Ed Bouchette: Good afternoon, let's begin

Steeltowntim@aol.com: Ed, Would you trade Brown for San Fran's fourth and our first? Would moving up that high negate our first rounder? Or maybe our second rounder?

Ed Bouchette: Yes, I would but the 49ers would not make that deal. I'm not sure what you mean by "negate." If you make that trade, you have the 4th overall pick but not the 20th, that's all. Still, a fantasy

Shades of Dennis Rodman: Do we know if Brown agreed not to further sabotage his trade value to the Steelers?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Not sure he can damage it much more than he already has

"Mr. Big Chest" VIA Burfict Inc.: Speaking of the Scouting Department, any particular Scout on the "outs" (on performance or lack of talent discovery) with management, do you suspect?

Ed Bouchette: Not that I'm aware of. The Steelers don't change scouts very often, usually only when one leaves on his own for another job or a promotion.

Manny: Ed, Can't trade Brown for Peanuts, at least a high second like SF 36th, if not sit him or suspend if need be if bad behavior occurs.. Why give him what he wants? We need good return this is business period. What say U? thanks

Ed Bouchette: He won't be back. It's just a matter of what the Steelers can now get for him. Sit him? Pay him $15 million this year to sit? And suspending him is not that easy.

Advertise with us

FloridaSteelers: Ed, talk me off this ledge please. Why would Art have a picture taken with this bozo? What is the franchise coming to?

Ed Bouchette: Proof they met?

WeegieT: Ed, does the cap money gained from Shazier and Bell negated by AB's signing bonus?

Ed Bouchette: There is no cap money "gained" from Ryan Shazier. His contract ran out, although it can be "tolled" at much less for 2019

Eric: Why can't team restructure AB's contract now so its not a 21mil hit to move him. Why not put the ball in his court and prove how bad he wants out....and thats in his pocketbook. Put up or shut up.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Sure, he'd agree to that.

"Mr. Big Chest" VIA Burfict Inc.: Fitipaldo rendered his first Mock Draft of the year - When's yours - after the Combine, perhaps?

Ed Bouchette: I do one, the week of the real draft.

Mitchburgh: At what point do we need to address the scouts in regards to all the misses at DB and LB’s? Also, in regards to that, would we be better off getting a Corner through Free agency? Thanks!

Ed Bouchette: I don't know that you can find a good corner in free agency. Better to fill in with a wide receiver in free agency and draft them. If you want to address the Steelers scouts, send it to them at 3400 Water Street, Pittsbugh, Pa. 15203

Advertise with us

Eric: Will Steelers kick themselves if they dont tag L.Bell and he signs for a lesser deal. Say 10mil per.....it might be what the market is willing to pay.

Ed Bouchette: The Steelers are as done with Le'Veon Bell as they are with Antonio Brown, although they still might tag him to try to get something for him, which I think is foolish

Franco: Hello Ed, based on the news about Brown and Mr. Rooney, are the Steelers finally headed on the right path?

Ed Bouchette: It's a start

"Mr. Big Chest" VIA Burfict Inc.: Ed, do any of your articles also get published or picked up by the Toledo Blade, as well?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Once in awhile, I believe

Bellgone19: Do you think the Steelers would use the transition tag just to keep Bell from signing with the Ravens who are in need of a RB?

Ed Bouchette: I suppose, but what I don't get is what if he then signs with them? Do they match it and try to trade him elsewhere?

JBOD : Since it’s a certainty AB will be traded, do Steelers replace him this year in free agency and also draft another WR this year?

Ed Bouchette: That is what I would do. Fill in with a veteran UFA to go with JuJu, Washington, Ryan Switzer and maybe Eli Rogers. You can draft one too but no need to go high

Advertise with us

Bud: Hi Ed. Is the idea of putting a transition tag on Bell, the hope to trade him for more than they would receive as a comp. pick? And if they do that, would you expect them to be really taking a gamble doing that?

Ed Bouchette: Yes, I think it is a gamble. I wrote an entire story about it recently that is still on our website.

AugustWest: Your reaction to AB’s comments about Ben having an “owner mentality.” Is this the opinion of one disgruntled diva or is the star QB disliked by a chunk of his own locker room? He hasn’t exactly won a lot of team MVP awards despite being their best player for more than a dozen years.

Ed Bouchette: Mr. Big Chest has made so many ridiculous statements lately and others that are not decipherable that there's no sense in ME trying to explain it.

