Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. I'll be back at noon to get the chat started. In the meantime, post your questions.
BB: Ray - Understand the importance to the players for All-Pro and Pro Bowl recognition for a lot of reasons....contracts, goals, achievements, etc. But couldn't we still recognize players as such without having to play that awful game??
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. This is topical because JuJu Smith-Schuster suffered a knee injury yesterday. Apparently it's a contusion and not considered serious. That's according to an Associated Press story. But could you imagine if it was serious? The NFL does a great job with the event throughout the week. They let fans in for free to practices so they can interact with the players. They should just make it a goodwill event for the fans and forget about the game itself. Let the players get their recognition and free trip to Orlando and let the fans have their fun. They can do all that without an actual game that borders on the ridiculous anyway.
SteelBone925: Does Juju's injury in the Pro Bowl change the front office feelings about AB?
Ray Fittipaldo: Everything I've read said it's not a serious injury, so no.
Jeff M: Hi Ray, Good article on Steelers ability to pursue free agents. If they add an upper tier FA or 2 (like they should) would that likely cost them the comp pick for Bell in 2020. If so would that make them more likely to transition tag him and see if they can get value that way?
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: You make a good point and that could factor into their decision on whether to place the transition tag on him. If you do that you have to be confident you can strike a deal with a team before you place the tag on him. It can't be a situation where you tag him and hope to make a deal. You have to have a deal in place. The compensatory formula is complicated and even GM Kevin Colbert admits he doesn't completely understand it. So I don't know exactly how it will affect the pick in 2020, but it most certainly would.
Retire21: You can do one. Resign Ramone or cut Gilbert?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's an odd way to phrase the question. I guess I'd cut Gilbert but only because I don't want to re-sign Foster. But please understand the only reason I would cut Gilbert is his inability to stay healthy. He's a good player when available. He just hasn't been available enough. As for Foster, it's time for him to get on with his life's work.
Epiballo: With reports of some Steelers wanting Antonio Brown back and others of AB photo-shopping a picture of him in a 49ers uniform ... what do you think is going to happen?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with Ron Cook's column from this morning. What are the leaders of this team doing? I understand most if not all of those comments were made before the photoshopped photo hit Brown's IG. But still, this is the guy who quit on the team when a playoff berth was on the line. I hope guys like Cam Heyward and Maurkice Pouncey are just being politically correct or acting on the advice of the front office in hopes of getting fair trade value in return. But if that's not the case -- if they truly want him back -- then I have some issues with their leadership.
Jeff M: I see 3 plug and play ILBs in this years draft. Do you think they would be satisfied with any of the 3, Devin White, Devin Bush or Mack Wilson? White may be the most unlikely to fall. This would allow them to focus on CB and OLB in FAs.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know exactly how they feel about the trio of ILBs you mentioned, but I can tell you how I feel. White and Bush would be slam dunks if they got either at No. 20. I'm not as big a fan of Wilson. I would not draft him at No. 20. He's not as fast or explosive as White or Bush.
Utah Jim: SF is never going to trade the 2nd pick for AB. They may part with their second round pick which is #36. Should the Steelers take it? I say yes if SF adds a few more picks.
Ray Fittipaldo: No. 36 is close to being a first-round pick, but I would still need the pot to be sweetened. Maybe if they added a third this year and a conditional pick in 2020. Let's say if Brown gets 1,000 yards it's a fourth-rounder. If he gets 1,100 it's a third-rounder, 1,200 a second-rounder. Something like that.
Scott in Dallas: Good Morning Sir. Certainly the Steelers will not pay Boswell the $2 mil option after the way he played last year... right?
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, they haven't cut him yet and he won't be under their supervision again until after the bonus kicks in, so it seems like they will. I think they'll allow Boswell the chance to compete with Matt McGrane at OTAs and training camp and then they'll make a decision in September.
Retire21: Could the addition of Austin salvage Burns?
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll see if a different coach can make a difference. Sometimes a different voice can help. But he's had Carnell Lake and Tom Bradley as coaches. Now Austin will try to help. It won't cost much to keep him around. It's the final year of his rookie deal so they can do it with little cost.
Utah Jim: If Brown is gone is WR a high priority in the draft or free agency? I say no since this defense has a bigger need for talent. If they can’t get in the playoffs with this defense and Brown they won’t with a WR drafted high or a high priced free agent. Defense needs fixed first.
