Ed Bouchette: Good afternoon, let's begin
Sylvester: Any word on rumor of domestic dispute involving Antonio Brown?
Ed Bouchette: TMZ reporting that AB was "involved in domestic dispute" in mid-January, that Hollywood, Fla., police were called but no arrests made.
Allan: Do the Steelers have to move Brown? Can they say this is what you need to do to play and if he doesn’t, suspend him without pay? Why does the played get to dictate what gets done?
Ed Bouchette: They can talk to him until they are black and gold in the face and he can make all kinds of assurances, but that hasn't worked in the past.
Sid Fernwilter: Have the Steelers given any thoughts to moving players into new positions (ie Offense to Defense or visa versa).
Read More
Ed Bouchette: If they have, they have not shared them with me. Not sure which players they could move. I assume you mean on offense since there's not much to move around on offense. They moved Sean Davis from strong safety to free last year and flip-flopped sides with T.J. Watt and Bud Dupree. If they are thinking about anything, they would wait until after free agency and the draft to see who they acquire first.
schnail: Is it really worse to keep Antonio Brown around than to devote $21M in cap space to someone who will be catching 100+ passes and 15 TDs for your opponents? I just can't get my head around that.
Ed Bouchette: Again, that $21 million in cap space would be reduced by his salary and roster bonus that comes to $15 M. Not sure why people aren't getting their heads around that since I've reported it so many times. Also, it's past time the Steelers have players who actually conform to the word "team" and not "me" all the time.
Larry in KY: If AB and LB go, who, if anyone, will emerge as next year's drama distraction? Any candidates in the house right now?
Ed Bouchette: No, that would eliminate the four who have prompted them most drama over the past two seasons -- AB, Le'Veon Bell, James Harrison and Martavis Bryant. Remove those four before 2017 and there might have been little drama the ensuing two seasons.
Robert: Is the Rooney rule experiment finally over? Thanks to Dan Rooney and Tony Dungy, we traded discipline, game prep, humility, situational awareness, time management, and sheer intellect for political correctness. Tomlin can thank his lucky stars he works for Art Rooney II and not Art Rooney I.
Ed Bouchette: Robert, that sounds more than a little racist.
ErieIke: If the Steelers cannot get a fair return, like a top 10 draft pick, for AB, wouldn't they be better off keeping him?
Ed Bouchette: Not in my opinion. I think they'd be better just cutting bait any way they can and move on. Did you see any future Hall of Famers at WR in the Super Bowl?
Peter: Hi Ed, the drama circus (Bell, Brown ) Missing the playoff and now the cherry on top Pats win another SB . Any idea to cheer a depress fans?
Ed Bouchette: All NFL teams are 0-0 for the 2019 season, including your Pittsburgh Steelers
Cburg Stiller: Reading Peter King's article yesterday, and he was discussing potential season openers for the Pats next season. He referred to a possible Steelers/Pats game as the 'Drama Queens vs the Model Franchise' He's not wrong but man that's hard to read as a lifelong Steelers fan. From what you can see, do you think Steelers ownership and front office and coaches have begun to take the necessary steps to repair that type of damage to the Steelers reputation and begin to get back to the 'Steelers Way'?
Ed Bouchette: If they enter 2019 without Bell and Brown it will be a big step.
Karl from KY: I think one of the Steelers greates weakensses is not having a player that can make a big play to turn a game around or finish out an opponent. We don’t have a Troy P or Jerome B in several years a guy that can make a splash play. What say you?
Ed Bouchette: Antonio Brown was that guy for awhile. Ben Roethlisberger is that guy. They do have a few on defense, but they need more.
Tucson: At The Trophy ceremony, Bill Belicheck was told what a great coach he was winning the game. Belicheck corrected the announcer and stated that it was the players who deserve the credit and not the coach. What does that tell you?
Ed Bouchette: That he was being politically correct
Oh No it’s JOE BLOW: Ed. You don’t really think Steelers are better w/out AB, right?
Ed Bouchette: I'm sorry, I missed the part where he led them into the playoffs last season, or to a victory against Jacksonville the year before. Do you think the Patriots are better off without Antonio Brown? Cut bait, go find a reliable player at the position.
TheStadndard: With the new's about AB's domestic violence does that speed up the trade or hurt it?
Ed Bouchette: It may speed it up, but reduce the bounty.
Oh No it’s JOE BLOW: If Steelers made playoffs and AB went awol the week leading up, no way the FO or HC suspends him from that game, right?
Ed Bouchette: I highly doubt it.
FloridaSteelers: Hi Ed, Is it even possible for AB to return to the Steelers? I just do not see his return leading to any other then more drama. Your thoughts please.