Calexico: Ed. At least to the public eye, AB went from normal to lunatic in a second. I seriously think CTE may have something to do with it. Is that nonsense?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Thank you, Dr. Calexico

Tom in Maryland: With Antonio Brown all but gone, do the Steelers have the luxury of rostering DHB another year? Wouldn't that roster slot be better served with someone who can play more than special teams?

Ed Bouchette: Yes, provided they can find one

Alabama Steeler Fan: Ed, Love the chats. As we sit here today, your best guess as to what the Steelers get for AB in a trade

Ed Bouchette: I don't think they can get a first rounder. I do think maybe a second or third. If Martavis Bryant could fetch a third with all his baggage, Brown should at least be worth that to someone

Advertise with us

Daniel: What message would it send to the rest of the league if the Steelers won the SB next year without Bell & Brown?

Ed Bouchette: The Patriots did it this year without either of them.

International steeler: Bryant and mike Wallace are free agents why not bring them back

Ed Bouchette: Are you masquerading as Mr. Big Chest?

Guest: Was there any chance going into this meeting between Art Rooney and Antonio Brown that Brown's relationship with the team might be salvaged? Or was this basically an exit interview?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Sounds like an exit interview. Notice the coach did not attend.

AB Fan: Ed, are you personal issues with AB getting in the way of your strong anti-AB opinions and related propaganda???

Ed Bouchette: I have no personal issues with Antonio Brown. He called me a name in training camp, later apologized to me in person. I've written facts and analysis on him lately, in particular that the Steelers needed to trade him. Now it looks as though they will.

Hickster: AB is now demanding more guaranteed money. Who would want him knowing he might sit on team he’s traded to

Ed Bouchette: No one is going to sign him to a new contract that guarantees him anything. Not unless they are insane.

Advertise with us

ALB: Have you watched any of the Alliance games? The quality of play actually isn't bad, but its funny how crowds of about 5000 are made to sound like 50,000.

Ed Bouchette: I glanced quickly at one on the first weekend. That was enough. I don't watch all football just for the sake of watching football.

Sean: Do you think Brown is purposely trying to tank his trade value so the Steelers will be forced to release him? He's talking like he's a free agent, not someone under contract for 3 more years.

Ed Bouchette: As I've written, the Steelers won't be forced to release him. At the very least, they could trade him for a conditional 7th round pick in 2020 to make sure they send him where they want and he is not free to sign anywhere.

AugustWest: Which of their own free-agents do you think the Steelers will re-sign?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I don't think too many. I'd sign Chickillo if his price is right. I'd also try to sign Ramon Foster to a 1 or 2-year deal, but he may find something better.

Stillers in Philly: Looking ahead, how do you see the franchise replacing the void that #84 leaves?

Ed Bouchette: Players leave all the time. Sign a vet UFA as I mentioned earlier and draft one. You can still win without Antonio Brown.

Tom in Maryland: Ed, you've covered the team a long time. When did the "Steeler Way" become more myth than reality?

Ed Bouchette: It's gone a bit off track the past few years. They now have a chance to head it back in the right direction

Advertise with us

Bobby: Do you see the Steelers getting an unproven WR in the draft or signing a veteran in free agency?

Ed Bouchette: Both

ALB: How much do teams rely on the recommendations of college coaches when scouting players?

Ed Bouchette: If they know the coach and trust him, they will lean on him for the intangible things, character, etc.

"Mr. Big Chest" VIA Burfict Inc.: Ed, any chance (in your opinion) that the "21st Century Pro Athlete" is just more prone or even acclimated to becoming a "prima donna" than in the past? Expect it to just get worse with ensuing generations?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Don't paint them all based on a few

AugustWest: The Rams made the Super Bowl with a grossly overweight C.J. Anderson taking carries from Todd Gurley. How does that affect Bell’s market value?

Ed Bouchette: I would think it doesn't enhance it.

Dr. Phill: Ed, Your take on how Art II has handled things? I think his Dad and Grand Dad would not be pleased. Didn't time but respect is respect and starts at the top. Thank you.

Ed Bouchette: Both previous presidents had many issues to deal with. Different, but it wasn't all smooth sailing.

Advertise with us

Nate L: What are your thoughts on Tomlin changing or not changing his coaching style with respect to toleration for future AB-like behavior? Think he stays the course? Kinda hard to change coaching style 12 years in right?

