Eighth in an offseason series breaking the Steelers down by position:

Safeties are all the rage again in the NFL. Just look at some of the free-agent contracts that were doled out in March.

Landon Collins agreed to a six-year, $84 million contract with the Redskins. Earl Thomas signed a four-year, $55 million deal with the Ravens, and Tyrann Mathieu inked a three-year, $42 million deal with the Chiefs.

One year after safeties were low-balled in free agency, they’re back among the top earners again. The reason is simple: NFL coaches covet versatile players who can play the run and the pass with equal effectiveness. And the good ones command top dollar.

Advertise with us

The Steelers have tried in recent years to find safeties capable of bolstering a leaky pass defense. They used a second-round pick on Sean Davis in 2016, and last year signed Morgan Burnett as a free agent and used their first-round pick on Terrell Edmunds.

But as the Steelers prepare for the 2019 season, they still have questions aplenty about their safeties.

Burnett was released Monday two months after he made it known he was unhappy with his role, and Davis is entering the final year of his rookie contract. Of the three safeties who played significant roles in the defense last season, only Edmunds is assured of being part of the Steelers’ long-term plans.

The Steelers have used Davis nearly everywhere in the secondary. As a rookie, he played slot corner and strong safety. He played strictly strong safety in 2017. Last season he made the move to free safety because the coaches believed that would be his best position.

Davis didn’t have a terrible year, but he didn’t produce the turnovers the Steelers expect from a free safety. He had one interception and has just five picks, one forced fumble and one fumble recovery in his first three NFL seasons. Those are not statistics that scream for a lucrative second contract.

Advertise with us

The Steelers usually like to extend young players they want to keep before the start of their fourth season, so it will be interesting to see how the front office feels about him. With GM Kevin Colbert saying in February the Steelers are going to value turnovers in their evaluations of defensive backs, it appears Davis must prove he can do more before the Steelers commit to him long term.

Davis is an interesting evaluation for Colbert and his staff. On the one hand, he’s been asked to play three positions and has never had a home. On the other hand, he’s never played well enough at any of those positions to stake a claim.

It’s early to make proclamations about Edmunds, but the Steelers believe he can blossom in their system. He was a surprise first-round pick last year, but he performed well as a rookie. He impressed the coaches with his ability to comprehend the defense in training camp and ended up playing in all 16 games, with 15 starts. He finished his first NFL season with 78 tackles, one interception and one sack.

The Steelers didn’t expect Edmunds to play that much. The original plan was for Edmunds to be a backup to Burnett at strong safety and play dime linebacker in sub-packages. But when Burnett missed most of camp with an injury, it opened the door for Edmunds to work his way into the lineup.

Even when Burnett returned to full health in the middle of the season the Steelers believed they were better off with a rookie at strong safety rather than Burnett. That speaks volumes for what they think of Edmunds as well as their lack of confidence in Burnett’s ability to stay on the field.

Advertise with us

Edmunds should be much better in his second season after learning on the job as a rookie.

With little experienced depth behind Edmunds and Davis — not to mention the uncertainty of Davis’ long-term future with the team — the Steelers are in the market for a safety in the draft later this month. In particular, they are looking for a safety that can run and keep up with receivers and running backs. That’s one of the reasons the Steelers moved on from Burnett. They want to get faster at every level of their defense, but especially in the back end.

This is not a strong safety class at the top of the draft, but there is some quality depth in the second round and after.

Defensive coordinator Keith Butler received criticism late in the season for having linebackers covering receivers. The lack of depth at safety was one reason Butler was forced to have his linebackers play in coverage so often. The Steelers attempted to fix that problem by signing linebacker Mark Barron, a former safety who played in a hybrid role for the Rams. He’ll certainly help, but the fact remain the safeties on the 90-man roster aren’t known for their pass defense.

Marcus Allen, a fifth-round pick last year, played sparingly as a rookie and the jury remains out on him. Jordan Dangerfield is known more for his special-teams abilities and being a box safety rather than a strong pass defender.

Advertise with us

If the Steelers add a safety in the draft, expect the player to have skills as a pass defender and, preferably, a history of producing turnovers.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.


Steelers safeties

Terrell Edmunds – Year acquired: 2018 draft, first round; School: Virginia Tech; Signed through: 2021 (club has option for 2022)

Sean Davis – Year acquired: 2016 draft, second round; Maryland; Signed through 2019

Advertise with us

Marcus Allen – Year acquired: 2018 draft, fifth round; Penn State; Signed through 2021

Jordan Dangerfield – Year acquired: 2014, free agent; Towson; Signed through 2019

Top five safety prospects according to nfldraftscout.com

• Deionte Thompson, Alabama Junior

• Nasir Adderley, Delaware, Senior

Advertise with us

• Taylor Rapp, Washington, Junior

• Chauncey Gardner-Johnson, Florida, Junior

• Amani Hooker, Iowa, Junior