Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Post your questions and we'll get started.
Pete: Who do you pick at 20: Greedy Williams, Deandre Baker, or Byron Murphy?
Ray Fittipaldo: If I'm the GM I go with Byron Murphy. He has ball skills so he can help with turnovers. He comes up and hits in run support, which is always important for the Steelers. He's not real big and he only ran a 4.55 at the combine so there are some concerns. But he'd be my choice. Greedy has everything you look for in a CB -- height, athleticism and he has ball skills too. Questions about his consistency so I'd take him next and then Backer third.
Professor Flush: Is there a bigger need to draft a blocking TE or a pass catching TE with some speed? Are they looking to improve from Grimble and the loss of James in free agency?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. There are not any indications thus far that the offense will undergo a major change this offseason. Of course what they do in the draft will foreshadow any possible changes. It would be nice if they got a good blocking TE, but they're hard to come by these days in the draft. The colleges just don't produce them much anymore. They use two TE sets a lot so my guess is it will be a pass-catching TE with some blocking skills. The only dominant blocker in this draft is TJ Hockenson, and he's likely to be gone by the time the Steelers pick in the first round.
BlackJack Bill: Is it time to ditch the 3/4 defense and play a 4/3 on first and second down? Your thoughts would be appreciated!
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: They've drafted the past few years as if they're planning to stick with it for a while as their base defense. You have pure OLBs like Dupree and Watt getting drafted in the first round. But as most know, they play 4-3 in sub-packages quite a bit so they have some 4-3 personnel and will continue to draft with that in mind.
HokeyPokey Bar: Who is the one player in the upcoming draft who is rocketing up the boards due to his combine or pro day workouts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Devin Bush for one. He was a late first or early second round pick at the beginning of the process and now he's being mentioned in the top half of the first round. Running a 4.43 as an ILB will do that. Devin White of LSU ran 4.42. That time seemed to solidify him as a top 10 pick. But he already was being mentioned as one of the top defenders in this draft.
john: Why do the Steeler's not have projected top picks come in for visits?
Ray Fittipaldo: They meet with many of their first-round targets at their pro days. But they did have Byron Murphy and DeAndre Baker in for visits. They're both projected as first-round CBs.
TXSTEELER : Faneca and other vets were critical of MT when he 1st arrived due to how hard/strict he was. When/why did that change? Bee asking for weeks, please answer now that the Brown/Bell stuff has passed.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if there is a time I can pinpoint, but Tomlin himself acknowledges he treats star players differently than others. He doesn't apologize for it. But perhaps it's time for him to make some changes in that regard. If he does it will be fun to watch if he can jam the toothpaste back into the tube, so to speak.
Rich: Ray thanks for all of your work. I think a lot of us are still scratching our heads over Boz 2018?? Can you clarify.. was he hurt, did he just snap mentally, or both?
Ray Fittipaldo: Only hurt at the end. He injured himself pregame in New Orleans. He kicked in that game but did not in the finale versus the Bengals. No other injuries that I am aware of. He just had an off year. A very off year.
Professor Flush: Are there any current Steeler practice squad players who might earn a spot on the final 53 man roster this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe Lavon Hooks and maybe Bucky Hodges. Hooks is a DL who has been around for a while. They need a sixth DL after not bringing LT Walton back. Also depends on what they do in the draft. They could draft a DL. Hodges is a TE who runs pretty well. Also depends on if they draft a TE. I might be missing someone, but that's it off the top of my head.
AL456: Hey Ray, I know the priority is on getting one of the top ILB’s, but with our schedule and considering the slot WR’s we’ll be going up against this year, I would put a similar if not higher priority on getting a taller, better coverage Nickel-back. Do you know if the Steelers have eyes on any CB’s in the draft to directly fill that role? Who would be your pick?
Ray Fittipaldo: Sure. Just take a look at the prospects that have come through for predraft visits. It's heavy on versatile DBs -- players that can play CB and S. They really like Darnell Savage of Maryland. He was in for a visit. They've also had Justin Layne come through and Sean Bunting too.
DaquidoBazzini: Hi Ray - If both Devins are gone when the Steelers pick at #20....
