Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Post your questions and we'll get started soon.
Bob R: Ray, I can’t wrap my head around AB’s current state of discontent. Does he feel he’s been slighted somehow? Does he believe he’s being denied something?
Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't try to understand Brown's state of discontent. He's a different cat. It's useless to try to figure out what makes him tick. Think about what he did. He walked out on his teammates in a week before what amounted to a playoff game. He was coming off a 14-catch, 185-yard, two touchdown performance a few days earlier against the Saints. He was in the midst of yet another monster season. And he goes AWOL because of a feud with a teammate and/or because he was not named team MVP? I've seen national analysts try to pin blame on Ben Roethlisberger or Mike Tomlin, and I think it's laughable. Brown is 30 years old and he's acting like he's 3.
DaquidoBazzini: Hi, Ray - Do you think the firing of Joey Porter last Friday means that DC Keith Butler is safe, or could he still go?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not entirely sure to be honest with you. I think there will be more changes on the coaching staff. Obviously, the defense struggled in some big games down the stretch so Butler and others on the staff are worth watching this week.
DaquidoBazzini: I know Art Rooney II is the decision maker with Steeler ownership.
Read More
Anyone that might be second in line these days on decisions?
How much input does a guy like Thomas Tull have?
Ray Fittipaldo: Thomas Tull is a minority owner. Minority owners don't have much say in the day-to-day operations of the team, but Tull does have more say than the other minority owners.
Clay: Hey Ray, do you forsee any more coaching changes? If so, when do you think they would be announced? I figured they would have been announced with the Porter news. Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: If there are any more changes I think they'll happen this week or next. Generally, coaches like to have their staffs ready to go for the college postseason games and the combine. Those games start happening later this month or next month. And the combine is at the end of February.
Sam: Do you think trading Brown would change what the Steelers choose to do with Boswell based on compiling dead money? Doesn't seem like McCrane is a real long term option with a range of maybe 48 yards and no real touchback threat on kickoffs.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think the Brown and Boswell situations are related. The Steelers know they'll have to absorb cap hits either way with both of them. And you;re right about McCrane. He doesn't have a strong enough leg for kickoffs. He said his No. 1 priority over the offseason is strengthening his right leg so he can improve his distance.
Dave: Quitting on your team seems like the ONE thing teammates should never forgive you for. Cap hit aside, do you see any way AB is on the roster week 1?
Ray Fittipaldo: Right now, I can't see how they keep him. He's not a stable force in that locker room. He's been a handful to deal with for a few years now. I can't imagine the criticism that would take place if they welcomed him back, and he did this type of thing again. I think it's obvious he wants to be traded, and I think the Steelers should accommodate him as long as they receive fair value in return. Nothing less than one first-round pick and maybe more would suffice in my mind.
Mar: Steelers cannot trade ab he is the best receiver in the game they have to figure this out this team will be worse without him our defense isn’t all that great and u weaning our offense this is easily a 6-10 team or 5-11 team
Ray Fittipaldo: I disagree. Ridding yourself of a distraction such as Brown could be addition by subtraction. Football is the ultimate team sport. Players step up. You learn how to win in different ways. It could galvanize the team. And I'm not minimizing Brown's accomplishments. He's been by far the best receiver of his era. But they've never won a Super Bowl with him. They did win Super Bowls with Hines Ward and Cedric Wilson as your top two WRs. In 2008, it was Ward and Santonio Holmes. JuJu Smith-Schuster proved this season he is capable of being a No. 1 receiver. They need James Washington to step up and play better or go find a No. 2 next season. But there is no doubt in my mind that they could be a better team without Brown.
Mark: With your proximity to the team, how often do you think Tomlin and Rooney speak to one another during the regular season? As in, does Rooney advise/tell Tomlin to change something or handle something different regularly in-season, or does he let the coach coach and sets expectations and demands for changes in the offseason?
Ray Fittipaldo: They speak on the field almost every day after practice along with GM Kevin Colbert. And that's just what we see as reporters. I would imagine they have an open line of communication at other times of the day as well. Rooney doesn't mettle in xs and os, but I am quite sure he is involved in other matters with Tomlin.
Mark: Hi Ray, how did the Steelers miss on Darius Leonard? Hopefully they will do a better job of evaluating linebacker talent for the upcoming draft....
