Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to today's Steelers chat. Post your questions and we will get started in a few minutes.
Steeler Joe: Hi, Ray. I'm genuinely confused about the transition tag and Bell. If they place the tag on him, they can pull it back, correct? Because I see a lot of scenarios where it would harm the Steelers, and only one way it could benefit them. Why bother?
Ray Fittipaldo: They'd bother if they believe they can get a pick better than a third-rounder and because that pick would come this April instead of 2020. Those are really the only reasons to do it. I don't think they will for the reasons Ed outlined in his story today, but it remains an option.
Dave: What is the Steelers lineback situation? Where are the mobile, yet aggressive types that they seem not to have?
Ray Fittipaldo: They're in the draft and their names are Devin White and Devin Bush. I don't think White will be there at No. 20. Bush might be. They're the top 2 ILBs in this draft and if the Steelers are going to take one in the first round they should get one of these two. After that, it's slim pickins and I wouldn't take another ILB in Round 1.
Ryno: Brown throws furniture off a 14th story balcony, and could have killed two people, and we hear crickets from the league, and the team. He pushes a woman and the league and team are both investigating? I got domestic violence is a bigger issue in the NFL now, but how did they not investigate when Brown nearly killed two people? Why has the league not looked into his obvious anger issues until now?
Ray Fittipaldo: The NFL very well could have investigated the incident and we just don't know about it. A lot of times we inquire and the league will respond with something along the lines of "we are aware of the incident and looking into it..." The NFL does not let us know when they begin investigations and when they end. In fact, they could be ongoing.
Larry in KY: Hi Ray -- It's been hard to wash the past year's Steelers season out of my mouth. Did the media ever ask Bell and Brown if they considered themselves distractions?
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, Brown hasn't really given an interview other than one at the Super Bowl where he didn't say much. Bell has kept to himself too. I suspect Bell will talk once he signs with his new team. Not sure about Brown.
Ryno: Do you think the Steelers have finally learned their lesson by picking up what is left over in the free-agent pool? I believe they've already reached the definition of insanity.
Ray Fittipaldo: I wrote a piece a few weeks back where I detailed all of their mistakes in free agency the past few years. It's not pretty, but as pointed out, they've had limited funds to spend in some of those years. This year is different. They have money to spend. And they have holes to fill.
Paul: How does the tag on Bell work. If the Steelers tag Bell, and if Bell gets a low-ball offer, and if Steelers refuse to match, does Bell have to play under the low ball offer?
Ray Fittipaldo: Usually in these situations, the team that signs the player will put in some ridiculous front-loaded salaries with complicated bonus structures that make it difficult or unappetizing to match the offer.
Scott in Dallas: Since nobody will trade for a player (AB) that could wind up on the Commissioner's Exempt List do you think they keep him for another season to rehab his value or just cut him and be done with the headache?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not so sure no one will trade for Brown. He undoubtedly is decreasing his value and the number of teams bidding for his services, but there is still a market for his services I believe. And I don't think the Steelers can just cut him. He's too valuable to do that.
Scott in Dallas: Since the theoretical SB window is closing, with Ben's career winding down, is it time for the team to show some more urgency in how they handle FA's even if it effects the Comp pick in 2020 for Bell?
Ray Fittipaldo: That might be part of the reason they are looking at a sign and trade with the transition tag. If they sign a big free agent this spring that would affect the compensatory formula for 2020.
pdxJaxon: Ray. It seems to me that over the last few years, the FO has been enamored with the combine darlings\SPARQ Stars to target in the draft.
Im wondering if this focus is part of the reason why we have the misses we've had and if there might be some changes to draft strategy this year....?
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe on a few occasions they became enamored with athletic traits more than football skills. Dri Archer comes to mind. Maybe with Bud Dupree and Artie Burns too. I know Dupree tested off the charts. Scouting is difficult. There are some really good college football players that don't make it because they don't have the requisite height, weight, speed or quickness. You have to rely on the testing to some extent, but it can't be everything. The scouts have to trust what they see on film and then weigh that along with the combine.
BB: Ray - How far has the trade value for AB fallen?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't have the answer to that question, but I know it's not going up.
Scott in Dallas: Do you believe that MT deserves a contract extension or should he earn it with the product on (and off) the field in the upcoming season?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think Tomlin has earned an extension. It remains to be seen if Art Rooney II feels the same way. He was non-commital when asked about it last month. It seems like we're headed down a road where Tomlin is proving his worth in 2019. That could be a fascinating backdrop to the season. The Ravens went through something similar last year. The Ravens won the AFC North, but it was looking disastrous when they were 4-5. Really, they only won the division because of the Steelers' collapse. Will be interesting to see if Rooney thinks it will be a positive or a distraction.