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you that ILB and/or CB should be addressed before WR. However, if they do get a first-round pick in return I wouldn't be against using that pick on a WR. In other words, if they get a first-round pick for Brown, I'd be fine with them taking a WR with one of their top three draft choices (1,1a or 2). They definitely would need a WR because James Washington did not do enough to convince me he's ready to be a starter.
Scott in Dallas: It is really nice to see a lot of the players coming out saying they want to have AB back and they don't care about his Diva act. Might it be that they know how to pump his trade value back up?
Ray Fittipaldo: I hope that's what they're doing. Or, as I noted earlier, it doesn't make me feel great about the leadership inside the locker room.
Retire21: Ben’s had some horrid first quarter of the season games. Do they need to play him more in preseason?
Ray Fittipaldo: I haven't looked at the stats from this year's early games, but I do know the Browns game was bad. They scored 37 against the Chiefs, but they got off to a bad start that certainly influenced the outcome of that game. I thought Ben was really good in the first half against the Bucs... Sure, if they can play him more without exposing him to injury I'm all for it. But if you do that you'd be asking your linemen to play more, and they'd be more at risk for injury.
Scott in Dallas: What under the radar move can the Steelers make that will make a big impact on the field next season?
Ray Fittipaldo: Add a top free agent at ILB, CB or OLB to help take the pressure off in the draft. That might not be low-profile, but it might be needed.
Scott in Dallas: Have the Steelers learned their lesson about reaching for need in the 1st round of the draft after the Dupree/Burns boondogles?
Ray Fittipaldo: I remember Burns had some differing grades. I recall one draft analyst believing he was a third-round type of guy. I don't recall that of Dupree. I think there was more of a consensus for him being taken in the first round. He had the size and the great combine performance. Unfortunately for the Steelers, his skills haven't yet translated to on-field play.
Alan: What's your take on the Brown situation? At this point, do you think he'll remain a Steeler or do they trade him?
Ray Fittipaldo: Despite the talk of his teammates at the Pro Bowl I still think they trade him.
Guest: Who are some free agent names that you think the steelers could possibly be interested in? Whether LB, CB, WR...etc
Ray Fittipaldo: Honestly, it's a little early for that. A lot of the top free agents will be franchise tagged.
Bruce: Ray..any chance the Steelers move up in 1st round to draft a CB?
Ray Fittipaldo: They could, but remember it costs a lot in draft capital to make such moves.
dennis dixon: Do you think AB is capable of the level of humility necessary to make a heartfelt apology to his teammates and the Steeler Nation?
Ray Fittipaldo: He's done it before, but it doesn't seem like he means it because he keeps going off the rails again.
Taz: If the Steelers are going to flex their FA$ this offseason, doesn't that make a transition tag on Bell more likely, as it could impact a prospective 2020 compensatory pick?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I answered that question earlier. It makes the transition tag more likely, but only if they know they can get a deal done with a team beforehand.
Bruce: Ray..is the culture in that lockerroom unfixable because Tomlin was the enabler?
Ray Fittipaldo: Eliminating Brown would fix a lot, but you have a point. Tomlin let a lot go with Brown. Players would be watching to see if JuJu or James Conner or anyone started getting special treatment.
AugustWest: What do you make of the report that AB lived in a rented villa during training camp while his teammates stayed in a campus dorm? Does this kind of star system send a bad message to the team - and did it play a role in the fiasco that ultimately led AB to walk out on his team before a de-facto playoff game?
Ray Fittipaldo: That was common knowledge among those who cover the team and many fans I think. It was out there although it might not have ever been specifically reported in a story. Everyone knows Brown got special treatment. Before the rented house, he never went to the cafeteria to eat. He's always had a special chef make his meals. He's always had a photographer/social media guy on the sidelines when no one else on the team had those privileges. The enlightening part of the report, to me, was the players that were interviewed were rooting for Brown because he was able to get away with so much. I found that to be kind of funny and disturbing at the same time.
Jake: Ray, Is there any real leaders on this team? For Captains to be saying they want AB back is absurd. Are we going the way of the Browns becoming a joke around the league?
Ray Fittipaldo: I tend to agree with you. But I'll pass final judgment when I can ask the players myself. I wasn't at the Pro Bowl so I don't know exactly what they were thinking when they said those things. As I brought up earlier, maybe they were asked by the front office to say nice things.
Jerry: Ray..isn't 31 old for a WR these days?
