How much are draft picks worth?
That question has been asked numerous times in recent weeks by Steelers fans who want to know what it will take to move up in the draft.
One Super Bowl-winning coach knows the answer: They’re worth their weight in gold if the right player is available.
The Steelers have traded up in the first round of the draft twice in their history, and the coach who helped them execute those deals would do them again in a heartbeat.
Former Steelers coach Bill Cowher was inside the Steelers’ war room in 2003 and 2006 when they gave up some valuable draft picks to acquire Troy Polamalu and Santonio Holmes, two players who helped the Steelers put the fifth and sixth Lombardi trophies in their showcase.
Cowher might know better than anyone what Steelers general manager Kevin Colbert is thinking as this year’s draft draws closer. Cowher worked with Colbert for seven years, and they won a Super Bowl together in 2006 with Polamalu as the centerpiece to a dominant defense.
Read More
Now Colbert and head coach Mike Tomlin are searching for the next Polamalu – a defensive playmaker who can lend speed, versatility and splash plays to a lagging defense.
Only the Steelers don’t need a safety this year. They need an inside linebacker to take the place of Ryan Shazier. Devin White of LSU or Devin Bush of Michigan, the top two inside linebackers coming out of college this year, are two players that have been linked to the Steelers for months, and it is widely assumed the Steelers are going to have to trade up to land one of them.
“I’ve seen them, but I’m sure I haven’t studied them like Mike and Kevin have,” said Cowher, who now works as an NFL analyst for CBS. “But they look like that player in the middle. They’re three-down players, they’re leaders. They played at a high level of college football. They can make an instant impact. The void of Ryan Shazier has yet to be filled.
“I certainly think they’re targeting a linebacker. It’s a question of how much do you have to give up to get there? It’ll be something they’ll entertain. When you get within 10 picks, that’s when you start to think about it. Need has to play into your decision-making. Taking best athlete is great if you don’t have needs. But sometimes need puts a greater value on players.”
Consulting the charts
When teams trade players, there is a basic understanding of the value being shipped out and the value that is returned. But draft picks are wild cards. Some will be stars, others busts and others somewhere in between.
To assess a baseline value for draft picks, Colbert and other general managers consult draft value charts and use them as a guide when making draft-day trades involving only draft choices. Every team has a different chart, but there are some basic similarities in all of them.

Every pick in the draft is assigned a value and the total compensation in any trade should come close to equaling the value of the pick that is acquired.
“Everyone uses their own [chart], and we understand that,” Colbert said at the NFL owners meetings last month. “When we are making a trade with a team, they may tell us it doesn’t match the value, and that is their decision. I think in any year that value is what you decide it to be. Someone may say, ‘We need this or it doesn’t match our chart,’ and so we may say we want to exceed those charts. We don’t know until we get moving on it.”
Draft value charts have been around the NFL for years, and they’ve been updated in recent years to take into account the salary cap and the rookie wage scale. Those developments have made draft picks even more valuable because young players on rookie contracts are cheap labor and valuable to general managers when constructing their 53-man rosters.
Rich Hill of PatsPulpit.com studied all draft-day trades since 2012 – the first year after the new collective bargaining agreement was ratified – and came up with a new chart that reflects the value based on all deals involving draft-day picks.
Using Hill’s chart, one can project the compensation needed to move up in the draft. For example, there has been speculation the Steelers might have to make a trade with the Broncos, who own the No. 10 pick, in order to secure White or Bush.
The Steelers likely would have to trade their first-round pick (No. 20), their early third (No. 66), their fourth (No. 123) and their seventh (No. 219) to get the 10th overall pick.
If White or Bush falls into the teens and the Steelers want to move up five spots to jump in front of Carolina, it likely would cost them their first-round pick (No. 20) and second third-round pick (No. 84) or their first, fourth (No. 123) and their fifth (141).
“Anytime you’re talking about trading draft picks I never just say ‘It’s a three and a six’ because that six might be Antonio Brown,” Colbert said. “Well, that seventh might have been Brett Keisel. So you never want to say ‘it’s just a pick.’ You try to associate a player you could get with those picks and you go back in history and look at what you got with certain picks. But then you also project who you might be turning away from in a given draft. This player would probably be a player we could get in each of those rounds so you have to try and equate and make the determination whether it would be beneficial or not.”
Super trade-ups
Trading up is a distinct possibility this year because, as Cowher noted, the Steelers have an obvious need for an inside linebacker.
The Steelers were in a similar situation last year. They had to replace Shazier, who was injured four months earlier, and were unwilling or unable to move up to secure Leighton Vander Esch or Rashaan Evans. Vander Esch went to Dallas at No. 19 and Evans at No. 22 to the Titans. The Steelers stayed at No. 30 and selected safety Terrell Edmunds.
And because they didn’t draft any inside linebackers in subsequent rounds, they will try to land one next week. Colbert could be more willing (desperate?) to make a move this year.
Colbert and Cowher know how big moves up in the draft can change the fortunes of a franchise.
In 2003, the Steelers gave up their first (No. 27), their third (No. 92) and a sixth (No. 200) to the Chiefs to move up 11 spots to No. 16. The Steelers selected Polamalu, who is expected to be inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame next year in his first year of eligibility. With the 27th pick, the Chiefs drafted running back Larry Johnson, who had a prolific but short career.
The Steelers gave up less value for what is suggested on the draft value charts and got a player that transformed their defense and helped them win two Super Bowls.
Cowher had worked previously for Chiefs coach Marty Schottenheimer and general manager Carl Peterson. It was Cowher who negotiated with Peterson in the hours leading up to the draft.
“We kind of started talking the day of the draft,” Cowher said. “Troy was a guy we thought, if he was there, we’d give up what we gave up. He was the one player who reminded me of Carnell Lake. A guy like Troy gave us so much more flexibility. He was a position-less player really, could play in the slot, could play deep. He was a special player.
“Carl thought we were taking Larry Johnson. That’s who he wanted. He wanted to know we weren’t picking an offensive player. And I told him. ‘I can guarantee you we aren’t taking an offensive player.’ He felt good that no one would take Larry after us. It kind of worked out. To get a player you wanted and knew he’d never make it to you, it was great.”
Three years later, the Steelers were in an entirely different situation. They were coming off their Super Bowl XL victory and had the final pick of the first round. They had a complete team they believed could compete for championships for years to come.
When Holmes was still available at No. 25, Colbert traded away No. 32, a third and a fourth to move up seven spots to get Holmes, who three years later would author one of the greatest catches in Super Bowl history to give the Steelers a 27-23 victory against the Cardinals in Super Bowl XLIII.

“We’re sitting there, picking last for all the right reasons, and you see the No. 1 receiver in the draft is still on the board,” Cowher said, laughing at the memory. “You have to seriously look at that. I don’t think it was our intention. When you get within 10 [picks] you start to think, ‘Wow we might be able to do this.’ What do we have to give up? Do we take this guy? Get Ben [Roethlisberger] another weapon? That just seemed like a no-brainer. This football team was young and solid in every area. You have to do it. After Ben was drafted, we gave him Heath Miller and then Holmes. We were trying to give him all the weapons he needed.”
The draft value charts suggested the Steelers gave up too much to move up seven spots to draft Holmes, but Colbert never thinks that as he walks past Lombardi No. 6 on his way into his office every day.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.