing to do it in college, even at Alabama; it is another to do it against NFL offensive linemen. But, right now, Buggs makes the team. Yes, he has problems getting off blocks, but he is quicker and has more sideline-to-sideline in him than Tyson Alualu and/or L.T. Walton. He just has to prove it at training camp. Grade: B-

ILB Ulysees Gilbert III — This was just another attempt to find a special-teams player and the reason why the Steelers didn’t need nine draft choices. At best, Gilbert is destined for the practice squad, unless he proves to be a coverage demon on kicks and punts. The Steelers want to rebuild their coverage teams, which is the reason for these late-round picks. Grade: C-

T Derwin Gray — There is little room for an offensive lineman on the roster, especially a tackle who will be ompeting against a pair of former mid-round draft picks — Chuks Okorafor and Jerald Hawkins. Gray’s only hope will be if he can play guard, which is where he likely will be tried. Grade: C-

Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac

Advertise with us