And the Steelers plan to sign CB Joe Haden to an extension....Doesn’t it make sense that they then go WR (where there is a lot of talent)?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure the value will be there for a WR at No. 20 unless there is someone they absolutely love there. This draft is deep for WRs in the second round and after. I've seen some analysts say there might only be one WR taken in the first round. That's not to say it's a bad WR class, maybe just not heavy at the top with elite talents. I'm guessing second or third round for a WR.
Andy: Greetings Ray. I believe the FA signings this year are much more solid compared to last year. I think Barron and Moncrief are good fits and will do nicely (especially Moncrief having a HOF QB throwing passes to him). That all being said, do you think Bush is worth what it would take to move up the draft board to get him?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they might do it for a couple of reasons. There is a big dropoff from Bush and White to the next ILB -- Mack Wilson, who might not get taken until the third round. So if you;re going to get an impact ILB in this draft you might have to pull the trigger on a trade. Plus, I think Bush is a player who can help the Steelers. He might be small, but he can run from sideline to sideline and he's good in coverage.
DeepWaterLife: odd we can get hock at 20? or nasir adderley in top 2 rounds? or a decent edge rusher/ola stepping up to replace bum dupree?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Hockenson will be gone by 20. He's a really good all-around TE. They've been looking at mid-round OLBs in the predraft process. Doesn't mean they won't draft one higher, but most of the players that have come through have been mid-round prospects.
DatBoiGood1: With the draft about a week away, who is your Top 3 choices for Rd 1? Mine are 1. Devin Bush 2. Byron Murphy 3. DeAndre Baker
Ray Fittipaldo: I like your first two choices. I'm not as high on Baker as some others. But as I noted earlier they had him in for a visit so it appears they are doing their homework on him.
Chuck_in_DC: Ray... I have to get up at 5:00 a.m. everyday... Do you think it will be worth waiting up until the Steelers make their 1st pick? LOL
Ray Fittipaldo: Sure, it'll come earlier this year because they're drafting at 20. Maybe by 9:45 or 10.
MTScott: How much would you give up to move up in the draft to get Devin Bush?
Ray Fittipaldo: Honestly, it depends on how the draft unfolds. The Steelers won't know that until they see what happens in the first 9 or 10 picks. Some have speculated they might have to get to 10 to get Bush. Others say the teens. And still in other mock drafts there are some who believe he'll be there at 20 and they won't have to trade up at all to get him.
Mark from Hampton: Do you see any scenario where they use Josh Dobbs as a slash player this year? He looks like he could fit in as a wideout
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't have the same feeling. That's a hard no for me.
Jason in Slippery Rock: What's with all the pre-draft RB visits?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. I'm going to write about that later in the week. Lots of guys in the second-fourth-round range too. Doesn't mean they will draft an RB that high, but it sure seems like a possibility now.
Brody 43: With the addition of Donte Moncrief, WR shouldn't be as big a priority in the draft. Do you think that he could be a good fit as a Number 2 ? Or, should we expect Washington to make the next step?
Ray Fittipaldo: I expect Washington to take the next step. I think Moncrief will compete to be a No. 3 or 4 WR depending upon what happens in the draft.
Ken Ward: Do you think the Steelers feel comfortable with their FA upgrades to the point where they will pick a TE or WR with the 20th pick, or BPA? thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: I think a WR is in play at 20 but not likely. Unlikely for a TE unless Hockenson somehow falls into their lap.
CanadianSteelersFan : Do you really feel as though our need at WR is as great as most believe? I know we lost one of the best in AB, but with JUJU and James on the outside and Rodgers/Switzer in the slot I feel like we’re in good shape. Plus factor in the Moncrief signing and the WR room is looking pretty crowded right now. I would think a WR drafted before the 3rd round would be a wasted pick.
Ray Fittipaldo: Nothing against Washington and Moncrief, but have either proved capable of being a No. 2 in this league? I think they are hoping Washington does that this year, but he had a very rocky rookie year. You can't count on him. They almost have to take a WR in the first three rounds if the value is there.
tom: thoughts on Ed leaving?
Ray Fittipaldo: Ed probably did more for me than anyone at the P-G. He fought for me to be added as a third Steelers writer five or six years ago. He asked the editors to being me on. They listened to him, and it's been a great move for me. Listen, it's a great move for Ed and it's great for me. I get to have more of a voice in the P-G's Steelers coverage.