Steeler Joe: In your opinion, does the front office take the approach: "Take what we can get for AB--and it'll be addition by subtraction"? Or will it be: "There is a bottom line for what we'll accept; if we don't get that, we will work it out with him one way or the other and keep him under contract"?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a great question. I wish we had that insight on what Art Rooney II is thinking in that regard. My guess is it's the latter, but I don't know that.
thomastown: The Steelers hired 3 new assistant coaches and promoted one. It seems like they could have done better with these hires in terms of experience and track record. What’s your take on these 4?
Ray Fittipaldo: Shaun Sarrett interviewed for the opening for offensive line coach in 2014 before Munchak was hired. The Steelers have liked him for a long time. I've also heard good things about Adrian Klemm, the new assistant line coach. I've been told he's a good dude. As far as the Teryl Austin hire goes, he's pretty experienced. He's been a defensive coordinator in the league and has worked for a number of teams. We'll see how it all unfolds this summer, but I thought they did OK with the hires. If anything, I would have liked them to hire another coach or two. Not really sure why they didn't bring in an OLBs coach.
Steve: Ray - The Steelers surely are not considering placing the Transition tag on Bell are they? I see nothing good coming from that. Do you see any upside from such a move?
Ray Fittipaldo: The only upside is they'd get the draft pick this spring instead of next year, but it's a gamble I'd rather not take if I was the GM.
Scott in Dallas: It seems like the team was more successful drafting the best available player in the past and really only started missing big by reaching in the 1st rd drafting for need. Should they return to that model which seems to be much better for long term success?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes to a certain degree, but there are obvious needs every year. If the Steelers have a higher grade on a DL and it's between that DL and Devin Bush they have to take Devin Bush because he fills an immediate need.
Matt In Ky : Hey Ray what do you feel the solution to the AB & LB fiascos will be? I just want them out of my teams locker rooms but what if any compensation will they get in your opinion? Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Bell will become a free agent and they'll get a comp pick in 2020. Brown's situation is so unpredictable at the moment. I still think they can get something in return for him, but probably not as much as his talent suggests.
Jared: Thanks for the chat, Ray. I'm seeing some mock drafts with the Steelers taking D.K. Metcalf in the first round, despite their glaring need at ILB, CB, and EDGE. With arguably the greatest WR of his era on the team, they've been a perennial disappointment (relative to Steelers' standards), I'm hoping the Steelers have realized that D wins championships and not offensive stars (with the exception of a QB). Any chance they take a WR in the first round?
Ray Fittipaldo: Glad you brought up Metcalf, Jared. I have a story that we well publish tomorrow morning on the top 10 WRs in the draft. There are some that fit the Steelers well and others that probably do not. Be sure to check that out. If they trade Brown they certainly would need to draft or sign a receiver to take his place. I wouldn't take one in the first round. I'd get my ILB or CB in the first round. The sweet spot might be the second or third round for a WR. They've found success there with WRs in the past, and as I mentioned, there are lots of WRs that will be available in that area.
Guest: Is it becoming more or less likely that Antonio Brown is back with the Steelers next season? I was in favor of keeping him until the reports last week that he pushed his kid's mother to the ground. But is his trade value declining so much that the Steelers might not be able to get enough in return?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's so up in the air right now. Things seem to change every week. It's clear he wants out, and he's not making it easy on the Steelers with all of his off-field shenanigans. If I was in the Steelers front office I wouldn't want him on my team, but I'm also not giving him away for pennies on the dollar either. It's a tough situation for team management.
Scott in Dallas: I really believe that Dobbs is the future QB of the Steelers, not Rudolph. Don't you think that his tool kit and high intelligence are so much higher and it was only doing so much in college with academics that kept him from realizing his potential there?
Ray Fittipaldo: I didn't see much when he filled in for Roethlisberger in the Oakland game. I hate to judge the guy on one performance, but that was a bad team with a bad defense, and he wasn't able to do much.
luke: Hi Ray, What's the chances of getting the raiders number 4 pick for Brown?
Ray Fittipaldo: At this point? Not great.
DaquidoBazzini: Does it seem that Chris Boswell would've been cut by now if that was going to happen?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I think so although his roster bonus is not due until mid-March. Still another month or so to figure that out. He'd cost $4.8 million against the cap if they cut him. That's not good and it's a big reason they'll probably bring him back and give him a shot to become the kicker again.