Ray Fittipaldo: Leonard is looking like a great pick. The Colts' system undoubtedly helps him. Their defensive line keeps him clean and allows him to run around and make plays. But he's very good at what he does, and he's a 3-down linebacker because he can cover too. I would have loved that pick. They took Terrell Edmunds instead. Edmunds started 15 of 16 games. He struggled early, but he played better late in the season. We'll see what the future holds for both players, but Leonard undoubtedly is ahead at this point.
jds317: The AB issue is grabbing all the headlines but isn't the bigger offseason issue on the defensive side? Half the starters are below the line (Bostic, Williams, Dupree, Hilton Sensabaugh) Do you believe they can upgrade positions on the D?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, they are going to have to upgrade. It's their only hope to get better. They have seven draft picks right now. The majority of those picks must address the defense and I would hope the first players chosen are defenders, just like 2016 when they drafted Artie Burns, Sean Davis and Javon Hargrave. Of course, the Steelers will be hoping this time around that their first-round pick develops better than Burns did.
Utah Jim: If they trade Brown what will be the cap hit to the acquiring team?
Ray Fittipaldo: His base salary, which over the next three years averages out to about $11 or $12 million in each of the final three years of his contract.
Gus from Mars: Has the window closed? I think it has. Rebuild the defense. Reign Ben in..run the ball
Ray Fittipaldo: They should retool the defense. No need for a complete rebuild. Watt is a budding star. Haden and Heyward are aging, but they're still quality players. Tuitt needs to play better, but he's quality too. They need to add to the talent that is there. And yes I agree with your points about the offense. They should tell Roethlisberger he has to be more careful with the ball. They also need to run the ball better. They were 31st in the league in rushing. There is no need to change the offense. Roehtlisberger is still among the top 8-10 QBs in the league. But at 37, why rely on him to make every play? Shorten games, learn how to win in the fourth quarter again. That's what I'd do.
Utah Jim: Tomlin has had three players basically quit on him, Brown, Blount, and Harrison. Did that ever happen to Cowher or Noll?
Ray Fittipaldo: You're testing my memory. I am sure Cowher and Noll had some challenging players to deal with. And I would argue it's much tougher to coach in this era. Players such as Brown who make $17 million a year know they hold the cards. Do the Brown and Harrison situations make Tomlin look bad? Absolutely they do. I think it's clear some players don't have respect for him as a coach. However, I think the majority of the players in the locker room do respect him. Tomlin should have taken stronger stands with Harrison and Brown. You live and learn. A lot of people are watching to see how he and the organization handles this Brown situation going forward.
Rico Steel: Realistic return for AB? Can they get multiple picks including a first rounder?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think you can do the deal if a first-rounder is not involved. Not unless you get Patrick Peterson in return. In that case, I'd take Peterson and the Cardinals' second-round pick.
Gus from Mars: Could the Steelers beaten any of the 8 teams this weekend? Seriously..maybe the Texans.
Ray Fittipaldo: Sure they would have. They would have handled the Texans easily just as the Colts did. And remember, they were up 23-7 on the Chargers before a few unfortunate things happened to them in the second half -- some of their own doing and some by the officials. As Bill Cowher once famously said: "There is a fine line in this league..."
Jeff: why the conflicting stories? I get AB has not handled this well but if Ben truly said "find me someone else" during a practice, I would be honked off as well. again, not excusing AB quitting but if Ben is really calling him out like that then some of this should fall on Ben
Ray Fittipaldo: So let me get this straight. The quarterback wanted someone in there who knew what he was doing during the week of a do-or-die game. And you're blaming the quarterback, not the diva receiver who went AWOL because his feelings were hurt? Remind me to never choose you as a teammate. This is the sort of garbage that is being puked by national analysts, most of them former players that seem to have a problem with Roethlisberger. I'm not saying Roethlisberger doesn't have his faults. He does. He should volunteer to stop doing his radio show. It causes more problems than almost anything for this circus that we call a football team. But blaming him for this Antonio Brown situation is the dumbest thing ever.
Utah Jim: It feels like every Steelers game the last two seasons has come down to the final play. Some of that is certainly due to the competitiveness of the league., but there has to more for the Steelers. What is it? Bad defense? Lack of commitment to the run game?