Ray Fittipaldo: Bring me on...
Mike: What is the likelihood the Steelers leverage picks to move up in the draft?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they'll investigate moving up thoroughly.
TC in Big D: I keep hearing mocks with the Steelers taking Marquise Brown. Please tell me that there is 0% chance that we pick Antonio Brown's cousin. Please put our minds at ease. Could they pick him?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think they will, but they did meet with him at the combine.
Bones: Is there someone in this draft that may drop to us at No.20 that the Steelers never thought would be possible, like DeCastro did? Maybe TJ Hockenson? Who would you like to see in this scenario magically drop to us?
Ray Fittipaldo: If Hockenson somehow fell to 20 they would have to consider him. He's like Heath Miller. He'll be your starting TE for the next decade and he'd start right away. That'd make Vance McDonald a very expensive No. 2, but they do use two TE sets a lot so it wouldn't be like they'd be wasting money.
Guest: Do you think there’s a chance we could move back a few spots in round 1 and pick up another 3rd round pick. Obviously we won’t use all ten picks, I expect the Steelers to do a lot of wheeling and dealing. Thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: They'd have to have a detailed plan because as you mentioned they already have 10 picks. So they'd have to have some things lined up with teams beforehand. This is a deep draft at several positions so there is value in those middle rounds. That's why I don't discount it completely. It's just going to be hard with all those picks already in the hopper.
CJ : If JuJu gets hurt the Steelers are screwed. Should they double dip at WR in this years draft?
Ray Fittipaldo: They'll definitely take one. I'd be surprised with a second WR unless it was in the sixth or seventh round.
Peasant 1963: Would or should, iyo, the Steelers consider Haskins if he is there when they pin rd. #1
Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah because they should draft a QB three years in a row.
Kalamazoo Dave: Do you think the Steelers should consider taking a punter in Round 6 or 7 - appears to be two good punters available?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'd be OK with that if they addressed their immediate needs by that point.
DeepWaterLife: tj hock or nasir adderley who has more value at 1:20
Ray Fittipaldo: Hockenson by far.
CJ : Murphy or Hock at 20 if both are there?
Ray Fittipaldo: Now that's a good one. Hockenson is almost a sure thing. Not flashy, but he's not going to disappoint. Murphy... the only thing I question is his athletic profile. He's not big and he's not super fast. I love his production. I love his tape. I just wonder about guarding elite WRs at the NFL level week in and week. But I like him best of all the CBs.
Guest: Knowing how Bruce Arians is still bitter about his "retirement" from Steelers, would he purposely draft Devin White at #5 to help prevent Steelers from getting Bush? ILB is a moderate need for the Bucs.
Ray Fittipaldo: Bruce will draft the best player for the Bucs. He doesn't care about what the Steelers might do 15 picks later.
CJ : The Steelers were way ahead of the game when they selected Shazier. They saw the evolution of smaller faster ILBs being more valuable in today’s game. Makes it all the more frustrating that they are in the position they are today chasing one. Do you think that plays into them possibilities doing whatever it takes to get Bush?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I think it's a factor. Now whatever it takes is a pretty broad statement. I don't think they'll do whatever it takes, but I think they'll look hard at trading up if it comes to that.
Ryno: Which position do you think would be a bigger asset for the defense; ILB, or CB?
Ray Fittipaldo: Both, but if I had to pick one as a bigger priority it's ILB because they signed Steven Nelson in free agency.
SteelersVAfan: Ray, as I recall the Steelers were high on Sean Davis playing FS his rookie year. I believe the ProFF nerds indicated the same. Now they may let him walk after his rookie contract is up. What happened? Slow decline? No development? Lack of splash plays? Other? Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: He's played almost everywhere in the secondary and hasn't really found a home. If you recall, Artie Burns was injured during their rookie camp in 2016 so Davis started the season as the slot CB. Then, in the middle of the season, they moved him to strong safety. Then they moved him to free before last season. It's an interesting evaluation for Colbert and his staff. Davis hasn't really done much to earn a second contract, but it's not like he's been given an opportunity to settle at one position. Let's see what they do this summer. Obviously, if they draft a safety high it won't be a good sign for him.