Ed Bouchette: When I was at the Super Bowl last week, I can't tell you the number of people -- writers, broadcasters, NFL people -- who came to me to say they were stunned to see what was coming out of the Steelers. Besides Bell early and AB all season, was there really anything else? To me, I don't see how you bring him back.
Karl from KY: Any chance putting the transition tag on Bell blows up on us?
Ed Bouchette: Very much so. Someone else signs him, you are left with nothing and you are committed to that amount of money until you decline to match. By then, the best free agents will be gone. And if you do that and don't match, he won't count in the formula for comp draft choices in 2020.
Mr.C: Ed what do you about switching Bud Dupree ILB and getting rid of Vince and Bostic and draft Bush or White?
Ed Bouchette: So you think Bud would perform better at ILB than outside?
TheStadndard: Whose decision is it to trade AB? Tomlin, Colbert, Rooney?
Ed Bouchette: Rooney would have to give his OK, maybe even be the driving force behind it.
Steubenville: Hi Ed, what are you thoughts on the Steelers placing the transition tag on Bell? If they do, are they keeping or trading him?
Ed Bouchette: I wouldn't mess with the tag. Just let him go as a UFA, find another back to complement your other two and take the third-round comp pick in 2020.
Steubenville: Hi Ed, with the new domestic violence accusation against AB, does that kill his value in a trade?
Ed Bouchette: It won't increase it
Ed Bouchette: And while there were no arrests in that case, remember that the NFL needs no arrests to punish players accused of such things as domestic violence.
Oh No it’s JOE BLOW: You think Ben skates by and gets his fair share of passes on his miscues more so than others on the team.
Ed Bouchette: So what miscue has Ben Roethlisberger "skated by" on in his career?
Leaper: If the Steelers transition Bell, is the goal a trade or to keep him?
Ed Bouchette: Trade
Leaper: Would the Steelers accept anything less than a first round pick for Brown?
Ed Bouchette: They may have to.
Oh No it’s JOE BLOW: Do u thinknthe team is split 50/50 on wanting AB back?
Ed Bouchette: I think you might see him losing some of the support he's had after the latest news.
Rahn: What does a passing game or run game coordinator do if the OC calls plays and position coaches coach the players?
Ed Bouchette: Truly, some teams have too many coaches.
Ed Bouchette: Next thing they'll have is a defensive run-game coordinator and a defensive pass-game coordinator
Robert: Wouldn't you want a GM who has recently played for NFL and knows talent when he see's it? Steelers need to get up with the times
Ed Bouchette: So you're saying the only ones who can determine talent is if they played the game? So, if you're fighting crime you want your cops who have committed crimes because they then have that experience? Have you ever heard of Art Rooney Jr. Dan's brother. He played a little football at Saint Vincent College but that's it. He drafted four Hall of Famers in 1974. I think he knew talent. So does Kevin Colbert or else the Steelers would not have had the kinds of success they've had since they hired him in 2000.
Leaper: Do you get a sense the Steelers prefer a CB, ILB or Edge in the first round?
Ed Bouchette: Way too early for that but I think they need help at all 3.
MeanfellaMike: If Antonio Brown gets handed some kind of suspension, once these allegations all play out, do the Steelers have any recourse to release him and NOT have to take the salary cap hit?
Ed Bouchette: If he is suspended, they probably could go after some of his signing bonus, and if successful, reduce their cap by any amount they would get back. That's rare, though.
Team TMZ: Why would the Steelers put transition tag on Bell and lose a probable 3rd round comp pick?
Ed Bouchette: If they think they can tag him and another team signs him to a contract, they match it and then deal him to that team for a draft pick. It sounds way too convoluted to me. I don't think they can pull that off.
Doley: Question I've always wondered. HoF bylaws say 80% vote needed for induction, but also require a minimum of 4 inductees every year. What happens if there aren't 4 guys with the necessary vote?
Ed Bouchette: Glad you asked that because they never say this but in that case, they would take the next highest vote-getter even if it's under 80 percent. Some claim that is how Al Davis got into the HOF
LambertLoon : Ed, when giving your presentation for a potential HOF candidate (like Faneca), is it bad etiquette to compare that candidates stats with those already enshrined? Or do you strictly stick to that candidates own merits for induction?
Ed Bouchette: I do a little of both. No, it's not bad etiquette because those guys are already in and you just want to show how he compares to current HOF. For example, I pointed out that only 5 guards in the HOF had more Pro Bowls than Faneca's 9.
Jeff from Indiana: Everyone loves to watch a train wreck, is that why we are so in love with the Steelers??? Been a fan for the past 60 years!!!