Ray Fittipaldo: You're right. Twelve of their 16 games this season were decided by 7 points or fewer. The final seven games were in that margin and all came down to the wire. They were 6-5-1 in those games this season, but they lost four of them in the final six weeks. They can't do that going forward. They have to find ways to win more close games or be better so they're not involved in so many close games.
Sam: If the Steelers absorb all this dead money from Brown, and I know they'll recoup some from Bell, how can they possibly address all of the following: losing the game's best receiver, upgrading a horrendous linebacking corps, and getting Joe Haden a capable partner. I never thought the Steelers needed Bell at $15M to win, but filling another all-pro whole on offense with the needs they have on defense doesn't sound too promising.
Ray Fittipaldo: They can address some of those needs in the draft and that's cheap labor for at least four years. No guarantee those players will work out, but that's how they usually operate. They don;t usually go ot and spend big in free agency. No doubt they'll have to learn how to win in different ways than what they've been used to in recent years with Brown leading the way in the passing game. But I'll remind you of this stat. Since 2011, when Brown became this team's dominant offensive playmaker, they've won a grand total of three playoff games. They can win without him.
Utah Jim: Has Tomlin really done enough to earn his apparent lifetime contract?
Ray Fittipaldo: Who said it was a lifetime contract? Chuck Noll was forced out. I'm quite sure Mike Tomlin, who has three fewer Super Bowl wins, can be forced out too.
Rico Steel: Is Bud Dupree safe?
Ray Fittipaldo: Safe? I don't think he
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think he'll be back on a one-year $9.2 million deal. But I think they could do a two- or three-year deal with salaries of about $4 or 5 million a year. That way, they have a solid backup if they find someone better in the draft. Or they have Dupree to start while they try to find someone. Either way, you can't pay $9.2 million to someone who has never had more than six sacks in any of his first four NFL seasons.
Utah Jim: What was the Steelers biggest offseason mistake?
• Misreading the Bell situation. Could have used that money on Defense.
• Not drafting a single ILB and only signing Bostic
• Ignoring Burnett’s long injury history
• Forgetting about Ridley’s long fumble history
• Paying a kicker, any kicker, $4M+
• Other
Ray Fittipaldo: Good list. All of the above.
Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: Hi Ray, I feel like the Steelers will go all D in the draft, for the exception of a RB and WR.. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm with you. They have to invest in the defense again especially after they went with three offensive players in their first four picks last season. And I don't think they need to take a RB high. They can use a late-round pick on someone to come in and compete for the No. 3 job. And I'm not sure they absolutely need to draft a WR high. Maybe third round if you're not convinced about James Washington. But not first or second round. Not a lot of people are talking about TE or OL. But they need to develop a TE if they don't re-sign Jesse James and they might have to replenish the depth along their offensive line if Finney and Feiler are promoted to starting positions.
Rico Steel: What are the chances ownership requires Tomlin to bring in some experts (Challenges, time mgmt etc.) to help him during the game.?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'd be in favor of it especially for the challenges.
JoeB: Who is James Jones' source? He is the only one reporting a pro-AB slant on what happened.
Ray Fittipaldo: He's not the only one.
Fredward: Is it realistic to think the Steelers can replace the best receiver in the league with a draft pick? Look how bad that offense was in Week 17!
Rico Steel: Why haven't we heard from Art II yet?
Ray Fittipaldo: So you learn to win another way. Run the ball more. Run the ball more efficiently. Feature JuJu. Throw to Vance McDonald more. Make sure James Washington is nourished instead of waiting until midway through the season to get him involved. There are all sorts of ways to win the NFL. Just look at the teams that made the playoffs. In case you have to be reminded, the Ravens won six of their final seven to win the AFC North with a running game centered around a rookie QB. Please don't tell me the Steelers can't figure out a way to compensate without Antonio Brown. Anyone is replaceable. This is the NFL.
Ray Fittipaldo: This is the answer to the Art Rooney question. He will speak to a few select beat reporters in the next week or two.
Zak: Read keion Adams got pay raise before last game to the 53 man minimum even though he is practice squad is this true? Can me expect him on the 53 next year you believe?
Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't bet on that. They just wanted to make sure another team didn't poach him. They want to develop him, but I think it's clear they like Ola Adeniyi better at this point. He was promoted from PUP to the active roster late in the season while Adams remained on the practice squad.