Les Lee: Ray, everybody keeps saying that Moncrief will have a great year for the Steelers because he will now have a HOF QB trowing to him. Didn't Moncrief start his career with Andrew Luck? I think Luck is just as good as Ben?
Ray Fittipaldo: He did, but he didn't get to play all that much with him. Luck was injured for much of Moncrief's tenure in Indy. When Luck was playing I think Moncrief put up decent numbers.
Utah Jim: Is this a make or break year for Tuitt? He hasn’t done much since signed the big contract albeit he’s been injured.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah that's a good call. They're certainly expecting more from someone that's making $12 million a year.
David Little : Sean Davis is just another guy in my opinion. Time to get a ball hawk back there! How do the Steelers feel about him?
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll find out soon. Like I said, if they draft one in the first three rounds it's probably not a good sign for him. But we'll know for sure when the season starts. If he's unsigned by game 1 they're willing to let him walk. They sign players they want to keep before the season begins.
Guest: I worry that Hakeem Butler has Limas Sweed potential. Lots of varying opinions of him. Would you be upset if they drafted him at #20 ?
Ray Fittipaldo: I like Hakeem Butler. Not sure if I like him at 20. Drops were a problem in college. But he does have the size, speed and playmaking ability to make him a coveted player. I'd love him at 52.
Skot: Not much noise about the need at OLB. With only one legitimate long-term starter on the roster (Watt) and the Barron signing, would you be surprised to see the Steelers pick OLB in the first? I'm not hearing much about that position and the talent available in the draft.
Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't be totally surprised. I mocked Brian Burns to them at 20 in my most recent mock draft. I still think ILB and CB are bigger needs, but we all know there is some uncertainty with Dupree and his long-term status.
Jack 58: Belichick would cut or already have cut Bust DuPree. Belichick would sign DuPree if the Steelers cut him. Can both be true?
Ray Fittipaldo: Probably.
Jack 58: D.K. Metcalf is a 1 trick pony, bulky physique, neck injury... yet some covet him for the first Steeler pick... please say no...
Ray Fittipaldo: He has all the tools to be a No. 1 WR. But there are concerns about his injury history. And yes, he is unusually muscular for a WR.
Peasant 1963: Equating Haskins to Dobbs and Rudolph is a bit sophomoric of a quip, Ray.
Ray Fittipaldo: They're not drafting a QB. Their plan is to extend Ben. And they have Dobbs and Rudolph as young backups. Where exactly would Dwayne Haskins fit in?
Phil-nj: Best guess as to starting WR game one: Ju Ju, Montcrief, Washington or Ju Ju, Montcrief, daft pick?
Ray Fittipaldo: How about JuJu, Washington, draft pick?
Joe: Why were they willing to pay dupree 9 million this year
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin likes Dupree. Thinks there is untapped potential there.
James: Given the number of RBs being brought in for visits, I have to think that the Steelers are not as comfortable with their depth chart at the position as some in the media are. Personally, I have concerns about Conner's durability and, I know many Steeler fans do not like to hear this, his overall ability. I think he benefitted greatly by running behind this OL and having Ben and AB in the same offense. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: I am a bit surprised by the number of RBs that have been in for visits. But remember, just because they visit doesn't mean they'll draft one. I think they had 10 or 11 ILBs in for visits last year and didn't draft one.
Les Lee: I keep hearing that the Jets are wanting to trade Darron Lee. I was able to follow Darron during his college career and he was very good at Ohio State. He seems to be a good fit for the Steelers. Do you think Darron would be worth the Steelers trading for if they could get him for a 5th round pick or higher?
Ray Fittipaldo: I have to be honest it's been a while since I've watched Darron Lee play. But to play along, if White and Bush are gone and the Steelers don't like any other ILBs then maybe they'd trade a late pick for him. I just haven't heard any buzz to suggest it's a possibility.
Sydney: No way they paid that much to Moncrief to be a number 3 received right?
Ray Fittipaldo: He's not making that much money. He'll be in the top 4
rman: Anybody ever do a study regarding Steeler draft visits in regards to actual draft picks?
Ray Fittipaldo: Coming up later in the week.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for all the questions this week. We'll do it again next week. Kevin Colbert will have his draft news conference next Monday so stay tuned for a time or day switch with this chat.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.