Ed Bouchette: I've seen Mike learn from the past, so Antonio Brown may have brought a lesson that he will embrace.

Mtsteel: Ed, thanks for your time. I really feel the Steelers get robbed if the accept anything less than a 2 for AB. I know all the talk, hes this and that. Ok so trade him but dont let all the talk devalue his production. Hes not career criminal, hes a future HOF WR and a Diva Thoughts and thanks

Ed Bouchette: You cannot bring Antonio Brown back. That's where you start.

Rob: Ed, Did you see all of this coming?

Ed Bouchette: From what point in time? We saw the deterioration of the situation as the season unfolded, but I don't think anyone could have predicted he'd walk out on the team at the end.

Michael B: Love the Chat Ed. As part of the trade clause can a team that is interested in trading for AB insist that he is examined by a neurologist or a psychiatrist. Mr Big Chest is out of control.

Ed Bouchette: Yes, they would have that right, I do believe, as part of a physical.

Jim66: Will team mates begin to openly turn on AB now? Will ABs actions make others who want out start to act foolishly?

Ed Bouchette: If they do, that's a dangerous game. LeGarrette Blount and James Harrison go their ways when the team released them during the season. I would think if something like that would happen again, the Steelers might have learned their lesson and instead suspend them.

Brian in CA: Brown and Burnett want out. Munchak left in a lateral move. Bell would rather miss $14.5 than be a part of the Steelers last year. Just a unique set of circumstances or are the Steelers not as desirable an org to be a part of as they used to be?

Ed Bouchette: Munchak left to be with his family. Brown and Bell really are unique situations because I've never seen anything like what Brown has done and only one other Steeler ever held out the entire season because of a contract dispute -- Mike Merriweather 30 years ago.

Shades of Dennis Rodman: Now that he has his picture with Mr Rooney wouldn’t he want one with Kim Jung Un?

Ed Bouchette: Talk about Mr. Big Chest

Exiled in MA: Do you think Tomlin should do away with the Team MVP like he did the pool table? Seems that the risk/reward just isn't there.

Ed Bouchette: I suggested just that and I know some players believe they should do away with the MVP. The pool table still sits in the locker room, but there are no balls nor sticks. The equipment guys sometimes use it at as a clothes rack.

Al in NJ: When looking for a trading partner for Brown, should the Steelers be concerned with who the other team is to them (divisional foe, Patriots, etc.) or just get the most they can possibly get for him?

Ed Bouchette: I believe it's a balancing act but he won't go to an AFC North team nor the Patriots.

Markieburgh: Since the meeting and subsequent statements is AB aka Mr Big Chest burning things up to maybe get an out right release so he can become a UFA and pick where he goes?

Ed Bouchette: That won't happen

JAMESH: If AB retired right now, is he HOF worthy?

Ed Bouchette: Yes, but he should know that quitting on a team during the season will not help him. Ask TO

ErieIke: Is a trade with the 49ers where they trade 1st and 2nd round draft positions in exchange for AB a reasonable trade offer in your opinion?

Ed Bouchette: No

Paul: can Juju be a true #1 receiver now that Mr. Big Chest won’t be there to occupy a double team?

Ed Bouchette: Yes, but the Steelers will need to adopt a new offensive philosophy that includes running the ball more.

Markieburgh: Ed, the longer this goes, will the team be forced to pay the roster bonus if it takes too long to get a tade partner?

Ed Bouchette: They'll have to weigh whether it's worth paying $2.5 million to wait another month if the price by March 17 isn't to their liking. But then, that would also be a gamble, that some team would change its mind in a month.

Markieburgh: Hey Ed, any news on JUJU's pro bowl injury? That's a lot more important than Mr BC

Ed Bouchette: It wasn't bad

Dag: Hi could the Steelers trade Brown for a conditional draft pick?

Ed Bouchette: If they do, they'd have to wait until 2020 draft because conditional picks are based on performance in 2019

Craig: Ed-thanks for the chat. Do you think we already have an acceptable offer in place for AB? 2nd or better?

Ed Bouchette: No, I do not

BigWoo: On trade talks, is it only the GM's who talk or do owners talk to each other to get something moving?

Ed Bouchette: Usually the GMs, except for Jerry Jones

Ed Bouchette: Thank you for another great chat. See you next Tuesday