The New England Patriots are once again on the verge of tying the Steelers with an NFL-leading six Super Bowl victories, which means it’s once again time to debate which franchise’s championship history is better.
There is no easy resolution on the emotional or observational levels. It’s impossible to compare, say, the dominance of the Steel Curtain defenses of the 1970s with the longevity of New England quarterback Tom Brady, who looks like a good bet to lead his team to Super Bowls in three different decades. Both are breathtaking in their own ways.
Comparisons are difficult on the statistical level, too. Six wins are more than five, and New England’s 11 appearances are more than the Steelers’ eight. One of the more popular tools for comparing year-to-year excellence, however, gives the Steelers’ Super Bowl track record a slight edge.
Pro Football Reference’s Simple Rating System (SRS) seeks to measure a given team’s quality above average, with average being zero, by weighing factors like margin of victory and strength of schedule in a given year. You can read more about the methodology here.
The important thing to know is that each team is judged relative to its contemporaries, giving us a consistent baseline helpful for making apples-to-apples comparisons through football’s ever-changing strategic landscape. A modern team, for example, may put up better offensive numbers than one from 40 years ago, but it won’t necessarily get a better rating unless those numbers lead to dominant victories against quality opponents.
The formula looks kindly on the Steelers’ six championship years, giving them an average rating of 9.78. That’s substantially better than New England’s 8.84 average rating in its five Super Bowl wins.
Read More
The Steelers’ 1975 team is the star of the group with a 14.2 rating. The teams from 1979 (11.9), 2009 (9.8.), 1978 (8.2) and 2005 (7.8) slot in behind, with the 1974 team bringing up the rear at 6.8.
On the New England side, the 2004 title team rates best at 12.8 and is followed by 2014 (10.9), 2016 (9.3), 2003 (6.9) and 2001 (4.3.)
Interestingly, the Patriots’ losing Super Bowl teams posted a better average than both franchises’ winning groups. Bolstered by the 2007 team’s monstrous 20.1 rating, New England’s five losers posted an average rating of 9.84. That dwarfs the Steelers’ average losing rating of 7.4.
Add the ratings of winners and losers and the franchises’ averages are within tenths of each other, with the Steelers coming out on top, 9.18-8.96.
That’s close enough that the result of Super Bowl LIII on Sunday in Atlanta could swing things one way or the other. If the Patriots come out on top against a tough Los Angeles Rams team, their final rating for 2018 could be just high enough to make up the franchise’s aggregated deficit.
Either way, it seems appropriate that the numbers back up what the eyes tell us. These are the two dominant teams of the Super Bowl era, and you can’t really go wrong in choosing the storied history of either one.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.