Ray Fittipaldo: Nope. Go to Pro Football Reference and look up Jerry Rice's best year. It came at age 33. Look up some of Cris Carter's best years. He had a bunch of 1,000-yard seasons after he turned 31. Do some fall off at that age? Sure. But Brown takes care of himself and is motivated. His age is not an issue in any trade scenario. It's the baggage.
tee: Its funny how people forget that BEN! not ab is the reason we are a playoff/super bowl contender every year. Also pretty ridiculous how much The national media hates on BEN.
Ray Fittipaldo: They can hate on Roethlisberger all they want. He doesn't deserve everything, but there are some ways he can improve the situation. What irritates me is how pro Brown almost every national analyst is. I was watching the NFL Network morning show this morning. The one that has Nate Burelson on it. He at least is more tolerable than most of these dimwits, but even he was saying the Steelers would be making a big mistake if they trade Brown. Listen up people: the guy quit on his team. End of story.
Utah Jim: I’ve read in some places the Steelers lack of quality corner backs is because of their usual low draft position. Do you buy that? Draft position hasn’t hurt the offense especially at WR. For whatever reason the Steelers are not good at identifying and developing players at corner. Bad luck has played a role as well, but not draft position.
Ray Fittipaldo: To a certain point yes. When they drafted Artie Burns in 2016 it was the first time they used a first-round pick on a corner since 1997 when they took Chad Scott in the first round. The troubling thing is they haven't been very good in subsequent rounds either. Senquez Golson was a second-round pick. Curtis Brown was a third-round pick. Cortez Allen was a fourth-round pick. I could go on and on...
Steeler Joe: Seriously--WILL the Steelers actually sign a significant free agent to help fix the problems on defense?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know, but they should consider it if they can find the right fit. As I noted in my story last week the low- and mid-tier free agents have not been kind to them in recent years.
Bubby Brister: It seems like the Steelers have too many holes to address in one off season, especially with the impending removal of Brown from the roster and their philosophy regarding free agency. Do you think this team will report to camp with a few high expectations on some recently drafted players and nothing else?
Ray Fittipaldo: As long as Roethlisberger is the QB there will be high expectations and there should be. If you have a franchise QB you have a chance in the NFL. And as I type that all of you know my feelings on how much he passes. They have to cut back on the pass attempts, feed the run game and play off the run game with play-action. They've gotten away from that and would benefit if they went back to it.
Jake: Once March 13th arrives does AB get traded then or draft day? Thank you.
Ray Fittipaldo: March 13 because he is owed a $2.5 roster bonus a few days later and they don't want to be on the hook for that. Let the acquiring team pay that.
mtsteel: Ray, thanks for keeping up the chats. I dont see how you move AB for less than a 1st round pick. He's not a criminal and his stats put Amari Coopers to shame. Anything less, I say we keep him and keep him under control. Your thoughts
Ray Fittipaldo: You mean: try to keep him under control. I'm sure they've tried that. They've been unsuccessful in making the situation tolerable. But I'm with you. If you can't fair value in return you can't just give him away. He's too valuable.
Confused: Early in the year, folks were praising Bostic's play and saying it was a prudent signing. Now, folks are generally saying all LBs but Watt could go. Yeah, the team in general collapsed but how did his personal level of play tail off? Never, even in the beginning, was a big playmaker.
Ray Fittipaldo: None of their ILBs, Bostic included, are good enough to play on all downs. That's why they have to invest in a fast, three-down ILB. No offense to Bostic or Vince Williams. Both are fine players and solid run defenders. But they often got exposed in coverage because they can't run well enough to keep up with RBs and TEs down the field.
JoeB: How can AB ever be a part of the locker room again after all the social media stuff he's been doing that is essentially saying he wants no part of the Steelers?
Ray Fittipaldo: Exactly. Although, to be fair, he posted that Friday. Most of the Pro Bowl interviews that I saw took place Wednesday and Thursday.
Huey Richardson: Why Do We keep Missing the Mark on drafting OLB's and CB's? Other than Watt. Do they have a problem with evaluating talent?
Ray Fittipaldo: Certainly the CB evaluations have not been good enough. That's been an ongoing problem. As you mentioned Watt is excellent. We have to give them credit for the good picks too. Jarvis Jones obviously was a failure. Bud Dupree isn't a failure on that level, but he's not worth $9.2 million a year either. So they have to negotiate that number down and explore a new, cheaper deal. If they can't it should be Adios Bud.