Ron: If you ask me (and nobody did), AB is a monster of Coach Tomlin's creation. There was never a price to pay for the stupid end zone celebrations that had us kicking off from the 20 after the penalties. Nor for the tantrums on the sidelines. It was clear his own stats / brand were becoming more important than winning. Then the Facebook live thing. Forty years ago Jack Lambert and / or Joe Greene would have put a stop to that conduct fast. But in today's NFL, its up to the head coach.
Ray Fittipaldo: Good points. And yes the blame does ultimately fall on the head coach.
Rico Steel: Bigger need in the draft this year...CB or ILB?
Ray Fittipaldo: Both. I give the slight edge to CB, but they desperately need a 3-down ILB.
Alan: What would you say are the chances the Steelers could get a 1st round pick for Brown?
Ray Fittipaldo: Depends what the market is. But I would never trade him for anything less than a first.
Nate : Ray in regards to AB. It has always been written about how hard he practices. Catches a pass at the 20 and sprints 80yrds to the end zone. Teaching by example. Now we hear he gets upset having to run a hot read 2 times. Has his effort in practice dropped over the years or what? Kind of confused by everything going on with him. Thanks.
Ray Fittipaldo: He's been different this year. Just different all around. Different on the practice field. Different in his interactions with the media. And I'm told different in his interactions among teammates.
Jack Straw: Hi Ray. You may have noticed that Ryan Clark said recently that "Ben is not a natural leader". From what you have seen inside the locker room, what do you think?
Ray Fittipaldo: I saw that comment. Ben might not be a "natural" leader, but the Steelers won two Super Bowls with him. They don't have an answer on their roster so they're going to extend him. With Ben, you take the good and the bad and hope the good outweighs the bad. And he's had by far more good moments than bad over his 15 years with the Steelers.
abowers: A lot of fans are angy that AB was paid despite being "benched" by the Steelers. First of all, is that accurate? Second, if the Steelers wanted AB to incur a financial penalty, would they have had to suspend him? I don't know what player contracts dictate or what the CBA mandates in terms of player punishment.
Ray Fittipaldo: He was made inactive for the game. He was not suspended. It was a delicate situation. I'm sure throughout the day Thursday and Friday they were searching for ways for this to end with him playing against the Bengals. But once he stopped communicating and didn't show up for his MRI the Steelers knew they had to do something. I can't tell you why a suspension wasn't on the table, but they made their point by benching him.
Rico Steel: How about one of the Raider's first rounders and Garreon Conley for Brown?
Ray Fittipaldo: Raiders have the No. 4, No. 25 and No. 27 picks. I'd take 25 and 27 for Brown in an instant.
JohnDK: Hey Ray, do you feel a Number 1 and Number 2 in 2020 would be compensation enough for AB?
Ray Fittipaldo: Depends where in the first round you're talking, but you're pretty close on that.
Jack: Do you see Conner repeating his performance from this year or will teams figure him out? Is the "real deal" at running back?
Ray Fittipaldo: Conner can be very good in this offense. He can run and catch passes. That's what they ask their RBs to do and he does that well.
Mac: Ray, So what do the Steelers do if no team wants to put up with Brown's antics? No one gives up a #1 or a good player and other draft picks?
Ray Fittipaldo: Then you bite your lip and try to work with him. But you can't just give him away because he's unhappy. You have to get fair return for him.
Adam: Are Conner and Samuels good enough? We need a speedy guy, but we've struggled picking those guys in the draft. Who can be our deep threat?
Ray Fittipaldo: They just need a solid No. 3.
Steeler Fan: What did you think about ILB Matthew Thomas going to the Ravens. I thought he may develop into a good player.
Ray Fittipaldo: I was a bit surprised, but I still don't know what's behind the decision or even if the Steelers wanted to keep him. I assume they did, but I don't know that for sure yet.
Adam: If we lose to the NFC West teams on the road next year(49ers and Cards), I'm done with Tomlin. Every year don't you worry about the bad teams more than the good ones?
Ray Fittipaldo: Jimmy Garopolo will be back next season. The 49ers will be much better with him. I'm not saying a Super Bowl contender, but he's a good QB.