Ed Bouchette: Well, they were certainly a train wreck for your first 10 years or so as a fan, and that train seems to be coming around the bend again.
Jim66: Are the Steelers as confident in Tomlin righting the ship as they portray in public?
Ed Bouchette: If they weren't, he would not still be their coach
Jim66: What is your best guess on Steelers resigning either or both V. McDonald and Jesse James? If you had to choose one over other to sign which would you sign?
Ed Bouchette: Vance McDonald will not be a free agent, James will.
Ryno: Great article on adding a booth official! The NFL claims to be somewhat opposed to that idea because it could slow down the game. Dont you think most fans would prefer game potentially ten minutes longer to a faster game where refs make bad game-affecting decisions?
Ed Bouchette: I know Saints fans would have preferred it.
Ed Bouchette: But as I noted in that story, I think it could speed things up, not slow them down
BB: Ed - Thanks for your chats. How confident are you the Steelers will address their secondary and linebacker issues during FA and the draft? I used to think they were only a player or two away but looking how tight the defenses were in the Super Bowl, I am not so sure?
Ed Bouchette: I thought they were going to address their ILB issue in last year's draft and they came up empty. They'll have plenty to address elsewhere too if AB and Bell are gone.
MeanJoeBlue: Ed, to help with the linebacker situation, do you envision the steelers switching back to a 4-3 alignment again?
Ed Bouchette: No. They've been with a 3-4 since 1982 and their players are built for a 3-4. Part of the problem too is they don't have enough good DL to do that.
JP: Hi Ed, do you guys have some sort of sports database that you use to answer or confirm facts when answering questions and writing stories?
Ed Bouchette: Not really. It's rapid fire answers. Sometimes, I'll take a quick look online to look up something or confirm, but these chats are not set up for much research time. What I won't do is use a stat I'm not sure about, or an opinion that I don't trust. But, for example, when someone asks if I think AB will be here next year, it's an opinion, not a fact, based on my experience covering the team and talking to people.
Jim66: Is there any fear amongst NFL teams that Brown is coach or GM killer or that he would be cancer to team chemistry or are there too many selfish players in pro sports to really single him out other then he is an elite player?
Ed Bouchette: Look around and tell me who the other players on the Steelers -- even in the league -- who are acting as erratically or selfishly as Antonio Brown . I can't think of many.
kevin in Punxsy: Ed, why, do you think, that a number of Steelers players who were outraged by AB's actions during week 17, and rightly so, are now calling for Art II to bring back AB?
Ed Bouchette: That truly surprises me
Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: Hi Ed, Why would the Steelers sign Rosie to a big deal last year, if they were not gonna use him more? NE is one example of using the FB and establishing there will to run when necessary.. Thoughts?
Ed Bouchette: I wondered aloud the same thing.
Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: HI Ed, In your opinion what percent of HOF voters go into Saturday am open minded and do each players presenters have much influence? Thanks!
Ed Bouchette: I think most go in with an open mind. I know I always have. I may go into it lukewarm on a candidate but then be convinced by the debate. I don't know that the one introducing the player to that debate has that much influence.
JR: Ed- Any realistic chance the Steelers try to keep Bell if Brown is gone?
Ed Bouchette: I would be stunned. Art Rooney told us he is happy with the two young backs -- Conner and Samuels -- on the roster
Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: Hi Ed, If Edelman is an HOFer, what does that make Ward? Thanks
Ed Bouchette: I don't think Edelman is a HOFer. I think Ward is, even if enough of my fellow voters don't recognize that.
Jorge: How do the Steelers keep Ryan Shazier? Do they offer a contract as a player or as an assistant coach?
Ed Bouchette: Since he was on PUP all last season, his contract will "toll" but at a significantly lower number, under $1 M. So they won't even have to sign him to a new deal. I was told that last week at the Super Bowl.
Mike: If you could only pick one of the following Patriot advantages to be transferred to the Steelers, which one Ed? (Head coach, QB, culture)
Ed Bouchette: Culture
Frank: Ed, time and time again, we see teams win Super Bowls without high paid RB & WR's. let's move from Bell and Brown and get team players, agree?
Ed Bouchette: We are beating the same drum, my dear Frank.
Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: Ed, In your opinion is Louis Lipps in the Steelers all me Top 5 WR’s? Thanks
Ed Bouchette: Let's see. Swann, Stallworth, Ward, AB. Am I missing anyone? If that's it, then he's No. 5 or at least competing for it with Santonio Holmes.
Ed Bouchette: Thank you for another great chat. See you next Tuesday.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.