Kev Dawg: If AB isn’t traded but pulls a LB and sits out, can the Steelers suspend him without pay and how does that impact the salary cap space?
Ray Fittipaldo: He's under contract so if he decided to sit out he most certainly would not get paid.
93.7 the idiot: Maybe the players get something you media folk don't when saying they want 84 back. Imagine if they made the trade you just outlined with SF. Trading a top 3 receiver all time for picks (no current 1st rounder) is laughable. You would be punting on the end of Bens career.
Ray Fittipaldo: How many Super Bowls have they won with Brown?
Shaun: Do you see a world where Larry Fitzgerald might end up a Steeler? I think he'd be a great addition. They'd still need a speedster to stretch the field, but his veteran presence would be a boon to the WR corp. Agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: No. He just re-signed with the Cards. And they're paying an exorbitant amount for a WR entering his 16th season.
Delton Hall Jr: Do you think they will go after a CB in FA or through the Draft? Considering they can't seem to do a good job drafting any.
Ray Fittipaldo: That might not be a bad idea. They did fine Joe Haden in free agency, although he was a free agent very late in the process.
Daniel: Do you see Mason Rudolph making the leap from third-stringer to franchise QB? How do you think the Steelers will handle their QBs over the next three seasons?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers have to see him play a lot more to get a good evaluation on him. He's entering his second season. Look at the jump Dobbs made from Year 1 to year 2; I'm sure they're hoping for similar results with Rudolph.
LI Steeler Fan: im indifferent regarding keeping/trading AB - but if they do decide to move on - b/c of his childish attitude they best get a least a 1st rounder and probably a 3rd as well. he's still playing as a top 3 receiver in the game and has a very attractive salary off $11+mio/year . Labriola and Bouchette seem to be happy if they get anywhere near a 2nd for him thats misjudging the market in a huge way. your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: I can't speak for Ed, but I think he's like me. They have to get a first-round pick or a player like Patrick Peterson in return.
Steeltic: How does swapping 1st round picks with San Francisco and trading them Brown sound to you?
Ray Fittipaldo: So the 49ers get Brown and No. 20 for the No. 2 pick? I'd do it,
Steller Fan: Is having TO as his "mentor" the most bizarre thing AB has done?
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, Ochostinko had been his mentor, so no.
Dave W: Thanks for your time, Ray. Do you think the front office will have a talk with #7 about his leadership "style", radio comments, etc.? Not dictate to him, but help him get better at being a leader.
Ray Fittipaldo: I would hope so. That would be on my agenda if I was Art Rooney II. Ben is fine for the most part, but I've been on record saying that radio show of his is bad for the team. It's because he's so honest on it. If I was Rooney I'd pay him whatever the radio station does and write that check to Ben's charity.
JoeB: If I recall Dupree's knock was that he was an underachiever. Did little with all that talent. Don't the Steelers usually place a premium on production?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but there's always a balance between college production and pro potential. Senquez Golson had 10 interceptions as a senior at Ole Miss. What did that mean? Gerod Holliman had 14 INTs. What did that mean for him? He never even made the practice squad. You have to balance production and combine stuff. Even then, you have a lot of first-rounders that don't pan out. That's why the NFL draft is such a crapshoot. There is no way of telling who will excel and who will struggle.
Jud: Assuming AB is gone. Will Ju-Ju be able to lead the WR room? Will we be doomed to repeat the same mistakes...Ward to Wallace to Brown ...
Ray Fittipaldo: JuJu is entering his third year. I think that's enough time in the league to take over that room.
Dave: If Steeltic's trade went down and Steelers sat at #2 do you think they would take Josh Allen? Imagine him opposite Watt rushing the passer.
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm writing about the OLB prospects next week. The story on the CB prospects will run tomorrow. I've watched a few Kentucky games in the past few weeks. You can see Allen is a freak athlete. And he has the size (6-5, 260). My only concern is every splash play I've seen him make has come as a result of his speed. Most of the time he's beating a tackle around the edge and getting a sack or a pressure. I haven't seen a lot of counter moves after he's initially blocked. But if you're taking a shot at No. 2 and you want the best OLB prospect he's probably the guy.
Taz: You don't think Ben goes on the radio show with FO blessing? I've always thought that his honesty in that forum only came out whenever he wasn't getting traction in the locker room - a last resort motivator, of sorts. Not like he spouts off on every single topic.
Ray Fittipaldo: I just think it's become a distraction. Best way to eliminate a distraction is to eliminate it altogether.