Lloyd's 3-Count: What's your sense about Faneca making HoF? The homer in me thinks Hines should make it and Troy (when eligible) but I'm wondering if we'll go 0-for3.
Ray Fittipaldo: Hines Ward did not make the cut from the final 15 to the final 10. The only one who is eligible next year is Faneca. The problem is three other offensive linemen are also eligible. There is a logjam so not all of them will get in. Polamalu becomes eligible next year.
We the North : What’s going on with the AB situation. Is this for real?? Or a lot of national media hype?? We up in Canada don’t get much info or at least we don’t get the real vibe. I’m think a lot of hype. Great for news. I think this will blow over.
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not so sure the Steelers should allow a player who quit on his teammates to "blow over."
Adam: How will the line be next year? Should we move on from Foster? Looks like Gilbert is gone. Should we draft a guy to fill in or do we have everyone we need on the roster?
Ray Fittipaldo: Foster turns 33 today. Finney is 27 and has proven he is more than capable of being a full-time starter. Is he the next David DeCastro? No. But he can be the next Foster. So I don't see any way Foster returns. Gilbert is a good player, but he's struggled with injuries the past two years. He's only played in 12 of a possible 32 games the past two seasons. And they can save $5 million by releasing him. Matt Feiler was solid in his place, and Chuks Okorafor might be ready to challenge for a starting job too.
LatrobeGuy: Maybe without Brown Roethlisberger will be a better QB, not trying to force him the ball and getting as many INTs.
Ray Fittipaldo: You might be onto something.
NPG2003: Is the biggest flaw in the Steelers' defense at this point scheme or personnel? Is it time for a new DC with a new scheme or can Butler improve the Defense with the better personal brought in during the off-season ( CB Patrick Peterson and stud LB from Draft)? Personally, I think it's time for a new scheme even with the new personnel - What say you Ray?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's both. It's obvious they don't have talent at ILB or at very many places in the secondary. But other teams are winning with equal talent. Coaches coach. They know what their personnel is going to be in most cases by June. They have to come up with ways to maximize the talent however mediocre it might be.
Andrew: Hi Ray, what do you think about the Steelers focusing on getting 1st rounder(s) in the 2020 draft for Brown? They may be able to get more value in a draft that has a few special QBs. By playing the long game, they might sacrifice 2019 to an extent in order to obtain a franchise QB for the next 10-15 years. Seems worth it to me.
Ray Fittipaldo: You're betting on way too much there. There is no way of knowing who is going to have a top pick in 2020. The Raiders thought they were going to get a high pick from the Bears in the Khalil Mack trade. But that pick is now No. 25.
Rambo John J: Why the insistence by the front office to give Ben an extension? If they were thinking 3 year extension why waste picks on Dobbs/Rudolph? Low income high production QB's is the way to build a team and has been since the CBA ratified rookie salary caps. He led the league in the most negative statistic and some reason everyone thinks he had an "mvp season"?!??? Does Colbert not know how to manage salary cap w/o redoing Big Ben contracts?!??
Ray Fittipaldo: The idea is to compete for Super Bowls. As long as Roethlisberger is here they'll have that chance. Does he have to play and lead better? Yes. He can't lead the league in interceptions. But I'm not turning this team over to Josh Dobbs or Mason Rudolph. I'm keeping Roethlisberger as long as he is healthy. He can still play at a high level.
Jitesh: Would Steelers consider going for Suggs? Great pair with TJ
Ray Fittipaldo: Too old. They need to find a younger OLB in the draft or free agency. By the way, I wish they would have given Ola Adeniyi more of a shot late in the season. I'm still high on him.
Jim: I think people forget how bad the Steelers looked offensively against the Raiders (1st half with Ben) and need to stop pointing to what we looked like without AB against Cincy. This team can thrive without AB as long as we have a franchise QB. Agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree.
Joe: Ray as for as you know has the league addressed their missed calls in the Chargers game?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not as far as I know.
Jitesh: Would Kevin green be an ideal replacement for Joey Porter
Ray Fittipaldo: Greene would be a candidate. I'd take a look at Lou Spanos. He's a former Steelers assistant who is on Alabama's staff now. He has recent experience as a college defensive coordinator so he knows how to deal with the talent the college game is producing. There are other good candidates out there.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for all the questions this week. My time is up. We'll do it again next Monday.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.