Kevin Colbert talks about the upcoming 2019 NFL Draft

By Sunday morning, just hours after the NFL draft is completed, websites across the country will publish grades for each team’s draft class. It feeds the appetite for instant analysis for the country’s most ravenous fan base, but it’s an exercise in futility.

Drafts can’t properly be evaluated after one year, much less after a few hours. It takes four years at least to get a handle on the quality of a draft class. By then, it is apparent how many players will sign second contracts and which won’t be part of the long-term plans.

For Steelers general manager Kevin Colbert, the 2015 draft is now four years old, and it’s shaping up as one of the worst of his 20-year tenure.

Of the eight players selected, only first-round pick Bud Dupree is a starter. He is playing out the final year of his rookie contract with his status beyond this year uncertain. Only one other player — sixth-round pick and reserve outside linebacker Anthony Chickillo — has signed a second contract with the Steelers.

Advertise with us

In addition to Dupree and Chickillo, the 2015 draft class included cornerback Senquez Golson, receiver Sammie Coates, cornerback Doran Grant, tight end Jesse James, defensive lineman L.T. Walton and safety Gerod Holliman.

Golson and Holliman never played a down in the NFL, and Grant played in only four games. Their failures mean the Steelers are in the market for defensive backs in the early rounds of the draft again this year.

Coates, one of the few receivers selected by Colbert to fail, was traded for a seventh-round pick, and the Steelers decided not to re-sign Walton. James did sign a lucrative second contract with the Lions in March, but the Steelers viewed him as a backup and did not make a push to re-sign him.

Colbert said he judges draft classes first and foremost by the wins and losses the team accumulates, but he said picks in the first three rounds should be “significant players.” He calls picks in rounds 1-3 “premium” picks.

“Historically, 75 percent of the first-ballot Pro Bowlers are first-, second- and third-round [picks],” Colbert said. “So you should get those right. The higher you pick, the more you have to hold yourself accountable.”

Advertise with us

Daniel Jeremiah worked in the scouting department for the Eagles and Ravens before entering the television analysis business in 2013. When he worked for those teams, they had a rather simple way of judging their draft classes after four years.

“However many picks you have, I kind of look at a good draft is if you’ve got three starters from a draft class,” said Jeremiah, who is the lead draft analyst for the NFL Network. “I don’t care where they come — first round, seventh round, whatever, but you’d like to come away with three starters. Anything north of that was gravy.

“You kind of look at some of the teams that have been on runs — I go back and kind of look at that Seattle team — you put together a couple drafts where you get four starters back-to-back years, you’ve transformed your team. That’s a franchise-changing scenario if you can find four in a couple drafts. You look at the New Orleans Saints and the recent resurgence and the run they’ve been on, you can trace it back to having a draft where you hit on four — not only just four starters but four upper-echelon guys. Three is kind of the target, and you get more than that, you’ve got something special.”

Conversely, when draft classes produce fewer than two starters in consecutive years, that’s when general managers could be forced to sign more free agents to fill out the starting positions on their team. The preferred way of team-building for the Steelers is through the draft, but with Golson and Coates failing, Colbert had to sign three free agents in March to either fill starting positions or to provide quality depth at a position of need. Cornerback Steven Nelson signed the richest free-agent contract in franchise history, and receiver Donte Moncrief and linebacker Mark Barron also were signed.

In an ideal scenario, Golson and Coates would have been good enough to sign to second contracts, or at the very least they would have contributed more before leaving. Their failures had a direct effect on the way the Steelers approached free agency and how they’ll approach this draft. Colbert made it clear this week the free-agent signings won’t preclude him from selecting corners, receivers or linebackers in the draft.

Advertise with us

“We evaluate every draft, every draft pick, every position,” Colbert said. “We think we know why a player succeeded or failed over the history. We know what rounds we’ve been better in and what rounds we haven’t been. We look at that each year. When we get up to training camp that’s one of the sessions we go through as scouts. We evaluate everything we’ve done to this point. If there are some things we need to get better at, we focus on trying to get better at a certain position, at a certain pick, at a certain criteria. … There is so much that goes into how you come up with a final evaluation.”

The final evaluation of the 2015 class will not be kind. Most agree Colbert’s worst draft class came in 2008 when players such as Limas Sweed, Bruce Davis and Tony Hills were drafted. No one from the 2008 class signed a second contract with the Steelers, though first-round pick Rashard Mendenhall did rush for more than 3,500 yards and scored 31 touchdowns during his five seasons.

Fortunately for the Steelers, there have been many more successful drafts that have kept them a perennial contender in the AFC North. The 2017 draft class included T.J. Watt, JuJu Smith-Schuster and James Conner. All three made the Pro Bowl last season and figure to be prominent players for years to come. It’s early, but the 2017 class might someday rival Colbert’s 2002 and 2010 drafts, which are considered among his best.

Starting Thursday night, the Steelers could use another strong class to help limit the damage on the misses from 2015.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.

Advertise with us