Shane: Ray, I believe that if they do trade Brown it will be important to find a quality WR2 in FA. AB has drawn safety help almost every route he's run in the last 3 years. I think this has helped JUJU win the battles in one on one. Therefore the importance of a quality WR2 is important. Thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Absolutely, yes. I'm not down on James Washington, but he did not show me enough to convince me he's ready to be a starter. What the Steelers really need if they trade Brown is a fast WR to threaten down the field. JuJu and Washington are not blazers. They'd need a deep threat to keep secondaries honest.
Greg: I wouldn’t reward my 3 year old for behaving badly. Why do we let Blount, Harrison and now Brown pout their way out of town? If the Steelers put their foot down years ago when it became to behavior we might not be here today. Thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: The problem is if you keep Brown he's demonstrated he's more than willing to sabotage an entire season. He pretty much tried to sabotage the team's efforts to make the playoffs by being insubordinate (AND CHURLISH!) in Week 17.
Nick: Can you elaborate on not wanting to resign Foster?
Ray Fittipaldo: Why would they want to re-sign a 33-year old guard? Especially when they have BJ Finney and Matt Feiler ready in the wings. Go back and watch the Chargers and Raiders games and explain to me why you want Foster back. He's the guy who held on the long Conner run at the beginning of the third quarter in the Chargers game. And he was at fault for Roethlisberger getting injured against the Raiders.
Epiballo: Do the Steelers sign Jesse James? And is Grimble gone after the stunt he pulled in Denver that cost the Steelers a win? Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't be surprised if Grimble is not back. I'd sign James, but I don't want to pay him a lot of $ because he'd be a backup to Vance McDonald. I'd sign him for $5 million over two years, something like that. Maybe $8 million over 3...
Vico: Do you think Rams can beat Pats?
Ray Fittipaldo: Can they? Sure. Every Super Bowl involving the Patriots has been close. Will they? I'm not so sure. I'm picking the Patriots.
FR: What do you make of SB Nation Simon Chester's article where he says the local radio stations are slamming Brown and local beat writers are trashing him as well.
Ray Fittipaldo: Who is Simon Chester?
tee: End of the day we live and die with #7 and i wouldn't want anyone else. They can say whatever they want about Ben BUT the one thing nobody can say is he is a quitter. That guy fights every game good or bad and we are never out of any game /season as long as he is our QB.
Ray Fittipaldo: That's all true. He does need to cut down on the INTs.
AtlantaDan: With regard to Foster, I agree the o-line needs to start getting younger, but by saying he needs to get on with his life’s work did his level of play slip significantly this past season (leaving aside his hold in the Chargers game that was one of the biggest plays of the season) that supports moving on for reasons other than age?
Ray Fittipaldo: Watch the play when Roethlisberger was injured in Oakland. Foster allows a player who was aligned as a 3-technique, maybe even a 4-technique over the tackle beat him to the inside. This penetration screwed up the right side of the line's ability to pass off the stunt. Therefore, the looping DT came around and injured Roethlisberger. Foster had to stick his guy on the line of scrimmage and be there to pick up the looping DT.
Alan: Lots to pick from, but who's the worst commentator/analyst from espn or nfl network in your opinion?
Ray Fittipaldo: Pretty much any of them.
Nycole: Who is your top player that might drop a good amount in the draft first round.
Ray Fittipaldo: Way too early to say. I was holding out some hope that Montez Sweat might fall to the Steelers at No. 20. But he probably solidified himself as a top15-20 kind of guy at the Senior Bowl. He would be a great bookend to go along with Watt.
RVNSH8R: Ray - we talk about the secondary and the LBs but I dont see much on the D Line. IMO they are not as good as we want/say they are. When I think of an Aaron Smith and Big Snack...I don't see our current D Line are anywhere near that dominant. Am I wrong?
Ray Fittipaldo: Heyward is plenty good. Tuitt has to start playing to his contract. Hargrave is solid. What they need is depth and possibly a project they can groom as Heyward's heir apparent. He's not going to play forever.
Steeltowntim@aol.com: Ray, any chance we can get the outside LB from Minnesota and cut Dupree. I had his name on the tip of my tongue? he was rumoured to be Pittsburgh first round pick but was off the board before they could get him
Ray Fittipaldo: I think you are referencing Anthony Barr. He hasn't produced like a first-round pick, but maybe a change of scenery could help.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for all the great questions this week. We'll do it again next Monday





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.