Epiballo: Ray, a writer at ESPN picks the Browns to win the AFC North, and a local writer has the Steelers finishing third behind Baltimore and Cleveland. Really? I don't see them falling off that far. Do you?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think the Steelers, Ravens and Browns will be good next season. I can see them knocking each other off and all having between 8 and 10 wins. Kind of like what happened in 2018 but with the Browns getting off to a better start and being in a legitimate playoff race. I'm not sold they'll win the North, but I think they'll be in the race.
tom: does your gut tell you, this is tomlins last year here?
Ray Fittipaldo: If the Steelers miss the playoff again? Yes, that's a decent possibility.
Pittsburghsouth: There is a lot of blame to go around in the secondary. The draft picks haven't planned out. The cupboard is almost bare. How do they fix it?Personally, it looks like a multi-year project.
Ray Fittipaldo: If they want to address CB in the first round they'll have that ability. Greedy Williams of LSU, Byron Murphy of Washington and DeAndre Baker of Georgia are some of the possibilities. They need better talent and they need to start getting younger because Joe Haden is 30.
WyoHunter: I think the most important thing to be considered is the “Team” aspect here. The best Steelers teams to take the field were the ones who had mutual respect for one another and played hard for their brothers. Recently, the top group has all been a bunch of self centered narcissists who simply care about themselves. They don’t need the best players, they need to become a team again. Until that happens, expect more of what we’ve seen this year.
Ray Fittipaldo: "They don't need the best player, they need to become a team again."... Sounds like the Patriots' approach to success.
Chris: Any chance steelers draft antonio browns cousin to replace him I wouldn't your thoughts.
Ray Fittipaldo: Read my story on the top 10 WRs in the draft tomorrow morning. I have plenty on that possibility.
Chris: Any chance that steelers draft greedy Williams
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe. Some draft analysts have him going in the top 10. Others don't even have him going in the first round.
MTScott: From a FA market - do you see the Steelers having more opportunities to resolve their LB or CB issues?
Ray Fittipaldo: CBs because three-down ILBs won't be available, at least not ones I would pay good money to. I think they'll be able to sign a vet CB, maybe even a mid- or high-tier one to help fix things in the secondary.
Jack: Is there an "Avery Williamson" type linebacker that you think might be available in FA this year? He seems like the type of 3-down linebacker they need desperately.
Ray Fittipaldo: Williamson signed with the Jets last year in free agency, right? I don't think he's available. Plus, someone I trust told me he's basically Vince Williams. That's the problem with ILBs. There just aren't that many true three-down ILBs.
Draft Greedy W.: "Others don't even have him going in the first round." Really... who?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Daniel Jeremiah of the NFL Network has him as his No. 34 overall prospect. Thus, early second-rounder. I understand top 50 lists aren't mock drafts, but my point is there is some debate about the corners in this class.
3rd Generation Fan: Worst play of the year for me was when Rooney dropped the ball and claimed there was no “culture problem.” Sure we can rid ourselves of AB and LB but if the enablers remain, what will prevent the next “young money crew” from rolling into camp?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good leadership and the head coach setting the tone by not playing favorites and allowing "stars" to have a different set of rules. Get the idea the outside perception of the Steelers is a country club setting. I think that needs to change.
Draft Greedy W.: G.W. is listed as 6'2" that is a rare commodity in top corners.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes he has the size and the athleticism. Very enticing traits to work with. And he looked really good at times. Some inconsistency in his play is what some analysts seem to be concerned about...
Chris: Could steelers go after the lb. from kc in free agency
Ray Fittipaldo: Dee Ford? He'll probably get $15 -17 million a year either from the Chiefs or another team in free agency. The Steelers have money to spend, but I don't know if they have that much money to spend.
WyoHunter: Thank you for mentioning getting a quality WR in a later round. Brown was a late round pick, as was Hines. I think we can fill the spot easily in the later rounds. We need some quality defensive players in the first and second rounds. IMO
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree.
Hank: Ray, I am not defending AB or Bell or anyone else, but what is it about Steelers fans (and maybe fans in general) that cause such knee-jerk reactions to players' lives? I can totally understand a Kareem Hunt/Ray Rice situation, but AB's for example was that his ex blocked the door, he asked her to leave, she refused, and he pushed her out of the door so he could shut it. Yet people act as if he smacked her with a Louisville Slugger. Why?
Ray Fittipaldo: Hank, you said it yourself. He pushed her out of the door. The incident report says she suffered scrapes and injured her arm. There has to be another way for a multi-million dollar athlete to solve his problems with the mother of one of his children. How about pulling out a $100 and reimbursing her for a hair appointment? That would have been much better than getting the police involved.
Draft Greedy W.: When Stephon Gilmore was a fa the Steelers weren't even in the conversation. He graded out as the top CB in the NFL in 2018-19... Why didn't the Steelers pursue him?
Ray Fittipaldo: Was that 2016? As I've pointed out before, the Steelers have been up against the cap in previous years and they've been limited in what they could do in free agency. That's not the case this year.
Jimmy: isn't there a chance that this whole "AB pushed his wife" thing could go away quickly & his trade value jump again...from reading police reports etc. it doesn't seem like a very big incident as these things go.
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll have to wait and see. It's up to the district attorney now. The woman did not want to press charges. I wouldn't be surprised if he's not charged, but we really don't know how it's going to play out.
No to D. Bush: Watched all his games at Michigan. IMO, overrated.
Ray Fittipaldo: Really? I disagree. He can run, cover and blitz. My only concern is his size and his ability to defend the run on a consistent basis because of it. I think he's just what they need. Don't get me wrong, I'd take Devin White if I had the chance. I just think he'll be gone by No. 20.
Big B: I feel so dissatisfied with the post season comments from Steelers ownership and management. It's all very noncommital and lacks the decisive action and direction I'd have liked to see outlined. What is Rooney's motivation for not being more open with fans and demonstrative that performance on and off field improve?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'd say Rooney is more open with the fans that owners of some other NFL teams. How about some other owners in town? How often does Mario Lemieux speak to reporters? How often does Bob Nutting? Rooney is much more accessible. You might not like his answers, but at least the fans have the opportunity to hear his thoughts.
No to D. Bush II: Ray, I think it's more of the fact that he can do all those things you say, but there is nothing "explosive" in his highlights. Many of his tackles are the "hang on and drag down" types. If he can't be explosive at Michigan, how is he going to be explosive for the Steelers?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think we watched the same games.
T. Lazarus Link, aka, The Bishop: Ray good analysis on physical traits vs. football skills, and why some picks fail. But haven't the Steelers also erred on the so-called football side? Matekevich has a nose for the ball but not enough athleticism to claim a starting spot. Ditto for Chickillo. I know good ST players, but neither one making a push to start.
Ray Fittipaldo: Right, but they're also seventh- and fifth-round picks. I don't think you're taking either in hopes of them developing into starters. The fact that Chickillo has been a serviceable backup and good special teams player is good value for a fifth-round pick. Getting a good special teams player is the seventh round is good value. Matakevich will never be a starter, but again, you're not looking to get starters in the seventh round.
Bud is Weiser: I know there is a lot of animosity between AB and the Steelers right now but I think it's in our best interest to try and work things out because we have him and Juju on the outside, they complement each other and we really have nothing else if we lose him. Agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: And what if the antics start up again in training camp? What is your plan then?
Jimmy: Without Brown wouldn't JuJu still give us as good a #1 WR as either of this years 2 SB teams?
Ray Fittipaldo: Correct. It would be all about surrounding him with complementary receivers/ players that could push the offense forward. It's not going to be easy, but it is doable.
Roy Fittipalda: Who will be the Steelers number 3 WR next year? Switzer, Eli, draft pick?
Ray Fittipaldo: James Washington or the WR they sign or draft to replace Antonio Brown. TO me, Rogers or Switzer can't be your third receiver. Maybe a fourth.
Roy Fittipalda: How important is it to find another legit OLB to complement TJ Watt? Or with further development he makes the other OLB spot not as critical?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they can get by another year with Dupree, but he is what he is at this point. I don't think he'll ever develop into a double-digit sack type of OLB. So to answer your question they probably could use an upgrade, but it's down their list of needs. They have more immediate needs at ILB and CB so I think those should be addressed first.
Jimmy: I say trade AB for whatever you can get and move heaven and earth to get Leveon back. Bell is such an extremely unusual talent & I believe he could fuel a SB run if he were happy with his contract situation.
Ray Fittipaldo: Why move heaven and earth to bring Bell back when James Conner went to the Pro Bowl. I think Bell might be surprised at his market in March.
No to D. Bush: Ohio State was the only team Michigan faced last season with anything close to the speed & talent that Bush will face in the NFL. Watch that game again Ray. In fact, as a Wolverine fan, I have to say their whole D, including Gary was way overrated... Not that I like admitting it.
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll have to wait and see what happens. Your assessment is noted. If I have a chance I'll go back and watch the Ohio State game. But I've seen plenty to suggest he'll be a very good player in the NFL.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for all the questions this week. We'll do another chat next week.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.